Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

Posts

Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#1

Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

woodburnbob

>I don't often visit Taunton's Knots (Hand tools), but just did.

I noticed another version of the Holtey kit question. Of course, I wondered, "Who is the Ian that speaks for Mr. Holtey and is so intimately involved in the internet marketing research?"

But several threads down on the Knots forum, there's another Holtey topic, this time about an Ebay Holtey. There are various questions.

In this earlier thread, a fellow, Malcolm, says he'll ask Mr. Holtey.

A few post later, Malcolm provides a copy of the email answer from Mr. Holtey.

The answer stunned me. It is an explicit rejection of the various theories attempting to explain the putative benefits of an infill's flat hardwood bed (e.g., dampening blade resonnance).

I don't dispute the proposition attributed to Mr. Holtey, but is it possible that the inside track to Mr. Holtey via Ian and Malcolm is a scam, a hoax, a spoof?

Sorry, I'm just thinking aloud again.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#2

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

Rob Lee

>Hi -

While I don't participate on the Knots Forum, I can tell you that Ian is completely legit.

The discussion is running on a number of boards right now...

Not sure who "Malcolm" is - but Karl and Ian are looking at producing kits.

Cheers -

Rob

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#3

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

mikew

>Malcolm is a gentleman who is making his own, very fine planes. That he both asked and received a reply form Karl is to all our benefits.

Ian is a gentleman who also has made his own very fine planes *after* building his own CNC machine.

Both have websites available to see their work--they are a couple continents apart iirc.

Ian has had the opportunity to work with Mr. Holtey personally.

This is no scam, Ian is involved in seeing the Holtey kits to fruition and may or may not be involved from what I can gather following the initial launch.

That these gentlemen and Mr. Holtey are cooperating in furthering and expanding the craft of fine infill making is also a great benefit to us all.

As to the blade dampening/resonation effects from a fully bedded iron vs. the Holtey method? I think Holtey makes a good arguement for how his unique method--coupled with a very thick iron--works. Better? Not better? I don't know. In principle, the Holtey bedding method would seem to provide a constant solid-to-the-bed support, akin to the bedding of a low angle, solid machined bed except at the higher angle all the while still utilizing the beauty of a classic infill of wood. Makes sense to me.

Take care, Mike

PS, my statements as regards the players mentioned above are assumtpion from reading pertinent threads on various forums, which I am sure will be corrected...

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#4

Flat beds or not?

woodburnbob

>The tone in my post was a little off. I mostly meant the hoax idea facetiously. From his website (at the end of his post), Malcolm exists and is legit also.

Just curious about the nature of the relationship between "Karl and Ian" regarding the enterprise of Holtey metal kits. I mean poor "Doug and Ben" are barely cool in their grave. Am I the only one cynical enough to notice a parallel here?

What I was really hoping for was more wisdom on bedding theories (and practices), from experts and lurkers alike. Are the flat-bed guys simply full of wind? You make planes, Rob. What's the goal at your shop: perfectly flat beds or 3-point tripods?

Bob

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#5

Great. What's Ian's web address?

woodburnbob

>

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#6

Ian's web address  *LINK*

mikew

>


Ian's web address

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#7

Could someone print Holtey's reaponse here?

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>There's something that Knots doesn't like about me, as I've never been able to connect to that site...

Thnx,

DC

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#8

Re: Could someone print Holtey's reaponse here?

mikew

>Hi Denis--hope it OK with all concerned

***************************************

From: Malcolm Apr-27 11:45 pm

To: ALL (9 of 13)

Here's Karl's response (in part) to my question:

" You are the first person to ask this. All my planes have a similar feature as this. Blade beds - there is no such thing as flat, especially where wood is concerned. By using the studs I am able to be sure that there is 100 percent contact at the front end of the blade and by supporting the blade at the rear end with nothing between the two support points, then I know that the blade is supported where it counts. This works well on any blades of reasonable thickness. As most of us know, when wood shrinks it shrinks across the grain which then could change the angle of any wooden bed, with the blade resting on the studs and not the woodwork the resting points on the blade are where I want. The principal of raising the rear end i.e. by resting on the stud, would be better with one stud in the centre where possible - as on my No 98 and infill mitre planes. This gives the three legged stool principal. With the studs that I use they are not merely stuck in the wood but there is some contact with the metal structure in the plane body. In the past I have increased the angle of the wooden bed to pre-empt the effects of shrinkage, but I have found it is not an exact science and find the studs work better."

Malcolm

www.macpherson.co.nz

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#9

Chris Scholz

Re: Flat beds or not?

Chris Scholz

>I have no insight into the business aspects of you question.

Concerning the damping issue: in another forum I hypothesized that if the advantage of infill plane's wooden bed is in damping than one might get similar advantages by using a laminated steel blade in cast iron planes (soft backing dampens vibrations). The consensus was what really matters in practice is the length of the unsupported blade. If this is true, Holtey's design has not adverse effects on the plane performance.

Unfortunately, AFAIK there are no thick high-quality laminated blades, so we might never know a definite answer...

Chris

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#10

Re: Flat beds or not?

Rob Lee

>Hi Bob -

No worries...I correspond with Ian, and had dinner with him last fall - a talented guy.

When it comes to plane bedding - I'm sort of in the tri-pod camp. Actually - a line along the mouth, and a high point as far up the bed as possible camp.

Nothing wrong with wood bedding either - though with a thick enough blade, it shouldn't make any difference. If you really want good bedding - use some sheet lead material!

Way back when blades were forged and less regular (than today, anyway) a bed that could deform somewhat certainly would have been a plus.

My take on infills is that it's the mass - and how that mass is distributed that make a difference...

But frankly - the wood being cut doesn't really care what the plane's made of, who's holding it, what the blade's made of, or even how thick it is. As long as the blade's sharp, restrained, and presents the appropriate effective cut angle you should be able to get the same quality of cut.

Cheers -

Rob

pigeons pigeons pigeons pigeons cat pigeons pigeons pigeons pigeons

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#11

Sorry, just can't help myself *PICS*

woodburnbob

>Holtey planes, Ian's marvelous brand new shop with CNC, Bridge City tools today on Ebay and me with too much time on my hands this morning.

Let me show you just 3 photos from the Nigel Lamphert book on Stewart Spiers and others. The photos are quite self-explanatory...except the last.

As far as I know, the last shot is the only photograph of any shop from which Spiers, Mathieson, Preston, Norris and all the rest produced their thousands of infill planes. No laser cutters, water jets, or CNC machines seen here. Yet there seem to be plenty of machines and devices. Wish I could spend a day watching how it was done then?








Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#12

Definitive Response *LINK*

Deirdre Saoirse Moen

>I think this is the definitive response, really.

http://www.holteyplanes.com/projects.htm

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#13

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

C.R. Miller

>As others have vouched for both Ian and Malcolm there's no need for me to do so as well. On the subject of the "tripod" arrangement vs an all wood bed I'm in agreement with Rob. It's the mass of the entire plane and the fact that there's a lot of "shock absorbing" wood in the construction of the plane that is the main thing at play here. Whether the blade rests on three points or not, those three points are themselves bedded into the wood (well, the top two anyway) and therefore the shock is absorbed through them. In this regard its harmony through disharmony of the two materials.

On another matter I'm a little....... I guess, anxious, to see how the Holtey kits pan out as I'm afraid that I've also gone halfway down that track since the demise of Shepherd Tools. I'm currently halfway through a production batch of 120 "scaled down" plane kits and I'm wondering just how to approach things now as I had absolutely no idea that Karl, or anyone for that matter, was considering the same thing. I have spent the last few days in a rather numb state on that front as I don't like stepping on people's toes - especially fellow planemakers.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#14

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

joel -( tools for working wood)

>If mass had anything to do with plane performance then C+W planes would not perform as spectacullly well as they actually do. But they do. Therefore I would stay that mass of the plane is not that important a factor.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#15

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

C.R. Miller

>C & W planes also have other things going for them as well - pitch, thickness of blade, composition of blade, build quality etc. Those things account for a lot.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#16

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

joel -( tools for working wood)

>that's my point. Mass is just one factor and I don't think a very important one in most plane designs.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#17

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

C.R. Miller

>Out of interest, what are some of the things that are more important in your opinion, Joel?

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#18

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

joel -( tools for working wood)

>Fit and finish is everything.

How well the iron is bedded is very important.

Flat sole

Tightness of mouth is important for difficult woods but gets in the way if you are planing regular woods.

Bedding angle is important as is a good thick iron.

but in general with a sharp iron you can plane most things with anything.

what is intersting is what happens as the irons wear. with a poorly fitted bed, a bad wedge, etc the iron will chatter and stop cutting. With a well bedded iron it will just be harder to push. (it has no place to go).

On an infill with a lever cap it's easy to get a lot of pressure on the iron and keep it against the bed. With a wedged plane it takes a skilled planemaker to fit it together but the result is the same.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#19

One source

Neal in San Jose

>Ohio Tool had thick, tapered, laminated blades. They went out of business in the early 1900s, but many of their planes survive. A couple of my favorite users are Ohio Tools, and they are the only metal planes I haven't put replacement blades in. They hold their own against my upgraded Stanleys, but I have made no effort (nor do I intend to) to do a meaningful comparison. FWIW, YMMV, I don't own stock in the company, etc!

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#20

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

Darin

>I wish someone would put this discussion to bed. A FEA of a simple spring mass model would answer the question about the source of resonance ( IRON, PLANE BODY, or both ). Rob please fund some graduate student to do the analysis and validation of results. The student and the rest of the woodworking world will forever thank you. One last thought Japanese planes never chatter.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#21

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>To some extent this topic was covered by Lyn Mangiameli (link below), whose study of high angle smoothers included a wide range of planes, including infills, metal and wooden. At this cutting angle (my emphasis), the mass of the plane, per se, was not correlated highly with the results. In other words, as Joel said earlier, mass is but one factor in the total equation at this cutting angle.

Regards from Perth

Derek


High Angle Smoothing Plane Review

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#22

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

Darin

>True but , chatter or whatever you want to call it is surely a function of the resonant frequency of the iron and or the body of the plane. Mass only contributes in that it may increase or decrease the frequency or the gain of the resonance of the system if the spring is mostly in the body.

I could give my opinion but it's only opinion and structural analysis in combination with instrumented tests is the best way to answer the recuring question about the best plane design.

O.K. a clue to what I think, Stanley had a insight when they put square sides on the Bedrock planes.

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#23

Re: Flat beds or not?

paul womack

>AFAIK there are no thick high-quality laminated blades,

Not in current production, no.

There are plenty of old ones.

BugBear

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#24

Re: Sorry, just can't help myself *PICS*

paul womack

>Wish I could spend a day watching how it was done then

Wayne Anderson makes his planes (almost) entirely by hand.

BugBear

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

#25

Re: Mr. Holtey on infill beds...truth or hoax?

Tom MacGregor

>Does anyone have or know where to find a photo or illustration of the multi-point bedding system?