Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Rumors of Holtey kits

Posts

Rumors of Holtey kits

#1

Rumors of Holtey kits

Michael Brady

>I saw in another forum that Karl Holtey is studying the market for infill plane kits, or partial kits without the wood, for those who (like myself) can't hope to afford a custom plane. I know there is a U.S. source for infill kits out in the Southwest. What is the scoop on those?

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#2

The other source in the southwest

John in NM

>is probably St. James Bay Tool in Mesa, AZ. The only time I visited, several years ago now, his tools all consisted of castings with mostly decorative infills and wooden totes. Blade beds were all machined from the casting if I remember correctly. Kits varied from rough castings (cheapest, but you have to have access to some machinery to complete the thing in less than a decade), to semi-machined and machined kits that cost a bit more (I seem to remember about 60% of a finished plane). But it was years ago, and I may have a bit of a cloudy recollection. He also (at the time) did not temper his blades, which I have to think is not such a great idea. Of course its so easy to do, maybe he was just figuring that his customers could do their own tempering and get the hardness/brittleness just the way they like it. I've got a half finished bullnose plane of his that I'll get around to one day, I think I planned to give the blade half an hour at 450 F, maybe sneak it in when Jean was cooking pizza or something.

If there's anyone else making infills in my neck of the woods (um, brush maybe), I'd love to hear about it.

John

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#3

Re: The other source in the southwest

Michael Brady

>That's a lot of information and I thank you. This whole fiasco with the Shepherd Tool Co. has raised my awareness of the possibility that an infill plane is within reach of a person with reasonable skills and patience. It's a darned shame that that the two Canadians handled themselves so poorly in their difficulty and frankly, screwed a lot of people by continuing to take their money. Someone like Karl Holtey could possible make the concept work as long as his business sense is on par with his craftsmanship. Another one who could consider it is Philip Marcou in New Zealand.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#5

Re: The other source in the southwest

Thom D

>Interesting. A few years ago Arnold Palmer was a player in the Pearless golf company that became the Parmer golf company. They offered their iron sets for sale on the component market, meaning you could buy the heads and assemble the shafts ferules and grips yourself, which is the way Palmer has always handled his own sticks. Anyway, the iron heads (8 to a set) were offered for 6.95 each head, or maybe it was 9.95, the latter would be a few bucks above the average cast component head. Those head prices haven't changed much since, while a set of name clubs with steel shafts sell for around 800 dollars. The shafts and grips cost under 10 bucks together. So what we have here is a product that cost about 150 in component form, that anyone can assemble, but sells retail for 800 buck or twice that with carbon shafts. Kinda peels back the curtain so you can see the Wizard.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#6

Pretty amusing prices

woodburnbob

>Thanks, Frank, for posting a link to the thread. The thread itself seems curious. It amounts to someone raising the question: Would a Holtey A13 metal-only kit sell very well at the �390 - �450 price range?

The dollar-pound exchange rate just took a lurch to $1.89=�1.

So, for those of us in the colonies, the price would then be $737.52 to $850.99.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#7

Beining a designer....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>Golf clubs are the worst... Epically woods! Nastiest surfaces ever to try to develop IMHO.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#8

Re: St James Bay Tool

barryvabeach

>I have purchased both types of kits from St James Bay Tool Co - the rough casting for a panel plane ( I have no machine tools to speak of, other than a dremel, a belt sander and a bench top drill press )and it took me nearly a year to copmplete it to my liking. I also bought a machined casting for a smoother - It took me a few weeks to a few months to finish it, but mostly due to my indecision about shaping the handles - I had it ready to plane wood in 2 to 3 weekends - the rest of the time was monkeying around with different angles,widths,etc for hte front tote and rear handle. From lloking at te price poitns the SJBTC would be the economical way to go.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#9

Re: Pretty amusing prices

Michael B

>As the original poster of this thread, if what you say is accurate, I would have to ponder that this business would be a non-starter, at least for those of us who have to deal in U.S. currency. I can't see value in a hand-plane project that would cost over $800.00 in kit form being viable, if volume of any kind is anticipated. That is very much different than the "marginally more than the Shepherd kits" pricing that was first posed. Karl Holtey will somehow have to determine who truly is willing to put up that kind of money and then have to rely on their own skills to achieve a finished product. I don't think I can join that elite club.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#10

scott grandstaff

Re: Beining a designer....

scott grandstaff

>Man you got that right.

Woods are tough.

This one is about 1/2 size. I carved it for my grandaughter, around 7 years old at the time. Being a southpaw nothing was available on the market. It's persimmon and brass.

yours, Scott


img

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#11

Curiosity

Bill Houghton, sunny today yahoo in Sebastopol, CA

>Scott, what is it about persimmon that makes it a good golf club wood?

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#12

scott grandstaff

Re: Curiosity

scott grandstaff

>Beats me. I'm no golf club expert. Persimmon is hard and tough and carves like frozen granite. It's what's traditional.

Not that much different than slow grown apple though, and not as hard as manzanita or any of several other woods I had handy.

I just had some is all and her step grandpa (who gets to see her almost everyday, the lowdown vermin!!! jealous jealous)

works at a golf course and I dunno. Seemed right.

But the gossip is she got 75 yards on the driving range with it on several ocasions which doesn't seem bad for a 7 yr old??

yours, Scott

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#13

It's A Bi%ch to work....

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond, CA

>To tell the truth, I have only played with it once. It's a lot like Manzanita(sp) but a little different. Both are tough as nails, but Persimmon has a great harmonic displacement (i.e.) Great infilll or dampaning/adsoribing material IMHO.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#14

Re: The other source in the southwest

steve knight

>When Karl called me he had talked about doing kits. he does not want to have to provide building support though. I cna't blame him as it could eat up a lot of time and make the kit cost more.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#15

So when our one tree that may be dying

Bill Houghton, sunny today yahoo in Sebastopol, CA

>finally kicks the bucket, I've got material for a light-colored infill smoother? Hmmmmmm

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#16

Re: Pretty amusing prices

woodburnbob

>...if what you say is accurate...

I was just taking the numbers floating around in the thread and plugging them in. Here's the basis for what I offered: Exchange Rates

I share your thoughts about value.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#17

Stinks

jim reed @ tallahassee

>I made some doors and a few mallets from a single persimmon board I found at the lumberyard. Very pretty wood with black streaks. Tough and STUNK badly when cut.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#18

Clark & Williams use persimmon

Wiley Horne

>in high-wear situations, like boxing in molding planes or wedges in plough planes. Photo attached is of persimmon boxing in a moving filletster. It's in the Diospyros genus--the only American ebony.

Wiley


img

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#19

Re: The other source in the southwest

GolfSteve in Calgary

>If he hopes to provide kits but hopes to not provide support he should forget the whole idea. That's just a recipe for bad press and unsatisfied customers, even if the kits are wonderful.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#20

Re: The other source in the southwest

mikew

>Ian has stated there will be instructions with pictures on the web site. He also mentioned there will be email support.

With comprehensive instructions, anything else is hand-holding. Being able to have prompt email responses is simply icing on the cake, so to speak.

The key is anticipating the types of problems, illustrating both how to avoid them, and how to fix them if the occur. I believe this is what they are attempting to do by having a good mix of experienced and non-experienced builders go through the kits.

Then, as time will tell, updating those instructions as needed.

Really, I cannot see what all the fuss is about. There is a market for Karl providing kits. Just like there is for him building his planes. Albeit, there is a more limited market for the kits than say St James Bay. But there is also a limited market for his planes. I cannot afford to have Karl build one for me. That hasn't stopped him from building them all these years.

The same will apply to the kits. Not everyone will be able to justify or afford one of his kits. So? There are other options. Buy a vintage one or by a kit from SJB--or not. While I lament the selling of my Preston infill [and other tools] in order to raise some cash for making the saws, I have gotten along just fine without it. When I can afford to add one back, I will look seriously at Karl's kits. And if I have that much discretionary cash at the time, I would gladly purchase one. I personally like the idea of building a kit. That's just me. ymmv.

Take care, Mike

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#23

Its density...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>now universally eclipsed by metal "woods," which propel the ball to a higher speed. Well, not always in my case. : )

Observed some Persimmon refinishing at a golf club building and repair certification course a couple years ago. It really is quite a beautiful wood.

Best, Ted

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#24

Re: Curiosity

Thom D

>Not much. The hitting surface is phenolic the weight distribution is via brass, and by the time woods were moving off the stage laminated mapple and balsa core where displacing persimon.

The great thing about wood was it allowed the club maker to custom control the surface shape for a more forgiving club or for variations of performance. There really isn't anything quite like that in the metal wood game, though there are many things you can fiddle with. Golf gear is big business and most of the focus is on helping high handicap players. I still work with a few low handicap players. Clubs are the easiest tools to sell I have ever been involved with.

Re: Rumors of Holtey kits

#25

Re: The other source in the southwest

Thom D

>His planes are really overpriced, that's good he has developed a reputation, but that doesn't translate to a kit. You can already buy his blades for reasonable rates, either the kits come with the possibility that the maker will mess up the minute details that separate his planes from others (if such details exist), or they will show that the planes are thousand of dollar over what is reasonable. I'm not seeing how that is a winner. But then I wouldn't have bet on his chances with his own planes either.