Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Quality of no name mortise chisels

Posts

Quality of no name mortise chisels

#1

Quality of no name mortise chisels

Bill Houghton, IT IS Spring in Sebastopol, CA

>I'm watching some English Oval Bolstered Mortise Chisels* on the Bay. The seller says they have no maker's mark, but they're definitely EOBMC from the pics. Is the quality of these chisels fairly consistent, or should I be buying only some with a known name?

*I can never type or think that phrase without adding in my head, "Tinker to Evers to Chance." It's just so long.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#2

Huh?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.

>I can never type or think that phrase without adding in my head, "Tinker to Evers to Chance." It's just so long.

Bill, what are you talking about?

T.O.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Huh?

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Todd,I'm guessing that he's talking about the politically correct term for pigsticker. Bill,I've bought a few various ones of those off ebay and while some are more beaten up than others,the quality is pretty consistent.I don't think there were too many cheap knockoffs of those chisels made.Most of mine are laminated.A few with no maker's marks.---Jack

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#4

It's a Walt Kelly thing

Bill Houghton, IT IS Spring in Sebastopol, CA

>There's something about the full name, English-Oval-Bolstered-Mortise-Chisel that builds up a momentum and needs more to go on the end, seems like. What better addition than the first double play in baseball? Besides, it keeps me from adding, "you know - [porcine expletive deleted out of respect for Joel]."

It's a stolen idea. I was an avid reader of Pogo in my youth, and Walt Kelly did books in which he did bits not possible in the comic strips. One of his books has a long, lovely riff on an English folk song whose chorus goes something like "Rowley to Powley to -- to --," and at one point, the chorus includes "Tinker to Evers to Chance."

Maybe it's one of those old guy things -- although the only pleasure I get from baseball is listening to the radio commentary in hardware stores (where it reminds me of following my father around the store in my childhood), EVERYone in my school knew the players who made the first double play in baseball.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#6

The King's English :)

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>If we are using terms such as English Oval Bolstered M .. mm.. mm ... OK, should it be MORTISE or MORTICE .... chisel?

Teasing from Perth

Derek

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#7

Re: The Queen's English...

Alice Frampton, UK

>Sheesh, I know Oz is a long way away, Derek, but I thought news had got through that we've had a Queeen for a while now... ;~)

Anyway, the OED gives mortise first, but mortice is also correct. It's just one of those little exceptions in English that keep us all on our toes.

Cheers, Alf

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#8

Re: The Regent's English - Engl. major's help pls!

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Alf/Derek,

It's actually one of those practise/practice forms of a noun/verb - as I'm not an English major I can't remember the correct terms.

You can touch a psychologist's practice or an ice cream. [the 'noun']

But you can't touch piano practise. [the 'verb']

So, you cut a Mortice with a mortising chisel.

Trust that this makes sense and awaiting help from those that have a far better command of the language. I know that practise isn't a true verb but I've got no idea what it's called.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#9

Re: The Regent's English - Engl. major's help pls!

Alice Frampton, UK

>Pretty sure it isn't, Andrew, but I'm willing to be proved wrong. Heck, I'm not even a English minor. Or miner.

I'll go now...

Cheers, Alf

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#10

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

Adam Cherubini

>I prefer laminated (I call them) Joiners' Mortise chisels (or just Mortise chisels as they were called originally). I'm with Joel, I don't like "pigsticker" either, BTW.

I think the quality of older mortisers is pretty consistent. It seems somes English companies tried to make all tool steel versions in the 20th c You can usually spot these by the bolster which is usually smaller and formed differently from the typical. Also, beware of very short chisels. These are often older, which in and of itself is okay, but I worry that they steel portion may be almost gone. Also, ergonomically, its nicer when these tools are at least 4" long. They were probably 8" originally.

I doubt the chisels you are watching are truly unmarked. You may find a mark if you win them.

Good Luck!

Adam

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#11

Another childhood myth exploded

Bill Houghton, IT IS Spring in Sebastopol, CA

>

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#13

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Bill

I have acquired several OBMC from different makers. They appear fairly consistent across the board. As Adam said, it is safer to only get nice long blades since the chances of these having being ground to death, and thereby losing their temper, is much less.

Below are a few of mine. I prefer to get those that require re-handling (an easy job), since they are much cheaper this way.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#14

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>These do have smaller bolsters, almost like the bolsters on carving chisels. Is this bad, or is all tool steel OK?

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#15

More info

Bill Houghton, IT IS Spring in Sebastopol, CA

>The seller says there's no sign of lamination, and the tools are "a min[imum] 45 years old."

Might try it tonight.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#16

Re: Pigsticker

Thom D

>The only advantage to the term is that people instantly know what is being talked about. Other than that it is sordid, hard to figure out why this particular chisel got saddled with it, etc...

Anyone have any idea how these chisels are made. Are they integral or is the bolster applied. The ones I have seen look integral but it is a lot of metal to upset into a bolster in pre-industrial forges, unless it only happened onto the scene with drop hammers and such.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#17

Wmburg's smiths

Adam Cherubini

>Thom,

I forget the guy's name, but the head smith at Williamsburg gave a presentation to this year's woodworking conference attendees showing exactly how these were made. As I recall the bolster was a seperate piece, forge welded in place and shaped with a special purpose die/swage. He had videos and what we saw took minutes. Amazing what those guys can do. More amazing that modern smiths aren't doing more of it.

Adam

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#18

Re: More info

Adam Cherubini

>I'd be wary of non-laminated tools. But as for seeing it, is this teh same seller that can't find a maker's mark? Its not usually easy to see the lamination line until you clean or grind the tool.

Adam

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#19

Yep, same seller

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Well, if the accountant will OK it tonight, maybe I'll bid but not go crazy on the size of the bid.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#20

Great handles.... and a question

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Derek -

Those are great looking handles!

I have a question, though, not about the handles. The second chisel from the left appears to have a curve in the back of the blade (i.e. the part normally flattened during sharpening). Is that the case, or is it just an artifact of the photography? If it is not flat...I have one like that too... that is, with a curve in the back of the blade. I assumed this was the product of missharpening over time (though perhaps I am wrong on that). But, again, if it is not flat, how do you make sure that the ends of your mortises are straight? Just eyeball it?

I hope my question makes sense.

Thanks -

Dave

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#21

Re: Another question

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>What's the wood you used for the second from the left? It has really interesting figure and color.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#22

Re: Great handles.... and a question

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>The second chisel from the left appears to have a curve in the back of the blade (i.e. the part normally flattened during sharpening). Is that the case, or is it just an artifact of the photography?

Hi Dave

The chisel back is, in fact, quite flat. The illusion of it being curved might come from its proximity to the curved front of the chisel alongside.

If yours is not straight, sand it flat with the help of 80 grit on a flat surface. I don't really like using power for these tasks.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#23

Re: Another question

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi William

I have 6 of these chisels altogether. The only two I did not re-handle were the two on the left in the picture. The far left looks like Rosewood. It is quite striking and, inspite of the handle being a bit on the skinny side, since it is a 1/8" and does not receive heavy blows, I have left it as is. The chisel you are referring to came from Ray Isles. It is a 3/16". I asked Ray what the wood is, but he really didn't know. I am hoping that someone from the UK can tell me. It is really pretty.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#24

Re: Wmburg's smiths

Thom D

>Thank you Adam,

I figured as much, part of the reason some modern guys don't do this kind of thing is because getting good iron is tricky, at least from the usual junk sources. Forge welding steel is a whole other process. However, for my purposes Tig welding would be in-elegant but effective. I just needed to know.

Re: Quality of no name mortise chisels

#25

Necessary?

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi guys,

Is it really necessary to weld the bolster to the blade? (that's not a rhetorical question)I always thought that if the tanged end of the blade had square shoulders the bolster would be well seated and no welding would be necessary. I made a bolstered chisel this way and the bolster is fine, solid as a rock. I think this would even be truer for hand-made chisels, where you can file the hole in the bolster to fit the tang snugly.