Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

Posts

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#26

Set screws on the sides???

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>What is the purpose of these tiny screws? Why is it none of my Bailey's, Bedrocks and LN's have set screws on the sides and why do I not miss them?

I don't have a problem with lateral adjustment on these planes whether they are BU or BD? To me the side screws are part of the "neato" features which don't add much functionality

Dan Clermont

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#27

Re: Q on the rules.

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>How about this for rhetorical:

Why not?

The issue as I recall it, was that a using a jack instead of a smoother wouldn't allow one to smooth a board that has moved somewhat. My point was that if the board moved so much that the jack can't do the job anymore while a smoother still does, then the board has moved enough out of flat to warrant re-flattening it before smoothing.

The more general point I wanted to make is that too many lock themselves in "rules"...

DC

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#28

Re: Q on the rules.

Paul Kierstead

>But, you are making your own rule right there. I would certainly agree with "why not?", but that is a far cry from "should". You are arbitrarily saying that if a jack can't smooth it, then it is not flat enough. Says who? You? That makes it a rule? Why not say if a jointer can't do it, then it isn't flat enough? It all sounds very arbitrary to me. That is the point! We all have different ways of working. For you, it should be jack-flat. For me, smooth-flat is good enough, and using a jack is a waste of time in certain cases. Now you object to my smooth-flat 'rule', yet introduce your own rule that it "should" be flat by jack standards.

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#29

Re: Quality. not Quantity

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Think we can come up with some more platitudes? How about "it all turns out for the best," even if you blow your food and rent money. Or "god looks after he who looks after himself?" Or.... :)

Pam

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#30

Re: Passion has no price tag Pam.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Sure, you can get more people to buy your stuff, even go broke doing it. Just look at all the people maxed out and then some on credit cards.

And passion is a very strong elixir; but it's not worth making so many feel so bad about not being able to buy the latest and greatest or one of everything good. And, of course, I agree there's a certain beauty in precision.

Pam

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#31

Agree

Bill Houghton, NO RAIN TODAY YAY, Sebastopol, CA

>We've been, more or less by choice, not real rich in $$. Decided to have one of us home while the boys were little, then discovered that it's just as important having someone home when they're teenagers, then my work exploded and having one of us home to provide the stability of an old-style home maintained our sanity...all of which meant $20 for a plane at a garage sale was a Big Deal.

So I've learned to make what I've got work, and work fairly well. The price is equal, just more in time than in money.

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#32

Tell you what

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>The first tool maker/dealer who can come up with a way to put skill in a box and mail it out to folks will be the one to get my hard earned money no matter what that box cost.Till then I`ll just have to keep getting those skills the hard way,and hang on to my dollars to buy what I can afford,rust.

MB-Who has yet to find a person who can look at a finished surface,run his hand over it and be able to tell if it was planed by a LN or a rehabbed Stanley(or anything in between for that matter).

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#33

Re: Agree

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yeah, Jack and I have always bought time rather than things like bigger houses than we need. Of course, we miscalculated from time to time. When we invested a fortune in Newton software development, we certainly didn't anticipate that Apple would kill the Newton any time soon. And we also didn't anticipate 9/11. At that point I started regretting the choice of time purchase just a bit, all of a sudden we had more than we knew what to do with. :)

Pam

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#34

He said / She said

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>She said:

"Sure, you can get more people to buy your stuff, even go broke doing it. Just look at all the people maxed out and then some on credit cards."

He said:

"Same here"

Then she said:

"And passion is a very strong elixir; but it's not worth making so many feel so bad about not being able to buy the latest and greatest or one of everything good."

He said:

"Agree, same here."

...and then both said:

"There's a certain beauty in precision."

Chico...

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#35

The screw which really works.....is

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>..the mouth stop screw. Wow! What a useful little bugger that is. God bless whoever thought of that.

Side screws... they seem like little bit of a novelty, but in joinery oriented planes, they're useful as well as in bench planes when planing softwoods with knots. After the initial set, one can tighten the blade laterally with those set screws and when (inevitably) a knot or two got hit, the blade does not move out of alignment easily.

Chico...

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#36

Re: The screw which really works.....is

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I like the idea of the mouth stop screw but don't like where they put it. WOuld have much prefered if LV would have kept the screw out of the mouth as I don't like obstacles when I am installing my freshly sharpened blade. Also found the lateral adjuster would sometimes pop out and made it even more challenging installing a freshly honed blade

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#37

Ta-dum! :)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#38

I apologize

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>To those of you who whom I may have offended by stating you needed to own high quality planes in order to do high quality work

Around here I have seen allot of people put allot of money into old planes. Way more then what it would have cost to buy a Clifton, LN, LV, Knight, C & W. Sad thing is they keep buying them looking for one they are happy with.

I have also taught others how to sharpen that Dunlap or Stanley Handyman and they are happy as can be it when they make a shaving.

In my shop, I reach for the same tools I rely on and have gotten to trust over the years. I really don't need anymore planes. I only lust over them.

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#39

That's where will go....

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>...on our seperate ways Dan. If you use the LV's you'll see soon that none of your "projected" problems are an issue. Besides, it's easy to say "they should put it somewhere else". Would like that as a "power option" as well? These are (hand)planes, not automobiles. ;-)

Chico...

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#40

Re: That's where will go....

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>IMO they should have used a set screw in place of the big brass mouth screw.

It is an option I don't feel I need as I don't have a problem with my block planes and my other BU plane

By the way, i tend to not buy cars "feature loaded" then yet again that is hust me.

Cheers

Dan C

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#41

Oh, THAT mouth stop screw

Bill Houghton, raining again...in Sebastopol, CA

>I was halfway through this subthread before I realized that you were talking about an actual tool part, rather than a metaphor relating to how out there some of the conversations get...

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#42

For the record

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I have had a BUJ and BUS smoother in my shop for 5 months. It isn't like i looked at a pic and came up with some Phantom issues I may not like about the plane.

Personally, I would have placed "triggers" on the knob and tote which run with a stepper motor so I could adjust the blade depth and lateral adjustment without taking my hand off the tote.

I would also have placed a programmable remote at the base of the knob so I could pre-program the volume controls for my TV and shop radio along with light dimmers.

While I am at it I'd like two headlights on the front so I can see where I am planing in dim light as my shop lights aren't that terribly great and I rely on natural light through the windows.

Dan Clermont

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#43

Re: Set screws on the sides???

david marcus brown

>I disagree entirely. I wish that my 4-1/2 had set screws on the sides to stabilize the blade. I often have to reset the blade when it's knocked off square by knots in the wood that I'm working. When adjusting the lever cap screw, it's a compromise between making the blade easy to adjust or able to resist skewing when you hit a knot.

Jim DeLaney, a woodworker that I respect, modified his 4-1/2 in just this fashion. I think that Stanley didn't add set screws because the sides of their planes weren't thick enough to allow it -- except on the war time models.


img

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#44

Re: Set screws on the sides??? *LINK*

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi David,

I built this closet organizer covered in figured maple and knots. I even used a LV 4.5 for part of it and never set the set screws. Also used a LN BU jack and a Bedrock 604.5

Not once did I have a problem with a blade getting knocked out of square. Maybe it was just me.


Closet Organizer

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#45

organizer

david marcus brown

>Nice organizer. Did you hand cut the sliding dovetails?

That's something I haven't gotten to try yet.

I'm sure we all have our unique experiences w/ blades moving/not moving, etc. I'm also beginning to see a little of what you mean about the intentional "style" of the LVs. I'm sure that in the end it becomes a case of "what works for you."

FWIW, I'm thinking about adding some shims to my 4-1/2 to keep the blade from skewing. I like to keep the lever cap a little loose to make it easier to adjust the blade on the fly. I like the idea of set screws but the idea of drilling and tapping my plane makes me crings.

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#46

Set screws..

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Drilling and tapping cast iron is like working butter. It is only sizing the bit to the tap that will complicate the process. get the two right and it is a breeze.

That said locating the point to drill so that the setscrew hits solidly at the blade could be tedious. I would want that to be as accurate as possible.JR

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#47

Re: organizer

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi David,

Thanks for the comments.

The female part of the sliding dovetail was cut with a power tool. The male part was hand cut using a piece of wood setup to a 1:8 rake and then I used a shoulder plane. Before the shoulder plane you need to score the width or depth of the dovetail, set the 1:8 block up on the line and then plane away. After that you need to square up the shoulder of the sliding dovetail with a chisel.

I would have prefered the organizer to not have been so square but functionality over ruled beauty in this case.

Cheers

Dan C

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#48

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Set screws..

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>If you're going to drill and tap for set screws, make sure you set the frog to its final working position before you locate the setscrews.

If you have the frog set forward, or back, of your working position when you locat the set screws, then they won't touch the blade properly after you move (adjust) the frog.

BTW, the WWII model planes, with their much thicker sides, adapt well to drilling and tapping for set screws. The older models, with the thinner sides, only allow for - at the most - about two threads. The WWII models will ger four, or maybe even five threads. BTW, I used 8-32 set screws on mine.

Jim D.

Re: LV LAJ and "The Rules" *LINK*

#49

Re: My apologies

ThomD

>Not at all. Just talking a lot of nonsense mostly, was down with a bug for a few days there, and less lucid than even the usual. My apologies.

I do get ticked at all the complaining about expensive and beautiful tools one can hear at times, because that is somewhat the activity I see myself as being in, making beautiful things, in form and function. Doubtless the people who make beautiful handplanes take great joy in never spending more than 5 bucks on a chair. And professional wooden chairmakers are never happier than when they can find a really nasty, cheap, plastic violin for their kids to go take lessons on. One can overlay a number of lenses through which that all makes sense: "choice", "economy", "environment", who knows.