Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

Posts

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#26

OT How about them anvils?

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>How did thay get so durn pretty? And where did you get them? Been looking for a nice one for the home shop.JR

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#27

Re: Home HT

ThomD

>"The most important factor for chisels is toughness at high hardnesss. You want an edge that will resist deforming as well as chipping while bashing the chisel. Abrasion resistance is of little concern, unlike in plane irons. I was told by a metal supplier that S7 was used for chisels ( I think that is its name, it was S something). When I looked up its properties, indeed it is very tough."

Survival chisel is an instrucitve concept. The survival knife varies from the everyday knire because one is cut off from one's full fascilities. The knife one designs for a situation where resharpening, ore replacement may be impossible, is different than the one one might choose in a kitchen. It's the same with chisels, the other stuff in the shop is important, from the fascility with which one can make chisels at the outset, through sharpening. It;s a cycle. If they were dispossible single use edge wear would be the only issue.

"Unless you are into do it your self for its rewards, I would encourage you to hire the heat treatment. There is no way you will get peak performance from steel without precise control of the heat treating process."

That's true, but easily handled at home. And if the HT isn't perfect you can just redo it any time you have 30 seconds.

I started with woodworking, and I am moving into metal working more and more. I already have pretty much every tool I really need, so even if the stuff I make is second rate, I am partly just filling in the areas where I never needed to buy store bought alternatives. I don't like carving all that much and never really ramped up for it, but having the ability to turn out chisels at will means I can make exactly what I want for pennies, the idea of 8 bucks for HT and 8 bucks for postage, and a month turn around just doesn't appeal.

I do think I can get result as good as a lot of very expensive tools I have bought over the years, but it isn't abosolutely necesarry.

Actually, another reason why it doesn't mater that much about edge retention is that while I would hand sharpen a Japanese chisel I paid say 300 for, I will happily grind and buff a home made chisel, so I am back in business much faster, the overall sharpness cycle is pretty much the same.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#28

Re: Two W1 square rod suppliers for toolmakers

ThomD

>Thanks, I may try that. They don't carry it up here as far as I can see. Importing from the US keeps getting harder... I do need some stuff from MSC.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#29

Ain't that the blessed truth...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>So I finally master inlaying gold into steel, and now I have to learn inlaying steel into gold. Great.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#30

I agree

Adam Cherubini

>I'm entralled by CPM, but I'm not sure its uber properties are exactly what I'm looking for.

I asked around at work about it. The view I got was that the Rockwell test indicates the matrix of CPM. Its actual hardness would be very much harder than the Rockwell test indicates. (because of the carbides?)

What I like are laminated blades, with their hard, fine grained edges and thick soft bodies (hey that sounds like some people I know!) because they're easy to sharpen. I'd like to see CPM in that sort of application so I wouldn't have to sharpen a 3/16" bevel of it.

That said, I like the idea of softer chisels on paper- here on the internet, because they are easier to sharpen. But ask me in the shop and I want the hardest tool known to man!

Adam

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#31

Re: Rat-kabob as only Todd can make it

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native now in Jax Fl.

>I'm wondering if it would be pssible to add more information to the "Todd Makes a Hewing Ax" link. I've seen this link numerous times now, and each time I always think that just a little more info would of made a world of difference. By adding just the length of time the piece was in the fire for each step, and to what approx temperture the piece was brought up to for each step would certainly turn this blacksmithing treatsie into almost a complete and fully functional "how-to" article.

Now I know that there are times when the piece has to really be soaked with heat to do a certain step, and other times it has to be brought up to White Hot like when the cutting edge is welded between the wrought iron sides.

Wasn't the Borax put onto the wrought iron sides/steel cutter after it was brought up to White Hot?

Is the last ax shown the actual ax that was made that day? I ask because the shape of the head is different than the one shown in a earlier picture.

I have on of Todd's mini axes, stood right there and watched him make it too boot, and I really love having it. I don't use it for chopping, but I show it off every chance I get to folks that I feel would appreciate it. I always say "Look what my buddy made for me" and they are simply amazed at how nice it is.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#32

Rat Story

todd hughes

>Boy that is a blast from the past eh? ...anyway I used to quench my knives in a metal container of vegatable oil which I sat a piece of tin on to keep out any rain water [leaky shop roof]. Befor quenching a knife I always liked to heat up the oil so less of a chance of the blade warping. I would do this by heating an iron bar up red hot and putting it into the oil. So one day when I did this I stick the red hot bar in the oil and when I pulled it out it had this long dead rat stuck on the end...the bar had burned right though it's stomach! Seems he feel into the oil couldn't get out and drowned.If I remember right actually found another one in it....Looked really nasty but sort of smelled like deep fried chicken.

Really miss blacksmithing and maybe one day will do it again...but to busy doing nothing right now....Todd

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#33

Re: OT How about them anvils?

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>You mean to tell me everybody`s anvil doesn`t look like that?

One of the things you find out about a dinged anvil is that ding will show up repeatedly in everything you make.Every time you hit the piece over that area the ding gets stamped into the work.Some folks just grind everything down as a final step so this doesn`t bother them.Others(myself included)try to take care around the anvil and keep it as smooth as possible.For rough work I used different scrap steel pieces or a junk anvil.The anvil I use for toolwork is smooth and free of large dings,especially in the most worked areas.Take a look at any above average autobody man`s toolbox(the real ones,not the bondo sloshers) and see if he doesn`t keep his collection of dollies as nice as dave`s anvils.

I suspect those small anvils Dave has are polished because they only see jewelry work done on them.Then again Dave probably has a fine enough touch to do whatever he pleases on the kitchen counter(provided it`s polished stone).

SWMBO always keeps a sharp eye on me whenever anything comes in from the shop.She only relaxes when it goes back out.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#34

PS

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>It goes without saying that the same holds true for hammer faces and forging tools like fullers,flatters,swages,etc.

Keep `em smooth if not polished for the finish work.

MB

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#35

Re: $60 oil and steel prices

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Tell me about it. We quoted on a huge job three years ago where we have to buy 2500 tonnes of steel - about 50% high alloy, remainder boilerplate. Contract was recently awared to us. Steel prices have doubled in many cases and in some cases we just can't get the material that we want at any price.

We're building a plant in China. The volume of construction occuring over there is just incredible.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#36

Re: PS

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Yes that is absolutely true. One of my responsibilities at the dealership where I work is to do the mechanical work for the body shop. All of the metal men have tools that look unused. The finess they have is phenomenal. But, I never see them rework the stuff, maybe they hire gnomes to do it after midnight:-)JR

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#37

Re: OT How about them anvils?

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Joe, small anvils like these aren't too hard to come by and shouldn't cost much. The larger of the two was about fifty cents a pound, as I recall. I come across small anvils now and then and if I find a nice one I'll let you know. Try Todd (Mrs. Deadhorse), too. Whatever you do, just make sure you don't get one of those awful soft-n-crumbly cast iron anvil-shaped-objects sold all over the place, esp. on eBay. The smaller anvil came from the Merchant of Ashby [unabashed gloat alert-->] along with four superbly forged silversmith's stakes, a big stake-holder, and the dolly-from-hell; a ancient, massive machined and hand-finished tool steel wedge that's more of an anvil than anything else and hard as a file. I can form damned near any shape I need on this singular wonder. Okay, steady yourself... sixty bucks for the entire lot. You can say what you want about Paddy, but he didn't get rich offa me.

Anyhow, Bob's absolutely dead-on right. Hammers get polished, wrapped in chamois, anvils, swages, mandrels and stakes get covered in kidskins. Humidity is kept skin-cracking low.

High-karat gold, silver, even copper comes off my forming tools so planished and smooth I have to rough 'em to take off the high shine. There really is no other way where 22k and 24k gold's concerned. Gilding your tools might look cool but four nines isn't getting any cheaper these days.

It doesn't matter whether the steel stakes and anvils you find are new and rust free or heavily 'patina-ed'. They all get fettled, shaped and progressively polished. Hammers often serve as stakes for small objects, too, so extra time is put into them on surfaces that might otherwise be though unused. If a raising hammer needs less slickness it can be matted back somewhat, but all are brought up to the highest finish first.

How metal flows on polished surfaces differs distinctly from less polished surfaces. Likewise, matting punches are distinct from planishers, and forming punches fall somewhere in-between. Rebound and hammer weight figure into the equation, too. A slower anvil can be very useful for controlled dimensioning. That little red guy has a lightning quick 'snap' to its action. Matched with the right hammer it can do extremely precise pointilistic work. The larger one is better for stretching and drawing out. By the way, my 200 lb. Trenton anvil is now as highly polished from horn to heel as these small anvils. Of course, I left all that gorgeous wrought-iron alone, so the contrast is fairly striking (pun unavoidable).

I use a lot of wood* for stakes, mandrels, mallets and punches and make up the most of my woodworking these days. Shaping them is one of those immensely pleasing right-brain activities and I get to play with my favorite woodworking tool group; rasps, rifflers, files and sanding sticks.

There's a common misconception that all silversmithing is done on metal forms. This is simply not so. Metal hammers on metal stakes, mallets (wood, rawhide, horn, plastics, soft metals) over metal stakes, mallets on wood or plastic stakes, and metal hammers over wood and plastic stakes are all valid and have their purposes at each stage. Wood mallets over lead shot or sand-filled bags is an essential technique. And yeah, I do use stone, too (jade blocks), but my kitchen counter's the wrong stuff.

___________________________

*Sugar maple, persimmon, boxwood, briar, LV, and so on, but softer woods such as white pine and linden, too.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#38

Ease of Sharpening is relative

Phil Smith

>Ease of sharpening depends on your point of view. We made a batch of CPM 3V iron this winter and I wound up grinding the bevels on about 30 CPM 3V and M4 irons, followed by putting a razor sharp edge on seveal of the irons. At the end of the grinding session I went back and reground the bevel on my LN and Clifton irons.

From my experience the high allow steels are much easier to grind to the edge on a regular grinding wheel, than the standard tool steels such as O1, or A2. You have to be very careful when grinding regular tools steels or you WILL CHANGE the hardness at the edge. The high alloy steels are tempered at much higher temperatures and are much more forgiving during grinding for mere mortals. Once you have a evely ground edge you can easily put a very sharp edge on the hollow ground bevel with with 1 micron diamond paste. Your are actually honing only a very small area of the bevel.

Just my prespective.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#39

A hammer question

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I had been meaning to ask about these before but it kept slipping my mind.

I picked up a couple of hammers awhile back(I`m a fool for a good hammer,aren`t we all)that look like odd planishing hammers in that they have very oversize round faces in one side of a decidedly small head.The other end is a small ball peen on one and a flat ended cone on the other.The handles are the real odd part they are long(about 18-20") and thin handles of straight grained ash with a bulbous end.

I`m assuming they were some type of planishing hammer but what`s with the other end and the odd handles?Can you shed any light on thier proper name,application,and hint on useage techniques.

I`d post pics but my son has the camera.He knows how to use it and I don`t.:^)

Mainely,Bob

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#40

Throwing out my cards!

Gary B in Central NY

>okay adam and tom,

thanks for all your input, and since we're on the topic, I figure everyone here may find this link interesting. This is the forge I plan to build.

http://64.176.180.203/washtubforge.htm

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#41

No reason to go underground with this thread...

Edward Damewood, Northern Alabama

>

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#42

Re: Very capable, very forgiving steel.

paul womack

>For really small stuff, W1 is nice to keep on hand;

I didn't know W1 was still around; I ADORE my old W1 woodie blades.

BugBear

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#43

O1, W1 and HSS... Questions

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Using O1 and W1 for small chisels and awls, how do they compare? Is one harder or tougher than the other? I had the impression that larger chisels needed to be made of O1 and tempered in oil because they had more of a tendency to warp if tempered in water. How would HSS compare with these two for use as small chisel, gouge, awl or plane blades?

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#44

Re: O1, W1 and HSS... Questions

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Ledgend says that W1 warped more because steam formed on the surface while quenching and caused the warping.Vigorous aggitation,adding salt,wetting agents,etc to the water helped overcome this to some extent.The truth is that W1 has always been alittle more trouble than O1 to deal with.You can quench W1 in oil and still get good results though.With practice W1 and O1 become pretty much equal as far as the forging and tempering part goes.

HSS is something else all together.Heat treating(HT) needs to be done by a pro with a proper(big bucks)furnace.The good news is that you can braze a piece of HSS to the edge of a tool and only lose a couple of points in hardness.One of the reasons HSS is used is because of it`s ability to retain hardness at elevated temps,the other is it`s wear resistance(which also makes it harder to sharpen).

I`ve used pieces of HSS and carbide to make all sorts of tools,to include turning tools and stone working tools.The body is usually made of either cold rolled or drill rod and the edge(the HSS/carbide) is either brazed or bolted in place.

O1 is such a relatively even tempered(pun intended)and easy to work steel that most any first timer can expect reasonable success.This it what makes it so attractive.The other steels require more finesse or HT by a pro so folks tend to shy away from them.Give toolmaking a try and before you know it you`ll be combing the dumps and scrapyards for old springs,crowbars,jackhammer bits,plow points,etc and hardly ever resort to buying from a catalog.

The only thing better than making your own tools is making them for absolutely zero cost(other than time)to you.

Mainely,Bob-Who`s teaching his youngest son how to make his own knives.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#45

HSS defined and elaborated, chisel criteria

bill tindall

>The name, high speed steel, simply means the steel retains its properties at hight temperature, a factor only of relevance to us during machine sharpening. Within this category the important properties-hardness, toughness and abrasion resistance(wear)- can vary widely.

It is very easy to decide what steel makes the best chisels. Chisels get dull by deforming or micro-chipping, not abrasion. So hardness-resistance to bending- and toughness-resistance to chipping- are the critical factors to consider.

All these steels can be hardened to Rc60 and above so only toughness needs to be considered in selecting the best steel for chisels. With better toughness, at equal hardness, one can successfully use the chisel at steeper bevel angles, desirable for ease of penetration.

I can appreciate that some people like messing with metal so their ability to mess with it (heat treat, and/or forge) becomes important in selecting steels to use for a project. Others tolerate the messing part to in the end obtain either/or better and cheaper tools.

If your goal is simply to make the best chisels possilble then search for the toughest steel possible at Rc 60 or greater. There is little metal in a chisel so the cost of the metal is unimportant. It costs the same to heat treat any of the tool steels so this factor is unimportant too. And they all can be sawed with nearly the same ease. They all can be sharpened to the same degree.

I found that M2 suffered micro-chipping at 25 degree bevel angles and hence didn't make a very good chisel. This was but one sample in this experiement so the conclusion is tentative.

Bottom line, if you want the best chisels use the toughest steel you can find. Best is defined as ability to use at the steepest bevel angle for ease of penetration.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#46

Re: O1, W1 and HSS... Questions

Gary B in Central NY

>"Give toolmaking a try and before you know it you`ll be combing the dumps and scrapyards for old springs,crowbars,jackhammer bits,plow points,etc and hardly ever resort to buying from a catalog"

Ok now, how do I know how to quench this salvaged steel. does it matter? This is definately appealing to me. how do I know it it will be high carbon? I don't want to save a few bucks but end up with an inferior tool. any tips are appreciated.

Gary

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#47

Junkyard steel

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>The local blacksmith would probably hold the steel to a grinder and do the "spark test" to tell what it was.

For a beginner the best way to get started would be to invest in a book such as "Toolmaking for Woodworkers" by Ray Larsen(sp)of Genuine Forgery or New Edge of the Anvil or the Alexander Weygers compilation of his 3 books.I`d give you ISBN`s but they`re loaned out just now.

The web is loaded with good info from many groups and individuals.Blacksmiths and knifemakers abound.

If all else fails you can always ask here and Todd H,me,or some other smith can probably answer the question.

BTW-old springs,crowbars,sawblades,files,etc are a good source of HCS that can be quenched in oil and then tempered to make surprisingly good WWing tools.Just like recycling your old ripsaw into cabinet scrapers you can recycle alot of old WWing tools too.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#48

Chasing chasing hammers (long) *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Bob notes: "The handles are the real odd part. They are long (about 18-20") and thin handles of straight grained ash with a bulbous end."

And asks: "I`m assuming they were some type of planishing hammer but what`s with the other end and the odd handles? Can you shed any light on thier proper name,application,and hint on useage techniques?"

You know, I'm sure I had a couple pictures of hammers like that somewhere on my hard drive but I sure can't find them now -- not too surprising considering my 80-gigabyte archive of tool and craft photographs. Of course, I may've incorrectly visualized your description of the conical poll.

The longish handles are unusual but not unheard of for chasing, and I've seen them used on large silver platters (in photographs from the large New England silver companies, c.1900), perhaps to avoid turning trays repeatedly (chasers often work opposing edges in alternating 'star' or rose fashion). The typical broad, flat or slightly domed face is often used for chasing, engraving, and planishing, too, so you're apt to find an amazing amount of variation in these old hammers*. The shaft can be very thin and whippy while the bulb could be big as an onion.

On hammers used for setting fragile gems I'm apt to use very light heads with an 8-degree forward cant, thin (around 5mm) medium-length shafts with a forward swept derringer grip. Specialized uses and idiosyncratic techniques are the rule, so it's not surprising to find just about anything.

The chasing hammer in my earlier photo is a 1 1/8" diameter face (downward-raked ball-pein opposing poll) Peddinghaus with ash handle. I removed quite a bit of wood as soon as I got it so now it's okay for medium-sized repousse in 20-22 gauge fine silver. You have to 'tune' each handle so you don't get that perfectly controlled crisp bounce without a shadow tap.

Most folks think that the whippy shaft is to establish a rhythm or to save the wrist. Both are secondary to getting the right distribution of energy through the tool, whether it be punch, chisel or graver. Matching pitch to metal to hammer is key. In repousse work the goal is to move the metal rather than thin it. Also, the wide face is not so much to avoid missing the punch, as is often believed as to allow normalization of energy from a variety of angles in both stroke and attack, hence the parallel poll thickness from center to edge.

Often the balance and weight of a chasing hammer can give clues as to its use. I like mine slightly weight forward for punch work but about 50-50 for tapping down bezels and prongs with punches. A particularly heavy hammer might've been for engraving guns*** where the gravers are shaped and struck like chisels to cleanly cut into steel. But even these heads can seem surprisingly light, as engraving in steel, while demanding significantly more moment, is still remarkably delicate work.

Oops! There I go again, and this isn't even woodworking. Sorry 'bout that. Problem is, I could easily go 30+ pages on chasing hammers alone until my kidneys say otherwise. On the woodworking part of these handles, one could get into the complexities of choosing, orienting and shaping** for spine strength, fast or slow action, 'snap', and so on (BTW, the index finger atop the shaft serves as a controlling fulcrum, spring, aims, and provides partial locomotion). Rats, there's another 10 pages, probably. I'll stop.

________________________________________

*Almost all modern chasing hammers are remarkably similar, varying only in degree of finish, handle quality and weight, of which there are far less than yesteryear. As one might suspect, Japanese chasing hammers differ from Western, generally have longer handles and are more often square. Some are very nice indeed.

**Or bamboo, graphite, fiberglass (think fly rods).

***I've linked a picture of a famous gun engraver's craftsman-made chasing hammer. Note the rather heavier and normal handle with a nearly conical poll, much more weight-forward than a stone-setter's or jeweler's hammer.


Lynton McKenzie's chasing hammer

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#49

Tweak...

David Barnett - SW Florida

>"so you don't get" should read "so you get".

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#50

One other possibility, Bob... *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>You might have older sheet metal hammers. One pattern of planisher is the bodyworker's 'pick' hammer. Just covering another possibility.


Large-ended 'pick' hammer