Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

Posts

Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#1

Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

Gary B in Central NY

>Hey everyone,

before I go take the "plunge" of becoming and self sufficient hermit and making my own tools, how good of an edge, both in terms of retention and sharpness, can I expect out of a homemade 0-1 tool steel blade (chisels, knives, whatever). All this assuming I properly heat treated it of course. Can I get as good an edge as I do out of my blue marples chisels? That's all I'm really interested in. I don't mind sharpening so I don't need A2 edge retention. Thanks everybody.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#2

O-1 steel will work well for you

Steve Elliott

>You can make a very good tool using O-1, and it is one of the easier steels to heat treat without high-tech equipment. You'll be able to get a very keen edge with better edge retention than Marples chisels, which in my opinion are way too soft.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#3

Very capable, very forgiving steel.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>One nice thing, as long as you don't outright immolate the stuff into sparks, you can reheat, reshape, retreat until you get it the way you want it. Recycles well. You can even water quench small to medium pieces if you run out of oil (helps to keep the forms not too radical -- no squirrely thicks to thins). Cuts smoothly with handtools (hacksaws, jeweler's saws, files, sanding sticks) when properly annealed. For really small stuff, W1 is nice to keep on hand; esp. 'square drill rod'. Way cheaper than precision ground O1, too. I love 'em both.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Pretty Simple stuff

Jim in Burlington On

>It's super easy to heat treat yourself. After you heat and quench it the Label says you get 63-64 Rockwell. As for tempering all I do is put it in a old electric frypan set at 350 for 45 minutes take it out let it cool and your all set. Certainly every tool I've made from 01 is leaps and bounds better then my blue chips ever were.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#5

I have to echo the 'Blue Chip' chisel remarks.

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Like Goldilocks, I've found three distinct Blue Chip characters, the rarest being "just right". The problem seems to be the coarse grain and distribution of carbides. I've rehandled a few after rehardening and tempering (you have to -- those moulded handles, you know), and I have about four that are now pretty darned usable. No, they're not Swans, Witherby, or even old Stanley, but I use 'em a lot and they don't chip like before. Now I can get them really sharp but they stay that way longer, too. Still, I had to try two or three times, hit or miss to get them this way. In my case, a very saturated brine quench in still water with some added wetting agent (laboratory type or Basic-I) aids the process. O-1, though, seems to have about the best all-round mix of qualities and yields satisfactory results over a wide range of conditions. So get a quench tub of peanut oil and a rat and go for it.

As I mentioned before, though, I really like W1. It has a small and homogenous grain that hones easily, gets VERY sharp and stays that way long enough to do good work. It's about as simple a steel as one can get; not doped anywhere like more complex modern steels, but it's good stuff, nonetheless. As for heat treating and quenching, just don't make anything too thin, although one of my more pleasant serendipities is a superb 'hook' carver/scorp, heh. Cut-style concrete nails are often W1 and a box of these can make some sweet fishtail gouges for detail work and lettering.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#6

We have lots of gophers - will those work?

Bill Houghton, sunny yahoo! in Sebastopol, CA

>What do you use the rat for? Or is this some blacksmith's term?

Bill, picturing a rat with a really little sledge hammer, forging chisels

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#7

maybe a more socially acceptable form of quenching

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Bill,

Since the japanese swordmakers used to (allegedly) use condemned prisoners or slaves who weren't working too well to quench the blades of a samurai sword, ...

Perhaps a rat would be an option you could use these days with a chisel?

Cheers,

Andrew

(who doesn't like rats)

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#8

Re: We have lots of gophers - will those work?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>This is an allusion to a story Todd tells. Unknown to Tood, a rat had fallen into his barrel of quenching oil, drowned, and sank to the bottom. Later, when forging a piece of steel, he plunged it into the oil, and skewered the rat. I'm sure you can imagine his shock on pulling the blade out. I've been told that BBQ'd rat works just about as well as plunging the red hot blade through the heart of a living slave.

On the Cohansey, we prefer woodchucks and muskrats.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#9

Rat-kabob as only Todd can make it *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Deep-fried* guinea pig (Cuy -- Google it) is the rage in Ecuador (and has been for millenia), of course, and presented spread-eagle like a crispy flying squirrel atop a big platter of papas fritos with a little indigenous hot sauce and a few shots of aguardiente, it'll almost take the chill out of that high Andean air.

Anyway, Todd's the one to ask for his recipe rodentia impromptu.

__________________________

*Spit-roasted and baked in a clay oven ain't all that bad, either.


Rattus rattus skewered in aged peanut oil teaser

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#10

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

ThomD

>Really nice stuff. There is better stuff, by a tiny fraction, but I use O1 because it is easily available. While heat treating it is A,B,C, there are all the other letters of the alphabet waiting for your exploration.

Even your Marples can be improved on with re-heat treating.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#11

Re: I have to echo the 'Blue Chip' chisel remarks.

ThomD

>You are right about W1. The challenge is finding the stuff, around here anyway. Seems to turn up in odd places, I was told some electrician's fish tapes are W1, though also heard it ia 1070. Old files, if you have them...

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#12

Reducing grain size

Adam Cherubini

>Theorhetically you can reduce crystal size by cold working the edge before heating.

I recently built a gas forge (which really hasn't been that successful) and tried heat treating and forging. I thought forging temperature and heat treating temperatures were similar (I got a D in this class in college). I was off by about 500 degrees! You can easily heat treat small parts with a MAPP gas torch. I recommend skipping blacksmith hokum and buying yourself a tempilstik. 1600 should do for most steels you will use. Tempilstiks cost about $20 each. I recommend tempering in an electric oven, so you only need one tempilstik.

Adam

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#13

Re: Reducing grain size

Gary B in Central NY

>Adam,

you may have to whack me in the head with this one, but what is a tempilstik?!? is it a digital thermometer? (no contact) thanks.

Gary

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#14

Re: Reducing grain size

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Adam,

Another way to tell that steel is at the right temperature to quench for maximum hardness is that it is no longer magnetic when it reaches the appropriate temperature. Check with a magnet, if there is no attraction it is ready (then remember the color of the steel for the next time).

Jim

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#15

Tempilstick

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>These are just crayons that you mark the steel with and then they melt at the temp you need.They are available in a wide variety of temps so they cover everything from pre and post heating to forging temps.Look for them at the local welding supply.

MB

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#16

Re: Reducing grain size

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Adam,

You may want to re-check your info.Most folks who forge tools refer to this process as "packing" and it`s done after the forging and at a dull red heat(almost no glow at all).

Stoneworkers used to use carbon steel chisels and refered to them as "firesharps" for this very reason.

Working tempered CS while cold usually leads to fracturing unless backed by a soft steel layer like you see on Japanese chisels and plane irons.The soft steel allows them to be "tapped out" when the hollow on the back of your plane iron meets up with the edge.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#17

Re: Reducing grain size

ThomD

>There isn't a 500 degree temp difference between forging and HT heats, the actual difference is steel specific, but is probably closer to 200 degrees, and it is a range from the upper transformation range on up. If you forge at very high temps even within that range, you can affect the carbon content and edge holding. Some guys therefore prefer to forge in a "cold" range hardly above the trans point, and you need enough hammer to make that work. Of course Blacksmiths do weld in those upper temperatures.

Most smiths don't mess with templesticks etc... except if they want to check the thermocouple they use, or their electric furnace. The magnet method is probably the best. It works for all basic steels even though the HT temp for any of them might be quite different, and since one doesn't necesarilly know even what the steel is... To use the templesticks, you have to know what the steel is and have the right stick for it. No biggie, but neither is going non-magnetic and then sticking it back in for 20 seconds.

The place where people seem to go wrong with the magnet is that the trans temp isn't always at magnetic, sometimes it is 50 degrees above, as it is for O1. One just needs to leave the steel in for a short heat after the steel goes non-magnetic. I look for any degree of perceptible colour change above what it was before I pulled it out to test it. The other place people go wrong is too slow into the quench, or not the right quench, etc... O1 tends to be forgiving about a lot of this except the fact it needs a little over magnetic.

I can help you with the propane forge thing...

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#18

Forging temperatures

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>There isn't a 500 degree temp difference between forging and HT heats

It really is/can be about 500 dF. I've been going back and forth between the metalurgists at work, and the smiths at Williamsburg to sort this all out. The Wmsburg smiths forge (shape) at orange or yellow which is above 2000F. I can barely make out a color change at 1600. The steel is just starting to turn red. I think you're right that people can shape steel at lower temperatures. I can't. I guess I just figured the critical temperature for heat treating was near melting temperature- like 10,000F or something.

The magnet method is probably the best.

Here's the skinny on the magnet. When you look at the graph for steel, the critical temperature (change from martensite to autenite ) is shaped like a funnel. The tip of the funnel (eutectoid) represents the steel that undergoes phase change first (.77% Carbon). That temperature is roughly 1350F. So above 1350 or so, all steels become non-magnetic. But high carbon steel or really low carbon steel won't become all austenite until at least 1600 or higher (depending on the alloy). So the magnet is a technically sloppy approach that doesn't guarantee that you are where you think you are.

The place where people seem to go wrong with the magnet is that the trans temp isn't always at magnetic, sometimes it is 50 degrees above

That's my understanding. You've got this all sorted Thom!

I can help you with the propane forge thing...

Thanks. I'll email you offline.

Adam

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#19

Re: Reducing grain size

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>You may want to re-check your info. Most folks who forge tools refer to this process as "packing" and it`s done after the forging

Don't do this to me, Bob. I'm not kidding man, I have this mental block on this subject. I got a D first time I took this class. I took it over and got a C. I think my prof took pity on me. I ask these questions of the best people in their fields- our guys at work who are the best and the smiths at Wmsburg. Trouble is, I don't always understand their answers.

My guess is as long as that "packing" is done under the critical temp, it may be considered cold work.

Adam

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#20

Re: Tempilstick

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>I've heard people say tempilsticks are like crayons. Tempilstick is a trade name and I have a tempilstick and its a lot more like a piece of chalk in an aluminum tube like the one my anal retentive high school math teacher used. It makes no mark on cold steel whatsoever. I keep pulling the steel out and writing on it. When the temperature is reached, the chalk melts and feels like a crayon.

Adam

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#21

chisels are all about toughness

W. Tindall

>The most important factor for chisels is toughness at high hardnesss. You want an edge that will resist deforming as well as chipping while bashing the chisel. Abrasion resistance is of little concern, unlike in plane irons. I was told by a metal supplier that S7 was used for chisels ( I think that is its name, it was S something). When I looked up its properties, indeed it is very tough.

If you are going to the trouble to make chisels I would encourage you to look into CPM 3V tool steel. Nothing else is as tough at high hardness. We have several posts on the Badger Pond archives about making chisels from this material. various club members and others have made dozens with excellent results.

Unless you are into do it your self for its rewards, I would encourage you to hire the heat treatment. There is no way you will get peak performance from steel without precise control of the heat treating process.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#22

Two W1 square rod suppliers for toolmakers *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Water quench (W1) cold drawn 'square drill rod' can be ordered from MSC and ToolAndDie in thicknesses from 1/16" through 1". ToolAndDie gives quantity breaks at three pieces or more. On the other hand, MSC sends out 20%-off coupons a couple times a year, so I usually wait and buy a big bundle of my most-used sizes.

Of course, round W1 drill rod can be found at nearly any industrial or metals supply and costs even less than square, but it sure is easier to start with square if you need square.

Although not precision ground like most O1, these bars are smooth, straight, twist-free and entirely useful, and considering the MSC cost for three feet of 1/4" square W1 at $4.51, compared to unnamed O1 at 21.65 and Starrett O1 at $31.65*, well...

If anyone has another supplier, please chime in.

MSC (Manhattan Supply Corporation):

http://mscdirect.com/ (wouldn't you know, MSC's site is down right now, so I'll just suggest browsing catalog section '9' (raw materials) or search using keywords: W1, square, "cold drawn", and so on.

_________________________________________

*ToolAndDie lists 1/4" square W1 at $4.31 for singles, $3.82 for 3+, and 1/4" O1 at $20.61, both Timken Latrobe (Koncor).

Cheap thrills -- my dwindling stash of W1 (the square stock doesn't start out shiny).


img

ToolAndDie.com W1

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#23

Re: Tempilstick

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>Shows you how long it`s been since I bought any.

The old ones used to be like lumber crayons(some call them keel) and even had the paper label like them.Talked to a friend who bought some within the last 5 years and he says they now come in a metal tube like you describe.

The only use I had for them was to pre and post heat for welding things like cast iron and aluminum when the preheat needed to be more precise than sooting would allow.

MB

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#24

Re: chisels are all about toughness

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Crucible's got a winner, all right. It's nearly impossible to chip this stuff. And tough as it is, high-speed rotary burrs will give amazingly clean cuts, which is why I use it for my hallmarks and maker's marks. Nothing cheap about it, of course, but in the amounts I use it's a bargain. These punches should easily outlive me. As for heat treat, I've had no problems in a well-controlled oven. It's not that difficult, esp. for such small workpieces.

CPM 3V's superb for survival knives, so yeah, it should make one heck of a survival chisel.

Re: Comparitive edge quality of o-1 steel

#25

$60 oil and steel prices

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>I have noticed my steel prices going north in the past year. Waaaaay up.