Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

Posts

Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#1

Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, everyone -

I'm converting an old 6" coffin smoother to a compass plane. The body's been reconfigured, and I'm wondering what I should do for a finish. An old David Charlesworth article suggests soaking the body in raw linseed oil. This plane was nearly pristine when I got it, looking almost completely unused, but the wood seems a little dry, so the concept seems reasonable to me.

Anyone have any experience with this? Where'm I to pick up raw linseed oil (dePot/Lowe's, or order)? Any other alternatives?

Thanks,

Scott

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

Jim in Burlington On

>I wouldn't use raw oil. It never dries and stinks forever memories of childhood baseball gloves. Much prefer to wipe on a few coats of boiled either tung or linseed oil and a nice coat of bees wax.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#3

I agree

Ron in Kokomo

>I'd keep smearing BLO on ity until it no longer absorbs. Probaby 6 or seven light coats.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#4

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

ThomD

>Or Watco. Has a drier in it, but it is said to be foodsafe. But the other stuff works also, as long as it is a drying oil.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#5

I wouldn't

Larry Williams

>Use an oil finish, preferably one that doesn't expand as it dries. The best thing I've found is plain old Minwax Antique Oil.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#6

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

Todd Hughes

>Just have to ask why you would take a rare plane like this to turn into a compass plane when you could use other more common planes that would probably work just as well....doesn't make sense to me...Todd

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#7

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>I dunno - so rare it turns up on ebay every other day it seems. Got it for about $4 plus shipping. Needed a small compass plane, bought two 6" smoothers, both in near-mint condition, and converted the one that was less nice. Beats the $85 Crown version by my budget. What other plane is better suited to conversion into a short, compact compass plane, than a short, compact smoother? I guess your reply didn't give me much information, other than "You're wrong". Which I'd already guessed.

What makes this an intrinsically valuable plane? I'd asked this a while back, and received next to no replies.

Thanks,

Scott

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#8

Common plane Uncommon Condition

Todd Hughes

>In my experance buying [and selling] tools for many years to find an older wooden smoother that is in "nearly Pristine" "almost completely unused condition" is a very rare find.Maybe I need to get out more but I sure don't see them in this condition as most saw hard usage...and show it.By the way Molding planes are much more common to find in excellent condition as they normaly saw less use.

...You didn't mention the maker I don't think but I am sort of surprised that these near mint 100 year plus old wood smoothing planes are so common on the ebay and go for so cheap.I've sold well used ones on it for more then $4 in the past....Todd

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#9

Re: Common plane Uncommon Condition

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>Hi, Todd -

The body of this, and the other one I got, show some dirt, but no wear or checking at all. The first plane I got was stamped "Foreign", and this one was stamped "British Made". I posted about the foreign plane a while back, and the response I got was that it was likely German-made for export to Britain. Also that it was rather late, somewhere in the late 20's or so. I'm guessing that the "British Made" stamp distinguishes this one from those imported.

The mouth on the 'German' plane is nice and tight, so I kept it for use as a smoother. The iron of the British plane was blunt, even though the body seemed unused, so it was the candidate for regrinding. There was some rust on the iron, and the back had been polished. Made me wonder if the iron wasn't original, but it works perfectly with the wedge and the body.

Scott

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#10

I would

David

>I've done this a lot and will continue to do so. The trick to keep it from being sticky is to cut the BLO half and half with REAL turpentine (not turpatine which is naptha and really does leave an unpleasant odor). Real turpentine is hard to find and kind of expensive - maybe $15/gal - look in the yellow pages for a paint store that sells to contractors.

The other recommended surface treatments are fine but, IMO, nothing restores dried, checked wood like this - I leave it in, making sure it is completely submerged, for at least a couple weeks. when you pull it out, wipe it down liberally with the real turpentine and let it dry a couple more weeks - the wood is good to go for another couple hundred years.

I had a very dry transitional almost double in weight by doing this - it is my favorite user.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#11

Re: I would

Larry Williams

>David, I'm glad you feel you had success with this. There are reasons, though, I would avoid it.

Most importantly, these old planes are the product of hundreds of years of evolution. Even the shape of the coffin smooth plane contributes to its stability. Wood selection is important to, beech is used and oriented such that it rapidly moves moisture to and from the core of the plane. Interfering with this is, IMO, like gluing panels in place when using frame and panel construction--it defeats the whole design.

Linseed oil also expands as it dries similar to other oil finishes I've used on planes. When absorbed into the ends of the rays which are exposed on flat-sawn surfaces, it can cause checking as it expands when drying. I found it terribly frustrating at times to lose a plane to finish expansion. Too see how much linseed expands, pour a little in the bottom of a jar and let it dry. It won't dry to a smooth surface, the surface will be heavily alligatored by ridges formed when it expanded and was pushed up.

Linseed oil supports fungal growth. My first bench turned almost black after a few years and was finished with boiled linseed oil. Looking at 19th Century planes that have had this treatment, one finds that same fungal growth as well as a layer of dried leached out oil on surfaces that weren't subjected to wear. This is especially true of end grain surfaces. I've seen instances of it covering the bed of a plane where it created problems with seating the iron after the iron has been sharpened down a little from the length it was during the initial treatment.

What I want in a finish is a relatively permeable coating that protects the wood. Just a couple coats of a nonexpanding oil with a light sanding between them and a good buffing of the final coat will allow sufficient moisture to pass through to allow a beech plane to quickly reach equilibrium in changing humidity. It's a little like frame and panel construction, the idea is to work with the wood instead of fighting its properties.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#12

Is it possible...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...that the reason raw linseed oil was suggested is to bypass the issues occuring with drying?

Thanks for the detailed input, Larry. A few coats of BLO it is.

Scott, butcher of fine planes since 2006

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#13

A point

Dan Donaldson

>I have a couple of Larry's planes and whatever he uses to finish them works. I must be in a climate similar to where they are made, but I have had basically zero problems with movement or going out of flat.

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#14

Agree

Wiley Horne

>The C&W planes are amazingly stable, and our weather in So. Calif. is very different from Eureka Springs, Arkansas. It seems to be as Larry says--the design allows the plane block to equilibrate quickly with seasonal weather changes, so that the plane holds its shape even though the wood's moisture content is changing. Moisture gradients do not build up in the wood, but quickly pass through.

Wiley

Re: Finish for beech plane - oil soak?

#15

Me, too.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>