Re: I had a positive impression becasue.....
Sgian Dubh
>You are correct Bill. As ever there is always more than one way to skin a cat.
The debate over the advantages of various options seems never to cease--- back bevels, grinding angles, sharpening angles (aka micro bevels) crowned (rounded) cutting edges, or straight cutting edges with a rounding off at the corners are all options... and more.
Interestingly this thread has turned into a discussion about which of the commonly espoused blade profiles works best for creating edge joints, viz, straight edge with rounded corners or crowned cutting edge. In my experience both work equally well if the worker has developed the necessary technique.
My try plane, in common with nearly all of my planes has an iron sharpened straight across with rounding off at each corner. I say it's straight, but it may be a bit off because I don't measure to see if there's a crowned edge. On the whole though I'd say I get the blade pretty close to straight.
I'll suggest another couple of wrinkles on edge joint preparation I use that I don't think I've yet seen mentioned. When I'm using the try plane right handed which I most often do to prepare an edge, if the edge to the right face of the board as I look at from the end that I plane from is high I usually do one of two things.
1. Move the plane to the right side of the board's edge and take a half width shaving. This means part of the edge to the left is not covered by the sole of the plane nor cut by the iron. A stroke or two like this can be followed up by taking a full width shaving to hopefully bring the full width of the edge back into square with the face.
2. The second technique is to pysically tilt the plane by half a degree or more to the right as required and plane a new reference surface square to the face of the board. I'm not quite sure how I developed the ability to tilt a plane reasonably accurately to a requisite correcting angle-- all I know is that I can do it most of the time, and I realised sometime in the late 1970's or early 1980's that this was what I was doing to correct edges that were off square.
Apart from commonly suggested techniques to create a slight hollow in the length of an edge for a sprung joint, e.g., emulating an aeroplane landing and taking off again, another trick is to bend the sole of the plane in the length as a shaving is taken. I believe that by twisting the wrists hard towards each other as you plane you can bend the sole of a No. 7 metal plane slightly concave or convex-- not a lot maybe but enough I think to make a difference to the thickness of a shaving. 3" or 4" into the length of a long edge I twist my wrists together in an effort to create a slightly convex sole, and near the end of the cut I relax the twisting. This does seem to result in a shaving that starts thin, gets thicker in the middle and thins off again at the end of the cut.
These techniques certainly work for me, but I've no idea if anyone else has found anything similar when using their planes. Slainte.