Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

To camber or not to camber

Posts

Re: To camber or not to camber

#26

Re: To camber or not to camber

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, now, Alan, this is a very interesting response. It has been posited that people are very receptive to speeches made by those politicians with whom they tend to align; whereas the same speech made by the "other side" elicits boos and catcalls by those same people. I find this to be true for myself and it's a tendency I try very hard to fight; but I still find myself yelling at the TV from time to time.

However, in woodworking there is no "other side" as nearly as I can tell. As Bill said above, there are always many ways of doing things, all of them valid.

So it sounds like you already like and associate yourself with Rob and David; therefore, anyone who attacks their way of doing things attacks you, and it's all personal.

Pam

Re: To camber or not to camber

#27

Re: To camber or not to camber

Joel

>"The idea behind a chambered blade is that the sole of the plane is in contact with wood 100% when edge jointing, if the edge is not square all you have to do is move the plane over , if there was no chamber the plane would have to be tilted which would result in only a small percentage of the plane sole being in contact with the wood (or I suppose you could tilt the iron in the plane)"

huh?

if the edge is not square and your blade is not cambered just move the plane over and plane square - don't tilt the plane - it don't work if you do.

with a cambered blade you do the same thing except the effect is a little faster in some cases.

when you are all done with a flat blade you have a flat edge. With a cambered blade you have to remember to center the plane so the concavity is symetric.

Both methods work, both have pluses and minuses, I find a straight blade much easier to use and maintain but that's just me.

To a large extent it depends on which way you were trained and once you get into the habit it's just automatic behaviour which ever way you know how. THe trick of course is practice and getting into the habit.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#28

Re: To camber or not to camber

arw01

>Pam:

As you say human nature is hard to resist. Since we are all colored by our experience, thought of expertise, and specifically genetic programming, most advise is well intentioned to cut the course length "of the school of hard knocks".

Myself, I'm more pratical, and curious for that matter.

In the case of the professor, I'd have to agree with David and that the opinion is nothing more than bigotry.

One of these days I'll either buy some LN, or get luck on Ebay for flat sided bedrocks. :)

Alan

Re: To camber or not to camber

#29

Re: To camber or not to camber

VTAndy

>Hi Joel,

Forgive my newbie self asking a question that is probably obvious! In your post, you propose using a blade on which "the edge is not square and your blade is not cambered," and that when the edge of the board being planed isn't square, you just move the plane over. I have read David Charlesworth's books, and I thought that that is the method he described. Can you (or someone, anyone) please tell me the difference between a blade with cambers and a blade on which "the edge is not square" -- I thought that this 'easing off' at the corners, accomplished by pushing a bit harder during honing, as done on Rob Cosman's videos, was the same thing as "cambering," but evidentally I'm mistaken. Thanks.

-Andy

PS: is it the difference between a fully rounded edge, like a scrub blade but not as extreme, and a flat edge on which the corners are slightly rounded?

Re: To camber or not to camber

#30

Re: To camber or not to camber

Paul Kierstead

>if the edge is not square and your blade is not cambered just move the plane over and plane square - don't tilt the plane - it don't work if you do.

with a cambered blade you do the same thing except the effect is a little faster in some cases.

Ok, I really don't follow you here. When you do this with a cambered blade, you leave the planes sole flat to the edge (in full contact). Now if you do this with a straight (un-cambered) blade, I can see no way that moving the plane to one side or the other will correct the out-of square edge; you will continue to take an even shaving and thus continue with the same angle as before. To correct an out of square edge, you have to have some some method of taking a tapered shaving (i.e. thicker on one side). I suspect you are saying you have to hold the plane square to the board; this is not necessary for the cambered method (where the plane just has to be held in full contact with the edge), and is really the fundamental difference between the two.

Good example: http://www.amgron.clara.net/planingpoints/edgeplaning/squareedgeindex.htm

Re: To camber or not to camber

#31

Re: To camber or not to camber

Paul Kierstead

>Of course, I should have added, you could be referring to using the adjustment lever, which then allows the full-contact-with-the-edge method with a straight blade, but that still wouldn't require moving the plane over, unless I guess the angle of the blade was so much that it had no projection on one side....

Re: To camber or not to camber

#32

Re: To camber or not to camber

Joel

>straight blade, set square - really simple - IIRC documented in Ellis modern practical joinery amongst other places - I will try to write a proper set of instructions later today.

joel

Re: To camber or not to camber

#33

Re: To camber or not to camber

tonyr

>this is a serious question -- what is the difference btw. rounding the corners of a plane iron and cambering the blade? i thought that it was basically the same thing? thx for the insight. tony.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#34

Re: To camber or not to camber

tonyr

>joel -- i think that you are going to address this question in your next post, but just in case, let me pose it: how is it possible to get a flat board without plane tracks (its the latter that i don't get) with a perfectly square blade (ie, one not cambered/not slightly rounded at corners (not sure what the difference is btw. these two))? thanks, tony. ps: ever hear back from colen re: the marking gauge?

Re: To camber or not to camber

#35

Re: To camber or not to camber (LONG)

Joel

>2 ways to square up an edge joint:

(Hopefully the comparison makes sense.)

Using a Cambered Iron:

You start out with the situation in A (see picture below) where the plane is symmetric but for some reason the edge is not square. By sliding over the plane (B) the a thicker shaving is cut evening out the edge. At all times the plane is bearing down on the entire surface of the wood. As you plane and reach square you must even out the cut (C) or you will end up taking too much off the side that was originally high. The advantage of this method of work is that the plane is always held stable against the edge and is easily controlled. The method is easy to learn as it requires no specific subjective ability. It is easy to do with modern heavy, low-center of gravity planes. The disadvantage is that depending on the camber of the blade and the amount you are out it is easy to plane a tilt in the opposite direction if you are not constantly checking square. The minimum correction is the amount of the camber on the iron which limits the potential accuracy of the joint (not a problem if you only have a very slight camber on the iron). If the wood still needs thicknessing after you are done the concavity in the edge from the camber on the iron might cause a visible glue joint. Since you re using the existing edge of the wood to guide the plane when you first start to plane the edge square you have to see how much out of square the edge is before planing so you can position your plane to compensate. (you can mimic the effect of using a cambered iron just by tilting a straight iron but this seems to me to be the worst of both worlds).

Using a Straight Iron:

Hold the plane square to the ground (see note below) with just one side of the plane on the high part of the edge to be corrected (1). Plane straight. You get a narrow shaving that gets progressively wider (2). If your plane isn�t held perfectly straight since it is only planing one side of the board (us a finger on the side of the plane as a fence) you won�t get full width shavings anyway and the result is okay. When you get full width shavings (3) � stop you are square. The advantages of this method is speed; once you can plane square you don�t have to worry about planing to much past square, or need to constantly check for square. It can be amazingly accurate. You get a square glue joint. Holding the plane square from the start results in a square edge that, hopefully, will need little if any correction. The disadvantages are primarily you need to develop the feel for holding a plane square. This isn�t hard to do but hard to explain but certainly is less repeatable in a class with beginners. Holding a plane square is harder with modern planes with heavier castings and a low center of gravity.

Both methods have pluses and minuses. Both are reliable.

Note: I was taught to hold a plane square by Larry Williams. Hold a full glass of water and walk across the room � you won�t spill it. Humans have an innate sense of balance and square. Hold your plane in the air. You should be holding it square. It is much easier to hold a plane square if it is light and high � like a wooden plane. With wooden planes the effect of square is so pronounced planing square is really easy to master. With regular Stanley planes the center of gravity is lower and the plane is heavier � giving less feedback. Long infill planes have a high center of gravity but a lot of weight which masks the effect. With modern planes with heavier casting the effect is lower still. With practice however any style of plane can be easily held square it�s just a matter of training oneself to be aware of the balance it�s just easier with wooden planes. And it�s like riding a bike, once you get the hang of it, it�s automatic.

(sorry about the very rough sketch � I hope it�s clear enough)


img

Re: To camber or not to camber

#36

Re: To camber or not to camber

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>By definition (not necessarily in practice), a cambered iron has the same radius all the way across the edge, while the other has an infinite radius across most of the edge, and much tighter radii at the corners.

A perfectly straight blade is mostly useful for jointing, because the corners of the blade don't touch the wood in this application, and therefore cannot leave tracks.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#37

Re: To camber or not to camber

Joel

>A cambered iron is an iron with a gentle curve along the entire iron. How much curve depends on the application. For jointers the amount is my training is nil. For jack planes a good bit. For smooth planes a tiny bit. Some people just knock the corners off the sides of a smoothing iron. It works but not as well as a camber.

THe short answer to your question is no. In theory you can but it's harder than having a slight camber. However the camber (for appearances sake) is very slight and only on a smooth plane - which is the last plane that touches a surface before finishing. Jack planes and panel planes which are used for dressing have considerable camber so that the planes can be used askew without tearout.

A long jointer used for accurately facing boards might have a little camber to it but mine doesn't as I will probably finsih plane the board anyway and I want to keep the edge square for accuracy. One reason I hate cambering a jointer plane is that when I am face planing for accuracy I want repeatable results and I don't want to get a different thickness shaving depending on where my blade hits the wood. it's just easier without it.

joel

(I didn't invent or discover any of this - but this is how I was taught and it works really well)

re: clenton - Yes - didn't we chat about this - we have a mortise gauge with knives not pins coming for you.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#38

Re: To camber or not to camber

Joel

>Tony,

See my post above - posted it in the wrong place

joel

Re: To camber or not to camber

#39

Re: To camber or not to camber

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Myself, I'm more pratical, and curious for that matter.

In the case of the professor, I'd have to agree with David and that the opinion is nothing more than bigotry.

Interesting paradox here, Alan. Either you're more curious and therefore eager to try new ways of doing things, or you can accuse someone of bigotry for disagreeing with the way you learned how to do things. I submit you can't be both.

Pam

Re: To camber or not to camber

#40

Re: I had a positive impression becasue.....

Sgian Dubh

>You are correct Bill. As ever there is always more than one way to skin a cat.

The debate over the advantages of various options seems never to cease--- back bevels, grinding angles, sharpening angles (aka micro bevels) crowned (rounded) cutting edges, or straight cutting edges with a rounding off at the corners are all options... and more.

Interestingly this thread has turned into a discussion about which of the commonly espoused blade profiles works best for creating edge joints, viz, straight edge with rounded corners or crowned cutting edge. In my experience both work equally well if the worker has developed the necessary technique.

My try plane, in common with nearly all of my planes has an iron sharpened straight across with rounding off at each corner. I say it's straight, but it may be a bit off because I don't measure to see if there's a crowned edge. On the whole though I'd say I get the blade pretty close to straight.

I'll suggest another couple of wrinkles on edge joint preparation I use that I don't think I've yet seen mentioned. When I'm using the try plane right handed which I most often do to prepare an edge, if the edge to the right face of the board as I look at from the end that I plane from is high I usually do one of two things.

1. Move the plane to the right side of the board's edge and take a half width shaving. This means part of the edge to the left is not covered by the sole of the plane nor cut by the iron. A stroke or two like this can be followed up by taking a full width shaving to hopefully bring the full width of the edge back into square with the face.

2. The second technique is to pysically tilt the plane by half a degree or more to the right as required and plane a new reference surface square to the face of the board. I'm not quite sure how I developed the ability to tilt a plane reasonably accurately to a requisite correcting angle-- all I know is that I can do it most of the time, and I realised sometime in the late 1970's or early 1980's that this was what I was doing to correct edges that were off square.

Apart from commonly suggested techniques to create a slight hollow in the length of an edge for a sprung joint, e.g., emulating an aeroplane landing and taking off again, another trick is to bend the sole of the plane in the length as a shaving is taken. I believe that by twisting the wrists hard towards each other as you plane you can bend the sole of a No. 7 metal plane slightly concave or convex-- not a lot maybe but enough I think to make a difference to the thickness of a shaving. 3" or 4" into the length of a long edge I twist my wrists together in an effort to create a slightly convex sole, and near the end of the cut I relax the twisting. This does seem to result in a shaving that starts thin, gets thicker in the middle and thins off again at the end of the cut.

These techniques certainly work for me, but I've no idea if anyone else has found anything similar when using their planes. Slainte.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#41

the back bevel?

Gary B in Central NY

>How do you make the bevel, and where do you place the chipbreaker then(and any mods required to the chipbreaker?) thanks for the info

Gary B.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#42

Re: To camber or not to camber

tonyr

>Joel, thanks, this all makes perfect sense. tony. ps: last we spoke, colen was considering how to make a combined cutting gauge, never heard an answer to this...

Re: To camber or not to camber

#43

Re: To camber or not to camber

Joel

>Tony,

Sorry - the combined version isn't going to happen. (at least not now)

joel

Re: To camber or not to camber

#44

Re: To camber or not to camber (LONG)

Paul Kierstead

>Thank you for the complete, thorough and thoughtful post. I see what you mean by moving over now, but really it is to balance the plane; it doesn't make that much of a difference to the actual shaving, but should make life quite a bit easier.

I tried 4 methods at some length: (1) Fence (many many downsides, really don't like this method), (2) Adjuster (awful for me), (3) Just holding square and (4) cambered. (3) and (4) gave *me* the best results. When I have rough wood, I still do (3) to get a starting edge (usually with a jackplane). I almost never seem to get it square, and I have done probably a 100 boards that way. Now maybe a woodie would be easier; I do know that I find the bevel up guys to be nicer to balance, so who knows. I have found the cambered method to be relatively foolproof and required a minimal amount of practice to do decently. I always have a straight-bladed plane on hand anyway, which a final swipe sorts out cambered edge issues.

OTOH, I will admit that the edge I start with on the jack has steadily got more square and I 'feel' it more then ever now. Maybe it is just a matter of more time.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#45

Re: To camber or not to camber

dennis mcdonaugh

>They probably are the same thing to a degree.

I sharpen my blade straight across, then round the corner off. The rounded edge goes no farther than 1/4" from the side of the plane. A two inch blade will have at least 1 1/2 inches of straight edge.

A cambered blade is not straight at any point, the edge slopes gently from the center toward each side. There is no straigt spot anywhere on the blade. The slope can be only a few thousands of an inch on a smoother or several fractions of an inch on a scrub plane.

You can master either technique and see no difference in your finished product. I just don't like seeing the cambered blade touted as the panacea for all planing ills.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#46

Re: To camber or not to camber

arw01

>Semantics..

open condemnation because it's different = a reasonable person would say bigoted

History is full of bigots.

Re: To camber or not to camber

#47

Re: To camber or not to camber (LONG)

paul womack

>Your straight blade 1-2-3 (*) method appears to involve holding the plane square without reference to anything (except gravity). I don't see how this can provide the same accuracy as taking a (very finely) tapered shaving with the plane sole fully referenced on the work piece.

BugBear

* (thank for diagrams - they should greatly ease discussion)

Re: To camber or not to camber

#48

Re: To camber or not to camber (LONG)

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>First, as I think Joel pointed out and according to Larry Williams, it's very easy to hold a wooden plane square on an edge without external reference. IME, this is true and is why I moved to wooden jointers/trys and gave up on low center of gravity metal planes. Second, if you're match planing, it doesn't matter.

Pam

Re: To camber or not to camber

#49

Re: I had a positive impression becasue.....

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I love your twisted method for making a sprung joint. Have to admit that's something you couldn't do with wooden jointers. :)

Pam

Re: To camber or not to camber

#50

Re: To camber or not to camber (LONG)

paul womack

> it's very easy to hold a wooden plane square on an edge without external reference. IME, this is true

What degree of angular error/accuracy are you hitting?

(yeah - I get the point about match planing, but let's take the two things separately)

BugBear