Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Whose make of shoulder plane

Posts

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#26

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

Cameron

>Where's the adjuster though? ;-)

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#27

Derek..I have to ask

McKay

>When do you have time to do woodworking? I see these really great reviews and nice web pages and I am wondering when one guy can get all of this done? Do you...like have a staff of people running around helping, or are the days just longer in AU?

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#28

Re: Derek..I have to ask

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Ha! I'll take that as a compliment. Thank you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#29

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

mikew

>A. T. Murray is the maker.

He forgot the adjuster...

Take care, Mike

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#30

Confessions of a shoulder plane junkie...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>Hi my names Scott and I'm a shoulder plane junkie. I have Records, Cliftons, Stanleys etc...

The one I reach for the most is a Stanley 94. I like its low center of gravity and its weight. It's an easy plane to use with one hand also.

I also like my Record 042 for thinner work.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#31

100% Agree!

Derek

>I completely agree with William.

I picked up a made-in-England Stanley 93 before they stopped making them some years ago. It was poorly made. I tried to fettle it and failed. I was a newby hand tool user so take that into account. Some things were made better 100 years ago!

I have the LN large shoulder plane and the LV medium one. Both are high quality tools. Because of my hands, I asked for the LV medium one for Christmas and my oldest darling-daughter purchased it for me!

The LN one is a bit big and heavy for most work I do. The LV medium is perfect and easier on my hands. I still use both and would not like to loose either but if I only could have one it would be the LV medium one. In fact, I used both on Sunday and Monday evening.

I can not comment on the Clifton since I have never even held one.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#32

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

Darin in Victoria

>LV also makes a bullnose. I have the LV medium and have been happy with it. I'll probably pick up their large one soon also. The medium one doesn't work so well in trimming long tenons.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#33

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

Tony - Memphis

>I can't offer any comparisons, but I got the Clifton from Highland Hardware a couple of years ago. I have really enjoyed using it. I'm not a hand tool fanatic - I use a mix of power and hand tools. I have used it for tweaking tenon shoulders and general fitting. The other similar tool I have found to be really nice is the LN block rabbet plane. Maybe you can find someone in your area that has the planes so you can fondle them?!?

Tony

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#34

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

dave caudill

>I'm with you Mike. While I know most of you are talking about the LN vs. LV I don't think the old infill shoulder planes should be ignored. I use an old english shoulder plane I bought from Bob Brode several years ago and can't for the life of me think why I would need to replace it. There are so many old shoulder planes out there and available that will work every bit as well as the LN or LV. And who knows maybe even better. And I sure have no beef with those who use the Stanley #93 sucessfully, good for you. I think with the old planes quality control was an issue and some of them are gems others are dogs, you just have to get lucky. Lets face it much of this is about persoanl preference. I prefer the older tools and take great joy in taking a tool that either hasn't been used for many decades or has been abused and refurbishing it and making it work again. And for many of us despite the new materials, superior machining, ductile this and whats-a-mahoozit that they just don't always feel good in the hand. For me its about function and if it feels good I'll most of the time manage to make it work good. So whatever your choice enjoy it and take everyopportunity to try every tool you can out there. Who knows you just might surprise yourself.

Dave

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#35

The #93 is one of my favorites

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>it was new and took some work to get it up to speed, but it is now my go to tool for many operations. I agree that it is somewhat hard to hold, but I set mine for fine dustings and it moves effortlessly as it snickers down the board.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#36

Here's the problem...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>It's the English ones. A US made 90-94 are great plane IMHO. I wouldn't get near a English made Stanley plane.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#37

You? A shoulder plane junkie?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>You're in denial, Scott. Leave off the "shoulder" part, and you might be about right.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#38

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

arw01

>Our woodcraft is supposed to have opened up, perhaps they will have a couple of them to touch this week and I can get a better idea.

Alan

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#39

Ya got me Bill... I confess

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>I just have a real soft spot for shoulder planes.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#40

Old ones?

Derek

>Every time I look at old shoulder planes, I see that they cost lots of $$$. I do not have time for rust hunting and when I have gone, I have found nothing of value. If I look at old tool dealers sites, they cost much more than a new LV or LN plane which do not need anything more than simple back and bevel sharpening.

I like old tools, but mostly want something which will work for me over a long time and do not have time to burn. I have some old planes which I use and like. I also have some new ones which I use and like. For me, it is too much to pay $250-$400 for a used shoulder plane which may or may not be junk and which will possibly need lots of fettling.

I struggled over the new vrs old question for a long time and realized it was not important to me. I am not a collector. I am a user and utility vrs. cost vrs. time is what drives my purchases. I was tempted to feel guilty about buying new for a while but I got over it.

Don't take me wrong - I am happy for you that you have found an old tool which you love. If I had found an old infill shoulder plane in good shape for reasonable money I would have been happy with it too.

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#41

Do you need a shoulder to cry on? :>)

Derek

>

Re: Whose make of shoulder plane

#42

Naaaaaa... I'll take solis in the...

Scott Burr, Freezing rain in Ben Lomond,CA?

>The Record 72 I'm cleaning up as we speak... :^)