Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Posts

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#26

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Paul, I know the Latin. I also know that the woodworkers who named the sub blade the sub blade probably don't know the Latin and/or don't much care. That is, I had nothing to do with it. I think it's more descriptive than chip breaker, especially given the shape and function (close to nil, it does bridge from brass rodlette to blade to brace the blade, which really doesn't need bracing). While the sub blade is on top of the main blade, it's the back of the main blade that faces the sub blade. Do you really want to go into this inversion of terminology?

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#27

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

paul womack

>Pam; you give an excellent exposition on why it isn't a blade, making 1 part of your 2 part name look very unfortunate :-)

Essentially, I'm joking with you; I don't think any of "cap-iron", "chip breaker" or "sub-blade" are particularly self explanatory or clear (see rest of previous thread).

I think any name is but a cipher.

For example, people (many, many of them...) who work with Bailey pattern planes are simply NOT confused by the word "frog", even though (AFAIK) the only etymology for this term is speculative.

BugBear

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#28

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>...it isn't a blade...

Ah, but it is, sort of, depending on the maker. In some cases, the secondary blade is a blade, forged exactly like the main blade, same metals, just a lot smaller. Dave Burnard, and maybe a couple of others here, can correct me on this if I'm wrong. Dave's an excellent blacksmith of the eastern persuasion, Thom and Wiley know a bunch, too.

For example, I've got this Michio Tasai "On" (means goodness, or thereabouts) plane, in which the tool steel is forged in a wave pattern at the interface with the soft iron. The secondary blade looks exactly the same and is sharpened. I'll test whether this blade can cut shavings one of these years, but it sure feels like it.

That should teach you not to joke around with me! A name is a cipher indeed... :)

Pam