Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Posts

Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#1

Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

John Friesen

>I'm in the process of making a wooden scrub plane. I'm using the Hock tools iron that Lee Valley sells. It comes with a chipbreaker, but I'm not sure if I should use it or not. I've read that a lot of scrubs don't use them. So, just wondering what the general consensus is?

Thanks!

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#2

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Scrub plane blades usually have such severe chamfers that I don't know how you'd make the chip breaker fit. My horn type scrub uses only a wedge. However, LN somehow or other uses a chip breaker, so it looks like you can choose.

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#3

No, not necessary

Wayne Anderson

>

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#4

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

ThomD

>For general scrubbing on wider pieces, I use it across grain, which allows it to operate like the crosscut saw of planes. It nips the chip for and aft, and it peels off easily. In this environment a chipbreaker would be useless. Of course I use it on endgrain and with the grain also, so for the latter I guess one could use a breaker. In general I'm avoiding breaker's where I can.

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#5

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

John Friesen

>Thanks for the quick responses everyone! I think I'll just set aside the chipbreaker that comes with the blade, and go without one. That was what I was leaning towards, but just wanted to make sure I wasn't making a mistake.

Thanks again.

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#6

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>John

Neither the LV nor Stanley scrub planes use a chip breaker. I doubt the LN uses one either. The woodie scrub I made only uses a wedge. These all use thick blades (1/8" - 3/16").

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#7

Re: which blade?

paul womack

>Did you buy?

Hock's list

BugBear

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#8

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Paul Kierstead

> However, LN somehow or other uses a chip breaker, so it looks like you can choose.

Huh? I think you have been mislead.

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#9

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Matti Kuikka

>I have made a scrub using Hock's radius edged blade. As it came with a chipbreaker, I used the breaker, too. It works well even with grain and is no hindrance cross-grain as you can naturally adjust the chipbreaker. Can't see no advantage in laving it out if You already have it.

Matti Kuikka

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#11

Re: which blade? *LINK*

John Friesen

>I'm getting it from Lee Valley, and according to their specs and Hock's specs, it's not quite any of the ones on Hock's list. It's 3/16" thick, 1-1/2" wide, with an approximate radius of 4-1/2".


Lee Valley Hock Blades

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#12

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, then, what is that screwed on the top of the blade in the photo at their site? At least a cap iron, no?

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#14

Scrub blades

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>We could rehash the old debate about what chipbreakers actually do. Some (like me) think they just stiffen the blade. Others think they actually cause the chip to curl and break. Whatever camp you are in, consider this--I make my scrub blades 5/32 or 3/16. They are stiff enough to stand alone. Standard lever cap or wedge pushes the chips out of the way. I say the thickness of the blade is much more important to the function of your scrub plane than is chipbreaker. Good luck with your plane.

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#15

Re: which blade?

paul womack

>Lee Valley item D == Hock #PR150 (near enough)

BugBear

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#16

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Danford C. Jennings

>Uh..."Chipbreaker" and "cap iron" are one in the same...What you are seeing is the screw cap; the equivilant of the lever cap on metalic bench planes...

Dano

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#17

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>OK, thanks, Danford. I was trying to find an example of a metal scrub for John so he could compare; but since I don't use one, nor have ever seen one in person so far as I know, that was foolish. In Japanese planes, we call a chip breaker a sub blade, which seems much clearer. I've got two scrubs, one a horned european, the other a C&W jack which is a somewhat milder radius blade, both with wooden wedges and no sub blade.

We talked about this last night in the hand tools chat. I couldn't figure out why LV/Hock were selling this blade set as scrub material. The curve looks way to mild for scrubbing. William pointed out that it might be very good for a mixed use scrub/jack to have the sub blade.

So, what is a screw cap? How far down the blade does it go?

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#18

Screw cap

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Screw cap is the same thing as the lever cap that holds the iron (or iron assembly including chipbreaker) on the plane, thus fulfilling the same function as the wedge on a wooden plane; except that it uses a screw to tighten instead of a lever cam (cammed lever?). You sometimes see references to "cap iron" to avoid the need for two terms. Common when, as with the Stanley scrub and its subsequent imitations, the cap iron pivots on a cross-pin rather than on a screw that can be adjusted for tension. And, of course, the cross-pin makes more sense with a scrub than with a bench plane because you don't need the slot (and it would weaken the iron) on a scrub plane because you don't have a chipbreaker.

Bill, doing revisionist engineering history like mad here

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#19

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Jim O'Neal

>How do you like the C&W jack? Do you use it on a regular basis?

Jim

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#20

Re: Screw cap

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks for the full revisionist explanation, Bill. :) I realized how it would probably work by looking real closely at Wayne's chip breakerless plane. I don't have any tools with anything like it.

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#21

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, I do like it and use it, it's one of the few planes I left out when I packed up most of the shop. Joel convinced me to buy it, and I'm glad he did; even though I had trepidations about replacing a $30 horned scrub that worked fine with a $240 scrub/jack.

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#22

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>Jim,

I agree with Pam entirely. I haven't used my LN40-1/2 much since buying this plane. If working roughsawn lumber, this plane would be in immediate use. It covers for much of what a scrub does, and it's very quick work with a trying plane afterward. One of the best things about it is how quick it is to set the blade depth, and then make fine adjustments using hammer taps. This is something I can't do with the LN (or other clamped-blade plane). In figured wood, this is the plane to be doing roughing work with, IMO, because the radius is just right, and depth adjusts are quick and fine.

Wiley

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#23

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

paul womack

>In Japanese planes, we call a chip breaker a sub blade, which seems much clearer.

Hmm. Despite being ON TOP of the main blade in use, you find "sub blade" clearer than "cap iron" ?!

Methinks clarity in this case is merely familiarity.

BugBear

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#24

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Toe and heel are reversed for Japanese planes, given that they're usually pulled instead of pushed. I'm sure this must mean something about the relative positions of the blades, but danged if I can formulate it right now at the end of a very long day.

Anyhow, in this case sub means subsidiary, not under.

Pam

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

#25

Re: Scrub Plane - Use a Chipbreaker?

paul womack

>Anyhow, in this case sub means subsidiary, not under.

etymological definition

Helpful quote

BugBear