Re: fragile- (technical mumbo-jumbo)
Adam Cherubini
>Technically speaking, that's not necessarily the case. The wooden screws typically have a larger cross section than steel screws, so that overcomes at least some of the difference in the Young's Modulus (I) as compared with steel.
so for a 3/4" steel bar,
I=.015in4 E=25,000,000psi EI or stiffness = 375000lbin2
for a 1-1/2 beech pole
I=.25in4 E=1,600,000psi and EI = 400,000lbin2
(I don't think the beech is truly stiffer, but the two screws are surprisingly similar in stiffness).
Malleting on top of a twin screw isn't the end of the world. Since my vise's nuts are set back from the front edge of the bench, there was no need to thread the first 3-4 inches of the screws. So you never actually see wood threads and thus there are none to damage. The reaction to malleting is largely taken in the bending of an 1-1/2" dia beech pole essentially. This is probably bigger and stronger than an axe handle. How well this happens has a lot to do with the fit quality, yada yada yada between the screw and teh hole I bored in the bench top.
You could pretty easily mallet on a leg vise screw. Its got a nice direct load path to the floor.
The problem with the metal vises are their attachments. You're probably never going to damage the vise screw itself, but eventually you could yank the attach screws out of the bench. The stronger vises have a face plate that screws to the bench front as well as an integral bottom. That allows the front screws to only take shear (which they do best). Vises that attach to the bottom of the bench top only force malleting loads to come out as a couple, placing the screws near the front edge in tension. So these should be the big bombers or be thru bolted if you need a really strong vise.
Its interesting to note that blacksmiths, who routinely beat on their vises, essentially copied the wooden leg vise design in their post vises. Nothing beats direct load paths.
Despite this mumbo jumbo- and it is mumbo jumbo, I think its bad practice to beat on stuff in your vise. I think its similarly bad practice to crank down on a vise as hard as you can. With this in mind, any vise can work.
Having run the numbers, I guess I'm a little surprised that the wooden screws appear NOT to be fragile.
Adam