Re: Mortise Chopping Query--LONG
Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA
>Hi Bill,
Here's something you might try. The key is to cut a deep, accurate V right into the middle of the mortise, after you have knifed in the outline. Once you have that V deeply set, and plumb, then two things have happened: (1) All the lateral support is removed from the rest of the wood in the hole, and (2) the remainder of the cut is pretty close to self-jigging, because the mortise chisel is at all times registering against the sidewalls established in the V.
How to get the V plumb...This can be done by eye. Stand where you're sighting down the chisel, and along the work, so you can see the chisel's profile, with the work spreading out on either side. You can judge when the chisel is vertical by equating the angles on either side that the work makes with the chisel side (I'm proving that this is impossible to describe, but is intuitively clear when you're doing it). Then make the two-hit or three-hit cut. Then do the same thing from the other side.
Making this V sets up a self-jigging situation. Like when sawing joinery, if you can saw 1/2" down two faces and still be in good shape, the cut is already getting self jigging for true. Same thing with sawing tenon shoulders 'around the corner'--you leverage your initial progress into continuing success.
What helps make the V plumb is that you're coming in from two sides--this helps plumb the cut also. Once you get the V to depth (pretty close to final depth), then start widening the V by cutting 1/8" (or so) courses off the slanting sides. The cut offers no resistance whatever, and the chisel trues itself as it goes due to its geometry.
Widen the V out to about 1/16" from either end of the mortise, and dig out the waste. Then pare the end pieces.
I find you can get a plumb mortise from this method, right off the mortise chisel. But what if you don't? Then pare the sides a little and transfer the mortise to the tenon board by making knife points in the tenon board. But mostly, it'll be good right off the mortise chisel.
This method works particularly well with mortise chisels honed under 30 degrees--like 27-28 degrees or less. The idea is to cut the wood, rather than dynamite the wood out. Those acute angle 3V mortise chisels you made would be ideal.
This approach is not my idea, although I forgot how I came upon it--I seem to recall it is close to Odate's method described in his book, and there was a thread on OLDTOOLS initiated by Bugbear which laid out similar (or maybe identical) ideas.
Wiley