Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Mortise Chopping Query

Posts

Mortise Chopping Query

#1

Mortise Chopping Query

bill tindall

>I need to make some deep long mortises. Are there any "crutches" to help keep them square (orthogonal) to the post?

At the glacial pace that I build stuff I wind up chopping mortises about once a year, not a recipe to gain proficiency. Hence, I am not too proud to lean on a crutch as needed, or even use the holow chisel mortiser in desparation. I have been making some practice mortises and fitting a practice tennon to them. I encounter the "Leaning Rail of Pisa" when the chisel is not held perfectly square to the post. Less a problem in a shalow mortise as a few degrees of error can be corrected with the slop in the mortise. But these ones need to be accurate.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#2

What I have learned

Ron in Kokomo

>Go slow And take little bites at a time. About every quarter inch in depth .. redefine the cheeks of the mortise with a wide chisel. Works for me. Brian Boggs showed me this way to do it

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#3

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>What I have found works for me is to set up a square just off the end of the piece that I am chopping the mortise in and stand so that I can visually line up the chisel with the square. I find that I can keep pretty accurate by doing this and it doesn't slow me down much.

If I stand perpedicular to the plane of the mortise, all bets are off!

Regards,

Ted

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#4

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

Adam Cherubini

>Bill,

I too have been doing some mortising lately. From time to time, I do "chop" mortises as they say. Last night I was chopping mortises and will again tonight. Joel tells me its much faster than paring the way I do. But I think I'm pretty godd at it and I'm not sure its faster than paring them out. My mortises are coming out pretty straight, but I think this is an indictaion that my internal plumb bob is beginning to function. That said, its much easier to stay straight and plumb paring. When you pare you use the chisel and your last cut to keep you on track. When you chop you loose all that. Every mallet blow has the potential to take you off course.

So my advice is to do two things: First, make sure the edge of your chisel is square with the sides. A slight angle really will pull yoru chisel around. Second, try paring. Just chop the ends in as you normally would, but instead of chopping, pare the middle down toward the chopped end. You need a sharp chisel and it gets easier and faster as you go. I think its THE way to go for mortises that are not 90, which are by far the trickier joints to cut.

I hope it helps. I'll be thinking of you tonight. I'll try to time my mortises.

Adam

P.S. I was watching Kaare Loftheim chop mortises in Williamsburg this weekend. His joints are just beautiful. I'm not sure I mean this as a compliment when I say they look machine made, they are so perfect. But I never saw him finish a mortise. He'd get halfway thru and say "you didn't come here to watch me do this boring work". Well I really wanted to see him finish one. If for no other reason to see how long it took him. One thing I did notice was how lightly he applied his mallet. I have a three hit rule. I'm convinced the chisel ceases to be a chisel after about three hits. Kaare seemed to have a two hit rule and his first seemed light. So it sounded like bin BANG, bin BANG. Maybe its my heritage but mine seem to sound like BATTA BING!

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#5

The two hit rule

James Watriss

>I don't know for sure how it's done at williamsburg, but with all the chopping of dovetails and other things I've had to do at school, I noticed that a two hit rule worked out very well.

-A light hit to set the point of the chisel. Nothing too hard, no wind-up, or anything that would move my body around enough to alter the position of the chisel. That way I know it's in position and ready for

-Hit Two. I let the mallet bounce up a bit from the chisel following the first hit, and just come down hard. I use a brass mallet, generally speaking, when I'm chopping. It doesn't rebound like a wooden mallet does, it has a very concentrated mass, and when applied in the proper fashion, it has some serious authority. It's like watching a panicked mom cut through a mall at christmas time... the wood just gets the hell out of the way.

There's an option for a third hit, but it's not always necessary for me.

Then reposition the chisel with a little care. Since you haven't chopped too deeply, you can do this fairly quickly, since you don't need a claw hammer to pry the chisel out. But thanks to the setting involved in the first hit, you don't have to get yourself all braced and ready to start hitting. If the first hit feels a little skewed, you can pause before the second hit to adjust the angle and general attitude of the chisel. But the slight nick in the wood can be used almost like a third hand, to hold the point where you want it to be while your other hand takes care of angles and such.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#6

I'm with Adam...

Jonathan Kaplan (OR)

>I learned to make mortises by chopping, and once constructed a bookcase-type-thing that resulted in my chopping something over 120 of them... Recently, in response to various posts on the subject, I've been trying the method of paring mortises, and I'm finding it, in general, to be faster and more accurate, at least given my particular set of tools and needs. But I often switch from paring to chopping about half-way down, as paring starts to get awkward and chopping easier (and more self-guided).

Another "trick," based loosely on one of Krenov's suggestions from one of his books, would be to clamp a square peice of scrap next to the mortise (after marking and paring back to the lines) and use that to register your chisel until you are happy that things have started off nice and straight, then trust the mortise itself to guide things. I've had reasonable luck with that sort of thing, too.

Hope this helps!

jk

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#7

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

joel -( tools for working wood)

>dumb question:

how deep is deep?

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#8

Re: Mortise Choping - square

Barryvabeach

>Bill, at the Williamsburg conference they were chopping a number of mortices of different angles ( like 86 degreees, 82 degrees etc) and the presenter made a small peice - maybe 2 " by 2" that had those angles cut on it and then held the guide on the wood and butted the side of chisel up to it and aligned the chisel just before striking it. In one case, where the stock was too narrow, he placed the guide on a cutoff held next to the stock. He didn't do this every time - but he did check it regularly. What I have found is helpful is using a long mortise chisel- Joel sold me a Sorby that is very long and makes it easier to see when you are out of square.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#9

Thats a chisel

Bob Fawcett

>I agree on the long chisel. I recently made a table and chopped the mortises for the rails in the legs. I did the first 2 with my bench chisels, then I bought a proper mortise chisel. The rest of them were much easier to align simply because of the chisel. The extra length made it easier to see alignment errors and the "thickness" helped align in what was already cut. The chisel is a 3/8" mortise but its 1/2" "thick" at the end of the bevel and tapers to 5/8" at the handle.

If you don't already have a good mortise chisel get one.

When I first got this chisel it reminded of the Crocodile Dundee line "thats a knife".

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#10

"Great" minds think alike (chuckle)

bill tindall

>By dumb luck, tonight discovered this approach and it seems to be working to result in a sufficiently well aligned mortise. The shape of what I am mortising makes it difficult to clamp an alignment piece (Krenov suggestion) but with some effort I could come up with something if this other technique fails.

My technique is to drill to depth an undersized pilot hole near the end of the mortise. This hole provides a place for the wood to expand into when I initially drive the chisel in on the first cut. The short amount of time to drill this hole is more than compensated by how quick I can begin driving the chisel deep in the mortise. I am using a 25 degree bevel chisel and I can cleave off about 1/4 inch of material up to 1 3/8 deep for each chisel setting(about 3 wacks). Penetration is remarkably easier if the chisel will hold up with a 25 degree bevel. These 4" long mortises go quite quickly if I can learn to keep the chisel straight. The warning to sharpen the chisel edge straight was well founded.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#11

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Bob's fault

Jim in Burlington On

>After seeing his giant mortice chisels in his article here and FWW at christmas my short LN's seem inferior. I'm thinking longer would help your body figure out what's square (and they look cool)

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#12

home made chisel

bill tindall

>I am using one I made. It is long, 1/2" deep for good alignment and tapered for clearance. Sharpened at 25 degrees it penetrates remarkably better than the 35 degree Sorby I previously used. I made it with a "butcher knife" shaped handle to enable it to be pointed more reliably than a round handled affair.

This chisel is like several of my rifles, better than I am at using them.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#13

Re: Mortise Chopping Query--LONG

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>Hi Bill,

Here's something you might try. The key is to cut a deep, accurate V right into the middle of the mortise, after you have knifed in the outline. Once you have that V deeply set, and plumb, then two things have happened: (1) All the lateral support is removed from the rest of the wood in the hole, and (2) the remainder of the cut is pretty close to self-jigging, because the mortise chisel is at all times registering against the sidewalls established in the V.

How to get the V plumb...This can be done by eye. Stand where you're sighting down the chisel, and along the work, so you can see the chisel's profile, with the work spreading out on either side. You can judge when the chisel is vertical by equating the angles on either side that the work makes with the chisel side (I'm proving that this is impossible to describe, but is intuitively clear when you're doing it). Then make the two-hit or three-hit cut. Then do the same thing from the other side.

Making this V sets up a self-jigging situation. Like when sawing joinery, if you can saw 1/2" down two faces and still be in good shape, the cut is already getting self jigging for true. Same thing with sawing tenon shoulders 'around the corner'--you leverage your initial progress into continuing success.

What helps make the V plumb is that you're coming in from two sides--this helps plumb the cut also. Once you get the V to depth (pretty close to final depth), then start widening the V by cutting 1/8" (or so) courses off the slanting sides. The cut offers no resistance whatever, and the chisel trues itself as it goes due to its geometry.

Widen the V out to about 1/16" from either end of the mortise, and dig out the waste. Then pare the end pieces.

I find you can get a plumb mortise from this method, right off the mortise chisel. But what if you don't? Then pare the sides a little and transfer the mortise to the tenon board by making knife points in the tenon board. But mostly, it'll be good right off the mortise chisel.

This method works particularly well with mortise chisels honed under 30 degrees--like 27-28 degrees or less. The idea is to cut the wood, rather than dynamite the wood out. Those acute angle 3V mortise chisels you made would be ideal.

This approach is not my idea, although I forgot how I came upon it--I seem to recall it is close to Odate's method described in his book, and there was a thread on OLDTOOLS initiated by Bugbear which laid out similar (or maybe identical) ideas.

Wiley

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#14

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

paul womack

>I need to make some deep long mortises. Are there any "crutches" to help keep them square (orthogonal) to the post?

If you can long mortise chisels like Bob Smalser seems to find, the length helps visual alignment.

Failing this, you can cramp a square block to your workpiece and use physical alignment.

(I'm assuming you want to hand chop mortices. There are "other ways" if a "mortise" as opposed to a "hand chopped" mortice is your goal)

BugBear

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#15

Re: Mortise Chopping Query--LONG

paul womack

>This approach is not my idea, although I forgot how I came upon it--I seem to recall it is close to Odate's method described in his book, and there was a thread on OLDTOOLS initiated by Bugbear which laid out similar (or maybe identical) ideas.


Here's the oldtools thread

And Jeff Gorman did a subsequent write up with some further experimental results.

BugBear

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#16

Re: Mortise Chopping Query--LONG

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>This is the approach I take, too, Wiley, very satisfactory. As many would suspect, I use Japanese and tapered down slightly from back to front western pig stickers (sorry, Joel, I honestly don't know what else to call them). I hadn't thought of it as providing a self-jigging cut, but that's exactly what happens. The cuts provide channels that make succeeding cuts easy to follow.

Pam

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#17

Crutches that worked for straight mortises

bill tindall

>As a result of all your valuable input the following was found to result in successful motises (at least on the practice pieces).

I drill an undersized hole to depth at the far end. Undersized so it can be drilled quickly and no need to be precisely located so long as it is between the lines. This hole provides chip clearance.

I clamped a stick to the side for sighting as was suggested. By looking at the amount of daylight between the chisel and the stick, verticality (new word) can be quickly and reliably judged.

I like the hard rubber mallet. It drives the chisel with authority and doesn't make annoying wacking noises like wood. It is the first tool I can remember ever buying with my own spending money, probably when I was about 10 years old.


img

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#18

Re: Eeek!

paul womack

>Ya' shouldn't really mortice in a vise.

If the workpiece is sitting on the guide bars, you might get away with it. But you're still (in effect) trying to hammer your vice off your bench.

If the workpiece is held by friction, you're in a world of trouble. The piece may slip and be damaged. And you're still trying to hammer your vice off your bench.

It's better to clamp the workpiece ON the bench, ideally over a leg.

This provides lots of rigidity and inertial damping, and also means the workpiece if fixed (what engineers call) "positively".

The easiest way I know to achieve this is to cramp a woodscrew DOWN onto your workbench, and then clamp your workpiece in the woodscrew's jaws.

BugBear

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#19

EeeK! fixed-thanks

bill tindall

>It is simply amazing the wealth of knowledge available on this Forum. I guess I was secretly hoping someone would respond to what even I had heard was a woodworking "folks pox" (or how ever the French spell it, helI I can't spell English). I couldn't figure out how to clamp a tall rail to the bench and you solved the problem. Thanks. Enough practice, I will be chopping the real thing this afternoon along with making bagels. Can't buy any decent bread items in this culinary wasteland; have to make them.

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#20

Ummmm Bagles...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>"Can't buy any decent bread items in this culinary wasteland"

Amen Brother!

I'll take mine with cream cheese, red onion, bacon and a nice heirloom tomato...

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#21

Culinary wasteland?

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>How would you like your chicken fried steak, sir?

Wiley......who had to look for a while to find decent grits last time he was back home in North Carolina

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#22

Mortising - how to attach to bench

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Paul,

The most common way is a 'mortising board', which is really just two bits of 1 1/2" thick stock by 4 - 6" wide and about 8" long, just joined in a 'T' shape.

You lay the 'T' sideways, put one half of the top of the 'T' in the vice and tighten it up, and then you have one vertical board that you clamp the job against (G-clamp)and the bit underneath to protect the bench from damage.

I just put a bit of stock in the vice, put a scrap bit of ply against it and clamp the workpiece to the vertical length.

I'll do a quick google search and see if I can find an article for you - something that may be useful for your website.

Cheers,

Andrew

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#23

Re: Mortising - how to attach to bench

Dean J in MN

>I often just use a holdfast, add a scrap under if the mortise is going through. Over a leg as suggested.

-Dean

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#24

holdfast 

Dean J in MN

>


img

Re: Mortise Chopping Query

#25

A picture tells a thousand words.

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Paul,

It was quicker to duck out to the workshop and take a photo - the 'mortice' is just laid out quickly by hand so pay no attention to any inaccuracy in setting out.

The other thing I forgot to mention is that the board under the workpiece prevents spelching as you get close to the other edge, something that holding the workpiece in the vice doesn't do.

Cheers,

Andrew


img