Plane selections for the shooting board
Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)
>Hi Bill
Shooting boards are wonderful - second only to the workbench as the most important tool in my book.
Which plane to use? The simple answer is that you can use just about any plane, however some are more comfortable and better suited for the purpose. A low cutting angle slices end grain more easily, and the bevel up configuartion has an advantage in this area. Below are some of my preferences from my experience (so note that this does not denote a "best of all planes" selection).
In my pre-bevel up days, my favourite plane for the shooting board was a HNT Gordon Try Plane. Its high cutting angle (60 degree bedding) managed to cut hardwood end grain well enough. It remains a choice if I am planing hardwood edge grain.
I then moved to a Stanley #62, a low angle jack. This is quite a light plane (think #5), but it remains my first choice when trimming softwood end grain. I like the delicate feel it provides. It does a pretty good job on hardwood, but there are better in that regard.
My top shooting board plane is the LV LA Jack. It is a heavy plane (think #5 1/2) and is designed for this purpose. The recessed "rings" on the sides are not decoration - they are finger grips. The general bench planes (excluding the purpose made planes, such as the #9 and the T5) lack the facility to hold them easily on the runway. The HNT Gordon is another that is held easily (see picture below).
The other plane that is excellent on a shooting board, and often forgotten in this capacity, is the LV LA Smoother. Length is not important on the shooting board, so the LAS is not really at a disadvantage because it is a smoother. It, too, has fingergrips on the side. Where the LV LA Jack is at a great advantage is that it is a heavy plane and carries much momentum through the cut.
Lastly, the other plane I occasionally use is my little LN #60 1/2 Block Plane. I find this preferable on very small pieces where delicacy is especially needed.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Picture below:
Jarrah ramped shooting board, with HNT Gordon Try Plane. Stanley #62 in background.
