Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

shooting board plane

Posts

shooting board plane

#1

shooting board plane

bill tindall

>I am begining to appreciate the benefits of a shooting board. Now, what do you all use for a plane? At least in my inexperienced hands it takes considerable force to push the iron across 4" of 1" thick hardwood. The typical bench plane (in my case a #4) isn't very comfortable after planing a bit. There isn't a comfortable place to grab it. I made a low angle woodie that I thought would be ideal, but it lacks mass to carry through a cut.

Re: shooting board plane

#2

Re: shooting board plane

I'm Dave Too

>Either my Veritas Jack (15") or the Veritas LA Smoother (10"). I don't find that there is enough "authority" using a block plane.

Re: shooting board plane

#3

Re: shooting board plane

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>The HNT try plane of desert ironwood with tool steel blade seems to work fine for me. On both my shooting board (for end grain) and sticking board approximation (long planing beam mounting 1/8" below my bench) for long grain. I've also used the LV 4-1/2 on the shooting board/end grain with success, at least in cherry and walnut.

Pam

Re: shooting board plane

#4

Re: shooting board plane

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bill -

I do a lot of work with shooting boards. My favorite plane for the job is my LN #62. For the 62 I have extra irons with higher bevel angles which I use for shooting difficult long grain.

I also have good results with, and sometimes use, a LN #9 and a Stanley #7. I've recently purchased a LV LA jack and find it works well on the shooting board.

Ed

Re: shooting board plane

#5

Re: shooting board plane

R.J.Whelan (Eastern Sierra, CA)

>Bill .... I used a #6 for about 30 years (wore out a bunch of shooting boards with that plane). About five years ago my bride bought me a LN Mitre Plane for our anniversary and I've worn out a couple of boards with that one.

The #6 had more mass, but I think the bevel up orientation on the mitre plane makes it a winner.

If I was going to buy a plane specifically for use on a shooting board it would probably be the LN #64 (bevel up Jack) or the Lee Valley equivalent.

RJ

Re: shooting board plane

#6

Re: shooting board plane *LINK*

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Bill,

I altered a Record 05 into a "T5" by drilling and tapping a hole for an upright handle on one cheek of the plane. I use it for most of my shooting now because it is a lot easier to control than a bench plane without the upright handle. It should be possible to do this with virtually any Bailey type plane. It took me less than an hour to make the alteration. I'm posting a link to an post in the archives that was posted by Scott Burr to show me the location of the handle.

It doesn't have the advantage of a low angle - but a really sharp blade makes things work better.

Skip


http://woodcentral.com.ldh0138.uslec.net/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl?read=50789

Re: shooting board plane

#7

Re: shooting board plane

Brent Smith

>I use my LN #8, once you get that thing moving the weight just carries it through the cut.

Re: shooting board plane

#8

Re: shooting board plane *LINK*

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Bill,

I have a small article on shooting boards ..link below..

with mention of the different chracteristics of a wooden plane compared to the LV #6... which I much prefer due to its' mass.

Norman


Shooting Board

Re: shooting board plane

#9

Steve Kubien

Re: shooting board plane

Steve Kubien

>Great article and link. There's a bunch of good stuff to be had there!

Steve Kubien

Re: shooting board plane

#10

Terrific article!

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>

Re: shooting board plane

#11

Plane selections for the shooting board

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Bill

Shooting boards are wonderful - second only to the workbench as the most important tool in my book.

Which plane to use? The simple answer is that you can use just about any plane, however some are more comfortable and better suited for the purpose. A low cutting angle slices end grain more easily, and the bevel up configuartion has an advantage in this area. Below are some of my preferences from my experience (so note that this does not denote a "best of all planes" selection).

In my pre-bevel up days, my favourite plane for the shooting board was a HNT Gordon Try Plane. Its high cutting angle (60 degree bedding) managed to cut hardwood end grain well enough. It remains a choice if I am planing hardwood edge grain.

I then moved to a Stanley #62, a low angle jack. This is quite a light plane (think #5), but it remains my first choice when trimming softwood end grain. I like the delicate feel it provides. It does a pretty good job on hardwood, but there are better in that regard.

My top shooting board plane is the LV LA Jack. It is a heavy plane (think #5 1/2) and is designed for this purpose. The recessed "rings" on the sides are not decoration - they are finger grips. The general bench planes (excluding the purpose made planes, such as the #9 and the T5) lack the facility to hold them easily on the runway. The HNT Gordon is another that is held easily (see picture below).

The other plane that is excellent on a shooting board, and often forgotten in this capacity, is the LV LA Smoother. Length is not important on the shooting board, so the LAS is not really at a disadvantage because it is a smoother. It, too, has fingergrips on the side. Where the LV LA Jack is at a great advantage is that it is a heavy plane and carries much momentum through the cut.

Lastly, the other plane I occasionally use is my little LN #60 1/2 Block Plane. I find this preferable on very small pieces where delicacy is especially needed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Picture below:

Jarrah ramped shooting board, with HNT Gordon Try Plane. Stanley #62 in background.


img

Re: shooting board plane

#12

Re:WOW!

paul womack

>When did that article appear? That's great work.

BugBear

Re: shooting board plane

#13

Re: stop design

paul womack

>

Norman - I notice that your stop fence is in two parts, which a white wood (maple?) held to the main board by vertical screws, and a dark face screwed onto the white wood with horizontal screws.

I've never seen this before (and I've read a lot), and I think I can see at least one benefit.

What were your reasons and/or inspiration for this unusual design?

BTW, in English craft language there's a wonderful (and specific) term for far side break out on end grain: "spelching"

BugBear

Re: shooting board plane

#14

What holds the miter attachment?

Bob Fawcett

>How do you attach the cleat for the 45 degree miter block?

How about the face miter jig?

Re: shooting board plane

#15

Re: Plane selections for the shooting board

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi derek,

I know you use a lot of really tough woods, so I have a few questions (these might be pertinent for Bill too). Do you have any trouble shooting Australian hardwoods (I'm talking about shooting end grain here)? I'm asking because often my low-angle planes just jam in hard woods (BANG, as if the plane hits a wall) and then the blade is toast. Another problem I have with low-angle planes on hard woods (again, shooting end-grain) is that I lose clearance quite quickly, after which the plane stops biting and just skips over the wood.

I don't experience these problems as much with my bevel-down planes, so usually end up using a #8 or a 4 1/2. AM I doing something wrong? I don,t think it's the sharpening; I put a 30/33� bevel on the blades.

Thanks for any feedback.

Re: shooting board plane

#16

Re: shooting board plane

gordon thomas

>Bill:The LN #5 1/2 or # 8 have the mass to be effective as a shooting plane. the other consideration is that the sole has to be machined flat. The LN's are. Other manufacturersa are anything but flat!

take care,

Gordon in Calgary

Re: shooting board plane

#18

Re: WOW! A Great Discussion! thanks

bill tindall

>the compliment and thank you was meant for all.. Sometimes I forget where I am at in these great discussions.

Re: shooting board plane

#19

Re: Plane selections for the shooting board

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Frank

I don't experience this. With very hard woods I always set the blade for a fine cut and make sure it is sharp. The LA planes tend to cut with less "crunch" than the HA planes. Sorry I can't help more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: shooting board plane

#20

Re: shooting board plane

I'm Dave Too

>No planes have flat soles but L-N? LOL!

Re: shooting board plane

#22

I use to use...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>A No.5 but get tired of scraping my knuckles. Then I got a Record T5 with it's side handle (liks Skip's). It's a bit on the light side for me. So now I use a LN 9. The hog dog is a must IMHO.


img

Re: shooting board plane

#23

Re: stop design

Norman (Metcalfe, Ont.)

>Hello Paul,

My reasoning for this was probably to have a replaceable fence

without needing to realign the whole fence perpendicularly to the edge of the shooting board. If you have elongated slots in this hardwood strip, you can adjust the fence further right when and if it wears down. Also, this piece of hardwood is much harder than the maple backer.

BTW, I've updated the page with a differnet fastening system for the miter jigs.

Norman

Re: shooting board plane

#24

Re: What holds the miter attachment? *LINK*

Norman (Metcalfe, Ont.)

>Hello Bob,

Excellent question..

I originally use metal pins in the bottom of the face miter and other miter jig. I would simply locate the jig on the baseboard and press down. I thought this was cleaner than using clamps or bolts, etc.

I didn't like the pins protruding from the jigs however.

Since then, I have gone to a locking knob system. It works very well,

permits me to adjust the jigs both laterally and against the fence.

I have added those photos to the article below...

It's also fairly quick release.

Norman


Shooting Board - Updated

Re: shooting board plane

#25

Re: The hot dog?

Marc in Luxembourg

>Scott, I used to shoot without the hot dog, but figured out it'd be pretty comfortable to have one, when shooting alot. So I ordered one. Thumb and index pressing against the body is painful at some point. So I think, a better grip with part of the palm, will avoid one or two breaks. Am I right? Anyway, it's too late the hot dog left your continent an saturday ;-) I'm awaitin it thursday.

Marc