Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Dovetail saw handle angle

Posts

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#26

Re: More data

mikew

>Well, that's what--forearm angle--clued me to the height of the piece...ill worded or not.

Fact is the elbow/forearm should be at its "resting" point if not during then at the end of the cut. The wrist should nearly always be straight. The body moves [mainly upper, but also the legs spring] to position also during the start/finish as well. All very dynamic.

The handle hang/workpiece should be at a height relationship to allow this. The pics show this ain't so...

Saw selection, work type, workpiece holding all have a proper relationship...

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#27

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Patrick Gibbons

>Don, you mention that the handle angle of a dt might be to keep the handle from running into the wood or presenting a problem when jointing. It seems to me that these considerations are the reason for not having an enclosed handle for this type of saw. The offending bottom part of the handle is MIA and not an issue. Adam- in your pictures you show all of the saws beginning the cut on the face towards the sawyer. Often times I start the saw on the face away from the sawyer. This way I guage the end of the cut on the far face and end the cut on the face that is in full view. Obviously I taught myself. My dts are none too good either. Doing it this way makes a dt saw with the hang like the saw you are using even more comfortable than one that is less skewed.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#28

Re: More data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Even without the fore finger the gents saw looks cramped in your hand. I grip my gents saw the way you do in the photo, but my handle is larger and my hand somewhat smaller.

I wouldn't be able to work with the board so far out of the vise. Perhaps my sawing is more forceful- I use only about 3 or 4 strokes per cut on a board like that shown.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#29

Re: Summation (and Quiz)

L. Hanson

>Thanks for the photo essay, Adam!

I've done a lot of looking into handle angles and what not - I find balancing the difference the exposed blade depth, weight, and length along with the intended use of the saw makes the most difference in optimum handle "hang". The angle on 'dovetail' saws 10" and shorter, especially, show the most dramatic effect - but often they are used at angles such as you show. A tenon saw might be used at the same angle, but it's required depth, length, and weight call for a different handle angle, at least for me.

The saws in the right column vary in length from 6" to 12", the saws on the left are 10" through 14" in length.


Also, a higher angle on a longer saw feels clumsy and awkward in my hands, but feels better with a shorter, lighter saw. Note the Groves saw handle angle on the bottom right - its my suspicion this saw's intended use was as a miter saw.

Leif

NorseWoodsmith.com

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#30

Early saws- blah,blah,blah

Adam Cherubini

>Boy, a picture is worth a thousand words, isn't it? That's a great graphic, Leif.

On early saws we see the dovetail handle pretty much as shown above (in Leif's post). My saw is a pretty accurate copy and not unsimilar to the LN saw. Early saws, seemingly new from the manufacturer, appear to have been tapered as mine is. I don't believe this to be an "in the spine or out of the spine" issue. But there aren't that many pristine early saws and only a few images so its hard to say anything on the subject for certain. It also appears that the saws have very little depth, but that's all really a different subject.

Early, long backsaws, typically had handles more perpendicular to the cut and often positioned lower on the heel. More like the groves saw. Seems to me, early factories standardized saw handles without regard for the usage of the saws.

Modern miter saws seem to have handles with hang angles more like dovetail saws than tenon saws. Which makes sense considering the saw is typically flat on a bench. My guess would be that the Groves saw handle may have been intended for a tenon saw. Early tenon saws were quite long- at least 18" or so. Such a long saw could easily be mistaken for a miter, or I could be wrong.

Jay Gaynor's book "Tools: Working wood in the 18th century" has a couple pictures of early saws worth reviewing for anyone interested in this sort of thing.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#31

Early saws- blah,blah,blah

Adam Cherubini

>Boy, a picture is worth a thousand words, isn't it? That's a great graphic, Leif.

On early saws we see the dovetail handle pretty much as shown above (in Leif's post). My saw is a pretty accurate copy and not unsimilar to the LN saw. Early saws, seemingly new from the manufacturer, appear to have been tapered as mine is. I don't believe this to be an "in the spine or out of the spine" issue. But there aren't that many pristine early saws and only a few images so its hard to say anything on the subject for certain. It also appears that the saws have very little depth, but that's all really a different subject.

Early, long backsaws, typically had handles more perpendicular to the cut and often positioned lower on the heel. More like the groves saw. Seems to me, early factories standardized saw handles without regard for the usage of the saws.

Modern miter saws seem to have handles with hang angles more like dovetail saws than tenon saws. Which makes sense considering the saw is typically flat on a bench. My guess would be that the Groves saw handle may have been intended for a tenon saw. Early tenon saws were quite long- at least 18" or so. Such a long saw could easily be mistaken for a miter, or I could be wrong.

Jay Gaynor's book "Tools: Working wood in the 18th century" has a couple pictures of early saws worth reviewing for anyone interested in this sort of thing.

adam

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#32

a few misc comments..

Adam Cherubini

>Yeah, I'm with you, Mike. To tell the truth I have no idea where I put the stock when I saw dovetails. I was on my way to bed, the camera was still in the shop, and I thought pictures would help with this discussion. I'm not sure I even had a point in mind. I knew you guys would find something interesting and helpful to discuss and I wasn't dissappointed.

One problem I've encountered (I think I'm flashing back to a discussion with Bugbear years back) is that I don't really have a great sense of how I do whatever because I don't see me doing it. Taking pictures has helped me to some extent. It was interesting to me to see how similar the starting angles were for the cuts. As for the finishes, I always mark the other side (since I chop from both sides) so I always look. Unlike Klaus & co., I have no built-in square or level. Further, IMHO people who recommend developing the internal square thru extensive practice are doing beginners a tremendous diservice. I've been sawing by hand exclusively for 10 years and I don't think I could make passable Dt's without marks. But then again, I never claim to be good with my hands. I've seen people who are good with their hands and I'm not one of them!

Just to be crystal clear, none of this is to say I don't appreciate your advice. I just stuck a board in the vise and tried to show, more or less how I begin a cut and end a cut with three different styles of western saws.

I have video taped me sawing before (because I was nude, these tapes are available on the internet for $24.95+s/h) and the tape was helpful. But I've never taped dt sawing (nude or otherwise).

Adam

P.S. I'm still waiting for the fetish community to discover my axe article.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#33

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Adam Cherubini

>Often times I start the saw on the face away from the sawyer. This way I guage the end of the cut on the far face and end the cut on the face that is in full view. ...snip... Doing it this way makes a dt saw with the hang like the saw you are using even more comfortable than one that is less skewed.

You mean the tenon saw (whatever you call it)? I think Cosman does this. He doesn't really start flat on the end grain, at least not in the dvd I saw. He nicks the far side then saw across the end grain line, The trick is that that's tough to correct for square. When you go the other way (sawing the near corner) both lines can be seen and corrected independantly. No snake oil required.

Adam

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#34

Re: a few misc comments..

mikew

>"I have video taped me sawing before (because I was nude, these tapes are available on the internet for $24.95+s/h) and the tape was helpful. But I've never taped dt sawing (nude or otherwise)."

That's the second time this morning I've nearly spit my coffee out on my laptop!

Thanks for making my day, Adam!

Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#35

Re: Early saws- blah,blah,blah

L. Hanson

>I'm sure you are right on the Groves saw being a tenon saw - I hadn't considered that possibility, with my training being a product of this generation.

Thanks for the book reference - I'll have to add that one to my list. The immensity of realizing all the context required for even a slightly realistic historical perspective can be a tall order. But I'm working on it!

Leif

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#36

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle--starting cuts

mikew

>And me? I start my DT saw flat on the end. The way I sharpen is for a fast cut and ease of start--and it does start very easy. No jittery starts for me. And it cuts faster than a LN...

If I use another saw, I use the method Adam shows. It really does make following both lines easy.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#37

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

ThomD

>I'm always trying to keep the starting angle flat, to get the saw going smoothly. If I start with the angle you have I seem to be catching in the tooth. I start on the far side, nick, and work back. But I do the same with Japanese saws, which is not terribly consistant, well it is in one way but not the other. I'll have to try your approach and see how it works.

I find my workpiece height in the vice seems to have more to do which a saw-off between where the best light is, what I can see, and vibration. I seem to get pretty shortsighted after a long stint in the shop.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#38

Gent's saw

Adam Cherubini

>Ya know, I don't hate the Gent's saw. I've made a lot of furniture with that thing. I find my hand gets tired if I saw for a few hours with it, which I almost always do when I do that sort of work. But for occasional use (I mean, that's what it was designed for, right?) I find it perfectly adequate.

I think Gents' saws get dismissed too quickly. I bought that saw at Woodcraft for something like $15. A little bit of filing and its fine.

Adam

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#39

Steve Kubien

what about using a drawknife? Eeek!

Steve Kubien

>

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#40

Re: what about using a drawknife? Eeek!

Adam Cherubini

>Just the thought kinda creeps you out, don't it? Yikes.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#41

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle--starting cuts

Paul Erickson

>Hi Mike,

Would you mind elaborating on your sharpening method? I just picked up the saw that started this whole thing off from the local Saw works, and I am hoping it is the last time I have to use their services. Learning to sharpen properly is coming up soon on my list of things to learn.

cheers, Paul

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#42

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle--starting cuts

mikew

>Hi Paul,

The short answer is adding rake and a tad of fleam.

Rake, though not as much as some popular DT saws, in itself makes a rip saw easier to start. The fleam angle [maybe a degree or so, but I've never measured it] allows fibers to be sliced a little. All very by the seat of the pants. Sorry I cannot be more scientific about it all.

The result is a saw that cuts aggressively, but pretty smoothly.

It is also necessary to take into account the ppi of the saw in question. PPI has an affect on the gullets catching a corner [far or near] and making the saw more difficult to start.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#43

Re: Dovetail starting cuts - another datum

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I drove almost 300 miles in the last two days starting out in the midst of this season's first winter storm, just to confirm your method and mine. Frank Klausz was only doing Sliding Dovetails, and the legions of forked tailed routers weren't giving up any mysteries, either, but I can confirm that Yeung Chan starts cutting his dovetails with the teeth FLAT across the end of the board. As far as I'm concerned, there is no hand tool furniture joiner currently working in either Occidental or Oriental traditions, with hand tools or power tools, more skilled than Jeung.

If it works for you, and you are satisfied with the quality and speed of your techniques, don' change what you are doing.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#44

Re: Dovetail starting cuts - another datum

Fred Krow

>At the Springfield, MA show two years ago, I spoke at length with Yeung Chan on the subject of his unique tool box and his favorite saw and if I remember correctly it is approx. 32 TPI. That would make the full contact and level starting cut easier than the western style saws.

Regards,

Fred Krow

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#45

Re: Dovetail starting cuts - another datum

mikew

>Yeung Chan...now he is one person I would like to sit down with for an afternoon--as well as work for a bit in a shop together.

Do understand that I adjust which saw I use depending on the wood being cut. If it is a thin piece, I use an old Sylvania Saw Corporation Gent's saw that has 25 ppi.

If the teeth are even, if the teeth are sharp and if there are enough teeth on the wood at the start, it will be a smooth entry, assuming there is not a zero degree rake on the teeth.

But like you say, works for me.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#46

Re: Dovetail starting cuts - another datum

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I didn't count the teeth, but there were a lot of them. It cut an amazingly thin kerf. I didn't write the name down, because I knew better :^) I know I don't need another tool habit, and I knew Harrelson Stanley was out on the exhibit floor with identical saws for sale. It was a lot less expensive than my Lie-Nielsen, but I knew I would have to change a lot more than just the saw to take full advantage of it. I also didn't buy Yeung's book on making traditional joinery with power tools, although I recognize it is a very good book, and quite clear in its drawings and explanations.