Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Dovetail saw handle angle

Posts

Dovetail saw handle angle

#1

Dovetail saw handle angle

Paul Erickson

>While repairing the handle on a 12" disston saw, which will have to be my dovetail saw for a while. (Yes, I would love to have one in the 8-10" class, but haven't been able to come across one that fits within my budget) I noticed that the angle of the handle was much more in line with the back of the blade than other saws I have, and have seen.

In order to try and make sure we are talking about the same thing. I am talking about the relationship of the axis of the index finger in relation to the back of the saw.

With this saw, the angle is about 5-10 degrees, compared to others I have where the angle is about 30 degrees.

I suspect that the height of the work piece is a primary consideration in determining what the proper angle would be. But am wondering if there are other considerations that come into play. I suspect that in some ways, this is a chicken and egg issue. eg. the lower the work piece in relation to the elbow position the higher the angle that will be required, and conversely, the higher the work piece in relation to the elbow, the lower the angle should be.

One of the reasons I am asking is that I am considering making some new handles, and want to know what the relevant issues are for determining handle angle before I start drilling holes etc.

Any issues I'm missing? Is there a more elegant way of describing the handle angle issue?

Thanks in advance.

cheers, Paul

p.s. sorry I don't have a digital camera to more easily show the differences I am talking about.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#2

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Paul there have been several threads about making saw handles and the "hang" issue came up in some also. "Hang" is the angle of the handle as it intersects the blade drawn with a perpendicular line to the hole for the fingers. You might search in particular for posts by Skip in Falls Church and William Duffield On the Cohansy(hope I spelled that right Sir Will) Both of these fine woodworkers have done nice work on saw handles.JR

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#3

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>You're opening another can of worms, here, Paul :^) If you think discussing bevel up vs. bevel down, tight mouth vs. high cutting angle, pins first vs. tails first, push vs. pull, Stanley vs. L-N vs. LV, iron vs. woodie, etc., can get contentious, just watch!

Having said that, a lot of guys like to cut their dovetails starting at the corner, because by following a line across the top and another one down the side at the same time is supposed to be easier to cut to the line. The problem I find is that to finish with a horizontal cut, it is necessary to bend your wrist way out of line. Also, I find it very difficult to start a DT saw with only one tooth cutting. I like a saw like the one you have, as long as the blade is nice and reflective, because I like to start the cut with several teeth touching the line on the end grain, and finish after just a few strokes, with the saw pointing in the same direction as when I started, and with my wrist straight for the whole cut. Of course, cutting dovetails is not as stressful as cutting tenons or ripping boards, so moving the wrist up or down away from its most natural position is not a serious problem. Ripping for a couple of hours every day with your wrist in the wrong position could lead to serious damage, but you shouldn't have any problem with dovetailing, unless you are predisposed to CTS from typing all day long or some such bad habit. In spite of all that "scientific" analysis, I use an L-N DT saw, holding my wrist wrong for the whole cut. What I really don't understand is those who find a gent's saw comfortable, and there are a lot of them who do, and who cut better dovetails than mine with them.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Jack Guzman from Maine

>Paul,this could be an ideal opportunity for you to make your own handle to fit your needs.Even though I haven't attempted to make a saw handle yet I plan to.I have a few pieces of apple I put aside just for that.---Jack

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#5

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Paul,

I think the person with the real answer here is Adam - in fact it sounds like your description of the hang of your handle is more like what Adam said a real tenon saw should be. Of course in keeping with the "mystery" part of the Arts and Mystery he won't seem to say much about handles except to blame the modern handle on Disston. :)

If I understand Adam rightly - and I'm sure he'll correct me if I'm wrong, the hang and position of the grip (along with the way the teeth are sharpened) pretty much determined the purpose of the saw. I'm still trying to figure things out myself. Something that drove me to making chair devils in frustration. :)

I also agree with Jack - take this opportunity to make a handle of your own - it's really easy and very satisfying. Try different hangs and see what works best for you.

As an aside - I'm almost done with the article on chair devils - I hope to finish it up this weekend. The last couple of weeks has been a bit busy.

Skip

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#6

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>As Sir William says, this is another minefield of different opinions. Percy Blandford, in one of his books, says that a line drawn at 90 degrees to the axis of the hand hole in a backsaw's handle should intersect the center of the length of the sawblade at the teeth (you'll find my scan of this drawing in the archives), regardless of type of backsaw (dovetail, tenon, etc.). The high end dovetail saws sold these days tend to have a much steeper angle, closer to the 90-degree line hitting the back teeth of the sawblade. I have a couple of Atkins saws and a Disston and Sons dovetail-size backsaw on which the handles are at this steeper angle, so Blandford clearly wasn't stating the Accepted Truth of his era.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#7

Saw handle angles

Adam Cherubini

>Gent's on top. !8th c style DT center. Disston (who know's what) bottom.


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#8

Gent's saw start 

Adam Cherubini

>


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#9

Gent's saw finish 

Adam Cherubini

>


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#10

DT start 

Adam Cherubini

>


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#11

DT finish 

Adam Cherubini

>


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#12

Tenon? start

Adam Cherubini

>This is not a dovetail saw. I'm just using it as an example of this handle geometry.


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#13

Tenon? finish 

Adam Cherubini

>


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#14

Summation (and Quiz)

Adam Cherubini

>I don't know about right or wrong ways. I'm just saying this makes sense to me:

Look at the shape of my hand and the line my knuckles make with respect to my wrist. Which saw appears most comfortable at the start and finish?

Adam

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#15

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>William, after reading your post I wondered how it was that I could use a gents saw (8") and a dovetail saw (10") without noticing a big difference in grip. I ran out to the shop and found that surpisingly I hold them nearly the same. In both cases my wrist is straight and my index finger is pointing to the middle teeth. My gents saw is one with a bulbous handle; I don't think one with a more cylidrical handle would work as well and I can't see how it would work to curl all my fingers around the handle and hold it like a wheelbarrow.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#16

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Dan Donaldson

>I have both the LN independence DT saw and the straight handled one. For me, I can cut better with the straight handled one. Not sure why, but I have an easier time keeping to the line and getting the cuts vertical.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#17

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Paul Erickson

>Hi Bill,

Thanks for the reply. I am having trouble finding the diagram you mention. Any assistance would be appreciated.

cheers, Paul

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#18

Re: Summation (and Quiz)

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Adam

Great pics (I have re-arranged them here in a way that may make it easier for all).

The Crown gents saw (which I own) has a nice, light feel and cuts very accurately. But it is light and requires a tighter grip and more downforce, which is evident in the position (and the tension ) of your forefinger.

The DT saw (which resembles the LN, which I also own) looks more relaxed - your wrist is straight and just pushing forward, as if you are just letting the saw�s own weight do the work.

The Tenon saw is heavy and unbalanced for this process (again, I recall using a 12� in just this situation). Your wrist is cocked upward, and this is not comfortable. Once the saw is level, however, your wrist/handle looks more relaxed than the others.

Regards from Perth

Derek


img

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#19

Re: Tenon? finish

Frank D. in Montreal

>I'd say the tenon saw. Is that a real tenon saw?

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#21

Re: Summation (and Quiz)

mikew

>I think Derek's photo compilation is a good example of handle hang, as well as how you are in one sense doing everything wrong, Adam .

The wood is improperly positioned in either the start or finish for one or another saw.

The wood should be higher to start/finish for the Gent's and lower for the start/finish for the tenon/back saw.

The DT saw has the wood marginally proper for the start, but Derek's finish picture shows that the wood should have been positioned a little lower. The DT saw's back is level--the toe is angled upwards. Part of this particular saw's issue, though, is the over filing towards the toe over time and or the back itself needs repositioned.

However, the DT would have finished with the blade bottom more at a 9 deg orientation to the wood had the plank been a tad lower in the vice. As is, the finish, in order to have the bottom properly positioned, your wrist would have been cocked downward.

Handle hang has a relationship to the wood's position in a vice or the bench top for the activity and saw in use.

Well, that be my observation and interpretation based upon my views of the issues regarding handle hang and wood position and saw selection.

Take care, Mike

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#22

Re: Summation (and Quiz)

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I agree with Mike.

The wood is too high for the brass backed dovetail saw.

When I cut tenons I keep the wood high in the vise and cut down the two lines using the exact same technique you are using.

When I cut dovetails I do it the Cosman way where I lay the saw across the end grain with a tooth or two resting on the far end of the board I then adjust the saw for a perpendicular cut with the face and saw away concentrating on keeping the saw perfectly vertical so I cut straight down.

I have no experience with Gent saws cause I am far from a Gent in real life.

Cheers

Dan CLermont

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#23

Re: Summation (and Quiz), and more questions

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Somebody should write an article :^)

The dovetail saw looks more comfortable at the start, when comfort is most important, because comfort affects accuracy. The Disston looks more comfortable at the end, but it's not nearly so important then. If you get the angle a bit wrong and cut too deep at the back (inside) or not quite deep enough, it doesn't show much. (We will disregard, for the time being, that this particular Disston is obviously too large and too heavy to be a practical dovetail saw, regardless of tpi and tooth configuration, but you already knew that.)

As I noted, the Disston would be more comfortable if you cut horizontally all the way across, but that's not necessarily the best way to do it.

Also, if you changed the height of the top of the stock, it would change your comfort and control zones. For example, if you dropped the stock to minimize vibration when cutting thin boards, I think the Disston would be even more comfortable.

To me, the gent's saw, the way you hold it, looks like it would be absolutely excruciating by the end of the cut, especially if you had several dovetaild drawers to do at one sitting.

Another observation: The very long, curved horns on the DT saw facilitate comfort, control and balance at widely varied angles of attack. The shorter horns on the Disston significantly decrease the included angle within which the saw is held effortlessly. To partially make up for this, the front horn above the index finger is larger, rounded off and smoothed on the Disston, so you can wrap your index finger around it to help lift the front of the saw.

I still don't understand the gent's saw's geometry. Would it work better if it were used on stock laying flat on the bench top, with a pull stroke, finishing vertically instead of horizontally? Somebody had to have tools and methods for cutting dovetails before the invention of the shoulder vise, right? Is this how Japanese saws are used?

One other non-observation (in other words, observing the evidence in the photos of sawing does not reveal anything meaningful): The DT saw has an open handle, the Disston has a closed handle. That detail doesn't seem to affect the operation of the saws. A speculation: Disston had tools for shaping handles the maker of the older saw did not have, which made manufacture of a closed handle saw easier? By closing the handle, Disston could make the handle stronger or maybe use less wood because he didn't have to watch the grain direction so carefully?

I have no historical evidence to back up any of these conjectures. The only saws I use that have the configuration of the gent's saw are much smaller saws, often called razor saws, which I mostly use for very small cuts on very thin stock, and a plug cutting saw with a handle cranked to one side.

Hopefully, you will get a lot more answers to this "quiz" from others with other experiences.

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#24

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

Don McConnell

>Hi Paul,

Your question has generated a number of interesting responses. So, I thought I'd throw in another consideration.

First a little background.

A couple of years ago, I decided to compare the "hang" of the various saws in the Seaton tool chest. They are all of one make (Kenyon, of Sheffield) and were all made about the same time (ca. 1796). With minor variations, the handles of the sash, tenon, panel and hand saws all had about the same relationship to the blades (based on the angle of the back of the grip). In other words, the four larger saws had about the same hang. The hang of the dovetail and carcass saws was noticeably different from the others.

After mulling over what this difference might be telling me about the usage of these two saws, I suddenly realized that I was overlooking something potentially significant. These shorter back saws also have significantly narrower blades. If their handles had the same orientation as the larger saws, the handles could easily run afoul of the work. Possibly more importantly, they would likely interfere with jointing the teeth as part of the sharpening process.

Just something else to ponder. :-)

I made up a handle for a dovetail saw based on the Seaton dovetail saw and really liked it. However, I also want to add that I believe we sometimes make too much of the issue of "hang" - especially if the saw is truly sharp and runs sweet.

For example, I've done some experimentation with fairly radical fleam angles for cross cut saw teeth (fleam angles which may have been more common before the widespread use of sharpening machines), and the last thing you want to do is exert downward pressure on the saw. Any downward pressure, and the saw becomes "sticky." No downward pressure, and it runs sweet and cuts very fast. A heavily canted handle on a saw with such teeth becomes counterproductive.

Don McConnell

Eureka Springs, AR

Re: Dovetail saw handle angle

#25

More data

Adam Cherubini

>Don't read too much into my fore finger. The bone dislocated and came out in a freak basketball accident. Because of the tendon damage, its never operated well since, and I lost a decent jumper.

I don't think it will be helpful to try to judge the height of my workpiece above my bench. Instead, look at the height with respect to my elbow. Like Chris Schwarz, I'm freakishly tall and I recently lowered my bench.

Adam