Re: Made a couple of devils :)
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>If you rework the handles on the next ones, be sure to keep these. They are really good looking, and will be a family treasure some day. I like your carvings.
For starters, I should mention that I have not used one of these, so the ergonomic advise that follows is all theoretical. I am assuming that you pull on the devil, while the chair spindle is held in a shaving horse, and that the blade takes a scraping cut, right? If so, I agree that you should get much better control if you drop the handles. Where they are now, it looks like you will get some torque, because the center line of the handle is well above the center of the scraper blade. I expect the torque will make them tiring to hold, because the handles will want to twist in your grip, and you will have to squeeze harder to keep the blade perpendicular to the tenon. It also appears that the surfaces where you will be applying the pressure with your hands are quite small, because the handles are narrow. I think the handles would be more comfortable if widened in that direction. You might also want to consider giving the handles a little bend in the other axis, slightly curving them away from your center, so that you will keep your wrists straight when pulling. The grip that I imagine using puts you hands closer together than your elbows. If any of this makes any sense at all, but is still not clear enough, let me know, and I can make a couple of drawings. I guess you could say I'm "playing the devil's advocate" :^)