WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

Posts

Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

#1

Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>Subsequent to the upstream discussion of hornbeams, and which (if not both) was used in the L-N chisels, I contacted Tom Lie-Nielsen to ask about the wood he uses.

He wrote:

"No hornbeam is commercially available that I know of, but we have a local source who is supplying us (the old fashioned way where they cut it in the woods for you...) and it is Hophornbeam, Ostrya Virginiana. Locally, it is known as Hornbeam or Ironwood. American Hornbeam also called Blue Beech I am told , and known as Carpinus Caroliniana, does not grow around here, although the ranges of the two species may overlap farther south."


Sir William's conclusion after examining his chisels was correct, and the surmise that some might be made of Carpinus Caroliniana is incorrect.

Re: Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

#2

Re: Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

john jesseph

>Any way of diffentiating these easily without actually breaking out Hoadley's book?

I have a bunch of chunks of hornbeam I got in Ohio, and a small log that is probably going to waste since I never milled it- maybe the wood would be good for something, I don't know. I planned on making mallets and tool handles from it, haven't done much yet. The biggest pieces may be good for small smoothers, but that's about it...

Re: Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

#3

Re: Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>This is all theoretical for me. They do not grow down here. Maybe some of folks in the temperate climates can respond?

Re: Lie-Nielsen Hophornbeam

#4

Re: Hop-hornbeam

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>The two trees are easy to distinguish by the bark. Hornbeam has smooth gray bark similar to beech, but with lumps resembling muscles. Hop-hornbeam has shaggy or flaky bark- thin, narrow strips of loose material.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.