WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Ruminations about saw reclamation...

Posts

Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#1

Ruminations about saw reclamation...

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>As I have mentioned now a few times below buried in a couple of threads, I have some of my grandfather's saws my uncle dumped on me.

I have read many comments about reducing the value of an older saw (or any other tool) by over-cleaning, removing patina, etc. However, in this case, there really isn't any "collector" value to destroy, since, quite frankly, the saws are in really really bad shape. For a recap, I have 3 saws. All 3 are bady rusted, and two have very broken handles. Only one has a medallion (a Disston), and it's a late model cheapo at that.

I'm in the process of removing rust through elbow grease and electrolysis but I'm wondering about the handles. Since these are in bad shape, I'm going to repair the broken ones and refinish all of them. How much effort I put in is really dependent on how the blades come out. The first one has come out fine...but I cleaned it using sandpaper/mineral spirits.

I'm not sure yet what finish I'm going to try...lots of possibilities...

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#2

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Christopher,

With a couple of broken handles you might find it fun to make a handle - especially if the handles are the newer ones designed for a 4 finger grip. If nothing else I'd suggest contouring any uncomfortable handles so they feel better. If nothing else you can always cut the saws up into scrapers. :)

Skip (seemingly addicted to making saw handles at the present)

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#3

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>That's part of my thinking...*if* the blades that pair with the broken handles end up worth keeping. I'm not certain they will. I have taken a pic or two so when I get further along I might post some pics.

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#4

Heard anything?

Tony - Memphis

>I was in Colco Saturday and heard the folks there talking about the place being sold (currently a verbal deal) and questioning what was going to happen to the store. My guess is that the retail business is about nill, but the back door stuff pays the bills. I sure would hate to lose the place as ita all we got nowadays!

Tony (bought a really nice piece of curly cherry)

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#5

I'm with Skippy

Ernie Miller

>Make some new handles they are easy and fun. even if the saws never turn out to be favorite users you will still have Grandpas saws hanging in the till to make you think of him.

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#6

No I...

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>hadn't heard anything.

hmmm...well I stopped shopping there a long time ago.

I figure if I need wood, I'll go over to the Woodwork Shop or maybe Nixon's lumber.

If colco gets bought and stops retail, then I would expect the Woodwork Shop to pickup some of the slack. They already have a smattering of wood in store. I bought a bunch of good poplar from them earlier this year.

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

#7

Re: Ruminations about saw reclamation...

paul womack

>I have some of my grandfather's saws ...

... I have read many comments about reducing the value of an older saw (or any other tool) by over-cleaning, removing patina, etc. However, in this case, there really isn't any "collector" value to destroy, ...

If you're not planning to sell them, the value question doesn't arise. Do as you feel best.

BugBear

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.