WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Walnut trim in workbench?

Posts

Walnut trim in workbench?

#1

Walnut trim in workbench?

Kelby

>I have been dutifully building my workbench over the past couple of weeks, and have a question. The base is completed and I am working on the top.

The top is laminated 6/4 hard maple (3-1/8" thick). To complete the top, I still need to (1) put on another 5" lamination on the front side of the top (the section with the dog holes in it), (2) install the endcaps, and (3) install the face vice and tail vice.

My question relates to using a bit of walnut to add some contrast. I have prepared some Walnut to use (a) for the endcaps, (b) for a 3/4" stripe down the front of the bench (i.e., next to the dogholes), and (c) for the business side of the tail vice. But before actually putting this on the bench, I noticed some website or other that showed where Walnut stands on the "hardness" index. Ouch. Now I know why people use Purpleheart for trim on workbenches. ;)

So my question is, is the walnut too soft to use as trim under these circumstances, or am I worrying too much? If it's an issue, I would rather go buy a few pieces of purpleheart now than spend the rest of my years wishing I had. If it's not an issue, I like the way Walnut looks a lot better than Purpleheart.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#2

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

David Wheeler

>Something to consider... a dark wood really absorbs light. I had some 8/4 Padauk that I used for my face vise and the bench dog length; it looks really nice; but in marking out and sawing DT's I regret not using all hard maple. I resort to using white paper against my work, at times, to reflect light on the piece. FWIW.

-David

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#3

David Barnett

Hardness 'numbers'

David Barnett

>The relative hardness scales for wood give a good general indication, but don't forget, they're normative. Wood hardness in some species can vary dramatically, and in the same tree. There's 'average' walnut, and there's walnut that's downright rock hard and stubborn. Most hard maple's plenty hard, but I've also seen variation there, too. If your walnut seems hard enough, then use it. I used it for my workbench base (walnut takes shock very well -- think gunstocks), but made the top from sugar maple, partly for the light. Lower reflectance could be a drawback for a solid walnut top, but for trim I wouldn't worry.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#4

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

Louis Bois

>Not that my opinion matters that much...but I really don't see a problem with walnut trim if you enjoy the esthetics of it...as long as the actual dog holes are part of the maple top. That is where the real stresses are going to be.

...you should be fine as long as you do most of your serious bashing a little bit in from the edge of the bench :)

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#5

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

Kelby

>Thank you all for your suggestions!

I hadn't thought about the absorbing light issue; I'll make sure to arrange the trim so that won't interfere.

Cheers,

Kelby.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#6

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

Ernie Miller Topeka

>I think you are going to want to use Ebony. You know dare to be differant. Wallnut will look nice.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#7

Should be fine...I think...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I'm using walnut for my vice faces (laminated to 10/4 hard maple) with no problems...so far. I'd worry about the light issue too on the front trim strip. It won't take a lot of contrasting wood to make a bench look nice. You could use hide glue to assemble it so that is changable if it doesn't work out for you.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#8

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

McKay Sleight

>I recently finished my own workbench, and I used maple on the edge which holds the dogs. The square dogs are birch. I have used the top extensively. In fact, I used the top to make the base which uses through tenons. I chopped the mortises on the top which was on a temporary base. The dark color of the edge and the Rosewood end vice were a pleasure to work with. Eventually, there will be tool cribs underneath the top to hold the tools that LOML does not know about.

Re: Walnut trim in workbench?

#9

Typo?

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>You wrote that you used maple on the edge, and then wrote about the dark color of the edge.

Dark maple?

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.