Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

Posts

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#26

A question Adam...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Why do you feel a bench should be against a wall?

I think it would be better to be able to walk around it.

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#27

Interesting! Thanks for the link. 

Jonathan Kaplan (OR)

>

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#28

Befuddled

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>...The legs are flush with the front of the bench, one centered under the twin screw with hole to insert a peg to hold up a board in the vise if needed...

I simply don't understand this. How can you have the leg both flush to the front of the bench and centered on a twin screw vise? The only way this is even possible is if half the vise hangs out further than the bench front, which seems sort of silly and unworkable.

Pam

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#29

Re: Befuddled

Dean J in MN

>

...The legs are flush with the front of the bench, one centered under the twin screw with hole to insert a peg to hold up a board in the vise if needed...

I simply don't understand this. How can you have the leg both flush to the front of the bench and centered on a twin screw vise? The only way this is even possible is if half the vise hangs out further than the bench front, which seems sort of silly and unworkable.


Hmm, I guess my description was poor. First, the twin screw is a face vise on my bench, not an end vise... The vise is on the front right side of my bench. The rear jaw is the bench itself. So my leg, which is flush to the front edge of the bench extends down from the middle of the "rear jaw" (the bench top). Does that make more sense?

-Dean, who is glad he doesn't make his living writing...

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#30

Re: Befuddled

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, I suppose so (I missed the right front position statement that you did make in the first message, sorry); but then the vise interferes with the benefits of having the leg flush with the bench front. I understand that you can remove the vise when necessary, but that seems a chore that's best no undertaken in the heat of work, definitely an interruption rather than flow.

Seems that it would be better to mount the vise on the end and add a leg.

Pam

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#31

Re: Befuddled

Dean J in MN

>

Yes, I suppose so (I missed the right front position statement that you did make in the first message, sorry); but then the vise interferes with the benefits of having the leg flush with the bench front. I understand that you can remove the vise when necessary, but that seems a chore that's best no undertaken in the heat of work, definitely an interruption rather than flow.

Seems that it would be better to mount the vise on the end and add a leg.


Well the intent of the flush leg and the hole(s) in the leg is not for edge jointing. It is to provide a load path for a board placed in the vise. The peg counters the load directed downward... And the leg flush counters another load, but really its there to provide a place to put your peg. So your board is secure in the vise and 'clamped' against that leg as well, and if needed a peg/holfast shank is there to stop it from dropping thru/provides support for downward forces. Think of cutting dovetails on a carcass side... I have a bit over 20" between centers, so I can clamp the entire carcass side, resting on a peg stop, and flush against the leg. A very secure position without having to crank vise super tight.

You are correct, you could get all these benefits if you mount the vise on end of the bench as well. But then it is in the way for cross cutting...

The sliding board jack is used for edge jointing. With the lenght of the bench I forsee the need to remove the vise to be very rare. (And it takes 15 seconds, maybe 30 if I have to clear a spot to put the vise, hardly a chore).

Cheers!

-Dean

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#32

Re: Befuddled

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>We clearly have very different ways of working. I have no need for a vise load path since I don't chop mortises in the vise. I understood the peg placement. Is this your load?

15 seconds to remove a twin screw vise. What kind of vise? Please be specific, I want one of those.

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#33

Re: A question Adam...

Adam Cherubini

>Why do you feel a bench should be against a wall?

I think it would be better to be able to walk around it.

I hear ya. And there's a ton of merit in what you say.

Here are a couple thoughts;

In historic shops, benches are only free standing when there are more benches than walls. Otherwise, they are always against a wall. One reason may be that this allows the bench to be proximate to a light source. No small consideration in a period shop.

But we can assume the wall is also used to add stiffness. The lateral force of planing is conducted through all the joints and inevitably is reacted by friction at the floor. Tying the bench to the wall short circuits the load path saving the bench joints, and stiffening the whole affair.

BTW snap-on claims its mechanic tools are stiffer than the competition. As a result, more torque is transferred to the job as opposed to being used to flex the tool. That means, according to snap-on, less energy to turn a bolt, and less worker fatigue over the course of a day. A stiff bench makes a lot of sense using a similar rationale.

Tool storage is another issue. While I find my traditional toolchest perfectly acceptable to work out of, period images typically show chests closed, and tools stored on walls behind the bench, and on or under the bench. It may be that toolchests were only used for transportation, and not ready access. That may help explain chests like Seaton's that stores molders sans blades and wedges. Free standing bencches are sometimes depicted with integral chisel racks (see Diderot).

The wall may have also served as a lateral support/fence for the work. The images I'm discussing are all of benches without tail vises. This "English-style" of working often requires an applied fence.

My bench is not currently against a wall. I did this so I could rip at the back of my bench (overhand). Also, because I have a scornful European style bench with a tail vise, the only free right hand corner is the one directly opposite the LH face vise. I'm not convinced this was the best idea. Also my walls are entirely used for lumber racks.

So (in conclusion) the structural benefits might help excuse our poor workmanship. The ancillary benefits of tool storage and fencing may be worthwhile. And I guess I think 100 years of woodworking wisdom is worth our serious consideration.

Adam

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#34

Thank you Adam!

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>As usual it makes some sense to me now. Thank you for your explanation.

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#35

Re: Befuddled

Dean J in MN

>Pam -

Yep, we all have different ways of working. I like learning about all the ways to complete a task, it is always interesting to learn a new trick!

I timed it last night, 15 seconds I really have to be cranking.. :) So 30 is more like it... It is just a Veritas Twin screw...

-Dean

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#36

Re: Befuddled

Wendell @ Murphy, TX

>Dean,

Is there any chance you could post a picture of your bench? It sounds very similar to what I envision building. Also, are you right or left handed? I am curious because of where you put your vise. The traditional place is the left side for right handers. I don't quite see the logic in it. To me it seems like it should be on the right side for right hander. The only reason I can come up with for the tradition is that a vise on the right would get in the way of edge joinging. Do you find this to be a problem?

Wendell

Re: Planning my bench, curmudgeon style.

#37

.

Eric Hedberg

>