Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

Posts

Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#1

Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In the shop to finish building that saw till, somebody changes all the parameters.

WARNING! If you are currently constructing a saw till, you may want to stop right here, close this window, and go back to what you were doing. The frame saw I recently built, and for which I provide construction details here, just isn't going to fit in the standard knuckle-dragger's saw till.

The article posted below is very long, and with lots of pictures.

Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS* *LINK*

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#2

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS* *LINK*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>You have been given fair warning. Here's the finished saw�well almost finished, anyhow. I really need to do something about the black plastic knobs. While they are perfectly functional, they somehow detract from the aesthetics. I'm also providing dimensions, in inchs and fractions and in American National thread sizes, in case you just want to "cut and paste." Instead, you can peruse the concepts, bleep over the excruciating details, and use whatever stuff you have laying around and gathering dust in your own shop. That's what I did. I'm not converting anything to metric or to decimal fractions for you, and I don't think you need to worry a lot about precise measurements either, regardless of your chosen system of measurements.


There are four major steps to the construction, in order:

� Find or make the blade;

� Make the blade tensioning mechanism;

� Make the frame to fit the blade;

� Lighten the frame and shape it to fit you.

The Blade

I used a Wilhelm Putsch blade, about 5 ppi, rip. These blades are carried by Woodcraft (about $6) and also Highland Hardware. They have way too much set to cut efficiently in seasoned hardwoods , but work ok in softwoods like SYP. Putsch also manufactures them in other tooth configurations, and sell a complete framesaw to fit. When I picked out my blade, I didn't even look at the saw, as I already knew I was going to build my own.

An even less expensive way to get a blade is to cut up an old beater yard sale saw. No, I'm not about to cut up my 50� ca. 1880 Disston D8 Thumbhole Rip with the "Rising and Thorne" etch, shown in the photo. It's just there for illustration purposes in case you don't recognize the term "saw" without any preceding adjective. You can score it with a scribe or a file and break it at the score line in a sheet metal brake or saw vise, or you can cut it with a torch or a hacksaw, or even use a screaming forked-tailed spark spitting blue demon, like the one in the photograph. Then use a pin punch, deliver a sharp blow with a heavy hammer into an end grain block of hard maple to make a hole in each end.


Making The Mounting and Tensioning Hardware

Next, the blade needs a method to mount it in the frame and tension it. The next photo shows the completed attachment. It will take several steps to machine the tensioners. I made two of them the same.


I started with about 6" of allthread (A.K.A. threaded rod). Here are c couple of links to an informal discussion of thread sizes, including American National Fine and Coarse threads. I used 3/8"-16 NC, because I have a pair of through-threaded knobs in that size on hand. I think the knobs were about a buck each at Woodcraft, but I might have picked these up at Woodworkers Warehouse or from TWC. 5/16"-18 NC would work just as well, and you could probably get away with 1/4"-20 NC. If you choose a thread size that is too small, you will have to choose a smaller screw, and may therefore have problems with the long-term durability of the screw. If you choose a size that is too large, you will unnecessarily weaken the wooden arms, or will have to make them thicker and therefore heavier, to compensate.

With a hacksaw, cut a slot in the end of the allthread. Neatness counts. If you get it crooked or off center, you will have trouble getting the blade in and out of the frame, may compromise the strength of the connection to the blade, and will definitely have difficulty keeping the blade from twisting during installation and use. I cut mine 3/4" deep, and use about 5/8" of that depth. You will have to calculate the depth based on the distance of the hole in the blade to the end of the blade.


With a file, flatten the first half inch of one side, so you have a flat to tighten the screw and lock washer against. In the center of the flat, about 3/16" from the end, make an indent with a center punch, to make it easier to start the twist drill.


I searched through my bucket-o-bolts and my paltry collection of taps, and found a match in a size that would hold the blade in place. I drilled and tapped a hole through the allthread to accept a 10-32 NF x 1/2" Phillips round head machine screw, with a split ring lock washer. Between the flat and the slot, I drilled an 5/32" or 11/64" relief hole, which clears the screw's threads. I then continued all the way through the threaded rod with a #23 drill bit, which matches the 10-32 NF tap. The tap and matching drill bet are sold as a set, and the drill size is printed on the shank of the tap.

I'm making two tensioners, one from each end of the 6" length of allthread. I'll cut it in two at the center mark later.


Here is the setup I used to hold the allthread while I drilled the holes. It is a homemade cherry V-block, held in a $40 Grizzly sliding cross vise. The allthread is held in the V-block with a C-clamp.


The SXV aligns the center of the 11/64" drill bit with the bottom of the V-block.


Clamp the allthread with the flat and slot horizontal, and center the drill bit over the indent.


At low speed, lubricated with cutting oil, drill to the depth of the slot.


Without changing the position of anything, remove the 11/64" drill bit and replace it with the #23 drill bit. Continue the hole on the same center, all the way through the allthread.


Put the 11/64" drill bit back in the chuck, turn the allthread end for end, repeat the alignment procedure, and drill the holes in the other end for the second tensioner.

Back at the bench, tap the threads in the bottom, smaller diameter hole.


I find it easier to hold a longer piece of allthread when I'm working on it, and then hacksaw it in two after everything else is done. The finished length is 3". Chase the threads with a triangular file or a die, and file off any burrs. Don't panic. I'm not cutting the file. The vise jaws are 6" above the bench top.


Attach a tensioner to each end of the saw blade with the machine screw and lock washer. It will be easy to remove if you want to swap blades, or whenever you need to sharpen the blade.


If you think all that is too much work, you could just drill a hole all the way through and use a 10d common framing nail, bent over, or even a cotter pin. If you don't have any allthread, you can hacksaw the head off a hex machine bolt or a carriage bolt. You only need threads in the last inch or so of the outboard end anyhow.


Here are the assembled components of the blade and tensioner.


Making The Frame

This frame is 331/2" long by 241/2" wide. It is constructed of oak, half red and half white, salvaged from a restaurant remodeling job. I scraped and sanded off the poly and planer marks and later strategically hid most of the holes. It started out at 13/16" x 13/4". The length of the arms was determined by how much stock I had left over after I cut the stretchers to fit the blade. This allows 101/4" between the kerf and the far edge of the sawn plank, which should be sufficient for most tasks I expect to encounter.


The blade is 271/2" long, but the stretchers are 273/4" between tenon shoulders. When the blade is installed and tensioned, the arms bend 1/8" each over their 201/2" length between tenons. If you are using different species of wood or different dimensions for the arms, you may need to lengthen your stretchers to get enough tension on the blade. When not in use, it is a good idea to release the strain on the arms.

Drill a 3/8" diameter hole through the center of each arm, to accept the threaded rod. If you use smaller allthread, definitely use a smaller hole.

Chop a mortise near each end of each arm, and cut a matching tenon in each end of each stretcher. I cut my tenons 1" long, 5/16" wide and 3/4" deep, 1/8" from the inside edge of the stretchers. I positioned the matching mortises 7/8" in from the ends of the arms.


Assemble the frame, insert the blade, screw on the knobs, tension the blade, and you have a working saw.

Note that you don't really need large knobs at both ends. On the bottom, you can use a wing nut, or a simple hex nut and a washer, since you can do all your tensioning from the other end. If you carry a wrench in your toolbox, you can even use a hex nut and a washer on each end. Making your own wooden knobs is the high class option. There are several ways to make them. Round ones can be turned on the lathe, or ones with wings can be made completely with hand tools. Threads can be provided by a T-nut or by gluing a hex nut in place with epoxy. If I get around to making some, I'll post another article on the process.


The saw met its first timber at just this stage of construction, and passed the test. While ripping about three fathoms of old growth long leaf heart pine, I paid close attention to where I was most likely to hold the frame, and where my hands felt the most uncomfortable. I even started working the edges of the top frame with a spokeshave to begin to refine the grip.

Do not glue up the frame. You want to be able to disassemble it to make it more portable, or to fit in a corner of your saw till. Also, you may eventually need to make another pair of stretchers to accommodate a different length saw blade. Disassembled, all the components fit in a length of 4" PVC pipe, with end caps, if you need to carry it down to the docks.


Refining the Fit

The first refinement I made was to glue some blocks onto the centers of each side of both arms to prevent the blade from twisting as I apply tension with the knobs, and later while sawing. The blocks are hard maple. They are rabbeted to fit to the sides and edges of the arms, while providing a snug fit to the tensioner, in case I want to use a narrower blade. The photo shows the cutting of slots in these blocks to accept the ends of the blade. Making the stretchers a little shorter and cutting into the arms is another alternative, especially if you start with well oversized stock.


At just over 4 pounds, the finished saw is not light. I don't know how much I could decrease the critical dimensions in oak without sacrificing needed strength. If weight were important, you could substitute hickory or even Sitka spruce for the oak, but you'll have to figure out for yourself how thin you could get away with. You could also laminate the arms and stretchers, insinuating fiberglass cloth or even carbon fiber between the laminations, if you wanted significant weight reduction. You could even go all the way, and build the frame from sections of a wipe-out wind surfer spar.

I planed the stretchers down to a little less than 5/8" thick. I bent a batten to define a gentle arc and tapered the ends of all four frame members from 13/4" at the center down to 11/4" at each end. I retained the original width at the centers, to minimize the loss of strength where the stresses are greatest. Note in the above joinery photo, the displacement of the mortises and tenons towards the inside of the frame, in anticipation of this refinement. I then rounded the ends of the arms, and eased the edges of all four frame members.

It was obvious that it needed larger grips for comfort. I also found out that sometimes I would move my grip toward the center of the arms, or out toward the ends of the arms, and even to the tops of the stretchers. I could thereby work different muscle groups, extending the time I could saw before exhaustion.

I found some scrap 1/4" thick mahogany, a lot lighter and easier to shape than the oak, glued two pairs of pads onto the top arm and a pair onto the top end of each stretcher. I rounded them over with rasps, files, sanding drum and sand paper, until they were comfortable. Again, if you start with well oversized stock, you can build the grips in from the beginning, and remove stock from everywhere else to reduce weight.


The next photo shows the completed anti-blade-twist blocks in use and the final shape of the grips.


I stained the oak and mahogany with vinegar and rust, to give it an "old wood" look, and then finished it with Watco Danish oil.

I made one more refinement, for portability. With a very thin kerf plywood blade in the TS, I ripped a narrow slot about 1/4" deep in the inside edge of one of the stretchers. When disassembled, I slip the toothed edge of the blade into the slot, and this stretcher now doubles as a blade guard.

I hope you get some useful ideas from this. I also hope it stimulates you to come back to us with some even better ideas.

William of the Cohansey

Loxahatchee Toolworks

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#3

Thank you sir!

L. Hanson - N. Idaho

>A keeper, for sure! I plan on doing one sometime this coming fall, this will be handy!

Leif

norsewoodsmith.com

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks William

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I just may get that frame saw built now. I like the idea of using a western saw blade. Has that method of scoring and breaking been tested and proven?I have a craftsman rip saw that would be a good donor. I could use the rest of the blade for scraper stock.

I wish I had your energy.---Jack

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#5

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Outstanding Sir Will! Your tutorial will be very helpful to those that may want a framesaw.JR

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#6

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Paul in NJ

>The Loxahatchee Toolworks R&D folks have come up with another winner!

Paul Dzioba

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#7

Re: Thanks William

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>I haven't done it myself, especially on a straight edge that long. In fact, I can't even get glass to break in a straight line :^) However, I do it all the time with hacksaw and bandsaw blades, and it is standard practice to produce smaller card scraper stock, by breaking up old wornout blades after scoring with a file. Even if it doesn't break smartly the first time, after flexing it a couple of times, saw steel is hard enough that it will snap. You'll probably have to clean up the edge with a file when you're done. Maybe Todd H. can help out with pointers on technique?

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#8

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>No D8's were harmed in the making of this tutorial. Thanks again for the opportunity for a small gloat.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#9

Re: Thanks William

L. Hanson - N. Idaho

>I don't know about scoring, but I've been cutting up a bunch of old saws to use the steel in some backsaws I'm making using a $2 cutoff blade in an old circular saw mounted in a makeshift table. I then just screw a piece of plywood to the particle board "table" that serves as a fence. I use a plastic tie to hold the trigger open, and just plug it in to turn it on. I'll put a pic below so you can see what I mean...

Works great for me and keeps the width nice and consistent with a good clean edge... does use a tailed thing, though.

Leif

norsewoodsmith.com


img

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Now I have to try it

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I'll let you know what happens,but I'm gonna try that scoring and snapping method on a cheap blade first.---jack

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#11

Leave it to you Sr. William...

Scott Burr Ben Lomond,CA

>I haven't seen all the pics (they load slow @ home), but I think I'm seeing something spawned here prehaps a great saw makin post.

I want more...

Scott, droolong tonight...

I've had dinner...

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#12

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Matti Kuikka

>Wery ;) nice work and presentation again. I see at least a couple of ways to improve a frame saw I made couple of years ago and haven't used much. I found it difficult to keep tracking because of blade movement despite tensioning. Also adding "pads" should maked it much more comfortable to use. Thank you.

I'm also curious how do you find working it as compared to a japanese rip cut esp. in smaller pieces.

Matti Kuikka

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#13

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

billp

>Thanks William for the inspiration!!

~williamofwisconsin

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#14

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Christof Hartge

>Many thanks, William for your detailed report. Since you annonced it, I expected it eagerly as resouce of ideas to build my own one.

Especially the anti-twisting blocks are a help for me.

To the weight of a frame saw: I saw pictures of an Lachapelle frame saw as it was build around 1900. Yours is a leight-weight model against it. It should be mentioned that their frame saw was 52" long. This saw had the strechters set more inside of the frame so that it forms an big 'I' with two vertical arms. As far as I know this was the form for cutting matched boards and veneer.

To the tentioners: Wouldn't it be also possible to heat the bolt at one end and hammer a flat surface on an anvil? The advantage might be that the blade rests on a bigger surface.

To the shape of the blade: The big saws, as the two-man saws often have a convex line of teeth. I don't know exactly what the advantage is, perhaps someone else knows. But if this good for big hand saw, is it also o good for a frame saw, cutting big stock also?

Greetings, Christof.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#15

Christof

Todd O. Cronkhite Native of Maine

>The big saws, as the two-man saws often have a convex line of teeth

I do believe that the big saws have the convex line of teeth, which here is commanly refered to as the "belly" is so that the lowest cutting line is below the lowest edge of the handle this allowing you to cut the log just about all the way thru without ramming your hand and handle into the ground.

Todd O.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#16

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Matti,

I don't have a Japanese rip cut saw, and do not have much experience using one. The times I have used one, I chose it because it was the only saw on the job site that would do that particular job. In those cases, the frame saw would not have had clearance. For ripping smaller pieces, I usually use a TS, until they get dangerously small, and then I use a tenon saw (a backsaw, filed rip) or the neanderbuddy and clean up with a plane. I find the frame saw tracks better than the D8 on large jobs, probably because it is easy to interpolate back from the far end of the frame to where the blade exits the kerf. The additional force I can apply to the blade through the heavy frame compensates very well for the much wider kerf cut by the grossly set Putsch blade. I'm planning to keep that blade for framing, cutting logs and softwoods, but will probably make another one with better geometry for ripping hardwoods.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#17

Re: Veneer Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>I've seen photos and discussion of a Galoot-made veneer saw. I thought it was an interesting design, as the stretchers were adjustable in slots in the arms, so you could move them towards or away from the blade, depending on the thickness of the veneer you wanted to cut In this manner, they acted as rip fences. That particular saw was delicate, obviously designed for book matched panels and fine cabinetry, but not a Nakashima coffee table. Building one of them would be a viable alternative to buying a bigger bandsaw, or even a riser block, for slicing veneer and book matched panels. There are advantages and disadvantages to such a saw. While the advantages are obvious, I'll mention some of the perhaps less obvious disadvantages, off the top of my head: it is more complicated to build; for the same strength, it needs to be heavier, due to the slots in the arms; wear-resistant wood is required for the stretchers. For more info on these, you might try searching the OldTools Archives. Regarding a 52" blade length: An advantage to a longer blade is that you can cut thicker wood, with kerf up to about half the length of the blade. Every tooth has to be able to travel all the way out of the wood either at the end of the forward stroke or the end of the backward stroke, else it won't clear the sawdust from the gullet and it will stop cutting.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#18

Re: Another Source for a Blade�

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>�that I forgot to mention: A piece of a blade from a bandsaw mill would work well, especially one that stopped before it got all the way around after finding a horseshoe or a ceramic insulator. You could consider it an "opoportunity" when the Woodmiser operator tells you that you just bought the blade :^( For some applications, a piece of a narrower blade from a smaller bandsaw will work as well. That would put the 52" version that Christof mentioned well within the realm of possibilities.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#19

Re: Leave it to you Sr. William...

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>I tried to keep the pictures small and cropped, but there are lots of them, with, I hope, lots of useful detail. If anyone needs a larger, clearer image of any part of the process, I can upload one.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#20

Re: Veneer Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS* *LINK*

Ted Shuck

>There is a link to a veneer saw built with fences on Bugbear's bowsaw page. The concept looked so good to me that I built one last year. I was not happy with the performance of the fences and wrote up my experience on Roger Nixon's "Traditional Tools" website. I have included a link to this posting below. Scroll about halfway down the page to find my post.

I separated the stretchers to the widest settings and still use it as a framesaw, but without using the stretchers as fences.

Ted


Framesaw article at TraditionalTools

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#21

Re: Veneer Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>Thanks, Ted. Somehow, during my research I missed the Traditional Tools thread and also Chris Swingley's instructions. I guess there's not much new under the sun, is there? I did see Josh Clark's version of the framesaw, but I still question his choice of joints. IMHO, the M&T is the better joint for a framesaw, but I haven't tested his DT joint to be sure.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#22

Steve Kubien

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Steve Kubien

>Well Sir William, that kinda puts mine to shame. I used some pallet-wood teak for the cross-members and 1" copper pipe (salvaged) for the stretchers. I built mine to help in ripping a 16" diameter cedar phone pole (also salvaged). I will guess that mine comes in at about 7lbs. I used a 1/2" 3tpi bandsaw blade and it is close to 4ft long. It's not pretty but it works.

Great post! Thanks for sharing.

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#23

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>I'd love to be a fly on the wall of your shop. Probably pick up enough knowledge just from looking around that it would take me 10 years to sort it all out. Thanks for posting.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#24

Re: Frame Saw Construction (LONG!) *PICS*

William R. Duffield on the Cohansey

>The spiders would get you for sure! I don't take photos of them, or their webs, or most of the accumulated dust and shavings. Just the cluttered bench, all the other kludges, and the incomplete projects are confusing enough.

Re: Just When You Thought It Was Safe To Go Back In�

#25

This will be an Article, right?!

Wiley Horne--Glendora CA

>It sets the standard for communication.

Wiley