WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

The oilstone wears

Posts

The oilstone wears

#1

The oilstone wears

Jonathan Peck - N.Y.

>Here's how them old dudes did it

The oilstone wears according to the peculiar method of the user. I once

heard of an old labourer, with a walk so shambling that his wheelbarrow

wheel accomodated itself to it, becoming worn in such a way that no one

else could push the barrow with comfort. A wheelwright in my village, not

having a lathe, made his bride a rolling pin with the drawing knife and

spokeshave. It was out of the true, but she acquired the art of rolling

out good pastry with it. It was the despair of her daughter and friends,

but the good wife used it with satisfaction to the end of her days. I

have seen oilstones so crooked with use that none but the accustomed user

could possibly obtain a true edge from them. But it should be explained

that the crooks were lengthwise and that crosswise the stone was fairly

flat.

It is easier to sharpen a true edge on a wide tool with a narrow stone

than with a wide one. Thus I prefer the 1 3/4 inch width, which I have

proved to be the happy medium, and I will not entertain the 2-inch width

usually stocked by tool factors. The slight increase in width makes all

the difference in the result, because the wider the stone the more is the

tendency to sharpen in the middle - a habit to which learners are prone -

thus causing the stone to become hollow with wear. Correct sharpening is

the primary art of all good workmanship, and all woodworkers know that it

is almost impossible to obtain a true edge on a hollow stone. But should

a stone become hollow it may be remedied by rubbing it flat on the side of

a grindstone, or on a flat slab of York stone with water and sharp sand,

as the stonemason does in the preparation of his work.

Walter Rose

Re: The oilstone wears

#2

Re: The oilstone wears

Tony - Memphis

>I took a carving class from Mack Headley a while back...his oil stones looked so crude...I think he got them from an older gentleman's tools. Anyway, it was neat to see what he did with them and how rough they looked. But after all, they are just rocks!

Tony

Re: The oilstone wears

#3

Re: The oilstone wears

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I have found several very good old stones at flea markets; the only problem is they were used for knife sharpening instead of chisel or plane sharpening, and are not flat enough lengthwise or crosswise to sharpen anything except a fish hook. The best stone is dished about 1/4", and at one time I started wondering how long it would take to flatten with sandpaper or a cement block, and wore through the cement block without making much progress.

I've wondered how a person who makes gravestones flattens their stones, and whether I would perhaps be able to find one of these people and have them flatten my stones for me.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.