WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

OT, Kinda long...

Posts

OT, Kinda long...

#1

OT, Kinda long...

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>Listening to my favorite radio talk show guy today gave me some insight into the power tool user vs the hand tool user discussion that peppers our messages.

The host was talking about the lack of personal contact our society seems to have. Mentioned gas stations of yore where the guy pumped your gas, checked your oil, washed your windshield and chatted with you while doing so. Replaced by self-serve cash & dash stations.

Air conditioning that keeps us in the house on a hot evening instead sitting out on the porch hoping to catch a breeze while talking with a neighbor or greeting a passer-by. I remember my mother talking with a neighbor across the fence while hanging washed clothes on a line in the backyard.

He mentioned how T.V. has replaced the need to have friends over for chats, cards, etc.

While he spoke, I thought about machine tools that have replaced the human contact with the wood; the absence of tell-tale marks left on the bottom of a hand made table by a scrub plane. Marks that testified to the once present skilled hands of a human. The marks that were once just one of many individual threads that bound us into a community.

Is it possible that those who cling most tenaciously to the Neander/Galoot philosophy are possibly the most 'human' of us all? Willing to forsake the convenience/speed/money that power tools promise to bring to a shop; they quietly engage the enemy in a pitched battle. In a society where time is money, to the unthinking casual observer they appear to be squandering their time. (Thinking of St. Roy, now) In the only way they can, they fire silent volleys against a society apparently bent on breeding a generation of citizens to whom impersonal relationships are considered as normal as Mom (surrogate of course), Apple Pie (Sarah Lee of course) and Baseball (on T.V. of course).

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#2

Re: OT, Kinda long...

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>The answer is a lot simpler in my case.

I am primarily a power tool user not because it's faster, but because it raises my skill level several notches. A good example is dovetails. With practice and a lot of ruined stock I could probably learn to do it by hand. With a router and a jig I did right the first time I tried. I can pass a 10 inch board through a planer and it will come out nice and even across its width. I could try the same thing by hand (I do have the toys for it)and there will be visible differences in thickness. Even something as seemingly simple as sawing to a line is never going to be anywhere near as good done by (my) hand as it will by sliding it along the rip fence of my tablesaw.

When they first became available, power tools served the purpose of making it possible for a skilled workman to do the job faster. Now for the most part they serve to replace skills that the user does not possess. Before I have a bunch of people from the other side jumping all over me, let me say that I know there are power tool users who do have the skills but just prefer to do it a little faster.

I salute those of you who can work just as well in an out building in the middle of a pasture as they can a few feet from a 200 amp electrical panel.

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#3

Re: OT, Kinda long...

Mike Real

>I look at life as a journey of learning and each project I do with handtools as a lesson. If I listen to the silence I hear the lesson the tool has to teach me. My shop time is centering time away from the madness our society is descending into. I can slow down and enjoy the journey to be followed in each project. We too often focus on the end of the project/journey and miss the joy along the way. We are afraid of mistakes and failure but these are the sources of learning and we should take pride in the real humanity of those mistakes. My first project with handtools was a shaker two step stool....awful handcut dovetails, botched measurements, etc. But I learned.

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#4

.It` just a different way of thinking

Bob Hackett

>I`ve come to believe that the only REAL wood comes from air drying instead of a kiln.It requires me to walk in the woods and look at trees,or drive down to the local family owned sawmill(Willis Libby)and talk to him to see what`s available or coming in.It allows me to build a rapport with the sawyer and other woodworkers who show up at the mill.I talk to the folks bringing in the logs too and they tell me where they left the burls or where to find the stump from a highly figured log they`ve brought in.

The main reason I use AD wood is that it still has the natural colors in it,unsteamed,unhomogenized.It also acts like it wants to work along with me instead of acting like something that was tortured into submission.AD or KD,either will end up at the same EMC when they`ve adjusted to thier new life and surroundings.

We put wood in a kiln for our own convenience and profit.Along the way we lose the contact with the sawyer,logger,and any number of other people with untold experience and stories.We also lose part of the wood and the skills needed to work wood directly from the tree.That connection is priceless.Yet another good reason to slow down and think about what it is we`re really after.

Mainely,Bob

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#5

Re: OT, Kinda long...

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi Frank,

Some interesting thoughts you bring up. I think using hand tools defies the capitalist mindset that is taking over every aspect our lives (I'll put on my helmet now...). I'm not anti-capitalist that's just the way I see history. It's basically efficiency above all; non-productive time is wasted time. Even things we considered as human or normal, like getting sick, having a few bad habits, having a baby or an accident...) are now claculated as losses or lost productivity; in effect, they have kind of replaced sins, and recent legislation has often tried to eliminate them at the expense of the individual (drug testing at work is a good example). No coincidence that modern, mechanized methods of production have been invented at a time when capitalism has flourished.

I think using hand tools, "wasting" time having fun, goes against this mindset, a way to say "the market stops here" or "this is where I start." So we might not be more human, but maybe more rebellious or affirmative, or more nostalgic of times when the human side of humans counted for more (has it ever counted for more? I'm not even so sure).

FWIW,

Frank

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#6

Re: OT, Kinda long...

Christof Hartge

>Hello Frank, basically you are right. Although I'm not sure, if we are the most human for that. Healthy mistrust against oneself is not the baddest thing.

I see it this way: Workingtime is the most precious good of our days. As spices were in the 16th century. As the only ship of Fernando de Maghelan that survived surrounding of the world was back in Spain, the sacks of pepper and other spices weighed up the total lost of the three other ships.

When we work with handtools and deliberately spend leisue time on them, we are able to give our projects a scent of personlity and craftmaship, as the most precious spice in the whole work.

Greetings, Christof.

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#7

Re: OT, Kinda long...

kees

>Hallo,

So you are a machinist? What you are telling is that everybody can do that kind of woodwork.

That's not a problem as long as you have customers for your work.

I've had furniture factory, and know every donkey/monkee a part of the trick.

regards,

kees

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#8

Nice metaphor, Christof

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>Your command of poetic English is always very impressive.

Re: OT, Kinda long...

#9

Re: OT, Kinda long...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>1. Sometimes they're faster, or permit us to do something that simply can't be done with power (quick: with a power tool, how do you remove an accurate 1/8" from the bottom of a post that's held 1" above porch framing, as I did last year? It took me five minutes with a sharp handsaw).

2. Sometimes they permit greater precision - a hand plane can remove a fine shaving to fit a board to a space with far greater precision than any power tool I know of - or better quality - contrast a surface hand-planed well with one sanded well.

3. Sometimes they permit us to work in spaces where power tools wouldn't - I do a lot of processes by hand in my shoplet because I can't run the boards across a power tool in a 11 x 11 shop.

4. Sometimes it's nice not to make noise and fine dust (now we're getting to the emotional stuff, although only for the user).

4. Sometimes it's nice to make something by hand and enjoy the intimacy with the wood and the meditative working style that a power tool won't permit; an inevitable outcome of this is that the resulting piece isn't highly regulated.

I kill a LOT of electrons on the weekends, but I go back and forth from power to hand, depending on all the above factors. I'm always happiest when I'm using hand tools.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.