WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

restoration question

Posts

restoration question

#1

restoration question

Bruce, a MN galoot

>My wife inherited a dresser from her grandfather, and I've inherited the job of restoring it. It probably dates back to the 1910's or so, maybe the 20's. I wouldn't call it an antique, just relatively old. Its major value is as a family keepsake, certainly not a treasured antique

The rails and stiles are held together by dowels, and they're loose enough to come apart, so I'm suspecting hide glue. The drawers are machine-cut dovetails. Drawer bottoms all have to be replaced. One of the side panels (plywood) is badly split and separated and needs to be replaced. The finish is damaged enough that my wife just wants it stripped and re-done.

Here's the major question. Those pesky dovetails are really rough. I don't have a digital camera so I can't post a pic, but the main problem is that I suspect that even when new they weren't particularly well fitting. The pins don't reach all the way to the bottom of the sockets.

There are three solutions that I see:

1. Just leave them alone, re-glue the joints as well as possible and let them go at that.

2. Where possible, drive shims into the dovetail joints and plane them flat.

3. Cut off the dovetails, shorten the drawer sides by 1/2" and re-cut the dovetails.

Any suggestions?

Thanks

Re: restoration question

#2

Re: restoration question

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>If it's an authentic restoration project, Bruce, try to do as little as possible. Maybe scrape the dowels and reglue with hide glue.

Leave the dovetails alone, to better display their original condition.

Best, Ted

Re: restoration question

#3

Ditto

glh

>

Re: restoration question

#4

Re: restoration question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Thanks, Ted,

A couple of the joints will have to come apart because they're loose anyway. But I'll leave it alone. This is hard for me, because my inclination is to make it better, not just restore it, but I think you're right.

Thanks again.

Bruce, who is off to the hide glue store.

Re: restoration question

#5

Re: restoration question

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Well, then, if you would prefer to "improve" it, so the piece is more useful to you or looks newer, just go ahead. And don't let anyone talk you out of it. You understand that in such a case it would not be a restoration, and future value to a third party would be diminished.

The point is for you to be happy with the piece. Or...the better point is for your wife to be happy with it. : )

Best, Ted

Re: restoration question

#6

Re: restoration question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I don't think I made myself clear enough. My inclination is to improve it. My wife wants it restored. Whatever makes her happy...

Bruce

Re: restoration question

#7

Whatever makes her happy...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Ahh, good decision. : )

Best, Ted

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.