WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

Posts

A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#1

A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>

Spokeshaves like the Stanley 151 we�ll be tuning here cut exactly like a plane � the critical parts are the blade support in back, the cap iron fit supporting the unbeveled blade edge, and the distance between the edge and the front sole � the opening of the mouth.


Check the blade support in the casting � this 15-dollar Ebay contemporary Stanley 151�s is fine�use Prussian Blue or soot from a smoky lamp to find and flat needle files to take down any high spots. Simply smoke or coat the blade, gently put it in place, and tighten the slotted screw to make the marks.


Using a straightedge, check the sole for flatness�


�and the side of the mouth the blade bears on for straightness.


If filing is required, use single-cut fine pillar files and flat needle files. Keep them clean as you use them. Folks have commented that these techniques apply only to flat spokeshaves and that soles can only be flattened on a ground surface, and not with crude files. I agree you can stone them or sandpaper them flat....but I'll have to do a piece one day on selecting and using files in the cross and draw mode....because filed metal surfaces certainly can go straight from drawfiling to buffing wheel and be dead flat...it's really not anymore difficult than freehand honing a plane iron. I wouldn't go to the trouble of cementing abrasive paper on the jointer table for flattening anything smaller than the sole of a smoothing plane.

And, of course, many of us make oars and spars and gunstocks and other rounded stock often and successfully without ever owning a concave spoke shave. I'm sure they have their uses...I just don't see the need for one. The soles of convex spoke shaves and travishers so useful for chair seats could also easily be flattened by drawfiling, and specialty shaves are tuned and sharpened using the same techniques with the addition of slip stones or abrasive paper wrapped on dowels for the inside bevel of concave blades.


Mount the blade in a welders vise grip and hone a 25-degree bevel and a 30-degree secondary bevel like with a plane iron. I use Arkansas stones in 4 grades and cutting oil, but cheap wet-or-dry paper cemented to glass or MDF with WD40 works fine, too. 100-600 grit in sequence�the duller the blade, the coarser the starting point.

Note the protractor in the pic. Blade guides won�t work on short spokeshave blades so you have to learn to hone by eye and feel. Simply set your starting angle with the protractor and memorize the feel of it�if you are careful and use a light touch you can feel the bevel on the stone�a bench height belt-buckle high facilitates elbow movement that keeps the bevel flat without rocker�but if you get some rocker in the bevel, it�s no biggie�just move on to your more-important secondary bevel and fix it next time you hone.

Flatten the blade back using the same 4 grades of stone or paper. On a blade that has never been flattened, do this [I]before[/I] you hone your bevels, and do it thoroughly.


Strop well on leather strap or a buffing wheel using Knifemaker�s Green Rouge

Continued

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#2

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>

Make sure its sharp enuf to shave hair painlessly�note the hair atop the blade . and the light's reflection on that 5-degree secondary bevel at the top of the pic.


Hone the cap iron surface that bears on the blade exactly like you did the blade back.


Check for a perfect bearing surface as you reassemble the shave. One important point often overlooked....after the shave is assembled and adjusted, tighten the cap iron slotted screw a bit to press the blade firmly against the casting before you tighten the knurled screw to apply a lot of cap iron pressure directly above the blade cutting edge. All the cap iron does is support the cutting edge....that slotted screw holds the cap iron-blade assembly against the casting.


Check your settings on a piece of tough hardwood like this walnut. Most folks like to round off the corners of the blade so�s there�s no danger of the blade corner gouging the wood�.I do that with smooth planes but don�t bother with shaves�notice the shavings here are the full width of the work piece and of even thickness. It may be difficult to see, but also notice I tend to slice with the shave on a slight bias�one hand being very slightly ahead of the other hand. This bias will unconsciously increase as the tool dulls in use.


Then check again in normal use.

All this took less than 30 minutes including the photography�.if I�da had to do some filing, it might have taken 45 minutes.

As I said, they cut exactly like a plane. When beginning the cut, pressure needs to be on the front of the sole....and when finishing the cut, the pressure needs to be transferred to the rear of the sole. After a while, you won't even realize you are doing it.

Doesn't matter whether you push or pull...you'll need to do both, depending on how the work piece is held.

And the screw adjustments on Bailey planes and 151-style spokeshaves are just eyewash....our forbearers used a light brass hammer to tap their wedged blades into set, and I do the same even on tools with screw adjustments inside the limits of the adjusting screw lash, because it is much more precise than those coarse screws. Set them light�try them out�and tap them in.

�When we build, let us think that we build forever. Let it not be for present delight nor for present use alone. Let it be such work as our descendants will thank us for; and let us think...that a time is to come when those (heirlooms) will be held sacred because our hands have touched them, and that men will say, as they look upon the labor and wrought substance of them, �See! This our father did for us.� � --John Ruskin.

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#3

Great, but...

jim_reed@marietta

>Woodies are great, but I have never found a use for iron spokeshaves. The blade seems set at too high an angle. Time to clear out my excess never used tools.

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#4

Re: Great, but...

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>I seem to make do with both types.

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#5

Re: Great, but...

Davy

>I've got a spokeshave with no maker name but it's numbered #153. It has no cap iron and I find it impossible to use. Is it just missing the cap iron or is it supposed to work without one? It either doesn't cut or it gouges. Can't get whispy shavings with it at all. Quite frustrating!

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#6

Lid for every pot

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>That's fine, Jim - you like your woodies, I like my metallies - some for every taste, as long as the work gets done with minimal electron death.

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#7

153 or 53? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I've never heard of a 153, but many makers used the Stanley numbering system, in which the 53 is an "adjustable-mouth" shave. There's some discussion of this shave in the link shown below (about halfway down). Is the front portion of the sole formed by a D-shaped casting on the front of the spokeshave (with the straight portion of the "D" at the sole side) that pivots about halfway up? If so, the top of the "D" should have a thumbscrew that allows you to set the location of the front of the sole by pressing against the body of the shave. If this is missing, or not set right, it may the source of your problem.

I own one of these, but have never done more than casual experimenting with it, as I have traditionally depended on my No. 52 for most shave work, and am learning to use a Veritas low-angle spokeshave (thanks again, Tom!).


Patrick Leach's article on spokeshaves

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#8

Re: 153 or 53?

Davy

>My shave is labeled 153, but it's just like a Stanley #53. It's built just like you describe. The reason I got it is that it's a clone of the 53 and I liked the idea of the adjustable mouthpiece. However, I just can't get it to work properly. Guess I'll stick to the standard 51 and 151 with a possible future Veritas sometime. I drool over those things.

Re: A Quick Spokeshave Tune Up

#9

I like them both !!

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>I've said it many times before that both types of shaves are useful and work well if tuned properly. The high angle metal shaves of the old makers often had too wide a mouth and produced chatter. This is solved easily by shimming the blade to close the mouth. I find the high ange style most useful when working in wood with reversing grain. Because of the high angle, you an often get away with shaving against the grain and not have the huge amount of tearout you get when trying to do it with a low angle wooden OR metal shave.

Low angle shaves of wood or metal are easier to control than the high angle type when working on regular grain and when you want to take exceptionaly thin shavings. They also allow you to set one side of the blade for a coarser setting to take thicker shavings while maintaining the other side of the blade for a fine wispy cut.

My personal assortment of shaves is about equally divided between high and low angle and they all get used regularly.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.