WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

Posts

ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#1

ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

John Truxell-Svenson (jvs)

>I managed to turn my polishing stone into raw materials for ~four slips by dropping it, and am in the market for a replacement.

I was pretty happy with my old one, which was a "regular" artificial gold stone, but are there any comments on ceramic polishing stones? Is the main difference the hardness and length of time between flattening, or do ceramic-binder stones cut any quicker? I've never had an issue with flattening stones in general (and don't want to pour gasoline on that one again), but am wondering about any other differences people have noted and where there are preferences one way or the other. The tools I use are regular western carbon steel and hard A2; no Japanese laminates at this point.

Thanks in advance!




/jvs

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

I am happy with Norton 8000

Jim in Burlington

>

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#3

Polishing Stone Preferences

Steve Elliott

>I've been using a Takenoko finishing stone (8000x) for several years and like it better than my ceramic Shapton 8000x stone. The Takenoko is softer, but has less of a problem with stiction on blade backs.

I've also used a King 6000x stone, which is very similar to the Takenoko but smaller in size. I prefer the larger Takenoko.

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#4

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but..

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I think the hardness of a polishing stone is less critical than the stone you would use for initial honing and especially flattening the back. I bought a coarse Arkansas stone to flatten my backs, a Shapton probably would be better, but plan on continuing to use the Norton 8000 grit for final honing, as it does such a nice job.

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#5

Ditto

glh

>

Re: ok, still haven't worn out a waterstone, but...

#6

thanks, guys--norton or takenoko it is!

John Truxell-Svenson (jvs)

>

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.