Coloring wood and fading
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
What makes something colored
To understand differences in light fastness/fading it is first helpful to discuss color and what causes something to be colored. If something is blue it means that the white sunlight that fell on the object interacted with the molecules or atoms of that object, the red part of the light was absorbed and turned into heat, and the blue light reflected back to your eye to experience the sensation of blue.
Atoms stick together to make steel, wood, varnish, onions,etc. Steel is different from wood, wood different from varnish, because the atoms that are sticking together are different and these atoms are sticking together in different ways. Wood and varnish are both made from oxygen, carbon and hydrogen. Wood differs from varnish only in the arrangement of how these atoms are stuck together.
The “glue” that sticks atoms together to make wood and varnish and steel are the electrons from these atoms that get shared between these atoms. A visual picture could be that an oxygen atom in wood has some nearby atoms of hydrogen and carbon. There is some electron “glue” between these atoms holding them together. Here are the three key points….(1).This electron glue has slightly different properties depending on what two atoms are stuck together, as well as the neighboring atoms and their electron glue. (2) This electron glue will absorb light. (3) What color light is absorbed depends on what atoms are stuck together as well as the neighboring atoms and their electron glue.
There are an almost infinite number of ways we can stick carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and hydrogen together to make molecules- wood, cheese, varnish, etc. The electron glue in some of these arrangements only absorbs ultraviolet light and these materials will appear colorless, for example lacquer and water. Other arrangements of these atoms will result in electron glue that absorbs red light and these materials will appear blue. Lots of possible arrangements of atoms results in lots of possible colors.
There are many of ways of sticking together atoms to result in an electron glue that absorbs red light. While all these atomic arrangements result in the red light absorbing, the other properties of these materials can/will be totally different. As a consequence there are many ways of making something that is blue(absorbs red) and the properties of these materials can/will be different. They may be a solid, or a liquid, dissolve in water or not, and, vary in light fastness.
Pigments and dyes
By definition a pigment is a particle of some colored material that does not dissolve in the wood. A dye on the other hand will dissolve in some solvent and when applied to the wood the dye molecules don’t reform into solid particles of dye. We say the dye molecules are “molecularly dispersed”. It turns out that clumps or crystals of something colored does not impart nearly as intense a color as when the molecules of the colorant remain separated/dispersed/dissolved. Hence, on a weight per cent basis, dyes are far more intense than pigments. And, a more finely divided pigment (“micronized”) has a more intense color and appears brighter than one with larger particle sizes.
Dyes are usually made up of carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen and oxygen. Dyes can be either naturally occurring, or made in the lab. We call this kind of stuff “organic chemicals”. Pigments can be an organic chemical, either man made or lab made, or they can be colored minerals, which we call “mineral pigments”. Red iron oxide and black manganese oxide are examples of mineral pigments. The picture shows a famous location in France where Ochre, a variety of finely divided iron oxides, were mined for centuries. On display, and for sale, are various colors of Ochre. I bought some to make cherry and walnut stain.

Light Fast , finally!
To review, we can stick carbon, oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen together with electron glue. Depending on how these elements are arranged, the resulting material will absorb light of different colors. Depending on how these elements are arranged, by that I mean what kind of atom (hydrogen, oxygen, etc.) each atom is next to, the material’s electron glue and the other properties will be different.
When sun light strikes a dye some amount of this light gets absorbed by the electron glue. Absorbing this light absorbs the energy of this light. Occasionally this energy will be sufficient to overcome the electron glue holding the atoms together. For example a carbon atom joined with a nitrogen atom will break apart and reform to make some other arrangement of these atoms. This new arrangement will almost surely not absorb light the same way as the original. It turns out that the new arrangement will most likely no longer absorb visible light and hence will become colorless. We say the material “faded”, that is lost its color.
Some arrangements of atoms break apart more easily than other arrangements. We say these materials fade easily. Some arrangements of the atoms resist breaking apart and we say these are light fast. The atoms in a mineral crystal cannot break apart so these materials never fade. The mineral pigment can, however, change color but becoming a new mineral when some new chemicals are present. Addition of water will make red iron oxide yellow, but we do not call this change fading.
Kinds of dyes
“Aniline dye” is a meaningless term. There are dozens of arrangements of atoms to make what is sold as a red “aniline dye”. None of them will have anything to do with aniline. Each will have different resistance to fading because the electron glue in each is different.
There is a relatively new way of assembling atoms to make something colored. These materials are called “premetallized” dyes. They will have some metal atom in them in addition to the usual carbon, oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen in traditional dyes. Transtint and many of the Mosher dyes are premetallized. A premetallized dye is easy to recognize from the MSDS for the dye. The MSDS will reveal the dye contains a metal atom.
Premetallized dyes are not as light fast as a mineral pigment. However, they can be much more light fast than what is called aniline dyes, the pigments in wood, or the colors imparted to wood by chemical treatment.
As an experiment I colored mahogany by treatment with ammonia, chromate, an “aniline” brown dye and a brown premetallized dye. I then had a lab do accelerated fading testing on the colored wood. The aniline dye and ammonia treatment faded the most and the premetallized dye the least, much less that either the ammonia or chromate treatment. As an editorial…… there is zero justification for using carcinogenic chromate on wood when superior coloring premetallized dyes are available to achieve the same result. Ammonia is harmless as it is normally used but the color it imparted almost completely faded in this experiment.



