WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

The most evil project I've ever undertaken

Posts

The most evil project I've ever undertaken

#1

The most evil project I've ever undertaken

Howard Rosenberg

The very worst project I’ve ever undertaken is drawing to a close: modifying my dust collector.

It started its life as a Delta 1 1/2HP two-bag DC. This was the year I thought I’d make a Thien separator.

Not a good idea.

It turned into a series of disasters I’ve been working on since July.

Four different attempts that included some of these standouts –

- 3/8” thick bendy plywood that wouldn’t form a clean circle without a flat spot where the two edges were to meet and was brittle, splintery and scared the fertilizer out of me when I tried cutting it on the TS

- routing the top and bottom four different times and finally breaking down and just buying a Super Dust Deputy

But some of the positives were –

- learned how to position the edge of a router bit’s cutter on a line with good accuracy

- chimney flashing - a very versatile product easily cut with a utility knife for custom widths

- the Milescraft circle jig – overall strangely fiddly, not very sturdy product that is basically effective

- the “shop-in-a-shop” dust control system using 8x10 tarps hung off the joists

But several weeks ago, I though I’m finally getting to the finish line.

Alas, no.

A new challenge – the “out-of-sight-out-of-mind” dust shroud under my contractor came apart at the seams.

I figured rather than possibly overwhelm the SDD and send more dust to the filter using a 6-to-5 inch reducer to the SDD’s inlet I’d just break down and buy 5-inch hose which meant also buying a 5-inch HVAC duct boot to make a new dust shroud.

Here are a few pics –

Pic 01 – the exterior is made of corrugated sign board – it’s bolted together using 6-32 bolts, washers and nylon-lined nuts so it doesn’t vibrate loose – everything’s angled to fit in the CS’s bottom and slope to the new 5” HVAC duct boot

Pic 02 - the corners are reinforced with the material drywallers use on corners – the paper extends beyond the metal corners

Pic 03 – the gussets I added to the drywall corners after my first test install and tore the paper and didn’t want to depend on duct tape to keep everything together

Pic 04 – the shroud’s interior – I’d hung on to the signs from a General Motors Christmas promotion



More to come after I stop pulling my hair out….

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

#2

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

Garthfromsandiego

Love the can do attitude.

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

#3

Looks fine sir - better than my 'solution'

Henry (Raleigh NC)

I had some level of dust collection underneath - that just continued to clog. I got into step 0 - that is removal of the old 'solution', and I stopped there.

I do have a top side blade guard with DC that keeps the stuff off my face, and that is quite effective (a cobbled together acrylic box, suspended from the ceiling on a reasonably stiff bar). However the sawdust pile under my TS belies the fact that I have not progressed past step 0.

I like you methods and pics!

Persist over the EVIL!

Henry

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

#4

BTDT....

Barry Irby

Recently, well a few weeks ago, maybe fifteen years ago I did dust collection in my shop. I used light weight (SD) plastic pipe for the ducts, 6" and 4". That boot you showed is an "end" boot. I too have a contractors saw. I made a sheet metal box similar to a cereal box and it slips up from the bottom around the blade and the lower end terminates into an end boot. It points toward the operator side and there is a blast gate with a micro switch that turns on the DC. The gate is beside the switch for the saw. The top of the box is cut off at a forty five to allow for a full tilt. There is a loose lid that closes off the top except for about a 1/2 slot for the blade. Does not sound like much, but a lot of thinking with into it. I don't have an over the blade collector. The way I can tell the DC is not on is sawdust hits me in the face.

I also started with a 1 1/2 HP Delta DC.

I suspect if you had a DC powerful enough to suck the carbide teeth off a Forrest WWII Combo blade the set up could be even simpler.

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

#5

Re: The most evil project I've ever undertaken

Howard Rosenberg

I had no choice but to keep trying over and over again...

I was too stupid to figure out when to quit

But I must say am pretty impressed by the SDD's performance and its simplicity. The only sour note - the flange on mine was mighty wobbly. They told me it was inside spec.

Another thing about Oneida, though.

Every time I called and punched the number for customer service their message came on saying they were in the middle of an unexpected number of callers. And every time I called right back and hit the extension for sales they picked right up.

Go figure.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.