WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Mendota Rails to Trails Project

Posts

Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#1

Mendota Rails to Trails Project

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


In the late 1800's a rail line was built from the main line at Bristol, VA to the coal country in SW VA. The first leg ran from Bristol to Mendota, on to Gate City then north to the coal mines. The line was abandoned in the early 80's. An effort was made to convert to a trail but it failed due to adjacent land owner opposition. Some years ago the city of Bristol acquired the RR right of way and proposed a trail. Local opposition was robust and the effort was abandoned.

In the mean time the coal mines of SW VA were closing and the local economy was collapsing. A lawyer in St. Paul VA. Frank Kilgore, had a vision of reviving the economy with outdoor recreation. To that end he created a conservation organization, Mountain Heritage. Agreement was made with the city of Bristol to transfer RR ownership to Mountain Heritage if a mile of trail could be opened in one year. A useless mile was opened from Mendota south, ending at a dilapidated 273 foot bridge across the Holston River. This achievement met the transfer requirement and Mountain Heritage now owned the RR right of way, much to the consternation of adjacent land owners that had used this land for decades.

Local opposition was intense. The Bristol end faced a dilapidated bridge only a short ways north. To get the project off the ground my wife and I agreed to fund restoration of Trestle #1.




Every obstacle was thrown at construction. Absurd requirements were invented to stop the bridge, but we pressed on. At excessive expense the bridge was finished which opened a 4 mile trail north to a dead end, a tall highly damaged very expensive to repair bridge at Benhams, VA, a tantalizing short distance from a dandy trail head.

Two years passed as the group tried to secure funding for this bridge. in the mean time Mountain Heritage passed ownership of the trail to a group just focused on the trail, Mendota Trail Conservancy. Focused, this group secured funding for this key bridge and the dominoes began to fall. A private donor stepped in and agreed to fund the next bridge north and my wife and I rejoined the group and agreed to fund the 1st bridge south from Mendota. With funding secured for the bridge over the Holston River, two more donors soon agreed to fund the next two bridges which will take the trail to another dandy trail head.

The State of VA was so impressed by the local funding support that they provided a $350,000 grant to do a series of bridges through the spectacular Wolf Run Gorge. We will begin these bridges next month, leaving only 5 short bridges and two hostile land owners remaining to repurpose.

Through reengineering, efficient construction techniques, shaking down suppliers, and volunteer labor we have cut the price of restoring a bridge by half or more. If there is interest in this part of the story I could put it together later.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#2

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

JohnV

Thanks Bill. Very interesting convoluted history to the project. We have had a similar history here in Missouri with the KATY trail. It has taken over 20 years to get 90% completed. Just a few smaller sections to be complete from Kansas City to St. Charles.

I've not had any connection to the project but have used parts of the trail.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#3

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

H Bruce McCrory

Fascinating! Thanks Bill. The differences in construction methods and material can be seen in the two photos.

This has opportunity to serve as a blueprint for other conversion projects. You should look into submitting the story to recreation publications.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#4

I'd read as much detail as you're willing to write


Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#5

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

Keith L Newton

My hat is off to you and Mrs. Tendall,,,,,, Mr. Bill.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#6

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

GolfSteve in Calgary

Great job, Bill! As an avid outdoor user, I think we need more trails like these! Landowners have nothing to fear from respectful trail users.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#7

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

Wiley Horne

Bill,

Everything about this project is of regional and national significance. Yes, this is an achievement the Nation needs to see.

I hope when you have a big ribbon-cutting, you will invite the press, from both VA and TN. From Richmond to Nashville, plus local. Plus Audubon Society and The Nature Conservancy—this is a template that TNC might adapt nationally. Plus Ducks Unlimited—Ducks is an amazing organization, and they will participate financially in enhancing wetlands.

I looked through the Mendota Trail website, but still haven’t found anything that captures the full scope and vision of these 7 bridges and the environments they connect. What is the narrative that pulls the 7 bridges together into a larger conception? Is there one? I am stumped for a graphic to go with the narrative: maybe an artist’s conception that compresses distance so as to show the bridges together. Or just great shots of each bridge in its environment.

Rails to Trails nationwide would benefit hugely by having detailed drawings and specifications of exactly how you cut costs in two—which is unheard of in my experience, though I know some projects whose costs doubled! You could co-author with the engineer who signed off.

This is a very big deal Bill. Tremendously inspiring!

Wiley

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#8

I don't know what you are asking for

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A rail line went from Bristol to Mendota, VA and on the way crossed 19 bridges, two of which went over highways and have been removed, leaving 17 to rebuild. What connects them is the rail road bed. Narrative? The older topo maps, to be found at USGS, show the RR.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#9

nothing to fear?

Clifton C

Landowners have nothing to fear from respectful trail users.

Respectful being the key word...

My observation is that the hoards of newcomers to our parks and trails do not seem to care what they leave in their wake. The old saw, "Pack it in, pack it out" has been left in the dust with the cans, bottles and candy wrappers tossed by the side of the trail...

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#10

Re: nothing to fear?

H Bruce McCrory

My son said adios to a date when she dumped her garbage on the floor at a theater. I guess she probably did the same thing at home.

Lack of respect for property and rubbish is a learned disease. In my youth I associated filth with drunks and lowlife. Now, everyone fits that category, or prove otherwise. Take your own, plus some more.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#11

Re: nothing to fear?

John in NM

Even well intentioned city folks can make a mess by not using their heads.

Earlier this year I was walking on a trail and came across a little blue plastic bag containing dog litter. They felt it was important to bag it up, but couldn't bring themselves to pack it out too. They left it on the trail, assuming that "the help" would be along to pick it up soon. Better to have let the dog do its business off in the bushes where it would decompose normally over the course of a few weeks.

On trails near town, there are as often as not a couple water bottles, granola bar wrappers, and lately disused face masks on the trail.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#12

Re: I don't know what you are asking for

William Duffield

What are you doing now where the trail crosses the highways since the bridges are gone? For example, in Reston, VA, where at least one of the major bike trails crosses a busy road, there are zebra crossing stripes, button activated stop lights and warning signs in both directions on the road (and probably on the trail, too).

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#13

Re: nothing to fear?

Garthfromsandiego

Some people are inclined to drop the bag alongside the trail with the intent of picking it up on the way back. Of course there is no way to know their intentions or track the actual results.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#14

Perhaps...

John in NM

But I walked by that bag for a month or more after it first appeared. I walk that trail a lot, maybe once a week at that time. I had seen the same at a different trailhead parking area a year or so before - no trash can provided so they just left it for someone else to deal with, sitting prominently on a rock so it was conspicuous.

Just more litter from my point of view - I usually pick up some, but I draw the line at bags of crap and old face masks.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#15

Re: I don't know what you are asking for

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I build bridges. The rest of the trail is someone else's responsibility to deal with.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#16

Re: I don't know what you are asking for

William Duffield

I build bridges.

And a fine job you do!

Does this imply you would like to build new bridges over the three highways? :D

Sometimes, it's sufficient to have an idea, and get it into the right person's head at the next board meeting.

I found the old USGS topo map showing the South Atlantic and Ohio railroad grade between Mendota and Bristol. I'm still trying to figure out how to convert it to a simple .jpg I can post here for interested WoodCentralians.

Re: Mendota Rails to Trails Project

#17

You're Correct.

H Bruce McCrory

"I build bridges. The rest of the trail is someone else's responsibility to deal with."

How one approaches volunteering, and bankrolling, service projects doesn't require expertise or the same desire to gloat about it to the world. You did your part to make it successfully work. That's what matters to you and your family. The trail sign says enough.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.