WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Needing new variable speed router?

Posts

Needing new variable speed router?

#1

Needing new variable speed router?

Keith L Newton

I haven't had a variable speed router since they first came out about 30 years ago. back then the switches didn't seem to last, and there was a noticeable drop in the power. Is this something that has been overcome?

I've got a project coming up where I'll be doing lots of hand held routing with a large cutter, and will probably stick with Makita since that is what all my others are, and all my other gadgets will interchange.

Makita RP2301FC 3-1/4 HP Variable Speed Plunge Router with Electric Brake

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#2

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Can’t help you with that particular model, but for 35 years the only router I had was its predecessor, the 3612 BR. It’s still going strong. If I were to need a new one, it would be the one you’re getting.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#3

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

howard gorman

I have the PC 3 1/4hp but it is mounted in the router table. While at times I have used this router free hand, they are really meant for a router table. Large bits in a large router like this creates a lot of torque so be careful.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#4

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

Keith L Newton

Thanks Howard, I'm aware of the power, since I still have 3 working routers of this brand and size plus several that I've worn out before getting them. The question is, does your PC have variable speed, and does it loose torque when you slow it down? Back when I started woodworking, slowing a motor involved draining the power off, then finally VF drives came along where the power stayed high with speed reduction. The electronics of this is above my pay-grade.

I personally believe that having a lot of power is a good thing, and in some respects safer than less power. For instance, if you try to climb cut, the router will keep cutting without slowing allowing the bit to take a proper chip. But when the power is low, the speed range is narrower. If you go a little too fast, the bit slows, and if you don't slow down quick enough, the bit is taking too large a chip to cut off, then it gets traction and takes off out of control. I find it easier to control when there is plenty of power to keep cutting. I've got a couple of wooden bath tubs to make, so there will be lots of pattern routing through 8/4 material.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#5

OOH! Bathtubs!!  That's a job for...

Barry Irby

a big CNC, maybe a four or five axis one. Get one, I want to borrow it.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#6

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

howard gorman

the PC 3 1/4 has 5 fixed speed settings from I think 10,000rpm for panel raising bits to 29,000 rpm.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#7

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

Walt

Keep in mind that Porter Cable routers are being discontinued. I believe this includes the 7518. If I go to Amazon and search for the 7518 it doesn't come up. Accessories are displayed but no complete router. There are other manufacturers making motors that fit router lifts intended for the 7518 motor.

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

#8

Re: Needing new variable speed router?

Howard in Toronto

I'd say it's probably safest to stay with products you already know that have provided good service.

In my case, my routers are all Makita products - 3612C, laminate trimmer and RF1101 plunge/fixed kit.

Bullet proof - no matter what I throw at them - they just keep working perfectly.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.