WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

Posts

Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#1

Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I bought some Odorless Mineral Spirits today to use for thinning poly.

It really smells for being odorless.

Wife doesn't want me using it in the house anymore.

Is there a less offensive thinner I could/should use?

Is regular paint thinner less smelly?

Thanks.

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#2

Easier to find a new wife......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

than to find a medium molecular weight hydrocarbon that is odorless. I would suggest forging on and after a while she will see that 1. it is harmless, and 2. the smell signals the near completion of a furniture project.

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#3

Switch

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

to water-based poly

Way cheaper than switching wives

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#4

Ellis Walentine

Shop around

Ellis Walentine

...not for a wife, but for a different odorless thinner. Dick Blick or similar art supply store will have several varieties, and some are much less offensive than others. My wife is an oil painter and uses Turpenoid. It's bound to cost a lot more than reguar mineral spirits.

Ellis

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#5

Can't answer but... weird smells with poly-urethan

Henry (Raleigh NC)

Sorry I can't answer your question, but I have noticed a weird smell that happens ONLY when I use both:

- an oil based polyurethane in the house (haven't in many years)

- AND we use the gas dryer (also in the basement).

This doesn't happen with one or the other, only when both are used. Not a more offensive smell than oil based finishes, just unique smell for that combination. I have since avoided the combination.

I have moved on to waterborne coatings and never looked back.

Henry

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#6

Unscientific but interesting

Bill Howatt

I've read this forum and others for years and not real long ago oil-based finishes were the absolute king and very few had anything good to say about water-based. It seems to me based on forum posts the tide has definitely turned towards favoring water-based.

Just a thought.

Bill

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#7

You might not like the answer

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

The gas dryer is supposed to be exhausting outside and only pulling air from the space it is in. If the dryer is causing smells, then you may have an exhaust leak from your dryer..

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#8

I get the same strange smell

Mike L

If I am working in my garage and using my propane heater when I apply Poly it has a strange smell. If I just use the heater there is no smell.

It took me a few different time to figure out it is the propane heater and Poly causing the smell.

It take awhile to clear out if I can't open the door.

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#9

Re: Can't answer but... weird smells with poly-ure

Barry Irby

The vent for a gas dryer is a flue, venting the combustion by products out doors. The vent should be made of solid metal pipe and sealed. If you are smelling something indoors you have a leak and it is conceivably dangerous. Get it checked.

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#10

Carbon monoxide monitor?

Clifton C

First question would be, Is the CO monitor reading any PPM?

Second question...

Re: Odorless Mineral Spirits really Smells!

#11

CO monitor is in place...

Henry (Raleigh NC)

No alarms from any of the several CO monitors...

Henry

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.