WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Removingn broken screw ?

Posts

Removingn broken screw ?

#1

Removingn broken screw ?

Michael van pelt

Small box hinge and I broke off one of the brass screws. Looking to order a screw extractor. Any recommendations of what kind works the best. Looked at Rockler hollow screw extractors and the 4 piece set of regular ones from Lee Valley. Appreciate some guidance. And yes I had pre drilled used wax and used a steel screw first. Darn thing just broke! Ugh. Thanks

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#2

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Extractor's easy to make with a drill press and a piece of rod with a diameter a bit bigger than the screw. Drill a hole in the end then use a countersink to taper the hole to get a sharp outside edge. Lastly file a couple of teeth. Chuck in a drill and drill the hole which you fill with a bit of wood. Here's a sample


Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

great tip


Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#4

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

Virgil Johnson

A steel roll pin can be used in the same fashion that Mark mentioned. These are heat treated and hold an edge better than a regular steel rod. As a bonus they come in various sizes. Grind the teeth with a Dremel cut off wheel. Just remember to make the teeth so they cut in the CCW direction.

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#5

 


Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#6

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

Ralph Lipeles

When using small delicate brass screws it is often best to first use a steel screw with the same profile as the brass screw.

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#7

I've found grinding a tooth on a roll pin works


Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#8

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

Michael van pelt

Ralph. Did you read my post. Did you read my statement?

Re: Removingn broken screw ?

#9

Suggestion....

Barry Irby

I have repaired/replaced dozens or hundreds of screws that were in holes that were wallowed out. I drill the hole out to a known size and cut a plug out of similar wood with a plug cutter and install it in the hole with glue and then start over with a new screw. This is much better than a dowel or tooth picks because the grain orientation is correct.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.