Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

West Australian Woodshow 2018

Posts

West Australian Woodshow 2018

#1

West Australian Woodshow 2018

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

The WA Woodshow began Friday 3rd August and run until the end of Sunday 5th. I could only get there on the weekend when, as usual, I join my good friend Chris Vesper on his stand. The Show is packed with representatives of power and hand makers and sellers, with many ongoing demonstrations, as well as the maker's competition put on by my woodworking club. Of course I was there for that as well, having an entry in the Apothecary Chest.

I must admit that my first port of call was the Old Tool Preservation Society, where there were sales ... and I was a day late! Still, I managed to pick up a set of three as new pattern maker paring gouges by Marples with boxwood handles, along with a (matching) Marples boxwood 1/4" sash mortice chisel.





The Society usually has a theme each year. Guess what it was this year ...




Chris Vesper, toolmaker extraordinaire ...


A plug for his tools, seriously the best in the world ...


There were the usual power tools ...



Timbecon was there with hand- and power tools. My friend Dane was demonstrating WoodRiver (Carbatec were not there to present Veritas) ...


This was balanced by LN Australia. Anthony (in the far corner), who runs the LN Oz, is a real enthusiast and a pleasure to chat to ..


There was a special area for kids, and my mate Greg Miller (Joy of Wood) was providing so much fun and education ...



Derek Doak "The Timber Bloke", with some of his wares ...


OK, enough of this I hear you cry, what about the furniture competition?!

Well, I did not place with my chest. There were really high standards, and I'll show you a few pieces.

First and Second places went to Ian Houghton, a professional furnituremaker. He specialises in sunbursts, which have appeared on a number of his past winning pieces over the years. This year he demonstrated his ability to laminate bent wood to an exceptionally high level as well ...

First prize:




Second prize:



Third prize was a sideboard:


As mentioned, I did not place. I was happy to be there, and received many positive comments (and two offers of purchase, which I did not accept - imagine having to build it again for Lynndy!) ..


There were some exceptional boxes.

The winning box was made by Denis Tapley (which looked very similar to his box, which won last year) ...


However, it is the boxes of Martin Burgoyne which I would like to showcase. Martin attended courses with me with Andrew Crawford (from the UK). He continued working on these, and I think that he has surpassed Andrew with his detailed inlay work. It is simply sublime!

I will show two pieces here, neither of which won a prize, however:

"The North Skyline". This is the Perth skyline.


Here is a very short video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZemtuoYSXr4&feature=youtu.be

The one that I thought was amazing was this "Puzzle Box" ...


Again, it can only be appreciated via video ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=8&v=oPCp7fWD50Y

Lastly, another prize winner, in a kinetic piece by Neil Hendry ...


This must be viewed on video (it moves) ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LZkyNJ93M88&feature=youtu.be

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#2

Thanks for the pictures

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Is the winning table as tippy and frail as it looks? Is the base stiff? It looks like the whole affair could be jiggled. Nice top, not nice unmatching bottom. Didn't float my boat.

The side board could be described as "trendy". I found the uninteresting inlay distracting and the door framing too clunky. By a wide measure I would prefer to have your stylish piece in my house.

What did a typical Stanley #4 sell for at this show? At the old tool meet we attended I was told the market has dropped. Nice ones that didn't have some collector enhancement (box, pristine condition, etc) could be bought for $30.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#3

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

Hank Knight

I agree with Bill re the base for the winning table. It looks flimsy and out of place with that spectacular top. I like the sideboard and I love the winning box. Derek, I thought your chest was a winner - I still do, after seeing the other award winers you posted.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#4

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

Mark Hennebury

Great to see, thanks for taking the time to share with us. Great job on your cabinet.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#5

Re: Thanks for the pictures

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Is the winning table as tippy and frail as it looks? Is the base stiff? It looks like the whole affair could be jiggled. Nice top, not nice unmatching bottom. Didn't float my boat.

The side board could be described as "trendy". I found the uninteresting inlay distracting and the door framing too clunky. By a wide measure I would prefer to have your stylish piece in my house.

What did a typical Stanley #4 sell for at this show? At the old tool meet we attended I was told the market has dropped. Nice ones that didn't have some collector enhancement (box, pristine condition, etc) could be bought for $30.

Hi Bill

The table was not for touching, and so I did not test out its stability. The side board was nicely built - a little on the high side for my taste, but otherwise clean.

I was chatting with one of the senior club members, who has won many awards in the past, and we agreed that there did not appear to be enough loading for degree of difficulty. It also serves to illustrate that many have differing opinions and tastes. Judging is a tough job.

I did not look at the handplanes (!). However, prices tend to range between $55 - $125. Don't forget that we do not have the population of the USA nor the accumulation of Stanley planes.

I did pick up these three Marples gouges and 1/4" morticing chisel. The gouges are unused. $95 for all.


The rule is metric.

I also purchased new from Chris Vesper these carving knives for spoons and bowls. They are made by a family business in Slovakia. I spent some time using them at the Show. Absolutely wonderful!


I received a special price since I am friendly with the agent :) so the price is not relevant.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#8

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

roger lance

Derek.....thanks for the pics.....I've never been to a show like this where so many used tools are available (you've influenced me to buy LV hand tools new)......

Given the simple laws of gravity and balance, the winning table can be nothing but tipsy......practicality must not be a priority judging criterion.....thus, "studio furniture" can be getting awarded and pieces that would be functional in a real life living environment can be overlooked and dismissed.

The side board is arts and crafts.....something from the Stickley school......and, as such, practical and destined for a long life in someone's dining room.....but, was not the challenge to make as your curved piece was.

That folding screen appears to be beautiful.....and a challenge to design and make with all the inlay......and possibly practicle if you need a screen in your home or have a spot for an interesting artifact.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#9

Thanks for the Pics....

Barry Irby

I agree with Bill. That table is a terrible design, flimsy and tippy looking. My friend looked at the the picture and said it looks like it will snap in half. It would take two people to set the table, one on each end to set the plates down at exactly the same time. Needs out riggers or training wheels. The good news is he can remove that terrible base and install that spectacular top on something worthy.

I like the side board but I agree the doors are too heavy. Should have made the frames lighter and featured the panels and left out the white squares.

You was robbed.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#10

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

Gerry in North Surrey

Thanks for the write up, Derek. As always, nice sharp pictures and clear concise comments. I have no design sense so am in no position to criticize anyone else's work, however, like Barry said, you was robbed.

Cheers,

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#11

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

Don Stephan

Well phooey.

Like everyone else the winning table doesn't look safe in a family setting so I'm going to argue it should not have been accepted. And the first and second place tables are derivations of each other, so only one should have been awarded if instability was not an automatic disqualification. The starbursts look to be well executed, and the figure is eye catching, but putting together a starburst, without additional highlights, seems somewhat routine.

The door frame proportions in the sideboard do not bother me. The piece looks well executed, but basically straightforward woodworking.

If the club doesn't have a list of considerations, each awarded 1-5 points (or something similar), I wouldn't submit entries in the future. Design proportions, wood choices, joinery, finish, originality, degree of difficulty would be some of the considerations that come to mind quickly.

Yep, ROBBED!

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#12

An Annual Favorite of Mine

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Derek,

Thank you for this great post. I always look forward to your reports from that show. I'm already looking forward to next year!!

Best,

T.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#13

Is it always in August?


Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#15

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

Joanne Adler

Thanks for the pics, Dennis. I think your chest should have won a prize! It's awesome. I guess the best prize is that your wife loves it. And I can't believe that puzzle box or skyline box didn't win, either. So cool. At least that horse won a prize. Mind-boggling.

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#16

A few more photos of the show.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here are a few more photos.

A table by Martin Burgoyne on the left. He has made some fine inlaid pieces. The credenza is classic mid-century Danish, now very in.


I loved the fun of this (full size) table!


A box Martin made a few years ago, one that won a first at that time ...


He did win a prize in the current Show, for this "small treasure" ...


It is best appreciated with this brief video ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfgZqpqqNGk

Another who does such fun and interesting carvings is Stephanie Ryan ...


and ....


Neil Hendry, who made the kinetic horse (which was based on a Lego model), is principally a turner. He won a first for this embellished bowl ...


Either of these boxes would have been worthy of a prize ...


So many wonderful pieces. I think that woodworking won.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: West Australian Woodshow 2018

#17

Re: A few more photos of the show.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

That zipper table is simply wonderful. T.