Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Felling Fracture Revisited

Posts

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#26

Re: Compression Fractures

AZ in Colorado Springs

I saw that very phenomenon is some African mahogany I used two months ago. I wondered at the time how that would come about.

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#27

Re: Compression Fractures

Don Stephan

Very similar picture in Understanding Wood is labelled a compression fracture.

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#28

Thank you Don 


Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#29

Bill we have a problem

Mark Hennebury

It appears that i got my information from Bruce Hoadleys book published in 1980.

It clearly states that compression fractures are caused by compression, whatever the cause of that compression, which can include compression caused by felling.

It seemed reasonable and logical to me that compression by any means could lead to this type of damage, and i therefore had no reason to doubt it until now, when you told me that it was inaccurate.

Not having read Richards book, can you tell me:

Have there been any studies that have disproved Bruce Hoadleys assertion?


Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#30

Re: Bill we have a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Have there been any studies that have disproved Bruce Hoadleys assertion? "

I don't know. I referenced Richard's text. Given the thoroughness with which much of his book is researched, it is possible he can provide references.

I have never see this failure in wood I have cut and I don't recall ever seeing this failure in any wood we planed for resale. Hence, I have no personal experience to offer, unlike the case of growth stress. Given that this defect doesn't affect my harvesting or use of wood I have no personal interest in the topic. I'll let those that will be harvesting mahogany worry about its origin.

I will offer that huge weak trees like coastal redwood can suffer damage when they hit the ground. Maybe the same is true for big mahogany. By the time I see this defect in mahogany it is well past any time I have to do anything about avoiding it.

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#31

Re: Bill we have a problem

Mark Hennebury

Hi Bill,

I added it to the thread as i remembered having known that felling was listed as a possible cause and felling damage was being discussed.

I have seen this type of fracture on several occasions, recognizing what is is and what type of stress caused it is important for structural integrity, but in most cases probably more for just general understanding. When the damage occurred is probably irrelevant to most of us. It is just part of the information that forms a better understanding of wood.

Much of this type of information is given to us by professionals in the field of research, and not something that most of us can ever test to verify.

So we have to trust that what they state as fact has been proven, or it should be stated as a belief.

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#32

Re: Bill we have a problem

Sgian Dubh

Mark, below is an excerpt of text from my book Cut & Dried that discusses the topic. It doesn't disagree with Hoadley's description, although it is somewhat more succinct. In the book there are photographic examples of compression fracture and brashness (aka brittle heart), and you'll notice pointers in the following quotation to other sections for additional information. I hope this helps. Slainte.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

"13.3.3 Cross Shakes

Thunder shakes, also known as compression fractures or cross shakes are often, but not always, associated with ‘brittle heart’ or brashness, see section 14.5.7 Brashness or Brittle Heart. In appearance the break is usually a ragged or uneven line across the grain. Closer examination reveals compression and rupturing of the wood cells at the fracture line and in some cases a creased, longitudinal folding over of the grain. Thunder shake is almost certainly a misnomer as shockwaves from thunder are an unlikely cause; on the other hand possible causes are extreme flexing of the trunk during felling causing compression failure of the wood cells on the concave side of the bend. Similar compression failure can occur to other extreme loads such as high gusts of wind or heavy snow loads. Another trigger may be internal stresses in the living tree, and where this is the case brittle heart or brashness quite commonly accompanies the shake. The timbers I most frequently see with cross shakes are soft tropical hardwoods, e.g., members of the genus Shorea, such as Philippine lauan or meranti, and in other species such as balsa wood and agba. This certainly doesn’t mean cross shakes don’t occur in denser woods and the compression fracture example in sapele in figure 13.53, proves the case and I have also seen examples of this fault in temperate hardwoods such as sycamore ash and oak."

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#33

Hurricane Hugo

DizD

produced this in southern yellow pines. During salvage it was discovered that these fractures were revealed after lumber was dried and planed - mills were unable to detect it until that point. The fracture came from standing trees which withstood the hurricane winds as I recall, not the downed trees. Clemson produced a tabletop display with examples and photos. I'll see if I can find it.

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#34

Re: Bill we have a problem

Mark Hennebury

Hi Richard,

First of all, congratulations on your book.

It is by all reports a fine book, and i look forward to seeing for myself soon.

Thanks for clearing up the Compression fracture origin question.

Much of woodworking can be learned through experimentation, observation, and analysis, but there is so much that we cannot find on our own and we need the benefit of scientific study to see the full picture.

The place of reference material will always be of critical importance to our better understanding of wood and woodworking.

Reference material opens doors, and brings us deep into the incredible nature of this fascinating material, Knowledge creates a desire for more knowledge.

To be of value it must be presented in a way that is easy to understand for the general public, and relevant to the way we work.

Many years back Hoadleys book was my constant companion and provided a tremendous help to me in my quest to understand wood and woodworking, I am sure your book will be the same for the next generation.

Knowledge fuels passion.

Regards, Mark

Re: Felling Fracture Revisited

#35

Re: Bill we have a problem

Sgian Dubh

Mark, I'm glad I was able to help a bit. I do hope you'll find my book useful when do get to see a copy. It covers some different subjects to those Hoadley covered, and Hoadley discusses some subjects I didn't discuss.

One key factor I kept in mind was to write as a woodworker for other woodworkers, and to most definitely avoid writing as a wood scientist for other wood scientists. In other words I tried to find ways to explain some difficult things for the general reader which, to be honest, is a category into which most woodworker's fall.

Hopefully I've succeeded and the book will become, as you say, a resource for the next generation of woodworkers (although, to be honest, I'd like it even better if those who gained their wood knowledge from authors such as Hoadley also find my tome useful). I hope that latter hope isn't too presumptuous on my part. Slainte.