Given that several here had not heard or seen the problem that can crop up when harvesting trees for other than firewood, I got the chance for some examples while harvesting some walnut this weekend. So, on with the show . .
This is "mild" fracture with a single crack running through the pith:
I'll be able to cut around the defect by keeping mindful of where it sits relative to the saw's plane.
This, other the other hand, is gonna be mostly firewood:
Using a Woodmizer I'll be able to salvage about half the log.
After the March storms here, about the last thing I need is firewood. Many more trees were weakened and don't take much to come down in a stiff breeze. I bought a house in the woods, but if I loose a couple more I'll be able to go solar on the roof!
I have seen lots of these. I don't know if the first is a "felling fracture" of just a defect in the tree revealed by felling the tree. Most of these have been sort of starburst pattern.
I don't call the second one a felling fracture either. That was not caused by the tree hitting the ground with thud, it's from the tree tearing itself apart as it fell.
Doing a CSI...Cut Scene Investigation, with so little evidence is a challenge
So...the first crack across the pith. It is so very rare to see a crack like that inside the tree that wasn't triggered by impact. I've had to take down
Stems like that in cookies 6" thick. Not something that would be brought to the light of day very often...almost never. Some sort of external load or
Stress. Like a slam dunk flopper
Second...the shatter
Impact or storm or some such. Trees don't shatter going from their growing position and shatter while falling. The do shatter on impact
Going back to the first crack. The edges are fresh. It just happened. Not something that was in place waiting to reveal itself on firewood making day.
Dr Alex Shigo showed that defects could usually be traced by to a wound. I e seen many of
His research samples and heard him speak many times before he died. Defects are caused by wounds. A wound can alter the uniform growth of the cam i sheath that grows every year. Think of cutting glass. In window glass which is uniform it's easy to make a clean straight cut using a scribe and a short, sharp, shock... ping... smooth clean break. Now go pick up a complex, layers piece of
Glass for
Stained glass work. Complex layers and not uniform structure. Much harder to be t a clean cut...because of 'defects' in the crystalline structure. We call that grain in trees
I've seen a lot of fractures when felling trees, some as severe as the second picture and some quite minor, but most jagged like that and extending from the bark inward.
I've also seen many, many cracks like that in the first picture, through the pith but not extending to the bark. However, I can't remember seeing a crack like that as soon as a healthy tree hit the ground. All I remember like that were formed as moisture left the end of the log. In some trees pith cracks formed with minutes on a hot day, while I was limbing and cutting the tree into logs. I've seen many start cracking in a few hours or days, even when well coated with Anchorseal wax.
My experience is cracks from drying stresses rarely extend far along the log until months or years after sawing. In some logs they will eventually extend to the bark and down the log.
I have only felled or participated in the felling of maybe 200 trees. So I am not an expert. And I have certainly not done any academic research into this. Not trying to argue with an arborist, an academic or a lawyer, just trying to learn something.
I agree with JKJ. About ten years ago we felled lots of walnuts and cherries on the family farm. I failed to take the Anchorseal with me on the first day. By the second day, cracks similar to the top one had formed. The crack did not seem present when the trees were freshly felled. May have been there and so fine I did not see them. My problem is I don't know how anyone would know if there were such an internal crack before the tree were felled. Most/many of the trees we felled came down as gently as they could in the woods.
The second tree looks like one one that fell before the sawyer was ready, shattering the trunk from bending forces on the way down and then the sawyer trimmed the end. We never had one that bad. The log in the picture has two piths. Could that be related?
About 7 years ago a 42" dbh white oak was felled by a micro burst storm. My rental house cushioned it's fall. Within two days I had some pro's cut it up and get it off the house. Those logs had starburst patterns in them bigger than my hand and blackened so I assumed they had been there awhile. I had the logs quarter sawn and the sawyer did his best to box the heart. I am making furniture out that bastard now. Crush my house and I will get even.
I wish I could have attended some of the good Doctor,s talks. When I was in college (50 years ago) there was a Professor studying nails and nail guns. He was like the mad scientist down in the basement driving thousands of nails and ripping things apart. Sort of like your guy, single minded purpose. We built a small building in his lab on a shaker table. Think 12 by 16 yard building with black fiber subsiding and sheetrock on the interior. Stressed the heck out of it, removed some component and stressed it again, and again. The result was the sheetrock provided a lot more strength than it was given credit for and mostly the ceiling. There is much to know.
The crack in the first picture has nothing to do with forces from cutting down the tree. This kind of crack is common in the butt cuts. It can develop at once or more common over hours or days. It is something to do with stress in the trunk.
It would be more enlightening to know the conditions that caused the damage in the 2nd picture. It looks to be a small log and perhaps the top of a large tree where the branches broke. Indeed it is common to break up the tops of trees but there isn't valuable lumber up there anyway.
No. 1 was not a butt-section; the cut shown was a good 15' up the trunk. The butt and the first 9' showed no fracture.
No. 2 was just below a crotch that also split when they dropped the "stick" after cutting off the smaller leader. The crotch would have had some nice figure but it went to the firewood pile.
Both the subjects were yard trees so there was no way to cushion the fells.
I'll be getting two more walnuts from the same property, one of which is 30" at the butt and 40+ straight feet to the first leader. The arborist has agreed to a rope take-down on that one. When done I should have 12 to 15 saw logs at 9' each plus several good crotches.
where ever crack 1 was it was not a result of the tree hitting the ground. It was a result of internal tension stress in the wood that got relieved when the section was cut. There is no external force that would cause a split like that. Any external stress from hitting something will crack from the outside in, tension on the stressed side and compression on the opposite, just like in PIC 2.
You are correct that forked trees can split if not laid down parallel to the fork. I cut two ash recently and didn't split either fork.
shown is what the end of a log looks like that has started to check from drying. The larger crack is likely a stress crack and not related to drying.
The second picture shows what I am calling a stress crack because I think they form as a result of internal stress in the tree stem. They often form after the log is bucked to length, they may or may not appear on the adjacent cut surface and they rarely penetrate more than a few inches. They always go through the pith and they rarely reach to outer edge, though I have seen spring-cut ash split in halves upon standing.
These splits rarely cause degrade of the log. The splits would be trimmed if they were very many inches into the end of the sawed board (forgot the details of the grading rule). Trimming would yield odd number lengths of lumber and odd lengths (9,11,15) are uncommon.
When you buy graded lumber and have a split end it very likely is the result of one of these cracks. With modern kiln operation it is rare to have cracks from drying.
To me an end grain crack/check due to drying is a stress crack. I think the actual configuration of cracks due to the stresses of drying may depend on some other things such as the species and maybe time of year. For example I've seen star cracks such as in your first photo often in some species, and single, straight cracks in more in others.
I recently saw a number of what you refer to as stress cracks in endgrain rounds from a persimmon tree. The tree cam down across my drive so I had to cut it up quickly and didn't have time to seal all the ends right away. Most of the log sections laid on the ground developed straight end grain cracks through the pith within a couple of days, more so on the ends facing the sun. Some short log sections I stood upright on the ground cracked the same way on the upper end that was exposed to air and sunlight, while the end against the ground stayed damp and didn't crack. To me, this suggests the cracks are related to drying.
The crack through the pith is a wind check. It is perpendicular to the direction of the prevailing wind and out is what allows the tree to sway in the wind with out snapping. Look at the stump and you will see a matching crack.
My guess is that you have excessive tension stress (natural stress in the tree; also called growth stress) in the walnut. End coating does not prevent checking associated with this stress; end coating prevents checking caused by rapid drying of the ends of the lumber
It is not preventable - it comes with the log. Oftentimes the greatest stress seems to be in 16" to 20" diameters. Some species have a lot more growth stress than others. ...... it is more common to see such stresses near the center of the log, but you will see them at all locations.
For those that do not know Gene....he is the font of wood knowledge gained at VA Tech and Forest Products Lab, Wisconsin.
A search will reveal scientific articles on the topic and even a book.
I don't know the cause of those, but I do know that they are very common in African mahogany (which is what the pictures look like). I've never seen them in any other wood, but have found them in about 10-20% of the African mahogany I've ever used.
As you've said, I don't see any way that the type of crack in the second picture could be anything but a tension fracture that is unrelated to means of felling. It should be pretty obvious that a crack completely internal to a log will be the result of internal stresses, whatever their ultimate cause (wind, rapid growth, etc). I think varying growth rates make a lot more sense than wind (sound outer wood with a fracture in the center simply defies the mechanics of stress on a beam) - but then I'm no expert.
The answer to this defect is to be found in Richard's new book, Cut and Dried, page 215. It has various names-Thunder shake, Cross Shake or Compression Shake. The book reference includes a nearly identical picture of the defect, (Richard has LOTS of pictures ). Causes are many but nothing to do with harvesting. I see it commonly in old growth mahogany.
To repeat, log degrade due to felling fractures is exceeding rare on professional logging jobs. It is simply very difficult to bust a sound tree stem unless it is small. (There is lots of felling collateral damage to small trees when a big oak hits the ground.) Personally I have never busted a sound tree and I have been careless with several beech I wanted to be rid of. It is easy to split a trunk with a heavy lean (and maybe die) , but there are techniques for heavy leaners to prevent splitting. Personally I try to avoid dealing with them.
An acquaintance had a tree trimmer drop some cherry trees on their New York farm and truck them to Cincinnati to be bandsawn into lumber. All the sections of log are about 18-24" diameter and 9-10' long. Probably cut 3-4 trees.
As the sections of log were being unloaded here he volunteered that he tried to position pieces of log on the ground so that each tree would fall on the log and not on the ground. No clue why he wanted to do that.
The shortest section of log (8') had several fractures in one end, some tangential and some radial. It certainly was useless for long boards, so I cut as many bowl blanks as I could in what looked like solid wood. As I was shaping the outsides, several of the bowl blanks quickly showed long longitudinal cracks and had to be scrapped.
Over the last five years I've cut a number of log sections into bowl blanks, and never experienced this before.
Hope the logs will be bandsawn in the next week or two, but none of the other ends showed the kind of multiple crack (i.e. fracture) damage like that in the original post picture. Hoping they aren't similarly full of longitudinal cracks.