Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

How to best cut a large circle

Posts

How to best cut a large circle

#1

How to best cut a large circle

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I need to turn a 34" square of 4/4 lumber into a 34" diameter circle table top. I have a large band saw and other common tools. So, how to best wind up with a circle with finished edge?

I can look up cutting circles on U-tube, but I won't. Not interested in how it might be done. Rather, what I want is the advice of someone here that has done it successfully. Absent some better way I will cut it on the band saw and plane/rasp the edge smooth. But even on my big saw it will be a challenge to handle the large piece.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#2

Re: How to best cut a large circle

Tom Norton

I have done it with my plunge router on a compass beam.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#3

Ellis Walentine

Agree


Re: How to best cut a large circle

#4

Another Router Vote!

Brad Chenoweth

That's how I did a 42" diameter top out of 5/4 hickory. Worked really well.

Brad

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#5

Re: How to .... cut a large circle.....

roger lance

I've used this type of jig to successfully cut circles......


The bandsaw method will also require a jig and a support for that jig.....and will work very well.

I would think that the router method may risk burning of the stock.....where the bandsaw might not. But each method involves making a jig and spending time to get things set-up properly. What's "best" for you.....you never seem unable to figure that out.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#6

Re: How to best cut a large circle

John McGaw

I've done a large (40") round tabletop precisely one time so I can't make any comparisons but mine was done on the bandsaw. Looking back I can see that a router could have worked just as well but back then I thought that I knew everything about the subject and just 'knew' that the bandsaw was the solution.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#7

Ellis Walentine

Further to the bandsaw technique...

Ellis Walentine

You can clean up and fair a bandsawn circle by taking the same table you use to rotate the blank over to the disc sander. In the case of a 34" diameter, this would entail a whole lot more work than a router trammel. You can clean up a router cut by taking a very thin finishing pass with a new or very sharp router bit.

Ellis

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#8

Re: How to best cut a large circle

Sgian Dubh

As others have said, Bill, a plunge router mounted on a trammel is the way to go. I can't recall how many discs I've knocked out using this method over the decades. Generally, using a bandsaw for this kind of task is slower and more fiddly, although it is admittedly quieter and less dusty. All the same, I go for the trammel and router method in preference every time. Slainte.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#9

Bandsaw plus router

Dick Coers

It cuts a lot easier with the router if only cleaning up the edge. I usually rough it out on the bandsaw about 1/8" from the line, then hit it with the router on a trammel. I've done big 8/4 table this way, up to 60" in diameter. On the big work, I've cut half way through on the trammel, then from the back side with a flush trim bit. Also used a top bearing pattern bit to get more depth from one side. Love the 1 1/4" diameter pattern bits from Freud. The increased diameter cuts cleaner and less chance of chip out when going against the grain.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#10

Re: Further to the bandsaw technique...

roger lance

Also, the bandsaw jig would be more complicated to make than the router jig. The router jig need be nothing more than a piece of scrap of suitable length and width.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#11

Re: How to best cut a large circle

jesse cloud

I've done it several times, both ways. Both work fine. Router jig is simpler to make, taking less overall time. Use a sharp cutter whichever you do. Don't rush the tool, let it go at its own pace.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#12

Re: Bandsaw plus router

Barry Irby

I have my lunch box planer set up so the top of it is exactly the same height as my bandsaw so it can serve as an out feed table or auxiliary support. Even with that I would suggest the router method. The problem I have with the bandsaw is getting the cut started. You CAN set the pivot exactly 17" from one edge and start there, but I usually end up with a slight flat there.

Using a router trammel I would cut from the back/bottom side and plunge the router in in steps. Maybe a 1/4" at a time and let the last cut be the lightest. I would make the top very slightly oversize and then move the router inward a 1/32" and make a cleanup cut.

I would use a 1/2" spiral up cut bit or and end mill. I have done it with a 1/4" bit, but it has too much whip. Styrofoam makes a good base to lay the piece on for this. Set it up so you can walk around the piece in a continuous motion if possible.

One of my routers has an edge guide that can be turned into a trammel and it has a micro adjuster on it that makes the final pass easy.

Make your trammel arm sturdy enough the router is not tippy. You will get a cleaner edge. Do not use 1/4" plywood. Use a fairly sturdy pivot point. Walk it all the way around once just as a test. Watch the router cord. You will have plenty to think about and watch once the router starts howling. Plan well, execute smoothly. Pull gently outward on the router as well as advancing it.

No plan survives first contact with reality. (Borrowed that from my Son, the combat veteran, No plan survives first contact with the enemy.)

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#13

Re: How to best cut a large circle

Ron Pemberton

Ditto on plunge router and compass beam.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#14

Well that is discouraging

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't own a plunge router. If I had one how is the pivot anchored such that it doesn't pop out of place during the cutting? It just sounds like something that would happen to me.

I guess it is band saw and rasp. When faced with these problems I think that they didn't have plunge routers in 1720, so how did they do it.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#15

Usually I use the plunge router / trammel

Keith Newton

If you run clockwise around doing the roughing cut, you will likely have more cleanup due to bit deflection even if everything else it tight. However doing all but your final cut will have the bit flexing away from the final edge through the earlier steps.

For larger tables, I like to save some router time by just making a 1/2" MDF template with the router. Then mark and bandsaw about 1/8" outside the line, then going back with a bearing over to cut down-slope for half, then flipping it and use a bearing under to clean up the other half. This takes care of any chips tearing out, which by the way are most likely where the grain is almost tangent to the circle. I always climb cut in that area if I think it is likely.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#16

1720? Bow saw and spoke shave

Dick Coers

Or they cut down perpendicular to the line with a hand saw, and chopped to the line with a hatchet. Then spokeshave.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#17

Re: Well that is discouraging

roger lance

Now, I know you know someone that owns a plunge router.....of all the people in your club/ww group somebody has a plunge router.

On the underside of the table top, you drill a hole for a dowel or wood screw that acts to hold the jig centered and in place.....having two people doing this works well....one to run the router.....the other to oversee that pivot point, the electric cord, etc etc.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#18

Re: How to best cut a large circle

Mark Hennebury

You can do it on a pivot point on the bandsaw, it will get you a pretty good finish, not as good as a router but not bad.

You need to make a sliding table on your bandsaw so that you can slide the table with your top into the blade until you get to the stop point. clamp the sliding table and rotate your solid wood top . I can expalin further if you wish.

You can also rough cut by hand on the bandsaw to with 1/16" then finish cut with a regular router on a beam. set to the bit to cut full depth. Make the beam so that you can start the router just outside the cut, then move it into the cut and clamp then rotate around to cut the circle. hang your electric cord overhead so you dont get hung up.

You can also rough cut on the bandsaw and then finish on a belt sander using a pivot to rotate it, not a lot of fun and hard to control.

Router is the best, but with a little imagination there are many ways.

May i suggest that you invest in a plunge router, there are endless advantages.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#19

Re: How to best cut a large circle

Barry Irby

I second Mark's suggestions. He beat me by minutes.

The sliding table is a nice idea but may be a bit difficult to get into place by yourself.

You could take a piece of plywood about as wide as your bandsaw table front to back that will reach from the column side (left) of the table to a point far enough to the right to support your top. Something about 18" by maybe four feet. Saw into the piece with the left end flush with the left edge of the table until the trailing edge is flush with the front edge of the table. Clamp it firmly into place. Now drill a hole for your pivot 17" from the blade on a line even with the front edge of the teeth. Drill a matching hole in the bottom of your top 17" from one edge, lay your top in place and screw through the hole with a short fat wood screw. At this point the corners should have been lopped off to be sure they don't hit the clamps holding the extended top. Turn on the saw and rotate the top. You should be quite able to smooth up the edges and fair the curve with your hand planes and spoke shaves.

Or set up a table the same height as your BS table and cut it by eye and fair the curves.

You don't really need a plunge router to do this, but this might be a good excuse to buy one. They really do have lots of uses.

Or you could do it with a regular router and just be careful lowering it into the work. Even if you are a little sloppy you can clean it up nicer by shortening the trammel a tiny amount.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#20

Oh No, Your in a time warp!

Keith Newton

After seeing your haul from the midwest tool collectors meet, I'm afraid your traveling back in time. I'll get with Ellis to round up a posse of others here to come by your shop to remove your table saw and other electric powered tools. You'll have to do all your post on the hand tool side from now on. ha ha

Or maybe you could buy and discover the wonderful world of plunge routing. There couldn't be a more perfect time. Just do it, you gotta have it.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#21

Or an opportunity

Kevin French

"Honey, that new table I'm building for you. Turns out I'm going to need to buy a Plunge Router to do it right."

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#22

This is not looking good

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I won a Festool plunge router in the WoodCentral jewelry box competition. It looked big and awkward for my uses of a router (to date) . Saw no future use for it and sold it, cheap. Then I won another plunge router and gave it to my son in law for I still saw no use for it. Now apparently I need one. I do have a hatchet and spoke shave :)

I used to look forward to situations that led to buying another tool. Now I am more inclined to cobble something together to get the job done from what I have at hand.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#23

Re: This is not looking good

roger lance

Now, that is funny!

and ironic.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#24

Re: This is not looking good

Barry Irby

Well there you go. The answer. Borrow it back form the Son in law. And have him help you.

I too have reached an age where I no longer look for excuses to buy tools. I don't need an excuse, I just buy anything that catches my eye as long as it's cheap. Sorry I missed that Festool Router.

Speaking of cobbling things together, here's an idea. Cut a stick the same height as your bandsaw table. Put a pivot point in both ends. Put a pivot hole in the bottom of your table top, stand it on the stick and cut out the top. Fair the circle. It only has to look and feel round, it won't be perfectly round as soon as the humidity and MC change anyway. Might want to have SWIMBO or SIL steady the stick. We may be overthinking this. Go for it, you have more ash.

Re: How to best cut a large circle

#25

Hey Bill, if you think a circle is hard....

Barry Irby

try an oval. My son and DIL wanted a oval coffee table.

With the help of several people here I hunted YouTube for a Trammel of Archimedes, made one and made the table which involved two full ovals and two partial ones.

Ellis called it a Smoke Grinder or BS Grinder.

Round and round she goes, where she stops....

It was about 42 by 20 inches.