I have been refining the design for a while, first on paper and then in person using some "top grade" materials. The thickness of the vertical pieces must proportion well with the top thickness. Short of laying up a top from real wood I don't know how to simulate the top thickness. As it stands the top will be 7/8" for that is the best I can tease out of the curly ash available. The vertical members are 1 1/8" in the picture.
Do you have a glue gun? you could cut a strip of cardboard & glue it around your table top. It wouldn't be pretty, but, should work for your simulation.
I'm wondering what your idea of "proportioning well" means to you. I'm also wondering whether there will be some kind of structure on top of the pedestal base to support the top?
Tables are interesting design challenges, as you don't usually regard them at eye level, but rather from a higher viewpoint, looking down. You can vary the appearance of the various members, regardless of their thickness, by curving the edges. For example, if you want the top to appear thicker, you can put a thumbnail or broadly rounded profile on it. And if you want the base and/or, the verticals to read a bit thinner, you might put a parabolic-shaped profiles on the edges.
The reason I asked about your plans for supporting the top is really twofold: First, I think it would be structurally advisable, to keep the top flat and to tie it solidly to the base; and second, it presents another design opportunity, to reveal some of the structure, thereby adding a note of visual weight in that area. Intriguing possibilities....
I also fear structural weakness with the narrow joinery between the column and the base. Of course, I don't know if you may be planning steel plate reinforcements instead of wooden joints.
To tell the truth, I like Bill's legs better than Sam's (please don't take this personally) with regard to the overall design. There's something fanciful about Bill's table. It, somehow, reminds me more of Charlie Chaplin than a tree.
Unclear what you are suggesting. What profile is to be maintained? Are you suggesting the vertical "post" should be make of the same thickness material as the base. The answer to that design is , no. It makes the column look too heavy relative to the top thickness. Even 1 1/4" material for the column is too thick.
Hardly. There are 4- mortise and tenons fastening the column to the base and they are spaced orthogonal and 4" spread between them. If someone sits on the table it will either tip over or the "arms" supporting the top will break off. I can not see any force the table would be subjected to that would challenge this connection of column to base. Even in pine with hasty M&T joints the post is solid. The large spacing and orthogonal orientation provides huge resistance to stress in any direction.
This design just eludes me. In present iteration I find it clunky. To MY eye it base needs thinning and sculpting. the top requires depth as in a entrance foyer/drum table. .
I wish I had better vocabulary to describe what my refinements might be helpful, but, in my view, this is not one of your better designs.
OK. You're designing and building it, and I know that you know what you are doing. All I'm working with is a picture that doesn't even show the joinery.
It will live in a "breakfast nook" by a window overlooking pasture and surrounded by ash kitchen cabinets. ....small dining table. We have a dining room that is used for most meals. Right now we have a card table in this area that seems to get used for various functions. The idea it to replace the card table. table top will be 32" across.
Mocking things up is probably the surest way of working out design ideas.
I like the way you made the column out of four pieces of flat stock. I think I would try to keep those pieces on the thin side, like 1" or less, while having the four base pieces significantly wider.
I would also play around with ways to avoid that acute angle transition from the column to the base - I find that part of it a bit unappealing. I don't think there is a way to transition the convex curve to a straight column just above the base without it looking funny, but you could perhaps have the column go into a transition piece on top of the base to break up the flatter lines of the feet meeting the column.
I better understand. Still, have you considered reversing the column so that the wider portion is at the base and the taper toward the top. Fastening the top might be by way of a metal spider like café tables on the street. Not all wood, I know, but perhaps more convenient. It could also enable the table to be a turntable if that has merit in under a three foot diameter.
you not going to find that in JC Penny! i'm not sure on all the resistance. sometimes coloring outside the lines is the best thing. maybe this will evolove to your own signature style.
Bill, are you using the plywood under the table top? Cut the top angles on your saw and fit dry to see they are even, then glue up the sections to the plywood and clamp as needed.
For the table bottom and post I would round over the edges with a 1/2" router bit and sand till smooth.
Since you said the table will be used for minor eating What I have said will suffice for looks.