only sharpen the ??? of the tooth.
John K Jordan
Revised post. I was confused as to which side of the tooth was the front! Thanks for Derek for pointing that out. I deleted the other message and reposting it here, slightly edited, to avoid confusion. JKJ
-----------------------------------------------------
Sharpening the gullet is probably ideal - when I send my WoodMizer blades in for sharpening it looks like they sharpen that way. Sharpening only the back of the tooth (the side of the tooth facing outwards) can affect the angles a little but that is not critical. It will affect the set, the amount depending on how many times you sharpen and how aggressive you are. It takes only the slightest touch with the abrasive disk, perhaps 1/4 of a second. Only an extremely small amount of metal is removed.
I generally sharpen the fronts of the teeth two or three times before I discard the blade. I have been resharpening this way for perhaps 15 years. Some people sharpen this way six time or more.
Although the resharpened blade may not be as good as new, there are still some benefits:
- sharpening the front is much easier and quicker than the back
- resharpening just a few times changes very little
- resharpening makes a dull blade cut like new
- resharpening 3 or 4 times greatly reduces the cost of the blade
- resharpening my last blade lets me continue playing in the shop
The cut after a few sharpenings may not be quite as clean as a new blade or one sharpened in the gullets but that doesn't affect how I use my bandsaw, primarily for preparing blanks for woodturning or making relatively thick resaws, both green and dry. I rarely cut thin veneer. As with many things in life one size does not fit all.
The difference in cut can be dramatic. A few days ago I started cutting up cutting a 12" thick log of osage orange with my 18" saw when I realized the blade wasn't cutting as I expected. Sliding my thumb upwards across the teeth confirmed the sharpness was not what it could be. (The difference is very subtle but can be learned) Twenty minutes with the dremel and it felt more like I was cutting basswood than osage.
It might be interesting to read what Stephen Russell writes about this:
https://web.archive.org/web/20170626234929/http://www.woodturningvideosplus.com:80/resharpen-bandsaw-blades.html
I think Stephen mentions that he would use a new blade when resawing thin veneer.
(I see he also calls the side sharpened the "back".
)
Cell phone photo of me sharpening:

BTW, I have experimented with two methods. Since the set on the teeth on my blades alternates (right, left, center) I have tried angling the abrasive disk to line up with the angle of the set. I found no difference in the cut when I sharpened without angling the disk but holding it in the same position for each tooth. I see Stephen Russell recommends aligning with the set of the tooth.
I have also experimented with the direction of the abrasive at the point of contact - into the tooth, away from the tooth, and sideways. I can't detect any difference in the cut. Any burr left from the abrasive wheel is gone on the first revolution of the band.
JKJ



