Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

What Bandsaw blade?

Posts

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#26

only sharpen the ??? of the tooth.

John K Jordan

Revised post. I was confused as to which side of the tooth was the front! Thanks for Derek for pointing that out. I deleted the other message and reposting it here, slightly edited, to avoid confusion. JKJ

-----------------------------------------------------

Sharpening the gullet is probably ideal - when I send my WoodMizer blades in for sharpening it looks like they sharpen that way. Sharpening only the back of the tooth (the side of the tooth facing outwards) can affect the angles a little but that is not critical. It will affect the set, the amount depending on how many times you sharpen and how aggressive you are. It takes only the slightest touch with the abrasive disk, perhaps 1/4 of a second. Only an extremely small amount of metal is removed.

I generally sharpen the fronts of the teeth two or three times before I discard the blade. I have been resharpening this way for perhaps 15 years. Some people sharpen this way six time or more.

Although the resharpened blade may not be as good as new, there are still some benefits:

- sharpening the front is much easier and quicker than the back

- resharpening just a few times changes very little

- resharpening makes a dull blade cut like new

- resharpening 3 or 4 times greatly reduces the cost of the blade

- resharpening my last blade lets me continue playing in the shop

The cut after a few sharpenings may not be quite as clean as a new blade or one sharpened in the gullets but that doesn't affect how I use my bandsaw, primarily for preparing blanks for woodturning or making relatively thick resaws, both green and dry. I rarely cut thin veneer. As with many things in life one size does not fit all.

The difference in cut can be dramatic. A few days ago I started cutting up cutting a 12" thick log of osage orange with my 18" saw when I realized the blade wasn't cutting as I expected. Sliding my thumb upwards across the teeth confirmed the sharpness was not what it could be. (The difference is very subtle but can be learned) Twenty minutes with the dremel and it felt more like I was cutting basswood than osage.

It might be interesting to read what Stephen Russell writes about this:

https://web.archive.org/web/20170626234929/http://www.woodturningvideosplus.com:80/resharpen-bandsaw-blades.html

I think Stephen mentions that he would use a new blade when resawing thin veneer.

(I see he also calls the side sharpened the "back". :))

Cell phone photo of me sharpening:


BTW, I have experimented with two methods. Since the set on the teeth on my blades alternates (right, left, center) I have tried angling the abrasive disk to line up with the angle of the set. I found no difference in the cut when I sharpened without angling the disk but holding it in the same position for each tooth. I see Stephen Russell recommends aligning with the set of the tooth.

I have also experimented with the direction of the abrasive at the point of contact - into the tooth, away from the tooth, and sideways. I can't detect any difference in the cut. Any burr left from the abrasive wheel is gone on the first revolution of the band.

JKJ

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#27

thank you for comprehensive description

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I will give it a try.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#28

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

Don Evans

Barry

I don't know if this is mentioned above or not, but, I decided to try the resaw blade that Highland Hardware sells I think they call it the WoodSlicer.

Its a fantastic blade for resawing, has the smoothes surface that requires very little sanding to remove cutting marks. Frankly I am very surprise at how well it works and it's not expensive $20 some dollars.

Try it before spending all that money for a carbide tipped one.

Don

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#29

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Don, I have a few of these. When sharp, they do cut well and leave a smooth surface. However, being plain carbon steel, they lose their edge too quickly for my taste.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#30

There's the rub....

Barry Irby

I am searching for the magic bandsaw blade.

I have a Forrest WWII that generally lives on my TS. I turn the saw on, make the cut, move on. The only time I change it is to put a flat top rip cut blade on to make flat bottom groves for splines. Even that change only take a couple of minutes. And I don't have to adjust the trunnions or calibrate the fence.

But, the bandsaw....Take off the old blade, roll it up trying not to slash my jugular, unroll the new blade, trying not to open a vein, put it on trying not to kink it, then adjust the wheels to track it and adjust the guides.I have Carter guides and a new upper block (?) and spring from Itturra and I don't know what else. In hindsight, I should have bought a bigger better saw I have spent enough money on this one to make a silk purse out of it.

I have ordered two Diemaster bimetal blades from Lennox. I will see how they work.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#31

Why is all that adjusting necesssary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are replacing with identical size blade there should be no adjusting required. What are you doing that is dulling blades at an annoying rate?

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#32

Re: thank you for comprehensive description

AZ in Colorado Springs

Ditto. That is a great description.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#33

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

T.M. Stock

Buy a new saw. The little Deltas and Delta clones will work for resaw, and with a lot of tweaking, do a passible job, but they will not tension anything in the way of a blade wider than 1/2" for resaw, and will not be all that happy about tackling stuff like 10" cocobolo or Macassar ebony without a horsepower upgrade, tension spring, etc. Cheaper in the long run to go to a saw that will run a decent resaw blade in stock configuration.

I've made money on each saw that I've sold on Craigslist, and there is a buyer for every tool given a little patience. The other option is to keep the little 14" for what it's good at - running a 1/4" blade for everyday band saw work - and pick up a 17" or 19" Griz or similar saw that will handle and properly tension a 1" or wider resaw blade.

Some woods common to luthiery eat CS and BM bandsaw blades for light snacks - just not practical to run anything other than carbide with something like curly anigre, where the wood is more silica than cellulose. The 1" Woodmaster CT is relatively inexpensive (at $115 for a 143" blade) and under $110 in quantity of 2 or 3...also easy to touch up. Most of the 16" and up machines will handle at least 1" width.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#34

Re: Why is all that adjusting necesssary

Barry Irby

Perhaps I was being a bit of a drama queen. If the blades are identical it really doesn't take THAT long, but is you change to a different type it can be get tedious. Mind you, it does not take a lot to hit my TEDIOUS button when it comes to the bandsaw.

Thinking back on it, my biggest mistake may have been not labeling the blades when I took them off the saw. I have at least about a half dozen that are probably nearly as good as new, but I would have to put them back on the saw to find out.

Incidentally, I have tried sharpening them the way JKJ described and from the gullet side. They both work, but I never seem to be "in the mood". There is never a good time to stop whatever I am working on to stop and sharpen. The problem is if you sharpen you might do a good job and get an almost like new response. If you install a fresh new blade you know you get a reliable blade. If a new blade is $12, how much can you save?

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#35

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

Barry Irby

I concluded a long time ago that I should own two bandsaws. Leave a bigger more powerful one set up for resawing and the 14" one for everything else. My biggest problem with that is I don't have the space. My shop is tiny. 14 by 22. If I get one more tool I will have to stand in the door and admire them.

I am considering a major overhaul.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#36

sharpening savings

John K Jordan

>>> If a new blade is $12, how much can you save?

Sharpen a $12 blade once, you've saved $12 by not buying another blade. Sharpen it a second time, you've saved $24; three times, $36. Buy a second blade with $12 of that and sharpen it three times, you've now spent $24 total but saved $48. Repeat.

(To double the savings start with a $30 blade. :))

Or another way to think of it: sharpening three times makes that $12 blade cost $3.

Invest the savings wisely and perhaps eventually that 18" bandsaw (whose footprint is not significantly bigger than the 14") will be free. I rarely use my 14" Delta since I got the 18".

I think of sharpening somewhat like I think about sweeping the floor - I don't enjoy it but I make myself stop and do it when needed. The time it takes to sharpen is less than that wasted on 1/2 hour of TV. I haven't watched an hour of TV in 12 years so I have plenty of time to sharpen.

JKJ

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#37

Re: Why is all that adjusting necesssary

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

If a new blade is $12, how much can you save?

Barry, it is not the money you save that is important. Being able to sharpen bandsaw blades offers freedom and independence. I never fear having my last blade go dull in the middle of a project. The blades I sharpen are often better than when they arrived in the box.

There is the money side as well, of course. The 1" Lenox carbide blade used for resawing was around $250. Lenox state that they can resharpen it once. Then it gets tossed. So far I have sharpened it twice. It is good for more. The 1/2" bimetal blades are around $60 each. I sharpen them at least 5 times. That's a lot of money, but it is just part of the benefit of sharpening oneself.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#38

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

T.M. Stock

I've run out of space in 2000 sf (basement with lots of existing conflicts on layout)...so certainly understand Fortunately, a larger bandsaw consumes very little additional space, so at least the upgrade to a larger saw is usually not a space constrained issue.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#39

Re: Why is all that adjusting necesssary

T.M. Stock

Good answer, Derek. I've never understood the rationale of 'saving time' when we are talking about hobby woodworking. For what? Work? ;-)

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#40

Re: Why is all that adjusting necessary...Doh!

Barry Irby

I clearly had not thought that through. I think it's time to start putting the old blades back on the saw and sharpen them as needed. I will search out one of the little diamond blades for the Dremel today. I have not had one of those. Wonder if it would be helpful to make a holder for the Dremel to support it at the correct angle?

OTOH, I just saw the blade I want on the TV show "How Do They Make That?" They were making "motion furniture" (recliners) with plywood frames. They had some sort of automated computer controlled bandsaw cut what looked like a 10" tall stack of 3/4" plywood. It was zipping through it with what looked like a half inch blade. That blade would last me a LONG time even if it only lasts them 2 hours as the Lennox guy told me.

Thanks to everyone who has responded. This is one of the best things about Wood Central.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#41

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

Yonak

"If I get one more tool I will have to stand in the door and admire them."

I can imagine that could get old in a hurry.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#42

Re: Why is all that adjusting necessary...Doh!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Wonder if it would be helpful to make a holder for the Dremel to support it at the correct angle?

Hi Barry

It s easy to do it freehand. All you need to do is stroke along the back of the blade. You will get it after a few teeth. Then it is just muscle memory. You really do not need (or want) a jig - get used to working without one. All they do is enslave you. Be free! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#43

diamond disk is NOT needed

John K Jordan

>>>I clearly had not thought that through. I think it's time to start putting the old blades back on the saw and sharpen them as needed. I will search out one of the little diamond blades for the Dremel today.

Diamond might be useful for carbide blades.

For all other bandsaw blades I use these little abrasive disks: https://www.amazon.com/Dremel-409-Cut-off-Wheels-thick/dp/B00004UDGX

The thicker disks also work but the thin ones work fine. You have to have the little mandrel that holds a disk in place with a small screw. A mandrel usually comes with a dremel kit. I run the dremel at high speed.

BTW if sharpening carbon steel blades be careful not to blue the tip with too much pressure/heat or you might destroy the hardness. A very light and very brief touch is all that is needed. If necessary, wait a beat to let it cool and touch a second time rather than overheat.

I do not use the fiberglass reinforced wheels - not needed and maybe they won't even work if the sides are not as flat.

These disks are fragile so don't bang them against something or cut a deep slot in metal then let them bind in the slot. They are small and lightweight but a piece could still fly into your eye so wear glasses or something.

No alignment holder is needed. I put the upper guides up high, put some tape or paint a section of the blade with a red sharpie or something, rest my arm to hold the dremel in a good position to touch at the right angle, then sharpen a tooth and move the blade with my left hand up or down a tooth. Sometimes I'll sharpen 4 or 5 teeth before moving the blade but that takes more care to keep the angle consistent.

JKJ

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#44

Re: diamond disk is NOT needed

Barry Irby

Thanks for that. I went to both Lowes and Home Depot and while they had lots of Dremel stuff,. neither had a diamond wheel.

I have some of those cut off disks. I will try one (or 2 or 3) of them.

This has been a great thread. Lots of input and lots of people participating. Thanks to all of you.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#45

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Denny

Derek, I finally experienced why you and others refer to the Woodslicer blades as being soft. I was resawing some 9" sapele and found the blade was useless after cutting through a few feet of wood. I was able to use your sharpening advice to resharpen the blade and it was as good as new, but only lasted for another few feet of resawing (Interesting that Highland advises that the blades can't be resharpened.)

So I spoke to the Lenox tech support guy and he said I could use either the Diemaster bimetal blades or the Trimaster carbide blades on my Jet 16" saw, but he strongly cautioned me not to use the carbide blades for anything other than resawing, because attempting to cut anything other than a straight line would damage the carbide teeth.

So I'm wondering if anyone has experience using the Diemaster bimetal blades for resawing, or should I just get one of each, a bimetal blade for general use and one of the carbide blades dedicated to resawing.

Thanks,

Denny

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#46

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I’ve never used a Diemaster, but I have both Woodslicer and Trimaster blades on a 14” Delta. It’s true the Woodslicer doesn’t last as long, but it leaves a better finish and tracks very well. The Trimaster has lasted more than 10 years of occasional use. It obviously last much longer, but IMHO doesn’t track quite as well or leave as fine a finish. The Trimaster can be resharpened, too.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#47

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Denny

Thanks Bruce, I think I'll start out with a Diemaster bimetal and see how it works for resawing.

Denny

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#48

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Please report back on that diemaster. I’ve been thinking about one, too.

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#49

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Denny

I did not reply earlier as my bimetal blades are not Diemaster. They are 3 tpi 1/2" from Henry Bros in Oz. I use them for everything but very serious resawing. Fantastic blades. I get about 5 or 6 sharpenings from each.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: What Bandsaw blade?

#50

Re: Bandsaw blades revisited

Denny

Thanks folks, I'll report back on the Diemaster after some testing.

Denny