Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Here's a picture, I hope

Posts

Here's a picture, I hope

#1

Here's a picture, I hope

Barry Irby

this is the chest I have been working of for one of my Granddaughters. the second one is nearly identical but is a step behind. Here Dad does not like the Beads on the drawer fronts or the wooden pulls. OTOH, he won't tell me what he does like.

The asymmetrical panels have me a fit. Just lucky to get lefts and rights.



I have no idea how big these will be. I have the original files I could sent to someone who actually knows how to do this to post for me.

I want to thanks everyone for there suggestions. (Whether I used them or knot.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#2

No idea why they are rotated.


Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#3

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You found some pretty wood for that piece. The only suggestion I would make is that some sort of molding between the top and the top rank for drawers would have dressed it up a bit.

The other advice would be to please the client, in this case granddaughter, and yourself. You are fee to ignore the rest.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#4

Re: No idea why they are rotated.

John McGaw

When you snapped the pictures with your iPhone 6s at 12:51PM, the camera encoded the orientation of the camera and added it to the image's EXIF information (along with a whole bunch of other information including precise latitude and longitude and altitude) . Now the image 'knows' what is up (literally) and any viewing program which honors this information will display it as the camera 'saw' it. Generally running the file through an editor program and then re-saving it without EXIF will fix this.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#5

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

Barry Irby

It was terrible finding the wood. I have several thousand feet of Virginia Cherry. Its full of defects. Splits, some sort of pitch pockets (?), on and on. Sapwood. Spent a lot of time cutting around defects.

Originally there were not going to be the little top drawers and some sort of molding under the top, but Grandma voted for jewelry drawers. Designed on the fly. There is a sloping "Molding" under the top.

Thought about making the jewelry drawers slide out and hang down for necklaces. Don't mention that again.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#6

images rotated

Yonak

Very nice. Very attractive. I agree with Bill : "... please the client ..., your granddaughter, and yourself. You are free to ignore [her father]."


Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#7

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

how did you do the drawers- wood on wood, drawer hardware, ?

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#8

Re: question

Barry Irby

The drawers are poplar I harvested where they were widening a road and had it sawed and air dried it. Resawed some 5/4 and let it dry further. Dovetailed the boxes with a Leigh jig. The runners in the chest are quarter sawn white oak from a tree that fell on my rental house. Beautiful pieces with lots of medulary rays. So I have softer drawers on harder runners. The runners are cut with a rabbet top and bottom for the drawer to run in and a dovetail on the back to slide into the chest. The cherry fronts are applied to the boxes.

I have one coat of shellac on the boxes. I think I am going to apply a second coat. You suggested a foam brush and that worked well. Thanks. Either way I am going to sand them smooth and wax them. The drawers slide nicely now and I think they will get better.

Trying to screw up my courage and hand cut some dovetails. I read your posts on DT's recently and am chasing it around in my head. The Leigh jug does a fine job, but I am not sure you have really made dovetails until you don them by hand.

Thanks for your help.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#9

drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Either way I am going to sand them smooth and wax them"

Yes. Shellac, sand with 320, maybe shellac a second time, sand again if rough and wax. Drawers will be near frictionless.

Editorial: What I despise about the emphasis on flauntable dovetails is that this emphasis discourages people from trying/using them and you are the latest example. "Well, your dovetails are not perfect. You must be a unskilled/novice/sloppy woodworker", they conclude, and worse, proclaim. Or at least the novice fears this evaluation.

Why not look at someone's finish instead to make a judgment of the makers worth (or best of all the whole of it- design, assemble, finish)? By this metric Krenov was not very skilled. It doesn't take much talent to rub a thin coat of shellac on something. I am more impressed by an expertly applied durable finish than I am by some aspect of furniture assembly I have to search out to see. Some fret over an imperfect dovetail. I look for orange peel. And some of you have it, or at least did. But I remain silent on the judgment.

If your dovetails hold the drawer together that is all you granddaughters will care about. After you risk the scorn of your fellow woodworkers by making a few less than perfect ones you will eventually get reasonable good at it...as good as you want to be at least. So get out there and saw some. As out of focus as you pictures are nobody will notice if they are perfect. ;) The Lie Neilsen video is a good teaching aid.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#10

Dovetails

AZ in Colorado Springs

Chris Schwartz suggested in a magazine article years ago to use some scrap to cut one set of dovetails per day for 30 days.

I felt the way you described about dovetails and realized that I'll never learn how to cut them if i don't try it for the first time. So I gathered some scraps and started cutting. I learned a lot in that first run.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#11

The problem with that training routine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The advice could work for someone that spends time in the shop to spend time in the shop. Anyone needing a place to store their socks, or provide their granddaughters a place to store their socks, is not going to postpone the project a month so that they can make flauntable dovetails for the project.

I have taught people to make functional dovetails in a half day and that is good enough for a place to hold your socks.

I have 2-3 month gaps between my need to make dovetails. And the wood may differ, which has an effect on the details of how much a scribe line is split. If my goal was flauntable dovetails I would need to practice some for each project. I get no personal reward from practice nor would it lead to any functional benefit to a sock drawer. So I forge ahead. By the time I am done with 8 drawers for a project I am getting pretty good at it, and more efficient. Now efficient I get a reward from.

Of more practical benefit to Barry and others in need of a place to put your socks, somewhere on the internet is a picture gallery of dovetails someone has found in furniture. My training advice is to practice a few and when they are as good as those in the pictures get on with making stuff an don't worry about what others think. Success is a drawer that holds together.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#12

Speaking of drawers that hold together.....

Barry Irby

I went to my 50 year High School reunion Saturday. To give you an idea of the class size, I was 9th in my class and did not make the upper quarter. My BFF was there and we worked our way through college building kitchen cabinets. He stayed in the cabinet business. "We" made hundreds of drawers. He has made thousands. Almost all of them plywood boxes stapled together with one of those new fangled air powered 1/4" crown staplers. In fifty years he has done some kitchens over two or three times in the small town we came from. He has never had a call back or complaint about a drawer failure.

So a drawer that is slightly better than that will hold your socks for a long time.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#13

Re: No idea why they are rotated.

TM Stock

Apps like NoIMGdata for Mac can kill the metadata, but a quick pull into a photo editing program and a rotation and save will reset the orientation.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#14

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Hank Knight

Bill, why are you on a tirade about dovetails? You seem to be focused on saving time in the construction process. Why? Are you running a production shop? Your output, compared to mine would indicate that you are. ;) I do this for a hobby. I don't care if it takes me a year to complete a project, which it often does, as long as I'm happy with the end result. I like to make "flauntable dovetails." They give me a great deal of satisfaction and a sense of accomplishment, even though almost no one opens my drawers to look or comments on them. I was not intimidated by the fear that someone might criticize my dovetails. I like the look of well made, hand cut dovetails, so I just dug in and learned how to do it. I tossed my Leigh jig when I was satisfied that I had the process down pretty well and I've not looked back. Hand cutting them is faster, even if I take my time to make them well. (I kept my small 12" Leigh jig in the unlikely event that I decide to redo our kitchen and need to make a bunch of drawers.)

Finishing is my weakness. I like the making much more than the finishing. I don't take finishing shortcuts; I spend the time to try to do a good job, but I don't enjoy it. I admire your finishing results. I need to suck it up and learn the techniques that produce the kind of finishes you produce.

By the way, I agree that one's work should be judged with a holistic view, taking into account all of the elements: design, materials selection, construction technique and finish. Interestingly, of all of these, a poor finish can wreck the end result faster than any others.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#15

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I thought I made it obvious.

There are two polar views to *publically* discussing dovetails. Look how skilled I am at making flauntable dovetails is one extreme. The other is, this is a useful joint I am going to encourage you to incorporate into your work. My public discussions tend in the direction of encouraging beginners to use the joint. What one does privately in their shop for their satisfaction is not part of this discussion.

The amature woodworking community has become so focused on dovetail quality as a measure of a woodworker's worth that beginners are reluctant to use hand cut dovetails. I would be delighted to never hear mention of them. The result might have been that Barry and others would have bought a dovetail saw instead of a jig.

When I taught dovetail classes everyone was fretting over gaps and overcuts when in fact any of the joints would have held a drawer together. There is a good chance that few that took the classes ever used dovetails for fear of not measuring up to the dovetail perfectionists that provide our club programs and videos.

To that end I strive to illustrate functional dovetails, preferably made by "antique woodworkers" in the hope that beginners will say, "I can do that", and then be able to take advantage of this handy joint.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#16

There's a blog 'The Furniture Record'

Chuck Nickerson

That has organized hundreds of photos, many of them dovetails.

That's probably the site you remember.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#17

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Barry Irby

I don't understand either.

I agree that making the DT for one drawer is probably faster if you are proficient in doing them by hand. But If you have to do 18 as I did for these two chests, I can't imagine doing the faster that a Leigh jig. And if you don't really care about the appearance why not use the jig? I'm stuck.

I just bought the 3M Accuspray gun. Has disposable interchangeable tip and cup liners. I am making friends with it. Beginning to like it.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#18

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Hank Knight

Your point about encouraging beginners to learn to cut dovetails by hand is well taken. If they are so terrified of having their work criticized that they won't try it, they're stuck. My point is that the learning curve doesn't stop once one learns to stick two boards together; it may as well include improving one's technique to the point that one can produce dovetails that will stand scrutiny of the woodworking club tyrants. (BTW, club tyrants are the reason I've never participated in my local woodworking club.) Some pieces of furniture have dovetail joinery that shows. The desk I'm working on is one such piece. The top and the sides are joined with half blind dovetails that are clearly visible from the top of the piece. If all I knew how to do was hack out a set of dovetails to stick a drawer together, I would be terrified at the thought of taking a saw and a chisel to the prettiest walnut boards I've ever seen. Instead, I'm confident of my ability to cut attractive, well fitting dovetails and I'm looking forward to the task.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#19

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Hank Knight

Barry, I agree that a jig has it's place. Dovetailing a number of drawers is probably there one that comes most quickly to mind. I saved my small Leigh jig for that very purpose. But, if you're like me, learning to operate the Leigh jig, and others I suppose, is not an intuitive task. I found that I used the jig so little that I had to go back and relearn the procedure every time I hauled it out. If you're cutting a hundred dovetails, that exercise is probably worth the time. If you're building two drawers or a case with relatively few, hand cutting is much faster. Once you learn how to do it, the muscle memory stays with you and you don't need to relearn it. I do occasionally do a few practice saw cuts first if I haven't cut any dovetails in a while, but it's a quick 5 minutes and I'm ready to go.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#20

Re: Speaking of drawers that hold together.....

Tony-Memphis

You know, the cabinets in my house are built just like that. My wife is 4'11" and 88 lbs, but she is terribly hard on things. After 19 years, all of our drawer boxes are good and solid. Even the cheap slides (those whit ones with the nylon wheels" are holding up.

Wall switches, on the other hand, I've replaced several (I used the 20 amp versions now - she doesn't like those!).

Tony

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#21

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

jesse cloud

The guy who taught me how to do dovetails, Bob Mays, cuts beautiful dovetails very rapidly. Even he said that if he were doing kitchen cabinets he would pull out a jig.

He never put down anyone's poorly made dovetails, only suggested what to do to improve them. His philosophy seemed to be that most people need to make a lot of mediocre dovetails before they can make fine woodworking dovetails. Mine still aren't fine woodworking level, but I think I would be letting Bob down if I didn't try to make each one the best I could.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#22

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

On wall switches...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Get commercial grade wall switches. They'll be a few bucks instead of $0.40, but you can tell the difference because they have a much more distinct snap when you throw the switch--this reduces internal arcing and premature failure.

Jason

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#23

Re: On wall switches... another option

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

If you can find them, the mercury light switches last almost forever, can't remember what I paid for the one in my Kitchen. I installed it over 40 years ago, it is switching a chandelier with 8 bulbs, for 30+ years these were 60 watt bulbs for a total of 480 watts! A couple of years ago I changed all the bulbs to LED so now it only uses less than 40 watt! It is a "silent" switch with no "snap". I remember when I purchased it there was a lifetime warranty. Doubt if I would try to return it if it did fail, but there is no sign of failure yet. It is the most used switch in the house.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#24

Re: drawer lube and a dovetail editorial

Brian Holcombe

I just built 15 drawers for a kitchen and did so by hand.

It's a lot of work but I can use 3/8" drawer sides rather than 3/4" required by a dovetail jig due to the radius it makes on the inside of the tails.

Re: Here's a picture, I hope

#25

Re: On wall switches... another option

Barry Irby

When I was kid I tried to use a mercury wall switch in the horizontal position. Did not work at all. Had to go back to the old fashioned snap kind. I am guessing the little glob of mercury was out of position.