I have bought a Domino 500 off Craigs List. It was a 100 miles away in Northern VA so I had my son buy it and he will be delivering it in about ten days. So I am watching videos and practicing in my mind.
I purchased about a thousand pieces of stock that are 3/8" thick and 7/8" wide and 16" long with radiused edges. I have cobbled together a loose tenon setup and they work very well. I literally have several lifetimes worth.
What I was wondering is, since the Domino cutter is 10mm which is 0.393701" and 3/8" is 0.375", could I have somebody custom grind a bit down to 3/8"? Who would do that?
$95 for the cutter? Wow! I guess they have to grind down the flute a little bit as well. And low production, but it is sticker shock for me and I have a Domino. Guess I'd better look up Festool price on a replacement to put it into perspective.
Sorry for the wild goose chase. I thought I had seen Imperial cutters on the Seneca website in the past. Maybe they have been discontinued. Consider that the stock cutters for the DF500 run about $44 each, and you would need to find a machinist to custom mill one of them for you, and the grind is a little complex.
I suppose you could run your stock through a belt sander and reduce them to 8 mm or 6 mm, but you would still probably want to touch up the radiused corners, and impress some channels for hydraulic glue release.
The Domino tenons themselves are not that expensive, especially when you consider the time it takes to set up most alternate loose tenon joinery machines, and execute a few joints for a small project.
One particular application for which I use the Domino is cutting mortises for shelf pins. 5 mm Domino tenons are substantially less expensive than shelf pins, and at least for all except the high end applications requiring brass pins and inserts, are totally acceptable, aesthetically and structurally.
I've made miles of loose tenon stock for my Multi-Router. I just chamfer the sides instead of radius. It fits the same, but allows any excess glue to flow out.
I have to admit I am fascinated and baffled by Festool and the domino in particular. the entire Festool concept of work is somewhat strange to me. It seems they are trying to completely avoid a traditional workshop. OTOH, I have spent most of my life with a traditional workshop and learned the methods associated with it.
My packrat (cheap) gene kicked when I considered using my existing stock or buying new ones. Actually, the Festool ones don't seem terribly expensive and look like they will be a joy to use.
Like I said earlier, I've made miles of loose tenons. I fit them like I would fit a real tenon. Just a nice snug sliding fit with glue on it. Maybe just the slightest hammer tap to set the loose tenon to the bottom. You don't get that with the Domino. They are tight on the ends and quite snug on the thickness. A hammer seems to be a necessity. I sand off the small line of wood on the ends if they are just too tight. When I get done with the big kit of Dominos, I'll go back to making my own.
As to your comments about traditional work Barry. I've built two types of furniture and cabinetry over my 4 decades of woodworking. Both are high quality, but I would call one style museum quality, and the other just quality. An example was two wardrobes I kicked out for my kids. I had 4 kitchen cabinet doors left over from a running change to a kitchen I was doing at my business. I designed around those doors, and made the rest of the wardrobes from plywood with hardwood edge banding. Even made 1/2" plywood drawers with small biscuits for the joinery, and hung them on full extension glides. Really, they were just giant frameless cabinets with a crown and base moldings. Guess what, both of those wardrobes are 30 years old and look like the day I built them. There is a limit to changing historical methods of course. An example is when a certain TV woodworker using the shotgun pattern of Kreg Jig screws with no glue. But, he often mentions his work is perfect, so who am I to suggest he is not!
to buy their wood in more plastic boxes. Especially when I've got piles of shorts to make tenons.
1. Plane to the thickness of your cutter
2. Cut to the width of your slot
3. Round-over the 4 edges
4. Cut to length
Since I got a 700 w/12mm cutter a couple of passes of 5/8 stock gets me to 12mm, rip to a fat 1", then edge with a 1/4" round-over bit and not only have a I saved the price of Festool tenons but I've also rescued previous depositees from the firewood kindling pile. Made 12' of tenon stock this morning and took me all of 20 minutes. If I want to get fancy, I can leave the stock at 13mm and then run it through the performax with 36 grit to give me 12mm and great glue surface.
It's European, not American. When you take over an apartment or a house in Western Europe, the kitchen is bare to the walls--no cabinets, no appliances, no lighting, no kitchen sink--the previous tenant or owner took it all with them. The cabinetmaker comes in with his stacks of Festools in Systainers on CTs and Syscarts, an MFT, and a stack of plywood, and builds your kitchen on the spot. While he's working, he'd better not make any dust, or the hausfrau will be most unpleased. (If you don't want a custom kitchen, Ikea will sell you flat pack cabinets, and you can assemble them yourself, or hire someone to do it for you.)
Barry, .020" isn't too fat a glue line for epoxy, and certainly if you thicken it a little with colloidal silica to keep it from sagging out if the joint is vertical, and the formula is slow to kick.
I think about the craftsmen who were making the furniture that is now antique. I am thinking excellent construction techniques made for sturdy furniture that was able to survive. Excellent style made it attractive enough that people cared enough to allow it to survive. I think part of what we should learn from "the old People" is the "engineering" and understanding of wood movement and other characteristics. I also think they were modernizing their tools as fast as they could. And they may have had apprentices (that I don't have) to do the grunt work. Perhaps I can think of my Festools as my apprentices.
And I have a ton of offcuts to make tenons out of.
I bet a guy with a stack of plywood is a pretty rare site. Nobillia says they build 535,000 kitchens a year in Germany. It sure would be tough to compete with that kind of production capacity!
Its the other way around. I have about a thousand pieces of 3/8" by 7/8" by 16" long with radiused edges to make into Dominoes. I suppose its may to too thick for 3/4" construction stock. ???? It would be easy to reduce it to 8mm. Would that be better? I have a Perfomax. I could reduce it with coarse sandpaper as mark suggested.
I am just brainstorming, fishing for advice for those of you with actual experience with the Domino While I wait for it to show up so I can hit the ground running.
I actually thought about that Keith. Can you mix it in little dabs good for a few joints? I like being able to do one or two. Maybe the West system with the Pumps?
The point of a Domino is conveniece. I fail to see the point of making tenon material for a Domino if it is a hassle and time consuming.
I would rather build furniture using traditional joinery. Not only does it give me a better feeling, but I think that it is stronger and more easily repaired when using the right glue (hide glue). Using epoxy to fill gaps because the loose tenons do not fit exactly seems to be heading in the wrong direction.
I have a Domino 500, and used it for my recent kitchen build. That is where a machine like this has relevance for me. A couple of packs of Dominos is cheap in the contect of this build, and their purchase frees me up to focus on more urgent activities.
The other point is that one will need different sizes of Domino to meet different needs. Small 4mm dominos may be used like biscuits to align panels. The one third tenon rule suggests that 6mm and 10mm dominos are more likely to be used in most builds.
Sorry, been out in the sun a little too long I guess...
8mm would be cool. There is an 8mm cutter.
8 mm is a little fat for 3/4 stock, but I have done that many times and it hasn't failed ever. 8 is spot on for 1 inch stock. Two 8's are spot on for two inch stock like table legs.
And if buying from Festool gives you the willies, CMT makes a cheaper one.
For mixing very small batches (smaller than one pump full) i use one of two methods: either I measure by weight with a small digital gram scale or by volume with these measuring cups:
I usually use the same measuring cups on the gram scale (accurate to 0.1 gram) when I'm measuring by weight. For maximum strength with West System, it is important to measure the resin/hardener ratio accurately.
I think using 3/8" tenons in 3/4" stock is completely reasonable. In fact, I never understood the 1/3:1/3:1/3 rule of thumb. 1/4:1/2:1/4 makes a lot more sense from a structural point of view. That's why I-beams are stronger and lighter than the same amount of iron formed into a square solid rod. I sometimes wonder if the "rule of thirds" is just easier to remember for those with minimal practice with fractions and no education in strength of materials.
Yes, I mix small batches all the time. The epoxy I keep on hand all the time is a 1-1 ratio, and is very forgiving if it's off a little, will still kick, unlike some of the others. It also is about half the price. I hated those pumps. If the resin was cool it thickens and sometimes a bubble would pull in, rather than move up the tube. After 6-8 pumps, a bubble throws the ratio for all the rest.
I keep clear Solo type cups in 2 oz 8 oz and 16oz sizes in the shelves where I keep all the other epoxy supplies. The small ones are usually used to measure into the others. IF it is a really small project, I may just pour a 1/2 into the smallest cups then pour one into the other to mix. It is more common for my larger projects to set two of the 2oz cups side by side, then pour the same amount of resin and hardner in each cup or twice for 8 oz into a 16 oz cup. Unless it is pretty warm, I go to the sink to mix while the cup is tilted 45º while the hot water is flowing over the outside of the cup. Once I feel a little warmth in the mix, I pour in about an equal amount of silica, then mix it. This amount will be about as thick as latex paint, which is about where I like if for applying with a roller for veneering or bent laminates.
For MT joints, I may mix it as thick as catsup or mayo. If I've mixed it to where it doesn't drip off the mixing stick, on a small project, I just use the mixing stick to spread it into the mortise and onto the tenon. As the project gets larger, I may pour it onto scraps of mdf or ply, then scrape it up from there. Keeping it shallow prevents the heat from building too quickly.
After buttering all the joints, assembly is a dream, compared to other glues that want to grab before joints are all the way home. There isn't any rush, because the glue won't be cured for several hours, plus as long as it is still in a plastic state, it can still be moved without destroying the bond. Most other glue is toast if you try to move parts after the cure starts.
As I mentioned earlier, epoxy likes a fat joint, which the .020" is only .010" on each side. It could be ten times that wide and still be good, if you aligned everything well . The mixed epoxy is stronger than the wood it's surrounded by, so if your mechanical properties or proportions are good, then you'll still have a strong joint.
I have also come to distrust the West pumps. If I'm mixing a batch that is large enough to require them, I pump the components into separate containers, and then mix them after completing the measurements. If I get an air bubble from one pump, I just pour that component back into the can and start over. My experience with air bubbles is that they are probably caused by the component sitting in the pump too long and flowing back down into the can due to a slow leak in the seals.