Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Air line options for the shop?

Posts

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#26

Re: Air line options for the shop?

John K Jordan

>>>I always turn the compressor off when not being used. That prevents the compressor from running continuously if a flex line should ever fail.

Since my compressor is not in the shop but in a closet for noise abatement, I mounted a disconnect switch outside the closet in the main shop to make it easy to turn off the compressor. The switch is rated for a 5 hp motor.

I also put all the controls outside the closet where I can get to them easier: a pressure gauge, water trap, dryers, regulator, and shutoff valves to the various lines.


Also, in my research on running air lines in a building I came across the recommendation to make a big loop with the line with drops off the loop where needed. This will not only increase the volume but will allow a higher supply when needed since the air can come from both directions AND the drops furthest from the compressor are less likely to be starved.

JKJ

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#27

Dry air

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The most important step in keeping condensate out of your air lines and tools is to keep your tank properly drained of condensation.

I've had, used, and highly recommend the pressure activated drain sold by McMaster-Car

https://www.mcmaster.com/#standard-moisture-removers/=17wecgi

If the direct link doesn't work, it's part No. 4919K13 on the McMaster website.

This replaces the funky twist valve on the tank and automatically opens the bottom drain on your receiver after a pressure drop of 20psi for several seconds. Once a year I remove, clean, lube, and reinstall it.

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#28

I'd disagree

Dick Coers

That automatic drain will make your tank last longer, but weather conditions and air temp in the tank are the biggest factor in moisture in the lines. High humidity and high compressed air temp let the air in the lines hold more moisture. Big commercial shops use an air drier, which cools the air, and lets the moisture drop out. I'd say it is fairly difficult to get the moisture in the bottom of the tank, to become atomized and get back into the lines. Now if you are talking about the tank being full enough to get to the air exit port, then there will definitely be an issue. I'd say the proof is in the color of the water coming out of an air hose. The water in the bottom of my tanks has always had a rusty color to it. I've never seen rusty colored water come out of a hose, or collect in my remote filters.

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#29

Re: I'd disagree

John K Jordan

>>>...I'd say it is fairly difficult to get the moisture in the bottom of the tank, to become atomized and get back into the lines. ...I'd say the proof is in the color of the water coming out of an air hose. I've never seen rusty colored water come out of a hose, or collect in my remote filters.

I agree may be fairly difficult, but the rusty water logic seems flawed to me. Unless, as you say, the water level pooled in the tank is high enough to reach the tank outlet, particulates will stay in the liquid water while under some conditions some of the water molecules in that rusty water could go into the hot air and out the lines. Think of how a distiller works. Of course with an air compressor this direction of moisture movement is more likely during periods of repeated compressor cycling when the temperature in the tank remains high and when ambient humidity at the inlet is very low.

Although it is universally acknowledged the most important reason to drain the water from the tank is to slow down internal tank corrosion and minimize the chance of death by rupture, from my research I believe it will also help with the moisture problem.

For example, from a Quincy article on keeping water out of air lines:

The first stage of keeping moisture out of your air lines is to drain your air compressor tank frequently.

http://www.quincycompressor.com/the-best-ways-to-dry-compressed-air/

I bought an electrical tank drain valve activated periodically by a timer. I use a dual moisture trap in my lines, the first a gravity trap and the second a centrifugal trap. Following these I installed a desiccant dryer. This may be overkill for some shops but a plasma cutter really likes dry air.

(Simple flow-through desiccant dryers are cheap compared with refrigeration or twin tower dryers, but they do require changing the desiccant occasionally.)

I have never seen one drop of water coming from a hose or from the trap on any of my outlets.

JKJ

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#30

Agree

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

As I said, only the first step.

In a high use system where the compressor is constantly recycling against continuous demand, far more ambient moisture is carried over into the lines. For that kind of system, a typical commercial/industrial situation, in-line refrigerant driers and spin traps are required to condense and remove the water vapor from the air stream.

But in a home shop situation where demand on the stored volume is sporadic, and air-powered tool use is rare, more water will condense into the receiver between cycles. Such a small system can benefit from a dry(er) tank, especially when it's not practical (let alone economical) to install a powered line drier that can cost as much or more than the compressor. In a situation such as most on this board may have, a dry tank and a spin dryer are sufficient to provide reasonably dry air. I never get water (or 'fog') coming out of my hoses either. During the humid Summer I'll open my drip-leg drains and maybe get a teaspoon of condensate once a month or so.

A benefit of a copper piping system not mentioned above is that the lines act as a condenser to pull water from the air stream and channel it to the drip legs.

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#31

You guys are sharing some good info, but I'll add

Keith Newton

Even if you have gotten all the air out of your supply line, the cooling effect at the tip of your blower or spray tip pulls the ambient air around the tip into the stream. If there is a high enough humidity, there can be condensation where tiny droplets of moisture form and get pulled into this cool low pressure zone. The closer this ambient air is to the dew point, the easier it is to occur, and keep in mind that the warmer the air, more moisture it can hold.

I know this is not exactly on the topic of this thread, but recall struggling against this dilemma I wish I'd know sooner when it finally dawned on me that drying the air supplied is only part of the equation.

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#32

Re: Agree

John K Jordan

>>>A benefit of a copper piping system not mentioned above is that the lines act as a condenser to pull water from the air stream and channel it to the drip legs.

For those of us who have the shop plumbed with plastic pipe, the copper pipe is perfect for the first 20' for the condensation reason.

The "experts" recommend putting the dryers 20' or more down the line from the compressor to allow condensation to prevent just blowing moist air through a trap or centrifugal dryer. I have plastic pipe for this initial section now but my plan is to replace it with copper, spiraling down from the ceiling in my compressor closet to the trap for drainage.

JKJ

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#33

Down there in Tennessee

Dick Coers

Isn't it really easy to get a 20' spiral coil of copper tubing back up in the hills?

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#34

yousta bin that mighta gotcha shot at


Re: Air line options for the shop?

#35

Re: Down there in Tennessee

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Hear tell dem revinoors up and busticated most alla dos curls . . . good shiners bin domisticated wit labels annol

:D

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#36

Had them down in LA too,

Keith Newton

LA, as in Lower Arkansas. Back when I was a teen, out squirrel hunting, I found a whisky still. I'm lucky I didn't get shot, since I got there before daylight, and had worked my way upstream of the little creek for about a mile, then crossed over it and back down the other side.

Since I wasn't backtracking, I went a little past where I'd entered the woods. On the way back toward the truck, as I was approaching the site, I could smell it, but didn't realize what it was, so just walked right into the middle of a sort of circle of 7 - 55 gallon drums. A couple were empty, and the others were full of fluid with the mash floating on top. I must have been there a minute or two before I looked right at the still when the lightbulb flashed on, and to my delight I proclaimed to myself, OH this is a whisky still!!!!!, followed instantly by a strong feeling that someone out in the woods nearby had me in their gun-sites. I went from standing tall, to tucking my tail as I skedaddled out of there.

Re: Air line options for the shop?

#37

Re: Y'all quieten down, I hear a banjo...


Re: Air line options for the shop?

#38

Paddle Faster!!


Re: Air line options for the shop?

#39

Another option

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I needed a 20 run and it was going to have several bends. I opted to use 1/2" id flexible air hose. Installation was shall we say trivial! It has lasted 24 years.