I'd like to run some air line across the shop and take it thru an exterior wall to provide a snap-in connection to my sanding station outside. I don't use this air to spray any finishes.
I've seen droopy flex air line stuff and whereas I wouldn't be pleased by that look perhaps other factors recommend it.
Water apparently does accumulate in air lines over time, and probably wouldn't be much better for your sander than it is for spraying. Water could accumulate in "droopy" runs. You might consider hard lines that slope to water drains.
Copper needs to be soldered with silver-bearing solder for proper seal. Some will tell you that type "M" exceeds the pressure limit on your compressor but I find the quality of modern type M to be questionable. I use type L.
Black iron pipe is the industry standard standard but is the hardest to run as all joints must be cut, threaded, and doped to maintain seal.
Air hose will have those droops your don't want but it's easy to run and make joints with barbed fittings and a compression tool.
DO NOT, EVER consider using plastic (PVC/CPVC) pipe. It is dangerous and can fail without warning sending razor sharp shrapnel flying. People have died or been seriously injured by this stuff. It's prohibited by OSHA regs for this reason.
Material choices vs. engineering choices... *LINK*
John in NM
Schedule 40 PVC is rated for working pressures well over the running pressure of even 2 stage compressors (see reference linked), and yet there still are instances were it has failed, causing injury.
The places I have seen PVC fail in use for compressed air is where it is exposed to direct sunlight. After a few years the plastic becomes very weak and prone to failure. I've seen both spontaneous failures and impact failures of sun damaged pipe.
Does that mean it's the perfect material for air line? No, its one of the worst.
But it is not a disaster waiting to happen if it is properly installed - shielded from UV degradation and impact damage. The need to take measures like this (and others) are the reason I say its one of the worst, and copper one of the best.
I don't recommend anyone use it, but the truth remains that in a properly engineered system, it will work indefinitely at the pressures we use.
As most will source PVC from the BORG, and given how materials may be handled from factory through X-number of warehouses, let alone items purchased and then returned by retail customers, the structural integrity of BORG PVC is open to serious question from hits, bruises, or partial fractures not readily apparent, let alone looked-for by a casual purchaser. For water, it's fine as pressurized water does not store energy like pressurized air so a failed pipe will just squirt water rather than explode into shards.
As I said, I don't recommend using it as one has to do a lot more work to ensure it's a viable system. However I don't think the case for extreme danger can be made if it is required that it be based on actual data rather than rules of thumb.
Much of the reason is taking the physical properties of PVC into account - at reasonable ambient temperatures (say above 40 F), it is not especially brittle unless it is degraded by UV or some other obvious no-no. The other reason is the huge disparity in working pressures and burst pressures (which were arrived at through testing to failure) and the typical pressure of a compressed air system.
The reality is that the stuff can work fine when one takes the effort to avoid it's flaws. These discussions are far more useful when based on data and reality.
It would seem the droopy flex air line stuff is the best option. If you accept that, then you need to look at why you do not want to use it. Your concern is appearance, a valid concern. But do not forget you are woodworker. I can make a support for all of the horizontal lines that might droop to keep them straight. Maybe a dado in a 1X2. Just put the 1X2 where you want to support the line and then insert the tubing in the dado. This will even help protect the line. Probably a number of other options for moldings that could cover the line, keep it straight and look nice.
I'll leave to OSHA. It doesn't issue prohibition rules based upon a few anecdotal stories. I have, however, seen the result of a PVC air line failure in a local guy's garage. Fortunately he was not in the space when the line let go. Splinters went completely through the sheet rock on the opposite wall 24' away.
is most important for condensation drainage. Dips in flex line will tend to collect condensate so that the delivered air has more moisture content. That gets tough on air tools and messes with spray finishing (if the OP wants to do them later). Lines should run slightly down-hill and have one or more drain legs installed to keep the lines as dry as possible. This is even more important with oil-lubed compressors.
No, OSHA does not base rules on anecdotes, but neither do the always base them on data. From what I've seen in my working life, they base rules on the assumption of lowest common denominator foolish behavior as often as on data & safety margins. OSHA rules are made to fit all situations, so they fit none particularly well - they are the huge baggy coveralls of regulation.
OTOH, I just thought of a point that works for your argument - cooling due to rapid pressure drop (say from running a sander rather than a nail gun). That could easily get PVC into a much lower and dangerous range of failure pressures. I would bet that could account for some of those failures.
Pex is easy to run and doesn't require sweating fittings like copper. I have never heard any reasons why not. It can handle the pressure. Anybody?---Jack
I installed the 1/2" RapidAir sustem bought from Northern Tool - it uses a flexible plastic tubing. They also sell a better 3/4" system but it was too expensive for me.
I put 8 outlets in various places in the shop and outside. One is connected to a Goodyear reel and delivers plenty enough air to run air tools such as 1/2" impact wrench, grinders, sanders, etc. I have air near the lathe, in the weld shop, etc. Connections are push-on. No leaks. I didn't worry about droop since all tubing is in the walls and above the ceiling. An enterprising person could run some wood strips around the shop and rest the tubing on the top of the strips for a nice straight installation, holding the tubing in place with the plastic clips.
You should never get water anywhere in the line if you do a few things. One, put the water separator and/or desiccant dryer 25' or so from the air compressor to allow the air to cool. Make this run go straight up from the tank the slope down the rest of the way. Put a water trap at the end. (I made one from brass tubing and a valve) Put a water separator and/or a decissant dryer next in the line. I used both. The water separator will sling any liquid water out of the air stream and it will collect in the bottom to be purged occasionally. A desiccant dryer will suck any remaining water out of the air. Next I put a regulator and valves to different lines in the shop.
The air at this point is very dry, dry enough for my plasma cutter which really wants dry air. Each RapidAir outlet has a purge valve for any water that gets that far but I've never found a single drop at any of them. Another important thing is to drain the condensed water from the bottom of the tank regularly. The manufacturers say to do this every day.
A lot of people use PVC pipe. After reading some accident reports I don't want to use PVC pipe for compressed air regardless of wall thickness. I understand it can become brittle with age. At one time I worked in pressure vessel inspection and testing. Unlike a non-compressible fluid such as water under high pressure, the force from suddenly released compressed is tremendous. I'd hate for the surgeons to be picking PVC shards out of my face and eyes.
I have used black iron and galvanized iron pipe before. Some people don't like it since any moisture inside can cause rust which can move through the lines.
John, what kind off through-wall fittings did you use? I've been looking for a flush mount push fitting, but I don't know if such a beast exists. I haven't been able to find one.
That's all quite helpful. I see the flexible stuff has an aluminum core, and is stiff enough that fellows complain about trying to straighten it from its shipped coil. The maxline version suggested by John Lucas seems like a good choice for my shop. I need to figure out what fittings I should use to penetrate an ext. wall with a brick veneer, and then have an easy connection on the exterior. Maybe use a floor flange? Guess I can contact the WI manufacturer.
My compressor is in the garage. I've used flex lines for years through the ceiling to the workshop. It's very convenient. I always turn the compressor off when not being used. That prevents the compressor from running continuously if a flex line should ever fail. It's never happened but I like to be on the safe side. The large tank on my compressor insures that I always have air instantly whether the compressor is turned on or off.
Whenever we will be away for more than a few hours, I hit the kill switch on my compressor, and I never keep air hoses fully pressurized; each hose reel has an upstream cut-off.
I know a certain website owner who lost his entire shop when his compressor's unloader valve stuck open and the electric power panel exploded from the big compressor's continuous running power draw.
1) Make your main line as large as you can afford. It creates a lot of volume. Shop like yours? At least 3/4".
2) Drains in the low spots at the end of the run. Watch for bellies during installation. This will hold water and muck up any air lines down stream.
3) Tap UP off the main line, then 90 or 180 turn down to your individual lines. Any moisture in the main won't automatically drain into your drops then.
>>>what kind off through-wall fittings did you use? I've been looking for a flush mount push fitting, but I don't know if such a beast exists. I haven't been able to find one.
I used these air outlets that RapidAir includes in their kit (and sell separately). It mounts on the wall and the air can come in from the back or from the top. If from the back, you use one of the push-in connectors with the plastic pipe - the pipe is flexible so I leave a few inches sticking through the wall, make the connection then push the aluminum block against the wall and fasten it down.
It does not come with the quick connect coupler. BTW, the type they show in this picture requires using both hands to make the connection. I use the type that allows one-handed connection (Home Depot, etc)
The valve on the bottom is intended to drain any moisture that collects at the outlet. As mentioned earlier, with good dryers there is never moisture in the lines.