Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Posts

Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#1

Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The question was posed on the Hand Tool Forum but I would like to start a discussion of the answer here where there are more finishers. Derek is building a table with a maple apron and legs, and walnut top. He anticipated finishing the top with oil. However, he has no experience finishing walnut and asked for suggestions

I have been finishing walnut for many years. I have experience with many finishes and how they change after many years. Walnut finishes fall into two general categories- formal and informal. General categories of finish are- oil, varnish, lacquer, shellac, waterborne. The long term problem with walnut is that it bleaches over time. In the extreme, the maple undercarriage and the walnut top will become almost the same color unless something is done to maintain the walnut color. With the grain filled and a rubbed out gloss finish walnut takes on an elegant formal appearance. With a dull close- to- the- wood finish, walnut looks good in an informal environment (think Danish furniture, which is varnished properly, not oiled).

Walnut benefits from a finish that yellows some with age. A reddish shellac is also beneficial to the final result. Personally, I like a burnt umber pigment oil stain followed by varnish or shellac.

Oil In the strict sense there are only two pure oils to consider-Tung and Linseed. Both are similar plant oils that slowly react with oxygen to form a cross linked polymer film. They each darken walnut upon application, and importantly, this dark color seems to be resistant to bleaching. I have gun stocks over 50 years old that are essentially the color they were when first finished. They penetrate. They cure slowly. They look pleasing upon application, then become less so as the oil penetrates and cures. However, numerous coats applied over the course of weeks results in a cured film building on the wood surface. At this point the finish begins to look like a close-to-the wood varnished finish, but without the durability.

Modified Oil Lots of “wipe-on” products called “oil” are actually formulated finishes with an oil component. They build quicker than oil and cure quicker. The end result looks like a multicoated pure oil finish. They may or may not be resistant to bleaching.

Varnish, wipe-on or otherwise These products are modified oils with other synthetic resins. They build quickly with 2-3 coats being sufficient. They tend to be more durable and cure quickly. The build (depth) of the final finish can be controlled by thinning. The ”plastic” look some complain about is the result of a too thick application, and not some inherent property of the finish. The brush-on products are typically sold too viscous to provide a close to the wood finish that levels well upon application. Thinning overcomes these deficiencies. The wipe-on products, reviewed by Fine Woodworking, are easy to apply and wind up looking as good as a brushed on product. An initial coat of cured oil to provide color and depth, followed by a varnish, shellac or lacquer is an attractive finish. These finishes provide more protection than just oil.

Shellac I don’t have experience with just a shellac finish on walnut. I don’t know if it will bleach. But garnet shellac over cured oil, or an oil stain, is an exceptionally attractive finish.

Lacquer Lacquer on walnut looks good in the short term but will bleach to a yellowish finish that looks dead and unattractive. However, if something is done to preserve the color-oil or stain- sprayed lacquer is a quicker to apply finish than varnish.

Waterborne- I have no experience with waterborne on walnut.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#2

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Barry Irby

Thank you for starting this.....

I would like to see you/us reduce this to a fairly straight forward simple low tech solution. Most of us don't have a spray booth any many of us don't have spray equipment. I have spray equipment but no booth and no room for one.

Personally I find it exasperating that the manufacturers of these products keep changing the contents of the cans and keep changing the labels and meanings of the words. I am not knowledgeable enough to read the MSDS and grasp what it means. I know some of this is driven by hopefully well intentioned politicians trying to save the environment by reducing VOC's. OTOH I suspect those of us finishing handmade furniture have little or no impact on the environment regardless of what we use.

I'm thinking of Tung oil that has no tung oil in it. Friend of mine bought a piece of fried chicken and asked for honey. The honey packet had honey flavored syrup with NO honey. High Fructose Corn syrup and flavorings. At least the chicken was some kind of bird.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#3

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Hank Knight

Bill,

Do any of the "modern" finishes have additives that protect against UV bleaching?

Hank

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#4

3-Play

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Over the years my finish recipe for walnut has evolved a bit, mostly to take advantage of new finishes becoming available.

Like you, I will start with an oil-based product. Here my choice is Waterlox Red-can Sealer. Depending on the piece I may add a bit of pigment, but the oil is primary to 'pop' the grain as well as to add some UV resistance.

Next is dewaxed shellac usually in a 1 lb. mix applied by mini-gun. I used to use Garnet or Dark Garnet but I discontinued them because of their limited shelf-life even in dry flake form. I now use either Ultra Pale or Super Blond. This seals the oil and provides the needed "tie" for the top coat's adhesion. If the oil base is not pigmented, I may use the shellac with dye added to tone parts of the wood for more harmony in the color. The shellac also gives the final a real kick for visual depth because the top coat is applied to a more reflective surface. The shellac layer must be kept thin if a waterborne top coat is used to prevent cold-checking.

Last is waterborne top coats. I started using Target's waterbornes years ago because of their 100% burn-in capability. I have tried others, but have now settled on General Finishes' Enduro line. These take 3 coats which I apply with HVLP, and they level so well that most all my final surfaces are left "off the gun" so I put away most of the rubbing-out stuff.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#5

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

CJ in MPLS

Garnet shellac and wax is a great finish on a walnut piece. Extremely easy to apply and very cheap. It is however, subject to wet dog damage. The finish is repairable quite easily, if one actually gets around to it. Luckily I have a strong preference for the kind of aging a piece gets in normal use so this kind of thing does not bother me over much.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#6

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't know. In any case they don't last forever.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#7

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Don Stephan

Very interesting that the original post in this thread talks of multiple coats of oil to build a thin film. Too often people refuse to acknowledge that only the first one or two applications of oil finishes are able to penetrate into the wood, and that additional ones begin to build on the surface. "Close to the wood" seems a better category descriptive than "oil" in that it recognizes a slow build with added applications.

The observation that oil finished gunstocks retain a dark color over time is helpful. Has anyone kept such walnut exposed to similar lighting as tabletops that have bleached over time, or are gunstocks typically kept where light exposure is minimal?

I think it was either a manufacturer of finishes or a well respected writer on finishing that answered my question by saying UV protection is achieved by an additive that is broken down by UV light, so that the protection is not permanent.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#8

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

As far as gathering information, Gunstock's were, and some still are, often made of Walnut. Today many of these are kept in dark areas IE: Gun safes. But years ago, in my youth most were either displayed in glass fronted "Gun Cabinets" or left in an area quickly accessible to the owner for protection for his animals (mostly foul) from predators. I have seen many of these firearms, including several I own. Other than a few very expensive custom firearms, most of the ones I have owned and observed were coated with BLO, a practice I continue on many pieces today.

I did/do not observe excess bleaching, although it is impossible to gage as I do not have unexposed examples to compare. In any event the wood stocks still have an attractive color. Almost all of the people, including myself, that maintained their firearms in good condition applied many coats of BLO to the wood of their firearms often, usually every time they were used for hunting. Some of mine had many coats which I rubbed on with my bare hands, allowed to set a few minutes then wiped off.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#9

A non traditional approach with traditional looks

Robin Corell in Atascadero

the finish I have been using on walnut for 6 or 7 years now is one that will probably make most people here think I'm crazy. I had done up several finish samples for a client and since they were just samples I didn't worry about what was the proper way to do them. I have often combined finishes, something over the top of oil. Oil for popping the figure and something else for wear. I would normally let the oil dry for several days and then give it a light sanding with fine paper or a scotch brite pad and then apply what ever top coat I wanted.

On my commissioned piece I had done the samples with the oil under coat still wet when I applied the top coat because all I cared about was the color and finish not whether the layers would adhere long term. Because I was running short on time I didn't have time for the oil to dry, but before calling the client and letting them know I would need more time, I pulled out the sample and tried to pop the water based poly top coat off the oil. It did come off, along with some wood fibers, so it was adhering to the oil strong enough that the wood fibers failed before the seam in the two finishes would fail.

After further experiments I have refined this a bit further. I apply the oil, lay out my rags and change to fresh gloves and start immediately applying a water based poly. I have used several different combinations but you will have to test your particular combo. I am partial to general's hp poly which has a UV inhibitor and I prefer an oil finish with tung oil vs linseed because other then the initial darkening tung oil will not darken over time like linseed oil. I am not using pure tung oil but rather a recipe with tung oil in it along with some damar, some turp and a couple of other ingredients. I hand wipe my oil and hand brush my water based finish, I've found 5-6 very thin coats of Generals Hp poly work best but can take on a plastic look. I let things cure for a day or two and hand rub the Generals in the same way I would hand rub a nitrocellulose lacquer finish and follow that with a coat of paste wax (I'm partial to tre wax).

So why such a crazy sounding finish? well the oil for the pop is kind of obvious. but for high wear surfaces like chairs seats and table tops I like something with better abrasion resistance and better water resistance for cleaning. I suppose I could use a catalyzed laquer product but there is another reason for the water based finish.

Some woods have so much oil in them that they start to oxidize almost immediately after planing them and this can lead to a profound color change. Camphor is one such wood. It has some exquisite pink, red and green streaks, but over a short time it turns a muddy brownish red. I started throwing some generals hp poly on my camphor the minute it came out of the planer and then proceeding with joinery in an effort to slow down the oxidation and it worked. I found this keeps the vivid colors for years vs weeks with an oil finish.

I think walnut changes its color more from UV exposure than oxidation but with such a high oil content there is bound to be some change from oxidation. My unscientific based opinion is that the UV lightens the wood in an all over kind of way, and oxidation accounts for the loss of the delicate green and purple streaks. As for empirical evidence, the oldest walnut piece I have in my home is six years old. it gets indirect light and has not changed color in any noticeable way.

I almost forgot, another advantage or the a water over wet oil is that it doesn't raise the grain.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#10

Brings Back Memories

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

of the M-1 Garand and M-1 Carbine I used in ROTC.

"MAKE'EM' SHIIINE!!"

;)

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#11

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

E Phillip Smith

Timing for this discussion is good for me. Just retired and starting to work on a very long to do list. Near the top of that list is finishing a walnut dinning table top for my son.

So what are preferred finishes for a table top that will see use in dinning area. Likely to occasionally get wet or see alcohol spills?

I am experienced with spraying cat. solvent borne finishes, just wondering if there is anything better?

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#12

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

jesse cloud

We have a dining set with several pieces: table, six chairs, and a buffet that I made 10 years ago. It has held up well, except for some epic incidents (knives and cast iron pans dropped on the table, my mom's wheelchair scraping against a leg of the table, etc). Lots of alcohol has been consumed there and even a wee drop or two spilled, with no damage.

Since I had several boards making up the top, each of a slightly different darkness, I started with a light coat of yellow dye to somewhat even out the differences, a seal coat of shellac, followed by red umber dye, and another seal coat, then grain filler dyed black, then Behlen's Rock Hard Varnish (unfortunately since discontinued) rubbed out to a piano finish on the table and matte finish for the accessory pieces.

I am about to refinish it to fix the damage (mom has since passed on) and will use the same schedule except for the Behlen's product. Probably another good varnish.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#13

Re: Brings Back Memories, indeed.

Jim Dillon

While my ROTC superiors never let me near real guns (they weren't stupid), they paid close attention to my shoes!! I finally learned the meaning of "spit-and-polish". Shoot, I ended working harder at getting those shoes polished than I did in advanced orgo (organic chemistry). But once I did, man, I was home free. Thanks for the memories as well. Jim

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#14

Re: Memories

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Had to be in Rotcee to be on the rifle team in '62.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#15

Re: A non traditional approach with traditional lo

Howard Pollack

Robin, can you say more about the Tung Oil mix you use? Thanks. Your post is very interesting.

-Howard

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#16

Re: Brings Back Memories (still have them)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Mark, I have 2 Garands, one I purchased from an individual and one I purchased from The CMP. I also have an M1 Carbine I purchased several years ago. Son and I are "into" collecting firearms, bought a 50BMG rifle about a month ago, it is a monster. Haven't hunted or shot any living thing for several years but still like to target! Don't really care for the "plastic" firearms, but do have a few with synthetic stocks. I do enjoy applying a coat of BLO on some of the old ones yet. I don't refinish any of the military firearms from WW1 or WW2 as I think they should be kept original, but do have several old hunting rifles that don't matter.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#17

JL

Are we talking black walnut or claro walnut?

JL

juglans nigra or juglans hindsii? Or heavens, English walnut (juglans regia)

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#18

Clint Searl

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

Clint Searl

This PA black walnut project dates to around '85, and if memory serves, the finish is thinned MinWax Red Mahogany stain under brushed-on Varathane oil poly mixed with a then available Varathane wipe-on oil product. The stain and poly mix produced an attractive warm tone.


Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#19

Gunstocks

John in NM

I've seen a few stocks that have faded, but I think it's unusual because even when heavily used the stocks don't see a great deal of UV. My impression is that even oil finished walnut will fade if it sees a few hours of direct sunlight day in and day out, but the effect is more pronounced with a lacquer or shellac finish.

When I finish stocks or grips, I start with a dip in a bucket of BLO, it helps the color a little. This may well be a pointless exercise, but since I have 4 gallons in a bucket (also soak ax handles) I figure it doesn't hurt.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#20

Re: Gunstocks

BrianMonumentCO

At gunsmith school TSJC (Trinidad State Junior College, Trinidad Colorado) we were taught to apply BLO with multiple applications, with wet (BLO) sanding to fill in the pores. But it was never taught as a soaking.

It was many thin layers. With sanding between applications. The BLO was in a product called Linspeed.

This was on Claro Walnut.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#21

Some practical experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Factory finish, at least from the past century, leads to fading and it doesn't survive hunting. Eventually it chips and comes off in patches. Refinished with multiple coats of oil a stock, if anything, darkens. Apply and wipe off excess treatments needed from time to time, depending on use and use in wet conditions.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#22

Re: Some practical experience

John in NM

In my experience most factory finishes since ~1960 tend to be some variety of lacquer like product, what you describe doesn't surprise me in the least.

I've had a few older rifles that were oiled from the outset and still faded, usually military surplus stuff. Mostly the old oil seems to keep a nice dark finish though.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#23

Re: Gunstocks

John in NM

There are as many ways to finish wood as there are people doing it. The way I learned to do the equivalent of what you describe is using pumice as the abrasive, helps fill the pores quickly. Its a fantastic finish if you have the time for it (most of the side work I do doesn't support that kind of time commitment).

I've heard of linspeed but never tried any. Is the color in the can about like BLO or is it mostly colorless?

Grips and stocks I mostly dip rather than soak - part goes in and comes right out to drip clean. Then follow with a film building finish, usually Waterlox. Maybe 4 coats of that and it's done.

I've worked with some surplus stuff that had to have been soaked in very thin oil. I would bet that was just the manufacturer's original finish, followed by applications of regular oil after issuing.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#24

Re: Gunstocks

BrianMonumentCO

It is BLO in color. IIRC it has some different hardeners in addition to BLO.

Got mine from Brownells, the biggest gunsmithing supply company.

Re: Starting a discussion on finishing walnut

#25

Re: Some practical experience

BrianMonumentCO

IIRC most military rifles with walnut stocks were coated quickly and not sanded for finish.

Their pores were not filled. The oil was applied in an effort to prevent water penetration.

A fully high quality finish would be shiny; Not an advantage for a combat weapon.