Starting a discussion on finishing walnut
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
The question was posed on the Hand Tool Forum but I would like to start a discussion of the answer here where there are more finishers. Derek is building a table with a maple apron and legs, and walnut top. He anticipated finishing the top with oil. However, he has no experience finishing walnut and asked for suggestions
I have been finishing walnut for many years. I have experience with many finishes and how they change after many years. Walnut finishes fall into two general categories- formal and informal. General categories of finish are- oil, varnish, lacquer, shellac, waterborne. The long term problem with walnut is that it bleaches over time. In the extreme, the maple undercarriage and the walnut top will become almost the same color unless something is done to maintain the walnut color. With the grain filled and a rubbed out gloss finish walnut takes on an elegant formal appearance. With a dull close- to- the- wood finish, walnut looks good in an informal environment (think Danish furniture, which is varnished properly, not oiled).
Walnut benefits from a finish that yellows some with age. A reddish shellac is also beneficial to the final result. Personally, I like a burnt umber pigment oil stain followed by varnish or shellac.
Oil In the strict sense there are only two pure oils to consider-Tung and Linseed. Both are similar plant oils that slowly react with oxygen to form a cross linked polymer film. They each darken walnut upon application, and importantly, this dark color seems to be resistant to bleaching. I have gun stocks over 50 years old that are essentially the color they were when first finished. They penetrate. They cure slowly. They look pleasing upon application, then become less so as the oil penetrates and cures. However, numerous coats applied over the course of weeks results in a cured film building on the wood surface. At this point the finish begins to look like a close-to-the wood varnished finish, but without the durability.
Modified Oil Lots of “wipe-on” products called “oil” are actually formulated finishes with an oil component. They build quicker than oil and cure quicker. The end result looks like a multicoated pure oil finish. They may or may not be resistant to bleaching.
Varnish, wipe-on or otherwise These products are modified oils with other synthetic resins. They build quickly with 2-3 coats being sufficient. They tend to be more durable and cure quickly. The build (depth) of the final finish can be controlled by thinning. The ”plastic” look some complain about is the result of a too thick application, and not some inherent property of the finish. The brush-on products are typically sold too viscous to provide a close to the wood finish that levels well upon application. Thinning overcomes these deficiencies. The wipe-on products, reviewed by Fine Woodworking, are easy to apply and wind up looking as good as a brushed on product. An initial coat of cured oil to provide color and depth, followed by a varnish, shellac or lacquer is an attractive finish. These finishes provide more protection than just oil.
Shellac I don’t have experience with just a shellac finish on walnut. I don’t know if it will bleach. But garnet shellac over cured oil, or an oil stain, is an exceptionally attractive finish.
Lacquer Lacquer on walnut looks good in the short term but will bleach to a yellowish finish that looks dead and unattractive. However, if something is done to preserve the color-oil or stain- sprayed lacquer is a quicker to apply finish than varnish.
Waterborne- I have no experience with waterborne on walnut.





