Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Posts

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#26

Determine, or restrict, freedoms?

Henry (Raleigh NC)

No real 'dog in this fight'... but I do want to respond with an aside, prompted by my recent personal experience.

You wrote "I personally don't want any of my freedoms to be determined by any government.... "

I understood your post, and believe I do understand what you mean here. In context you were clear; the sentence out of context is just what 'struck me.'

I would choose to narrow your word choice a bit, restating this as "I personally don't want any of my freedoms to be restricted by any government.... " Our American government, unlike many others around the world, (presumably) does ensure that you have very significant broad freedoms and rights.

I am definitely not trying to open political debate here - I am a newly minted American citizen, as of 6 days ago. So in the last month I have had both a citizenship interview, with the associated History and Civics test, and a Citizenship ceremony with oaths and pledges. In doing so I have been reminded of our rule of law, and the rights and responsibilities we have.

Simply put, our government (Constitution) has determined our freedoms; you don't want government to restrict them.

Henry

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#27

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Not a lawyer and have no special knowledge of the case, but I've got to wonder how the insurance industry might be one of the primary drivers of this regulation. Remember, in the Massachusetts lawsuit, it was the insurance company, not the injured man, that pushed the suit.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#28

Not quite correct

John in NM

Also verging into politics, but it is an important distinction:

"Simply put, our government (Constitution) has determined our freedoms; you don't want government to restrict them."

The US Constitution sought to emphasize that people's basic freedoms are innate, rather than bestowed or determined by any governing body. This is why it is logical for the Constitution to recognize that no government can restrict those basic freedoms, they are above governing.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#29

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

CJ in MPLS

"Protecting intellectual property is important, but the laws are often bent and twisted to favor one company over another."

Intellectual property is protected by explicitly favoring one company over another. That is what the ITC proceedings over Bosch's saw were about. The ITC found that the Bosch saw infringed and as a result those saws are not permitted to be imported to the US.

No laws have been bent or twisted. The outcome may rankle, but that has nothing to do with the law as such.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#30

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

CJ in MPLS

"Freedom means you can swing your fist as far as you want as long as you don't hit anyone else."

The foregoing is perfectly true. The problem is that folks can and do honestly disagree about whether contact has been made. My more legal type opinion is that the government has made a sufficient case that contact is being made and that regulations drawn to reduce the damages will be upheld. Lost productivity, workman's comp, and medical bills are all things that impact us, however diffuse those impacts may be for each of us on an individual basis.

My personal opinion is that Darwinian solutions to safety problems do not generally make for good public policy. Recall that lead is pretty useful in gasoline and paint.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#31

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Bob Lang

I probably should have been more careful in my selection of words. My statement wasn't referring to the basic principle of patent law, which of course favors one company over another. I was referring to the way some companies use the law to get patent protection far beyond the original intent of the law.

Examples of this are everywhere, perhaps pharmaceutical companies are the most egregious. One of the meds my father-in-law takes recently changed from a round pill to an oval pill. Minor changes generate a new patent for a new product effectively doubling the life of the patent protection.

For an interesting exercise do a Google patent search for "Stephen Gass" as inventor. I just did that and generated more than 280 hits. I don't have the patience to wade through them all, but there is an obvious pattern.

Many of these are "improvements" to the original SawStop patent, with relatively recent dates. I don't see a clever guy trying to protect his ideas from would be competitors; I see somebody trying to sew up a significant market segment by patenting every possible part multiple times. If you were trying to compete with that you would spend a fortune on legal fees just in researching the existing patents. Unless our current system is changed the SawStop patents will never expire.

That's what I meant by "laws get bent and twisted to favor one company". For what it's worth I think the SawStop was a great idea. I also think the greater good is served if there is no monopoly granted by our legal and regulatory system. SawStop has an incredibly large market share, and if it were me I would be happy with that.

Bob Lang

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#32

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

BrianMonumentCO

Question is how many board feet of lumber has been cut per table saw injury that the sawstop could have prevented. Or perhaps some other metric like cut lengths or something of that sort.

Reality is that in being a amateur cabinetmaker and gunsmith, I have NEVER had an accident in which a technology like that being pushed by sawstop would have prevented it.

The other part of that is are those people who were injured doing something wrong..... IE not trained properly.

IE is this regulation necessary?

And is it a regulation that causes more harm than good.

Harm here could be couple companies going out of business.

Or a dramatic increase in price of a saw that complies.

In any event my view on this type of regulation is that; The government should under no circumstances enact a regulation, legislation or court ruling that makes something a REQUIREMENT if a single company has a patent on that technology. I have fewer problems if the sawstop patents are repealed (or whatever term is correct).

The main problem is that the patent itself is an advantage for an inventor. For the government to make that technology required gives the inventor an entirely doubled down advantage. That is clearly an abuse of the system.

This set of regulations SHOULD NOT be approved/enacted.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#33

Didn't we have the same spat about riving knives?


Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#34

The cynic in me sees this differently

ian neuhaus

I'm sure that back in 2011 the major table saw manufacturers were fully aware of the CPSC's position as reported by Hank:

however impressed [the CPSC was] with the SawStop technology, the Commission was not about to mandate a monopoly to benefit SawStop. [Inez] indicated that the Commission would wait until viable alternative technology was available and on the market before proposing regulations to require these kinds of safety features.

If you do the sums (from a manufacturer's perspective) licencing SawStop's technology is no big deal. Wikipedia suggests that licencing the SawStop patents would have added at most 8% to the wholesale price of a table saw. Which is maybe just $7 in respect to the $129 Ryobi RTS10G table saw carried by Home Depot.

BUT based on the example of the Bosch Reaxx (cf Bosch 4100-09), building a portable saw to withstand the forces imposed when the blade retraction / brake feature is activated adds around 50 pounds to the weight of the saw and something like $500 to the wholesale cost.

I can see the manufacturers going "Umm, if we incorporate the technology into all our portable saws, we will effectively remove all sub $1000 (retail) saws from the market. Not many people will buy a table saw if the cheapest option is around $1000." It follows, from the manufacturers' perspective, that delaying the introduction of the technology until SawStop demonstrated a significant market for the technology is not an unreasonable stance.

As to whether the CPSC should regulate for the inclusion of the technology in all table saws, the numbers would appear compelling. "CPSC estimates that the rule could produce annual benefits of [up to] about $2.3 billion in injuries prevented." Based on the treatment costs for a simple bone fracture in a hand (a non-shop injury), CPSC's numbers do not appear exaggerated.

I guess an analogy is windscreen washers for automobiles.

You can't buy an automobile without screen washers, but as far as I know there is no law or regulation that states that you have to put water (or washer fluid) in the reservoir -- i.e use the washers.

And Governments regulate all sorts of things for reasons that are deemed to be "for the greater public good". In the case of the US, the most visible case of "for the greater public good" is probably the maintenance of the military. If I have my understanding of the Constitution right, the founding fathers assumed that the defense of America would be by way of a militia raised in times of need -- hence the 2nd Amendment Right to bear Arms.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#35

Cost of regulation

CJ in MPLS

I understand the issues with cost. I looked a few things up yesterday and my back of the envelope assessment is that costs might rise between $50 and $200. This is based on some guesses as to margin and what licensing fees might cost. In my opinion, costs are going to be capped by the current differential in prices with and without the flesh sensing technology. As you suggest, saw customers are price sensitive. I cannot see any current manufacturers cutting their throats by passing on costs in such a way that would make their saws noncompetitive with SawStop.

I also think that prices might actually drop a bit as multiple companies hit the market with competitive technologies, even if they have to take a SawStop license. This is speculation on my part, but the saw manufacturers that oppose SawStop are a pretty ruthless bunch and I can see there being some price wars as a result of a new regulation just to stick it to Gass. Lower prices will mean lower royalties and fewer sales by SawStop.

As a side note, the hot dog trick is for show, but the flesh sensing technology works. I stood 5 feet from an unlucky fellow that ran his finger across a dado stack running on a SawStop saw. He lost a chunk of skin on the end of his middle finger, but with a band aid was able to keep going after replacing the cartridge and stack. Admittedly, not two hours before this someone accidentally set off the cartridge by getting too close to a metal fastener that he knew was there. That cut could have been made without setting off the cartridge but laziness set in. The real world demonstration of the safety mechanism was the reason I bought one of these myself.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#36

Re: Cost of regulation

Dick Coers

I see the numbers on table saws sales dropping off so much in the future, that projections are incredibly speculative. If the numbers of estate sales and poor used machinery market are any indicators, woodworking will be a rare hobby in 10-15 years.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#37

Bosch Reaxx is the example

ian neuhaus

as far as I can tell, the Bosch Remaxx job site saw is a Bosch 4100-09 with the Bosch's "active response" technology.

The Reaxx is 17 lbs heavier than the 4100-09 and 2" taller -- presumably because the technology requires a larger, more rigid frame.

I would expect that this weight gain would be roughly constant across most higher priced job site saws, and substantially greater for lower cost saws which typically use a lot of plastic components.

Whilst, I have no way of knowing how much "exotic" material (e.g. Magnesium or aluminium) Bosch incorporated into the Reaxx -- the price differential to the 4100-09 (about $900) would suggest some -- if other manufacturers used steel rather than a light weight alloy to improve a saw's rigidity a much larger weight gain is likely. In respect to cabinet saws, the issue of weight gain through the adoption of heavier castings, etc is probably inconsequential.

As I mentioned in another post, I don't see the licencing fee or even the R&D costs as being significant factors influencing decisions taken by the major power tool manufactures in opposing the adoption of the technology. Rather I suspect that the cost impact of upgrading lower cost saws to withstand the forces that need to be resisted when an "active response" technology is activated would result in there being no sub-$600 saws available through places like Lowes and Home Depot. I believe that over 80% of the table saws sold in the US each year cost less than $300.

So, for the major power tool manufacturers, the "real" cost to incorporate "active response" technology in every table saw is not the licencing costs, it's the likely very substantial reduction is table saw sales.

The latter may or may not be a bad thing, depending on how you view table saw use by untrained hands.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#38

Re: Bosch Reaxx is the example

CJ in MPLS

You are correct. Since SS and XX saws do not sell down at the $130 Harbor Freight 10" saw price point and adding that technology would raise the costs pretty significantly, we are likely to see far fewer of those types of cheap saws. However, since it seems likely that saws at the sub-$200 price point are better correlated with injury than $1500+ saws, the proposed regulation would probably be effective in reducing the raw numbers of injuries. Table saws are scary to begin with but those little direct drive monstrosities make me want to vacate the premises when someone starts one up.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#39

Re: Cost of regulation

Joseph Mulherin

I have two saws, and instead of buying one of these "newer" saws with this new regulation I will just keep them and buy a new motor for each and resharpen my blades until they are not regrindable.

Seems to me we are all to jump on the "new"bandwagon when something "new" comes along.....BAHHHHH

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#40

Kneale Brownson

Re: Bosch Reaxx is the example

Kneale Brownson

So a reduction in injuries will result FROM a reduction in folks using tablesaws?

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#41

Probably

ian neuhaus

pricing table saws out of the reach of many would be expected to lead to a reduction in table saw injuries.

but it might also lead to a substantial increase in circular saw injuries as people try to use a circular saw or saber saw to make cuts that really should be made on a table saw.