Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Posts

New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#1

New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Gary Smyth

FYI

In Friday’s (tomorrow) edition of the Federal Register, the Consumer Protect Safety Commission (CPSC) is proposing a new safety standard to make table saws safer.

CPSC said emergency rooms treated 33,400 table saw-related injuries in 2015, and 92 percent were likely related to the victim making contact with the saw blade.

“CPSC staff’s review of the existing data indicates that currently available safety devices, such as the modular blade guard and riving knife, do not adequately address the unreasonable risk of blade-contact injuries on table saws,” the agency said in its rulemaking.

Under the proposed rule, manufacturers will have to limit how deep the saw can cut to 3.5 millimeters in testing when a fake human body part comes in contact with the spinning blade at a radial approach of 1 meter per second.

The proposed rule would address an estimated 54,800 medically treated blade-contact injuries annually. CPSC estimates the rule could produce annual benefits between $625 million to about $2.3 billion in injuries prevented.

The rule is expected to cost industry between $170 million to $345 million annually.

The public has 75 days to comment on the proposed rule.

Contact: Consumer Product Safety Commission

Toll-Free Consumer Hotline:

Phone: (800) 638-2772; TTY (301) 595-7054

Hours: Mon.-Fri. 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.; messages can be left anytime.

I'm told that they expect many comments.

As this information is only proposed, and not yet available (possibly tomorrow or Monday), until it is posted on their site there is no information at this time as to how the safety device is to work and/or any technology involved or recommended. Nor any info of what to do with older version saws.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#2

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Bart S Goldberg

Here is the link to the related page on the CPSI website:

https://www.regulations.gov/document?D=CPSC-2011-0074-0001

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#3

Hmmmmm

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Since this was tried before (and failed) leading to SawStop creating major waves in the market, in the present political climate of reducing or eliminating regulations, somehow I have trouble seeing this as a successful effort.

I could be wrong.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#4

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Ray Newman

Bart G: the date on the link you posted is 10/5/2011.

Garry S: do you have a link for the information you posted?

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#6

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

BrianFromMonumentCO

None of this type of legislation should be legal until the proposed solutions are actually outside of current patents and are safe and economical.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#7

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Here is a link to all 198 pages of it.....

Bob in NJ


https://s3.amazonaws.com/public-inspection.federalregister.gov/2017-09098.pdf

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#8

agree about "outside of patent"

ronster

I agree about rejecting proposed regulation if it gives a patent holder an industry monopoly. What's the rush? Sawstop patent(s?) should be expiring soon, right? since the report says they began production in 2004 and iirc patents have 17 year lives. The report does try to respond to this criticism about p. 66. They discuss Sawstop and Bosch, and say there are as-yet-undeveloped techs for meeting the regulation. That's weird.

Regarding "economics," the government analysis is pointing out that benefits exceed the costs of this technology. Perhaps this analysis is done incorrectly however, because the regulation can't affect existing table saws and they say that "45 percent of all estimated table saw-related, emergency department-treated injuries that likely related to the victim making contact with the blade involved consumers older than 60 years of age". When economically assessing a proposed regulation, the focus should be on the difference-making of the regulation (what benefits and costs change due to the regulation?).

Be careful out there friends.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#9

Link and request

CJ in MPLS

The text of the proposed rule may be found at: https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/FR-2017-05-12/html/2017-09098.htm

I would also request that we refer to this for what it is: rule making or proposed regulation. Perhaps it is because I am an attorney, but calling this legislation is to me about the same as someone calling a 24" wooden plane a 'block planer'. Makes me wince every time. :D

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#10

Re: agree about "outside of patent"

CJ in MPLS

Full disclosure: I am a patent attorney and I am a happy SawStop owner.

I think you may want to reconsider waiting until all relevant patents expire for a safety regulation to come into being. For practical purposes, there are patents on everything. Since patents on standards required technologies is a well understood issue, the way that this is handled is that such patents are required to be licensed on reasonable terms. 'Reasonable' means different things to different people, but it is an amount that is greater than zero.

Another thing to consider is that this rule making may be a way for companies like Bosch to get their products into the American market before the expiration of the SawStop patents.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#11

Read the report -- my take

Gary Smyth

I'll wait for the public comments and review the numbers pro and con to get a better opinion. The report is substantial. My feelings:

1. A compelling case for need for the safety of most operators and operations using table saws.

2. The failure of post SawStop stop-gap devices (example riving knives, splitters) to eliminate serious table saw injury.

3. A compelling argument for the need to delay immediate or short term implementation in order to retool manufacturers products

4. Expect substantial price increases in upcoming years for table saws as existing or new technologies come about. Not only for AIM (active injury mitigation) but possible liability insurance increases for the new technology

5. Many patent fights will take place, but that may not affect the end user except to delay manufacturer launches. However, expect the inevitability of more AIM saws.

6. It may take a decade or more (based on the average lifecycle of bench, contractor, cabinet saw) but non-AIM saws (or retrofit) will be scrap iron and have poor resale value. (unless specific exemptions are enacted)

7. Stockpiling current technology saws (non AIM) as a backup for future use will be a risky gamble.

8. Not part of the report, but this administration may ignore further regulation UNLESS a "public interest safety announcement" is politically expedient to relieve tensions in other areas.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#12

Re: Hmmmmm

Keith Newton

Hummm,,,,,,, Maybe this is not to just burry it, but to drive a stake through its heart down in the grave??????

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#13

Re: Read the report -- my take

Bob Lang

This was proposed before, but the Obama administration didn't follow through with it. Whether or not the current administration pushes this through or lets it die remains to be seen. The important points as I see them:

As others have noted, this is a federal regulation, not legislation.

There is only one saw on the market that would meet the regulation.

That saw is protected by not one but dozens of patents. The inventor of that saw and principals of the company are also patent attorneys. If the patent office and the courts continue to operate the way they have recently, these patents will never "expire".

The first time around, there was quite a PR campaign in favor of this. Much of that was in the form of press releases from a lobbying firm with a name that makes it sound like a consumer safety organization. Most of the media took the bait and ran stories that reiterated the press release.

I worked for Popular Woodworking at the time and did a lot of research and wrote many blog articles on both the CPSC rules process and more importantly, how not to hurt yourself while using a table saw. Here is a link to those articles:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/tag/table-saw-safety

We also conducted a survey of people who had been injured, which was pretty interesting. Here is a link to that:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/article/table-saw-injury-survey-results

My opinion is that the SawStop is a pretty remarkable invention. It makes sense for it to be in schools and shops of hobbyists who can afford it. A group of other manufacturers worked together to develop a similar system that stops the blade without slamming a block of aluminum into the blade. They worked pretty hard to avoid violating existing patents, but there is an ongoing court battle and so far this system has been kept out of the market.

My opinion is also that competition is better for everybody than a monopoly. Adoption of this regulation would essentially give a monopoly to a company that has already earned a huge market share based on their implementation of their good idea.

There should be a public comment period on the proposed regulation and I urge everyone to weigh in.

Bob Lang

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#14

Re: agree about "outside of patent"

BrianFromMonumentCO

Whether you like patents or not the issue here is how much more will my saw that I want cost , NOT the only one that has this technology cost? How much will other companies products cost to be modified to this new standard? And will other makers modify their saws to meet the new regulation.

Will this piece of unnecessary regulation make certain companies withdraw from the marketplace?

That is a big question and should be the main qualifier for any regulation like this.

Proper training on the operation of tables saws would tend to reduce if not eliminate the kind of problem that this regulation is aimed at.

I don't TRUST a machine like that....

Why should I be FORCED to buy one.

Just because some company has a patent on a "toy" that demonstrate using a hot dog.

Let the patent holder make a demo selling this technology using his hand.

And then do it multiple times NOT just once.

How long will it take before the nanny government is allowed to shut a business down because they don't use a sawstop.

Will the nanny government cause hobbyists to buy them also.

Or force all makers of saws without this technology out of business.

I also am troubled by the destruction of saw blades when the device falsely triggers.

My bottom line is lets have more complete demos as above, ie patent holder using his hand.

And the voluntary implementation of more saws by more manufacturers so this proposed regulation is NOT a sole source regulation.

Not for my home shop..... (yes I know it is a commercial regulation only.)

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#15

Re: Read the report -- my take

BrianFromMonumentCO

Regulations or laws should NEVER be enacted, passed, approved or even considered seriously if they result in a sole source situation WRT patents.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#16

Re: Hmmmmm

BrianFromMonumentCO

I hope so.

Unless sawstop will release the patent or whatever.

And more than just sawstop has the technology for general sale.

IE more than just a single vendor.

Bad regulations should be terminated ASAP.

OR be fixed. (not as in a dog, or perhaps so.)

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#17

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Hank Knight

Inez Tenenbaum was the Chairman of the Consumer Products Safety Commission in the first Obama Administration and chaired the hearings on table saw safety at which Mr. Gass testified. She is a friend of mine. I spoke with her at length about the SawStop technology and Mr. Gass' efforts to get the government to compel manufacturers to use it on new machines at a Christmas party shortly after the hearings. As the introductory notes to the new proposed Regulation indicate, the CPSC believes that table saw injuries are a real problem and need attention from the Commission. Inez said that, however impressed they were with the SawStop technology, the Commission was not about to mandate a monopoly to benefit SawStop. She indicated that the Commission would wait until viable alternative technology was available and on the market before proposing regulations to require these kinds of safety features. As we've seen, viable competitive technology has been a long time coming. I have not read all of the proposed new regulation or the many pages that accompany it, and don't plan to; but from what I've seen, the proposed reg purports to set a standard that new table saws must meet with regard to limiting injury. it does not seek to mandate how that is accomplished. It looks to me like the CPSC is trying to force the industry to get busy and develop such technology. It If they are successful, I'm sure we're in for a spate of patent litigation over whatever comes from the R&D. It will be interesting to watch.

Hank

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#18

Re: agree about "outside of patent"

Hank Knight

CJ, I agree with your assessment. See my post below.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#19

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Bob Lang

Bosch introduced a job site saw recently based on the Power Tool Institute patents. Rather than jam an aluminum block into the blade and drop the blade below the table, it used charges similar to those used in automotive air bags to drop the blade below the table and cut off power. I'm not sure if there is an additional breaking mechanism or if the blade spins to a stop out of harms way.

The whole thing is a great idea, but the technology that makes it work is pretty simple. The "flesh sensing" part is the same type of circuit used in a touch lamp, so what is left to patent? Or do we patent the larger idea and say that any device that stops any machine when a finger touches the dangerous part belongs to one company?

The legal battle started before the Bosch saw was released and I think some were sold before there was a ruling and an injunction. Bosch is a huge company with pretty deep pockets, so they didn't come in to this unprepared. As I said in my previous post, SawStop has it's own patent attorneys. Some people cast this as David vs. Goliath, but that's not the case. David doesn't need to hire an outside firm to fight the case in court.

Like most things in our legal system patents and patent law are used in all kinds of ways to stifle competition. Protecting intellectual property is important, but the laws are often bent and twisted to favor one company over another. My understanding is that the Patent Office no longer checks as thoroughly as they once did and lets the courts figure it out later. The real problem to me is that we are no longer trying to make the world a safer place or protect an inventor from being ripped off, we're waiting to see who can out-lawyer the other.

Bob Lang

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#20

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Hank Knight

Bob,

CJ in MPLS is certainly more qualified than I am to respond to your post, but I'll give you my thoughts. I agree that the patent laws are broken in a number of respects and need serious updating and revision. But they were not originally intended to be used the way they're being used today. The original idea was to encourage research an development by giving an inventor a protected interest in his invention for a period of time. The purpose is still valid. Without real incentives, few would be willing to risk the kind of serious investment in R&D and marketing that is required these days to perfect a truly new product and bring it to market. Unfortunately, the cost of litigating patent issues has put the legal system out of reach for the ordinary small businessman, and this is the root of the problem. Until the legal protections afforded by the law are reasonably available to everybody, the patent laws will continue to favor those with deep pockets.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#21

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

BrianFromMonumentCO

All this is true about a broken patent system. And my opinion is that the period of the patent is too long. And has been already stated, the patent office does not do the checking is should do. Look at Bell of telephone fame. My understanding is that another party had entered a patent application days later for similar thing. Should have been either a joint patent or rules common idea or whatever the term is.

But in sawstops case, the patent is being driven as a vehicle into a government regulation. Again an abuse of the system. That should be plainly stopped.

As I have attempted to suggest before, this regulation should NOT happen unless and until the patent is either nullified or forced to be totally minimized.

But regulations should NEVER be aimed at producing a monopoly for a given vendor based upon a patent.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#22

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Ray Newman

Hank Knight posted: " It looks to me like the CPSC is trying to force the industry to get busy and develop such technology."

BINGO!!!!

Yup. I think the industry is sitting back waiting for the SawStop patent(s) to expire, then copy or clone the technology to save R&D costs.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#23

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

TomD

"92 percent were likely related to the victim making contact with the saw blade."

Which is operator error, there is never any excuse for that. Which presumably makes some kind of technology the only solution for those whose stupid can't be cured.

"2. The failure of post SawStop stop-gap devices (example riving knives, splitters) to eliminate serious table saw injury."

That is clear, though those products are the actual ones that should be relied on. It is like adding more soft surfaces to cars when you can't stop jack asses from simultaneous vaping and texting.

If this one gets through then what is next. There are all kinds of tools that mangle people.

I think a SawStop enshrining rule would help return the tool business to the US, to some degree. Regulation is a means of installing non-tariff barriers. That might appeal to the Trump admin.

The army won't even take 1/10th of the human population, they are too stupid. Functionally mostly prepared for a life of crime. More than a few take up jobs related to wood processing.

Part of the problem with the US stationary power tool market is that it has not in it's designs embraced proven technologies and advances in machinery, and designs dating back nearly 100 years remain in the market. Then the Asian discount companies copied the tired designs and kept them alive for the last 40 years, when they surely should have cratered. SawStop is just another kludge to keep bad designs in the market.

There are accidents of all kinds, but a workshop is a pretty laboratory predictable environment in which to execute a routine. We aren't talking about moose stumbling out into our way, or drunks, as in driving. It is a sad commentary people keep getting eaten.

I was just thinking about murder today, no reason, just a train of thought thing. I was thinking if I could get the victim into my shop unconscious. I could stick a hand into my metal lathe and wrap him up on a spindle like a gyro meat sandwich machine. I would pay sawstop to stop that happening to myself as an accident, a few cuts here or there, no biggie. Words can't describe a lathe accident, except if you want to google it.

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#24

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

TomD


Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

#25

Re: New PROPOSED table saw legislation

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Personally I have never felt the "need" for Government edict protection from ANY machine. I have been using, did design and build machinery for 60+ years. I have a joiner that can rip your hand off, a planer that can do the same, a Lathe and Routers that can mangle all your appendages. Not to mention my 1 HP drill press that can wrap your hand around a spindle or make many serious cuts if a piece of metal is caught on the bit and starts swinging.

When the Government sets safety standards, our freedoms are little by little restricted. We as a human race will always figure out how to bypass safeties, do stupid things with a tool that it was never designed or intended to do. I like many others have not had my overhead guard on my Unisaw since I purchased it many years ago, but I do use Grr-Rippers faithfully and have NEVER made contact with the saw blade with any part of my body.

Due to the Lawyer connections and the fact the same lawyers tried to force the Sawstop on the public ~ I personally would never purchase one even if they were the cheapest, best saw on the market. This is me, I don't fault those who made the decision to purchase one, but I sure feel it should be their/my decision.

You can force people to wear seat belts, but you can't stop the people that pull out in front of traffic, play with their cell phone and have a head on collision with traffic in the other lane etc., unless you restrict or eliminate their driving their own vehicle.

I can see the thinking about the government restricting what safety features are required when machinery is used by a business as they employ people. The employees have no choice in determining what safety features they want or need.

But as hobbyist's, we do have a choice (currently), I have seen posts here where people use a bandsaw as they are afraid of table saws. Others choose to use hand tools only (although I have had more injuries from chisels etc. than most other tools.), and they are free to determine what tools they feel safe using.

There was an old idiom my father used to state. "Freedom means you can swing your fist as far as you want as long as you don't hit anyone else." In my mind that is still true. You should be able to do anything you want, or use any machine or tool as long as it doesn't harm or endanger others.

Freedom does involve risk, when edict's are made that prevents any danger at all, some freedoms are lost. I personally don't want any of my freedoms to be determined by any government....