Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Posts

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#26

Re: I'm with Dick.

Brian Holcombe

Slab tables take a lot of planning, it's common for people to use aged lumber for that purpose and frankly I also look for pieces that have been at the sawmill for a long time, the longer the better.

You're correct in that most of the lumber used for slabs are logs that would not be appealing to a mill that planned to use them for dimensional lumber. Most that I have encountered would make character grade lumber at best. That is one of the reasons that they're slabbed and turned into live edge, it's a good utilization of what would be otherwise useless.

Before slab tables were a display of hugely expensive and rare materials, they had been a display of lumber that was showing the character of an unusual tree, something that would have made lousy dimensional lumber. The spirit of their design was in a utilization of materials that had gone unappreciated, but when finished properly they were quite beautiful.

Have a look at Nakashima's peace Altars. Nakashima made a few of these tables and shipped one to NYC, one to Asia and one to Russia, one in 1986 then I believe another was made in 1995 and the third in 1996.

https://farm6.staticflickr.com/5594/14893140813_bdebba349e_b.jpg

That is a nearly 12' wide table, made of two slabs of black walnut crotch sections. It has been in that installation since 1986.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#27

beam stiffness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

beam deflection is a squared function of beam depth and scales linearly with width. So a tall batten will buy more stiffness than a fat one. However, once the piece is dry there is risk of splitting a cupped thick slab while pulling it flat.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#28

Re: I'm with Dick.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I do think it is possible to keep lumber from changing shape so long as the moisture content of the piece doesn't change, which assumes it was dried for the purpose intended and lives in an environment that doesn't change much. However in my house the humidity can get to 80% in the spring before we give up and turn the air conditioner on, or 30% in the winter. My shop has a smaller range of 40 to 60% and my unfinished 3' wide bench responds by "flapping its wings" during the course of a year. I never saw the need for a perfectly flat bench so it is not an issue. And it might not be noticed in a dining table.

I know someone that works on pipe organs. He told me that the 100,000+ wood pieces in European cathedral organs function over the course of the year because they live in a massive heat sink that doesn't change temperature much.

Who ever dried those pieces knew what they were doing. I wonder if they were dried free to wander or restrained, w or w/o heat and humidity control.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#29

Re: Good advice

Keith Newton

John, The thickness was 3', and the thickness was 2",but we don't know if that was actually 1.75" or 2", and what I'd like to know is how far from the pith is the center of the slab?

If the slab was just air dried, and the pith was near the top surface, this cup, would more likely be ^ kinked up near the center rather than a smooth arc that I'd expect if it were sawn from farther out. Without knowing how extreme the situation is, I'm not sure what I'd suggest.

Cupping is easier to prevent than to correct. What I like to do, is to cut a T slot on the underside, then with a really tough wood mill several cross members which may double as apron parts or handle drawer slides even. The wings of the T and inside the groove are waxed before assembly, which allows easy contraction and expansion, and of course screwed in the middle only for indexing.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#30

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Nolan

Thank you all so much for all the thoughts and advice. Much of it is comforting to hear. While the situation might have been avoided and while it also may be possible to save, I fear this was a learning experience on the shop's part--a shop which all they do is large slab work like this. We spoke for quite some time about the project, they saw pictures of the space and they installed it onsite. It never occurred to me that the heater would pose a problem for such a large piece of wood and so quickly have an effect.

To answer some of the questions posed: It is 2" thick by 10' x 3'. There are not too many knots, although a small amount of epoxy fixed a few cracks. It is not cracking anywhere currently. The bowing is along the long axis, right down the middle. Each long end (against the wall and facing the room) has bowed down at least 1". It is significant.

It is finished on the top and bottom, although it does not have a high gloss thick varnish that I see sometimes. I wonder if that would have helped seal things in/out.

I was told the slab had been dried for 18months in Pennsylvania and I'm in NJ. I did ask whether it the different environments would effect anything and was told that while yes, the wood would expand and contract throughout the seasons, it wouldn't be significant. we left maybe 3/4" on either side so it wasn't completely flush with the wall to anticipate this. Photo included this time of when it was first installed.


img

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#31

Thanks for the photo

Keith Newton

If I'm understanding you, it sounds like it is just sagging under it's own weight in middle, due to lack of support there. In the photo I can't tell if there is anything under there to help support, or if it is all dependent on the strength of the wood?

If that is the case, then you can either add more legs, or if that is out of the question, you could add some steal underneath running down the length. Height of the beam makes it stiffer, but having some pre-bend in lighter weight material can take care of that too. For instance, If we were to estimate that pushing the middle down one inch more took 200# of pressure on top, you could add a couple of 1" box beams back in from the edge, out of sight, which were bent along their length, that required 100# to push them back to straight. Although I'd be tempted to over bend, then fit the ends with a threaded knob that could be used to add or let off whatever was needed.

By the way, if it is sagging under it's own weight, I don't think the heater has anything to do with it. It's all about gravity.

Now, IF you are saying that on each end right and left is bowing down in the middle, this is called cupping, and that is due to loosing moisture possibly from the heater. From the looks of the front edge, the pith center would have been maybe 6" - 10" below the bottom side. It would be natural for this board to cup as it looses moisture. It would really help if you could post another pic showing the problem.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#32

Re: Thanks for the photo

Nolan Haims

Actually the middle is bowing UP against gravity, and there is no weight issue with it sagging down across the short edge in the middle. Here is another photo from underneath showing the supports where hopefully you can see how it is bowing up.


img

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#33

Re: Thanks for the photo

Keith Newton

OK, you posted while I was typing. What you are showing, is due to the heater drying the underside faster than the top. That slab should naturally cup the opposite way if both sides were giving up moisture equally. It may flatten some whenever the top looses more moisture, but I think I would suggest giving it a bit more time to equalize. It might want to go back the other way.

I hope you will keep us posted, because this is a good lesson piece for everyone to learn from your experience.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#34

that is the data we needed-case closed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was not dry when installed and the heater dried the bottom faster than the top dried. Conclusive

How was this conclusion reached?

When a wide piece of lumber dries naturally with equal drying from both sides it cups because the radial shrinkage is about half the tangential shrinkage. If the resulting piece was laid on the floor with the outside of the tree facing up (your orientation) the edges would be lifted and the middle sunk to create a trough.

As I understand your situation, your piece is the opposite situation. The only way this result can happen is for the bottom to have dried faster than the top. In this case the bottom shrinks in width faster than the top which pulls the edges down. (lumber does not shrink significantly along its length. I would have expected the resulting cup to straighten out some as the top of the piece continued to dry to the same moisture level as the bottom.

That piece will be strong. If I owned it I would put something stiff along the bottom at one end like a 4 x 4 and put a monster C clamp in the middle and see how much force it took to more or less flatten it. If it flattened without unimaginable force I would implement Ellis' suggestion and extract a discount from the shop for my trouble.

I suggest you have some reasonable expectations for something this big. If you can get, and keep it flat to 1/4 or 3/8" no one will ever notice and just live with it. Pull it away from the wall so air can escape up the back as well as the front and hope it doesn't split at its ends. I am astonished it did not split at the ends. They must be well sealed.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#36

Re: that is the data we needed-case closed

Keith Newton

Bill, I think I'm going to have to be against you and Ellis suggesting to pull that on down. Keep in mind that the weakest property in all aspects is tension perpendicular to the grain. If he forces that on down, I'm afraid it's going to split, and when it does, it'll likely eventually make it up to the face.

A board cut in this fashion should have cupped away from the heart, just the opposite of this. I'm expecting it to start coming back on it's own before those heaters are used again, and maybe even cupped back the other way by the time it is finally dry or at EMC.

Noland, you might ask the fellow who made it if he still has any end cuts from this slab still around. You or he can cut off a 1/4" cross grain slice and put it in a warm oven for an hour to see what it wants to do, then compare that to what this piece is doing. You can also try to push a cross section down flat as the others suggest, to see if it splits before actually doing it on the real piece. Testing is just a form of quality control.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#37

Re: I am wondering????

clay foster

That's what I have done before on wide slab counter tops. It works.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#38

I agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I should have been more clear. If in straightening it there is a lot of resistance it is in risk of splitting. I would straighten a 4/4 board with this problem without hesitation. But I have no experience with something that will be this strong.

I have a wide piece of 8/4 maple that cupped in drying. I have no doubt I could park a car on it and it would not flatten. If it was oak with its weak splitting resistance I would not even consider trying. But walnut.....maybe try some force.

And I agree that the cup should have lessened as the top surface became drier. If I owned it there are other things to try. Like putting wet paper on the concave side. When the cup got straight enough, restrain it with 4/4"s and hope to hold it flat as it dried out again.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#39

Hate to bring it up, PPB.

Dick Coers

Have you heard of powder post beetles? If that slab was only air dried for 18 months, there is always the possibility that it has PPB eggs or larvae in the sapwood and may hatch out. Watch for really fine sawdust on the floor. Proper kiln drying kills the eggs and larvae, air drying does not!

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#40

Re: Hate to bring it up, PPB.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The finish solvent can do them in.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#41

Ellis Walentine

Right, beam engineering must be right


Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#42

Another thought....

Barry Irby

Is that table tight to the wall? The reason the "Heat" is along the wall and under the window is to offset the chill. The window and the wall to a lesser extent cool down in winter and the chill slides off them onto the floor. Putting the heat there warms the wall and the window and has the effect of reducing the radiation off your skin to the colder surfaces. Those units look more like convectors that radiators. An open slot at the bottom allows colder air off the floor to be drawn in and heated and it rises out of the slots on the face and top. Supposed to "wash" the wall and window with warm air.

If there is no space behind the walnut slab you have diverted the circulation and now the warm air will roll along the bottom of the slab. Should be pretty toasty under there, but the window and the wall will be colder. The window may sweat.

I might try putting some gentle steam on the bottom side and heat lamps on the top. Just a little wetness under neath and a little dry warmth on the top. Might take a few days.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#43

Possibly, but not always *LINK*

Dick Coers

This information says an infestation is discovered when activity is discovered in finished products. I'm sensitive to the situation since just this week I finished cleaning out a shed on my Mom's farm. We threw away over a thousand board feet of hardwood. The extent of the infestation was shocking and alarming. The air had to be thick with beetles at some point, there were just that many holes in the wood! When cutting up the air dried stock, you could see channels all the way through 12/4 lumber. It was a heartbreaking experience. Actually heartbreaking in the fact my mother is now in assisted living because of such a loss of mental capacity, and I'll never have a reason to go on the farm again. Then add in the destruction of the hardwood to top it off. It's been a rough couple of months!


http://owic.oregonstate.edu/sites/default/files/pubs/powderpost_beetles.pdf

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#44

Noland, Where are you located?

Keith Newton

you don't have to be specific, but it is important to know if you are heading into Summer or Winter. I was assuming that your in the Northern hemisphere and that the heat would not be back on until maybe late Oct. However if your off down on the other end of the world, the situation is different.

What Bill and Barry are suggesting to add moisture back to the bottom comes from the old trick of laying a bare unfinished cupped board out in the damp morning dew on the lawn, which adds moisture to the cupped side while the Sun dries the top convex side. However laying it in the Sun on a piece of metal or some surface without gaining moisture from underneath would have the same effect by drying the top causing it to contract.

I don't see the point of trying to add moisture to the bottom, since it is already finished, it will be slow to absorb, then the heater will just undo any gain whenever they are back on again.

It would be much better to seal the bottom better to totally eliminate an more moisture loss from that side. Finishes alone won't stop vapor loss. If it would, you wouldn't have this problem. Heat alone doesn't make wood shrink, but it does speed evaporation. I started to suggest tenting the top with a space heater blowing under to dry the top more, but you could cause some surface checks, which may have already happened underneath. The core doesn't give up the moisture as fast as you can dry the surface, so going slow is good.

If you are in a cold Southern climate zone, this is different. gotta go now

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#45

Re: Thanks for the photo

Sgian Dubh

If all else fails to flatten that top, if that's what's desired, here's something that might work. Remove the slab from the wall, flip it upside down, run a series of something like 3/8" - 1/2" wide grooves the full length of the slab to within about 1/4" - 3/8" shy of the top face. Space the grooves about 2" - 3" apart. This weakens the slab. Flatten it and machine up sticks to fill the groove as neatly as possible, and while the slab is flattened out glue these sticks in place ideally with thickened epoxy resin which has excellent gap filling properties and also pretty good structural integrity in itself. This frequently leaves the top show face somewhat rippled necessitating additional levelling out or flattening and refinishing.

I'm not suggesting you do the work - it doesn't come across that you're a woodworker, but the maker of the piece should be able to do it, or any half competent woodworker for that matter. The 'cup correction' method I've described isn't guaranteed to succeed, but I've resorted to it quite a few times over the years and found it pretty reliable with some near unsalvageable pieces that haven't responded as desired to other attempted solutions. After flattening the piece it will need fixing down solidly to something like cross mounted bearers with an allowance in the fixings for cross grain movement (expansion / contraction).

As to the cause of the initial cupping problem, others have analysed that pretty well already - no need for me to add anything that I can see. Slainte.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#46

Richard, I was going to suggest that,

Keith Newton

But I wanted to let the moisture content even out some first. If the OP is from somewhere in the Southern Hemisphere where they are just starting to use heat, rather than the end of the cold season, I'm expecting it to relax some before the heat is back on. Fixing the problem he has now, might only cause the face side to split if it dries too much while the core is bulked up with moisture, or filled with epoxy and strips.

I'm not sure we'll ever hear from him again.