Re: that was some sage advice....
Grant Smith
Bill: To be added....If the piece is 3' wide and has large knots add " a lot" after each of the "moves", and "move" might be changed to the more alarming "warps".
Grant: Point taken.
Bill: I can't imagine selling someone this piece without making them abundantly aware that it will likely not stay flat. And, how did they get the piece flat to begin with. Anybody got a 3' wide planer?
Grant: I use a PC 7518 with a 1" planing bit. Works fine, takes a long time. Could also use a drum sander as pointed out. Maybe both.
Bill: And to be added....if it cupped up the heater is definitely not the cause. If it cupped down the heater could be the cause but grain orientation could be instead, or in addition.
Grant: Maybe I am thinking backwards, but wouldn't heat under the top dry that side, thereby contracting the wood on that side and causing the high center warp as described? Any board cups towards the side with added moisture, so it follows that it would cup away from a drying heat.
Bill: Question to you all.......If this piece was properly dried and then positioned to where one side dried from shop relative humidity to house relative humidity in March where ever it lives, faster than the reverse side.....would it not eventually even out in moisture gradient and return to the shape it was in the shop?
Grant: I believe it would return to its previous flat state if the top was returned to wherever it was seasoned, and "if" the humidity returns to where it was when the wood was last surfaced.
Bill: On the other hand, if it was wet when delivered such that it continued to dry and shrink around all the grain changes we would expect it to permanently warp and assume a new shape.
Grant: Yes, and if it shrank, bulged, cracked, etc. one would know just how well they really dried it (or didn't). It will, given a stable environment, eventually reach an equilibrium, however. It is true these large slabs continue to move due to the wild grain, especially when placed in an environment like described. One can build for it, or at least plan on it, however. Such slabs are very popular around these parts. So much so that people who don't know what they are doing are installing them left and right. I recently went to a brew pub and saw their massive bar top. The craftsman had used 4" thick slabs 20+ inches wide and ten or more feet long, then arranged them in an "L", and used a mitered corner!!!!. The day I visited I commented on the 3" gap across the corner where the wood had moved. They said the carpenter was supposed to come back and re-miter them soon. I suggested they find a different carpenter who might better understand wood movement. I then suggested they butt them together at a 90 degree angle instead. Before long, the owner, bartender, and the owners wife were peppering me with questions, and asking for solutions. I guess they paid nearly $10K for the top alone. I could have had the fix job, but I was there for dinner, and I'm only a hobbyist. I instead told them what they needed to know and faded away. The wife took lots of notes, and I drew her a picture of how to arrange things so it would only move on the inside of the bar with the butt joint.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa