Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Posts

Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#1

Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Nolan

I'm not at all a professional or even hobbyist, but I'm hoping those with more knowledge than me could weigh in...

About 4 months ago, I had a 10' x 3' x 2" Walnut slab custom designed as a free standing. The legs were simple steel rectangles on either end. After only 3 weeks the slab began warping up significantly along the long center axis.

Desk was flush against the far end of a wall that contained a baseboard steam heater.

Though the shop that did all the work installed the desk on-site and assured me it had been dried for 18months (approximately), it started warping almost immediately which was something I was told just shouldn't happen. But they blamed the heater.

Initially the shop wanted to try to unwarp the slab through some strategic new bolts on the leg, but they just said they will probably replace it.

My question is: do you think it was really dried long enough?

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#2

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

If the moisture level where it was stored or worked on before it came to your house was higher than your house it is not surprising that there is some movement occurring over a heater. If they only finished the top surface, they have created the potential for moisture differential in the wood. If they replace it request that they apply equal amounts of finish to all sides which will help slow moisture changes in the piece of wood.

A 2" thick slab needs 70-200 days per inch of thickness to dry from green to 20% depending upon the time of the year the wood is cut. Ideally it should be dried further to 7-8% to be stable in your house.

Here is a good drying reference; https://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/fplgtr/fplgtr117.pdf

Lee

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#3

These rules of thumb are useless

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The bottom line is that the wood was not dry enough. That said, it will not be a good idea to put a slab of that size over a heater. I'm surprised the ends didn't split. Look closely...I'm amazed the ends didn't split.

How fast wood dries depends on so many factors that rules and guidelines are unreliable. Under the correct conditions 18 months is more than enough time to dry the lumber. Under less than optimum conditions this slab would never be dry enough to put indoors over heat and unrestrained.

How much did it cup?

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#4

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I doubt you will ever keep a 3' wide slab perfectly flat.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#5

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Don Stephan

The description is a bit confusing for me. The slab is curving along its 10' length so that the ends are higher or lower than the middle, but still flat across the 3' width?

Ideally there should be the same number of coats of the same finish on all surfaces, so that moisture movement into and out of the slab is uniform on all surfaces.

Readings from several places on the slab's top and bottom using a good moisture meter would be helpful, but my feeling is that the heater (or an HVAC forced air duct) immediately underneath will cause problems for any solid wood, regardless of its initial moisture content.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#6

Ikea has a lot to answer for

Ian Neuhaus

in answer to your question

do you think the slab was dry enough

yes, I think the Walnut slab was dry enough.

But what you wanted the slab to do -- form a table top above a heat source -- is not where I'd locate such a slab.

The location and design is more suited to the chunks of paper wrapped expanded cardboard sold by Ikea as shelving.

Harsh, but, I believe, a realistic assessment of the likely performance of any piece of solid timber 10 foot long, 3 feet wide and 2 inches thick, placed above a heater.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#7

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Brian Holcombe

It's fair to blame the heater, to some degree. Flat sawn wood is going to move to some extent in unpredictable ways, it does so as the relative humidity changes.

I'm not a big fan of metal bases that don't offer batten support to big slabs, but in spite of my opinion they remain popular.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#8

Yeah, look to the heater...

John in NM

Not sure what a steam heater is - do you mean an old fashioned radiator?

Heat alone would do it if the slab were not fully dry, but if it's some kind of heat/humidifying device that would mess with even kiln dried wood.

On the other hand 18 months doesn't sound long enough. Surely the shop used a moisture meter? If they got it below about 10% EMC (equilibrium moisture content) it would be considered dry enough for the construction you described. Much over 20% EMC and I would still expect to see some end splitting and pronounced warping.

Depending on the extent of warping they might well be better off fully drying the thing if need be and then planing it flat. 1/4" over 10' would not be significant warping IMHO, 1" over 10' would.

Trying to pull wood flat with steel or added bolts or whatever won't work. Steel has greater tensile strength than wood, but also far greater flexibility. Even if some means of pulling the slab flat again were successful, it would probably crack the wood (depending on how warped it is and how much more it wants to warp).

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#9

and another PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have seen some of these slabs at lumber yards that cater to the Studio Furniture builders. They are not the clear, relatively straight grained pieces of wood I build from. Unless someone slabbed a $20,000 veneer log this piece of wood likely has large knots (called figure and character when marketing this kind of wood). The grain running every which way around these areas will result in a piece of wood that will not respond to changes in humidity in predictable ways. Bottom line, it is unlikely to stay flat under any circumstances.

A fundamental question to ask is how much experience does the shop have building from this kind of wood. I'm surprised an experienced shop would risk the construction you describe.

As an aside, I have never seen a piece of walnut 3' wide nor a tree that would yield such a width. I'd like to see a picture of this wood.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#10

But it worked on the TV show...


Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#11

We had this radiator discussion earlier

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. We have no evidence to suggest the slab was "dry enough. We were given no information about the journey of this slab from tree to house. There is a slab mill in Indiana. They have an on-site dehumidification kiln that would have been capable of adequately drying this piece of wood in 18 months. On the other hand if it was put somewhere with poor air circulation and high humidity after 18 months it could easily have been over 20% MC.

2. Lumber suffers it greatest dimension changes, which lead to warping, in the range of 25 to 15% MC.

3. Many thought that a steam radiator heated by convection when we had a discussion of radiators in the past. If radiant heat from this device is minimal there would not necessarily be a heat gradient around the slab as it continued to dry in the house. Drying rate top to bottom, especially if adequately finished, would be largely the same. However, I'll bet this piece has some huge knots with grain running every which way. When this kind of lumber dries unrestrained it warps in many directions around these knots.

4. It's not the fault of the desk owner that this construction failed. He said that he was not a wood expert. He relied on the expertise of the shop to make this top. The shop undertook what I would regard as a highly risky construction and it failed. It may have failed through faulty engineering, or insufficiently dry lumber, and likely both factors led to failure.

Not everything that can be made from wood can be made so that it will last. Once a maker departs from construction that has stood the test of time, as evidenced by antique survival, there is risk. Studio furniture, where novel design is most important, is particularly at risk. Antique trestle tables, made from huge slabs, invariably are warped. A modern shop should not expect a different result.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#12

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

Grant Smith

Rule #1: Wood will move.

Rule #2: You can't change rule #1.

Rule #3: Building using wisdom can help prevent rule #1.

thoughts:

a. If the wood is not acclimated to your home, then it will move.

b. If the wood is not finished on both sides, it will move more than it needs to. That said, wood still moves, despite the cost, beauty or number of coats of finish. Finishing both sides will slow down movement to some degree, however.

e. As to whom is at fault is only a matter of getting it right the next go round. If the customer fails disclose that they intend to place the furniture near or over a heater is at best an oversight, and at worst negligence on the part of the builder for not warning against it, assuming they knew of the plan.

We can offer more information if you tell us where you are. A great deal depends on locale when it comes to wood movement. Also keep in mind if you intend to ever move to... say the desert southwest, or perhaps Georgia.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa ,

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#13

that was some sage advice....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

to be added....If the piece is 3' wide and has large knots add " a lot" after each of the "moves", and "move" might be changed to the more alarming "warps".

I can't imagine selling someone this piece without making them abundantly aware that it will likely not stay flat. And, how did they get the piece flat to begin with. Anybody got a 3' wide planer?

And to be added....if it cupped up the heater is definitely not the cause. If it cupped down the heater could be the cause but grain orientation could be instead, or in addition.

Question to you all.......If this piece was properly dried and then positioned to where one side dried from shop relative humidity to house relative humidity in March where ever it lives, faster than the reverse side.....would it not eventually even out in moisture gradient and return to the shape it was in the shop?

On the other hand, if it was wet when delivered such that it continued to dry and shrink around all the grain changes we would expect it to permanently warp and assume a new shape.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#14

Re: that was some sage advice....

Barry Irby

While nearly none of have or have seen a 3' wide planer, there are lots of 3' wide bet sanders around. I was in a shop recently that flattened huge slabs by "flying" a router over them. They has a big table with sides on it and a router mounted on square steel tubes that had to be ten feet long. Two guys spent a long time shoving the router back and forth until the top side was level. Then they did the back. Then they ran it through a huge belt sander. (Day----something Sander?) If it would fit.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#15

Ellis Walentine

Here's how to save it

Ellis Walentine

I'm undersdtanding that the board is cupped across its width, right? If so, you can get it flat and keep it flat by adding about four beams crosswise and equally spaced under the slab. The beams must be thick enough to be able to counteract the warping, so if the slab is cupped concave down, the top edges of the beams will also need to be concave. You can have the guy bevel back the ends of the beams so they are not a visible eyesore.

Using 3/8" lag screws in countersunk holes, screw the beams to the underside. You'll need three to four bolts per beam. If you use four, space them equally and have slotted holes for the bolts nearest the ends.

I know this method works, but that said, it is a matter of accurate engineering. The section modulus of your beams must be enough to pull the slab flat or the deal is off. This means that the stiffest wood possible should be used. Walnut is pretty stiff, but something like hickory or locust would give you more beam stiffness so your beams can be thinner.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#16

Re: that was some sage advice....

Brian Holcombe

If well battened they can remain functionally flat. I work battens into many designs that other people often do not batten and I do so for that purpose that it helps to let the board settle in without anything going terribly out of flat (in most cases).

Flattening big slabs is not terribly difficult, I do it by hand but it can be done by hand tool method using winding sticks, a long straight edge and an electric planer.

After which you can send the board through a giant planer (thicknesser) or wide belt. Or you can do what I do, which is to flip it over and repeat the previous process once more, then finish plane.

Taking the least amount if material off and using wood that has been well seasoned certaibly helps.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#17

It will take some really robust battens!

Dick Coers

Attempts to control a big slab like that is a big task! Depends on how close the the pith, and how straight the grain is. But my feeling is that slab will do what it wants to do unless you fasten it down to basically an I beam with slotted holes!

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#18

Dado's

Brian Holcombe

Dado's break up the field of material into smaller sections. One of the details I find to be critical is to make the batten integral to the slab and in doing so it makes the slab less capable of twisting.

Basically I believe taking every advantage that is available so that it minimizes every other factor.

I'm also of the opinion that especially heavy slabs are more of a detriment than a benefit in situations like this. I would rather attempt to control 1.25" then 1.75" and 1.75" than 2.5"....ect. Obviously you wouldn't want to make a flimsy table, but so often I see incredibly heavy slabs that would be better off having been make into two when they were sawn.

Heavy chunks of wood have their purpose and benefit, but giant slabs are not necessarily better off for being heavy as it is often assumed that they are.

It's not much of a stretch to suggest that the idea of a slab table, in contemporary terms is owed much to Nakashima and yet those who build in the trend that he started do not often take notice of the fact that his tables are not often very heavy in thickness and the bases are often substantial.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#19

Re: that was some sage advice....

Grant Smith

Bill: To be added....If the piece is 3' wide and has large knots add " a lot" after each of the "moves", and "move" might be changed to the more alarming "warps".

Grant: Point taken.

Bill: I can't imagine selling someone this piece without making them abundantly aware that it will likely not stay flat. And, how did they get the piece flat to begin with. Anybody got a 3' wide planer?

Grant: I use a PC 7518 with a 1" planing bit. Works fine, takes a long time. Could also use a drum sander as pointed out. Maybe both.

Bill: And to be added....if it cupped up the heater is definitely not the cause. If it cupped down the heater could be the cause but grain orientation could be instead, or in addition.

Grant: Maybe I am thinking backwards, but wouldn't heat under the top dry that side, thereby contracting the wood on that side and causing the high center warp as described? Any board cups towards the side with added moisture, so it follows that it would cup away from a drying heat.

Bill: Question to you all.......If this piece was properly dried and then positioned to where one side dried from shop relative humidity to house relative humidity in March where ever it lives, faster than the reverse side.....would it not eventually even out in moisture gradient and return to the shape it was in the shop?

Grant: I believe it would return to its previous flat state if the top was returned to wherever it was seasoned, and "if" the humidity returns to where it was when the wood was last surfaced.

Bill: On the other hand, if it was wet when delivered such that it continued to dry and shrink around all the grain changes we would expect it to permanently warp and assume a new shape.

Grant: Yes, and if it shrank, bulged, cracked, etc. one would know just how well they really dried it (or didn't). It will, given a stable environment, eventually reach an equilibrium, however. It is true these large slabs continue to move due to the wild grain, especially when placed in an environment like described. One can build for it, or at least plan on it, however. Such slabs are very popular around these parts. So much so that people who don't know what they are doing are installing them left and right. I recently went to a brew pub and saw their massive bar top. The craftsman had used 4" thick slabs 20+ inches wide and ten or more feet long, then arranged them in an "L", and used a mitered corner!!!!. The day I visited I commented on the 3" gap across the corner where the wood had moved. They said the carpenter was supposed to come back and re-miter them soon. I suggested they find a different carpenter who might better understand wood movement. I then suggested they butt them together at a 90 degree angle instead. Before long, the owner, bartender, and the owners wife were peppering me with questions, and asking for solutions. I guess they paid nearly $10K for the top alone. I could have had the fix job, but I was there for dinner, and I'm only a hobbyist. I instead told them what they needed to know and faded away. The wife took lots of notes, and I drew her a picture of how to arrange things so it would only move on the inside of the bar with the butt joint.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#20

I'm with Dick.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If that slab is not dry it will take a lot of force to hold it flat if it wants to move. It may not flex something 4" thick by 3' long but I think it will easily bend something 2". And keep in mind, my bet is that this slab has huge knots with the usual distortions around them as they dry.

On the other hand maybe they did cut up a $20,000 veneer log for this slab and it is clear.

Reminds me of the 4/4 gum I foolishly bought and dried. It looked like attractive lumber off the saw. I piled it under 500 bdft of walnut and it lifted the walnut pile as it dried and made potato chips.

The reason commercial kilns can get flat lumber is steam. Early in the drying the kiln is hot and steamy which softens the lumber desiring to become potato chips.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#21

Agree on all points....except

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

our notion of "up" is different. We know what it will do if heat dried the underside and not so much the top. But describing it without a picture apparently failed me. If I could figure out how to rotate ( ...........

If heat was the primary cause of warping I would have expected some splits on the ends.

Loved your bar story.

Indeed there seems to be a robust market for wide bark edge slabs. And they are usually cut from wood of too poor grade to make marketable lumber. What I saw at the mill in Indiana were primarily large walnut yard trees. It is nice there is a market for them.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#22

Re: that was some sage advice....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Flattening big slabs is not terribly difficult" I recall you saying that you don't book match because it is hard to plane. The slabs I saw in Indiana would take the hand planing challenge to another level or two. Knots many inches across were in abundance and ends often forked with fiddle back grain. The customers like lots of character.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#23

Re: that was some sage advice....

Brian Holcombe

Context is important here.

That statement applied to finish planing book matched panels and that I found having grain that was exact opposite of one another to be additionally time consuming to finish plane.

One normally does not glue solid two slabs to form one book matched slab. Normally a gap is left between them, this allows expansion toward the center and edges rather than having one giant piece that now moves as a whole. Sometimes it is done but it is normally not done for especially large tables. The people doing that are normally sanding to a finish.

None of this applies to my statement about flattening slabs, which is a straightforward enough process.

Finish planing slabs like that is a separate process, I did not refer to it as I suspect that I'm one of a rare group that is finish planing slabs.

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#24

I am wondering????

Barry Irby

This is probably anathema to those who really want a real honest to goodness slab, Why not allow the slab to return to flat and cut lengthwise kerfs in the bottom side that come close to but not all the way to the ends and then install battens? Wouldn't this "break its back" and relieve the stresses?

Re: Warped slab after only 3 weeks

#25

Good advice

John in NM

And as you say, accurate engineering. Slab is what, 3"? Those are going to be pretty big beams! Still a perfectly feasible approach however.

This sort of solution is also where I've seen people attempt to use steel - mistaking tensile strength for stiffness. I've even seen professional engineers make that mistake between aluminum and steel.