Grain of salt?
ian neuhaus
funny, I can't find a retailer in Australia who carries Cabot's "Australian Timber Oil" ...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Grain of salt?
ian neuhaus
funny, I can't find a retailer in Australia who carries Cabot's "Australian Timber Oil" ...
Location, Location, Location
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Similarly to what the real estate agents claim, location is everything. In the case of this screen door the location includes both its location on the house, its location relative to the sun and weather and it geographical location.
My screen doors have all had an overhang above them and not subject to direct rain. Here on the river's dampness any outside wood turns black from mold whether it is left natural or varnished. I use white pine for screen doors because it makes a light weight sufficiently strong door. I paint them because paint is the only finish that provides attractive protection that lasts more than a year or two.
Obviously there are locations that would lead to greatly different solutions for a screen door. And my point is...... both the requester of advice and those offering it must provide the information in the context of location. We don't have enough information on the location to offer reliable advice. Rot resistance may or may not be relevant. A natural or varnished finish may or may not have a useful life. Etc.
Under the right circumstances, maybe...
John in NM
That oil is pretty similar to Thompson's in results (as is the ad campaign!
). The actual oil used and the thinners used may well be different, but it acts about the same. If anything Thompson's is a bit thinner (which is good in the way we've been using it).
In spite of the reputation, Jean has actually found a good use for Thompson's. We have some ipe decking around the place, porches and stairs that get direct 7,000' sunlight. Nothing holds up and she doesn't like the weathered look. These cheaper deck oil products hold up about 4-6 months like everything else, but do not require sanding when they start to look a bit worn. The last couple years she's been just doing a quick re-coat, and though I was extremely skeptical I have to admit it's working better than anything else we've tried.
Re: Type of wood for screen door?
Brian Holcombe
Western Red Cedar, or most cedars for that matter are not specific enough in name only. It's really only the heart wood that survives the outdoors and further still it should old growth to truly stand a chance.
The same applies to most softwoods.
I would use either Honduran Mahogany or OG Douglas Fir.
Plane them (with sharp hand planes) and you can leave them without a finish 
Re: Australian Timber Oil?
Ellis Walentine
I tried it on my ipe veranda and it was a disaster. It didn't soak into the ipe (which isn't surprising) but the big problem was that I left it on there to dry, and it didn't. I don't know if it's just because of chemicals in the wood (like rosewood does under varnish), or because it has so much long oil in it that it doesn't polymerize. It just got sticky and I ended up having to remove it. The trick would have been to thin it and wipe it on and off a few times, but I decided to just let the porch go to silver.
Ellis
Probably climate differences...
John in NM
The one time I used the stuff, it didn't behave like that on ipe, though I wouldn't swear that it was as thin as the Thompson's we're using now.
Even when applied too thick, these finishes do tend to cure better out here, between the added heat and UV.