I am going to make a new screen door for the front door, a standard 3'x6'8. Replacing crappy finger jointed big berg door falling apart. We love the sound of the screen door slamming and announcing someone coming in. Am looking for suggestions on type of wood to use and joinery. Not looking to paint it, either clear spar varnish or possibly stain but I'm leaning towards clear. Thanks in advance
"Cedar" doesn't mean a whole lot. It is a generic term that covers many different species in many genera, with widely varying properties. If someone handed you a board of Spanish and another of Atlantic White, you might ask, "Are these both wood?" Your profile doesn't tell us what part of the world you live in, which might be important, since particular "cedars" vary a lot geographically in price and availability.
With those caveats, redwood, western red cedar, atlantic white cedar, northern white cedar, and even bald cypress would be good choices, depending on the quality you can find at your local suppliers.
Mortise and tenon joinery (and not stub tenons) with waterproof glue is advised. I would use West System epoxy, because it is flexible and gap filling.
A real spar varnish is a good choice for an outdoor object that needs to be flexible and stand up to the weather. Most of the highly marketed varnishes that call themselves "spar varnish" aren't. Go to a boat specialist and pick one made by Interlux, Sikkens or Epifanes, and schedule periodic maintenance on it.
Ash is heavy, but it is available, shows grain, is workable, is going to be varnished anyway and is a choice wood for making exterior doors and oars. It might also be better looking than some other woods for a front door.
The last couple I've made were from Spanish Cedar, with bronze screens. This Wood is KD works easily and is very durable. WesternR Cedar here is sold green, so it would need drying time before working it up.
I also needed to replace a crappy contractor-installed screen door on our screened porch over 15 years ago. I used 5/4 Douglas fir with pegged M&T joinery and Titebond II. I painted ours and it's still as good today as the day I installed it.
I like fir for a screen door frame but most woods will be fine. Here in new england screen doors of any species will rot if not protected. Like others said,waterproof glue and mortise and tenon joinery and seal it good you should be good to go.---Jack
Thanks for all the tips. I went to the hardwood supplier around here and got some very straight QS white oak. I will be using mortise and tenon joinery. I have had very bad experiences with the western red cedar I get around here. Deck rotted badly and I was diligent in staining with oil Cabot stain ( before they went to crap) posts have rotted so I am a little leery of Western red cedar which is about the only kind I have seen except for aromatic around here. Thanks again
Seems like there will always be nooks and crannies on wooden screen door to catch and hold water, so I would want to use a wood that stands up to moisture, like white oak, cypress, and the others already mentioned. And keep a good finish on the wood.
What I am going through right now Ive learned something abt wood rot. Its no screen door but My above gnd pool steps 2 years ago I partially made them out of regular untreated wood and moisture treated wood. Dumb on my part. Everything was painted with Benjamin Moore paint.The untreated lasted 2 years and the treated I think will last forever. So, if you cant get at least cypress, Id get pressure treated as close to size as possible and make it on the table saw. Good luck. Jerry
I have made many with traditional mortise and tenon construction. They can not rack unless enough force is applied to break the tenon.
A note...put the middle divider at whatever level the owners hip is at. A hip will be used to open the door when the owners arms are full. We are short people and I put our dividers lower than typical, for example.
Yabbut, what kind of regular untreated wood? Stuff like SPF (construction grade lumber), tulip poplar, maple, cherry, and many others have zero or very little natural antifungals and antiarthropodals. Other species of wood have significant rot and bug resistant chemicals built right in. That's one reason some are recommended for exterior use (as offered above) while others are not. The problem with the chemicals that are insinuated into pressure treated lumber is you don't want to breathe them, or carry their sawdust into the house, because they are toxic to humans, too. Once the varmints have broken through the protective coating, it's party time! Outside in the weather, especially around a pool, you won't find many paints that are impervious to attack from the varmints, the weather and the UV.
I would NOT use Pressure treated wood to make a door. (I have never seen the word "insinuated" used in reference to Pressure treated wood before.) To treat the wood, they put kiln dried southern yellow pine (SYP) into a vacuum chamber and suck out the air, then introduce the chemicals in liquid form under pressure to force it into the cells, all the way through the wood, leaving it completely saturated. SYP tends to warp. Pressure Treated SYP is almost guaranteed to warp. not the best thing in a door. They treat SYP because the cell structure will accept the treatment, many other woods will not. The heartwood will not accept the treatment, but tends to be naturally decay resistant.
Like most words in English, insinuate has multiple meanings. A friend of mine, who is a PhD organic chemist likes to use it in the context of gluing together parts of sailboats with epoxy resin.
Insinuate - To instill or infuse subtly or artfully
I would have to agree with Irby for the douglas fir, and make it like In addition, I would suggest making a
bandsawn leafy cut design with limbs for the upper supports. Cover the outside with either a screen wire or a sunscreen to keep the bugs out of the patio and house.
... and many have been covered or suggested here. I vote for Spanish cedar because it is relatively inexpensive, dimensionally pretty stable, and widely available at lumberyards. It's also "durable," which means it doesn't rot quickly in exterior applications.
Western red cedar is very soft and weak, and it doesn't last for projects like this. It is fine, say, for clapboards, where it is painted and will drain properly. Doors have places where water sits and sucks down in, and that will rot woods that are not extremely durable.
Other options might include Teak (expensive), genuine mahogany (fairly expensive), cypress (inexpensive but soft, prone to warp and come apart at the summer wood), black locust (heavy, difficult to work, not very likely to stay flat, not commonly available except from mills), and white oak. Truly durable woods will hold up without a finish, although they will go to a natural silver gray color in a couple years.
As others have noted, non-durable woods like pine, Doug fir, poplar and others will last a long time if properly painted and the finish maintained.
As for finishing, no clear coats last indefinitely outdoors. Spar varnish will work but only if you are resigned to putting on three coats on day one and another coat every spring. I've done a lot of experimentation on this when I was building driveway gates. Better spar products are available from boat dealerships.
Another good product is Sikkens varnish. I just today checked out a porch floor that was finished with this stuff about four years ago, and it is still intact and looking good. It looks a bit artificial and is not a "clear coat" like spar varnish, but it holds up longer than most other clear coats.
Back in the day, one had to guess at the meaning of an unfamiliar word (or unfamiliar usage), or pull a heavy dictionary down off a high shelf and dust off a magnifying glass. Things have improved substantially, making it much easier to learn new words, since PCs come with a built-in dictionary, and Google, et.al. provide immediate access to even the most erudite usages. There's no longer any valid excuse for boring writing, or misspellings, much less for an auto-correct faux pas.
I'm making a replacement screen door for a client out of QS white oak. I chose QS white oak because it is very stable, almost bullet proof, and is resistance to rot. The original screen door was white pine or some other conifer, about 90 years old, and was beyond repair about 20 years ago. The upper opening will be glass, the middle part a storm window, and a panel down below. All mortise and tenon joinery. You can't buy a screen door like this at the Big Box.
The advertisements for Australian Timber Oil look impressive for outdoor projects like decks and porches. Would it work to use it by itself and without top coating with marine spar on a screen door or similar? I have no experience with it, but I would appreciate hearing from those who have used it.
That's what advertisements are for, but are often otherwise close to meaningless. You should search for reviews and Safety Data Sheets for this or any other exterior finishing products you might want to compare it to. If you find reviews on the manufacturer's website, you might consider taking them with a grain of salt.